In no way shape or form is Dawkins close to JT3. People on here just associate him with Big John and they hate Big John. There may also be some recency bias since we all saw UCF's moral victory every Duke, but overall Dawkins has been awful.
It's definitely not a hire I'm super excited about, but there are some positives.
Stanford, largely, sucks as a basketball program so he sort of gets a break there. He has been decent at UCF but you qonder if that was only because Tacko is an easy piece to build a defense around.
Vanderbilt has things to sell (contrary to what some believe) in terms of offering families a shot at ensuring their entire family is set for life. A VU diploma is as valuable as any in college basketball AND you get to live in Nashville AND you get to play in the SEC.
It's a fairly easy sell and if Dawkins can parlay his time with Duke and Rat Face with his 9 years in the NBA, I think he has a shot to be a good hire.
That said, I don't know and wouldn't be surprised if he was terrible either.
Blowing this up with Drew may turn out to be a 3-4 year rebuild where if we had kept Drew for one more year, the following coach would have taken over a program in much better shape.