It's the talent

newwavedave1

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2006
3,982
3,522
0
Great article by Politi about the McNulty hire. States that during his previous time at RU he had much better talent. Teel, Rice, Britt, and NFL caliber players on the OL, including Davis. Unless we get better talent, don't expect miracles. He's still a good get and a part of the process of getting better. Patience everyone!
 

BlockR

Heisman
Dec 28, 2015
23,169
22,175
113
talk to Ash about adding upgraded Recruiters as new Assistants instead of some unknown guys from University of Montana.
New Jersey is getting bombarded with recruiters with deep NJ ties...
add another after PSU just made Phil Gialiano a full time assistant.

Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,610
61,944
113
talk to Ash about adding upgraded Recruiters as new Assistants instead of some unknown guys from University of Montana.
New Jersey is getting bombarded with recruiters with deep NJ ties...
add another after PSU just made Phil Gialiano a full time assistant.

Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!

Holy **** dude do you EVER stop beating this drum lol?
 

njknightsfan

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2001
2,612
3,429
113
talk to Ash about adding upgraded Recruiters as new Assistants instead of some unknown guys from University of Montana.
New Jersey is getting bombarded with recruiters with deep NJ ties...
add another after PSU just made Phil Gialiano a full time assistant.

Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!

After 2 years at RU, you don’t think Ash and staff haven’t built relationships with NJ coaches? You don’t think all the camps, visiting high schools have any impact, hiring Mantz, you don’t think any of this helps? It’s a question of the staff having the ability to develop the talent and winning some games, than recruiting will take care of itself.
 

Scarlet Haze

Senior
Aug 31, 2016
633
859
0
Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash![/QUOTE]
--------------------------
NJ is cold enough.....why would anyone with half a brain want to play and live in the arctic tundra of Minnesota??????????????? Good luck (not really) Rossi.
Don't forget to tell them about the great summer (full of mosquitoes) that lasts from July 07 to July 22.
 

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
talk to Ash about adding upgraded Recruiters as new Assistants instead of some unknown guys from University of Montana.
New Jersey is getting bombarded with recruiters with deep NJ ties...
add another after PSU just made Phil Gialiano a full time assistant.

Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!

Jersey ties don't matter remember?
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,610
61,944
113
After 2 years at RU, you don’t think Ash and staff haven’t built relationships with NJ coaches? You don’t think all the camps, visiting high schools have any impact, hiring Mantz, you don’t think any of this helps? It’s a question of the staff having the ability to develop the talent and winning some games, than recruiting will take care of itself.

Exactly. It's also a matter of the ill-feelings left by the previous staff, not only with the NJ high school staffs BUT on the kid who were already sophs, jr, and srs in high school, before they left. The class of 2019 were frosh the last season of the previous regime so, hopefully, those feelings are a little less prevalent with them.
 
Last edited:
Sep 29, 2005
14,051
16,131
0
Great article by Politi about the McNulty hire. States that during his previous time at RU he had much better talent. Teel, Rice, Britt, and NFL caliber players on the OL, including Davis. Unless we get better talent, don't expect miracles. He's still a good get and a part of the process of getting better. Patience everyone!
Captain obvious?
 

AshCatchEm

Heisman
Jan 8, 2016
13,896
19,972
113
Great article by Politi about the McNulty hire. States that during his previous time at RU he had much better talent. Teel, Rice, Britt, and NFL caliber players on the OL, including Davis. Unless we get better talent, don't expect miracles. He's still a good get and a part of the process of getting better. Patience everyone!
I wouldn't wipe my *** with that article
 
  • Like
Reactions: AreYouNUTS

njknightsfan

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2001
2,612
3,429
113
Exactly. It's also a matter of the ill-feelings left by the previous staff, not only with the NJ high school staffs BUT on the kid who were already sophs, jr, and srs in high school, before they left. The class of 2019 were frosh the last season of the previous regime so, hopefully, those feelings are a little less prevalent with them.

People have short memories, the only thing that matters is you put a competitive product on the field. Lat year was an improvement from the previous year but the offense was just pitiful to watch. If McNulty can show a pulse and improve the offense, I think our D will show improvement than 2019 could be a banner year in recruiting. If the offense is as sh**ty as it was the last 2 years than all bets are off. If we win or are even competitive against the big boys and maybe even steal one from Mich, Penn St., Ohio St.... next year, I say the flood gates open for recruiting. It's a catch 22 situation for Ash but the opportunity is there for the taking for the right coach. Look at what Pikell has done and will do here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AreYouNUTS

jerzeyguy

All-Conference
May 18, 2008
3,517
2,600
0
That's why Al Golden was the smarter choice. He was a name coach from Jersey who would recruit well and upgrade the talent. May not be a good coach.. But let's be real. No coach was winning after Flood- unless it was a proven winner level coach. RU was looking for a bridge coach untill the money came in. Bridge coach Al Golden upgrades your talent. Bridge coach Chris Ash brings disciplined and structure. We need the talent more
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUaMoose_rivals

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,216
17,017
113
That's why Al Golden was the smarter choice. He was a name coach from Jersey who would recruit well and upgrade the talent. May not be a good coach.. But let's be real. No coach was winning after Flood- unless it was a proven winner level coach. RU was looking for a bridge coach untill the money came in. Bridge coach Al Golden upgrades your talent. Bridge coach Chris Ash brings disciplined and structure. We need the talent more
Golden hasn't been hired by any college program since his players under-preformed at Miami having one good year out of the 5 he was there , being fired after the 7th game of his 5th season there.
I think I'll take a HC that is still learning the job but instills discipline in his players over someone that can't coach the talent he brings in and has an under-preforming program
Ash made mistakes, but seems like he's learning to correct them and bring in the type of talent RU FB needs to be a winner after the previous HC made RU a place HS talent stayed away from
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,610
61,944
113
That's why Al Golden was the smarter choice. He was a name coach from Jersey who would recruit well and upgrade the talent. May not be a good coach.. But let's be real. No coach was winning after Flood- unless it was a proven winner level coach. RU was looking for a bridge coach untill the money came in. Bridge coach Al Golden upgrades your talent. Bridge coach Chris Ash brings disciplined and structure. We need the talent more

Here we go again....
 

scfa99

Freshman
Oct 4, 2007
34
57
0
Great article by Politi about the McNulty hire. States that during his previous time at RU he had much better talent. Teel, Rice, Britt, and NFL caliber players on the OL, including Davis. Unless we get better talent, don't expect miracles. He's still a good get and a part of the process of getting better. Patience everyone!

Politi seems to think McNulty's success was mostly due to Teel, Rice, Britt, Underwood, Brown and the OL. Well I think it's easy to say that based on history.

However, looking at recruiting ratings from those years here are some interesting facts that appear to demonstrate most of these players greatly outperformed their recruiting rankings:

Britt - 4* 5.8 rating
Rice - 3* 5.5 rating
Underwood - 2* 5.2 rating
Teel - 2* 5.4 rating
Brown - 3* 5.6 rating

OL
Stapleton - 2* N/A
Zuttah - 3* 5.5
Sosa - 3* N/A
Davis - 4* 6
Fladell - 2* N/A

Let's look at the "talent" on paper that he has to work with vs the above, Ratings are what they are (flawed) but on paper its not all that different. This batch is very young but this team is far from talentless. I think a better argument could be made for the level of competition between that conference and the B10 East.

Hopefully McNulty played a large part in developing the above talent and can do the same with these guys:

QB
Sitkowski - 3* 5.7 rating
Chatman - 3* 5.5 rating
Lewis - 3* 5.7

RB
Blackshear 2* 5.4
Pacheco 3* 5.6
Hilliman 4* 5.8

WR
Melton 4* 5.8
Lewis 3* 5.7
Lacewell 3* 5.7
Wormley 3* 5.5

OL
Clark 4* 5.8
Vretman 3* 5.7
Maietti 2* 5.3
Krimin 3* 5.6
Cole 2* 5.4
Jackson 2* 5.3
Seymour 3* 5.5
 
Aug 18, 2003
380
246
0
Screw NJ kids who think that they're too good for Rutgers. I want Ash to start looking for more Florida kids. The 2006 team was full of them.
Florida is a different animal now compared to when Schiano was here. back then, you only had 3 Florida programs scooping up the talent. now you have UCF, USF, FIU,andFAU in the mix. Charlie Strong, Lane Kiffin, and Butch Jones ain't exactly chopped liver when it comes to recruiting.
 

Dpgru

All-Conference
Jan 17, 2015
4,603
4,761
0
Calm down about the NJ ties thing. Ash and staff have had two and a half years to develop NJ ties. Think about it, if the guys on the staff now, who many of you claim don't have NJ ties, leave here and go elsewhere (say, SB, DM, ETC.) they could very well be sent back into NJ to recruit by their new schools because, having worked for a year or two at RU, they have NJ ties. once you develop a relationship you develop a relationship. This staff has been here long enough that it does not need to bring people in in order to develop a relationship with the NJ high school players and coaches. If they haven't done it by now they never will.
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
24,481
13,091
113
talk to Ash about adding upgraded Recruiters as new Assistants instead of some unknown guys from University of Montana.
New Jersey is getting bombarded with recruiters with deep NJ ties...
add another after PSU just made Phil Gialiano a full time assistant.

Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!

Keep on beating is drum. Maybe soon or later the HC will wake the f up.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,986
8,958
113
Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!
--------------------------
NJ is cold enough.....why would anyone with half a brain want to play and live in the arctic tundra of Minnesota??????????????? Good luck (not really) Rossi.
Don't forget to tell them about the great summer (full of mosquitoes) that lasts from July 07 to July 22.
[/QUOTE]
Is this the same Joe Rossi whose defense was torched through the air for gruesome amounts of yardage by an option team?
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Screw NJ kids who think that they're too good for Rutgers. I want Ash to start looking for more Florida kids. The 2006 team was full of them.
I want Ash to go get OL from wherever Wisconsin gets them. I'm guessing Wisconisn in a severely under-recruited state based on Wisconsin's reliance on in-state recruits, their performance and how low Wisconsin is ranked in per-capita P5 recruits.
 

LETSGORU91

All-American
Jan 29, 2017
7,208
7,962
113
After 2 years at RU, you don’t think Ash and staff haven’t built relationships with NJ coaches? You don’t think all the camps, visiting high schools have any impact, hiring Mantz, you don’t think any of this helps? It’s a question of the staff having the ability to develop the talent and winning some games, than recruiting will take care of itself.

I am kind of with you for the most part on that. But next September, we should have at least 4 St. Peter's Prep kids on the roster. That's not a bad place to start when making inroads to top programs.
 

THERAC

Senior
Oct 25, 2006
2,630
468
47
Talent coming into Rutgers during that era was -
Teel - 2 Star,
Rice - 3 Star,
Underwood - barely a 2 star,
Jack Corcoran - 2 Star.
McCourty Twins - 2 Star

Team Ranking
52 - 2004
68 - 2005
42 - 2006
37 - 2007

Vs.

43 - 2017
48 - 2018

From a recruiting perspective JM will be dealing with the same talent (if not better) coming in. The difference is the development of players NOT talent.
 

RU19931

All-Conference
May 3, 2004
2,887
2,679
0
After 2 years at RU, you don’t think Ash and staff haven’t built relationships with NJ coaches? You don’t think all the camps, visiting high schools have any impact, hiring Mantz, you don’t think any of this helps? It’s a question of the staff having the ability to develop the talent and winning some games, than recruiting will take care of itself.
No I don't think they have built any relationships with any coaches. Don't you know get all NJ coaches are pig headed an will only deal with RU coaches hat have NJ ties. Lol, NJ isn't producing enough elite players for us to only recruit NJ. That is why this staff is recruiting nationally
 

vandalen1

Junior
Feb 4, 2006
5,904
227
0
Politi is not exactly right because Teel was a horrible QB is 2006. He had 12 TD's and 13 ints. He still had Britt and Tiquan and Clark Harris. Rutgers was 11-2 because of a great defense.
After McNulty took over, Teel improved quite a bit. More TD's than Int's. a much better QB rating including more yards per catch. Same group of receivers less Harris.

McNulty, IMO, can develop QB's and he'll add schemes to get receivers open.
 

rucoe89

All-American
Jul 31, 2001
13,473
7,595
113
talk to Ash about adding upgraded Recruiters as new Assistants instead of some unknown guys from University of Montana.
New Jersey is getting bombarded with recruiters with deep NJ ties...
add another after PSU just made Phil Gialiano a full time assistant.

Joe Rossi‏@JoeS_Rossi 8h8 hours ago
Super excited to be back in the great state of New Jersey! A lot of ELITE talent in the Garden State for 2019. #RTB

Your move Coach Ash!
Wait, are you serious? If I’m Rutgers I’m loving this! The counter argument is 4 year old obvious. “ Hi Phil, Joe, how is Kyle doing? You know how clueless he and his staff were. Sure am glad we don’t deal with them anymore. Hey, weren’t you key players on Kyles staff? Oh looky here, seems like I have to be somewhere else. Good luck and don’t bother giving Kyle our regards.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: JetFire JP

RUwoz

All-Conference
Jul 20, 2014
3,266
1,982
0
Talent coming into Rutgers during that era was -
Teel - 2 Star,
Rice - 3 Star,
Underwood - barely a 2 star,
Jack Corcoran - 2 Star.
McCourty Twins - 2 Star

Team Ranking
52 - 2004
68 - 2005
42 - 2006
37 - 2007

Vs.

43 - 2017
48 - 2018

From a recruiting perspective JM will be dealing with the same talent (if not better) coming in. The difference is the development of players NOT talent.
Recruiting has come a long was since then, apples and oranges. Offenses have even changed a ton since then
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod