It may be blasphemy...

hawkeyemark18

Senior
Aug 16, 2019
256
450
63
Too soon and probably not quite right given Ronnie’s run to the final four
If Ben can get Iowa a Big tourney crown and a sweet sixteen let’s talk.
I would take a national championship run and adequate showing in the Big Ten tournament. I don't find the BTT all that meaningful aside from teams that won't otherwise make the NCAA tournament have a chance to make a run and get in. I have never liked it but like the conference championship in football it provides another way to bring in $$$. The comparison still doesn't make sense any way you slice it.
 
Last edited:

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
5,589
11,347
113
I would take a national championship run and adequate showing in the Big Ten tournament. I don't find the BTT all that meaningful aside from teams that won't otherwise make the NCAA tournament have a chance to make a run and get in. I have never liked it but like the conference championship in football it provides another way to bring in $$$. The comparison still doesn't make sense any way you slice it.
Agree. The BTT is just an extension of the regular season games.
 

joelbc1

All-American
Sep 5, 2007
3,958
5,058
113
Agreed. Ronnie also was a consensus All-American. In my 63 years I'd say 1. Lester 2. Woolridge. 3 Stirtz 4. Brown
You were too young to appreciate how good Fred was. ;)
Ronnie took us to the final four. Andre led the league in points and assists. If Stirtz does one of those two things, then I will gladly annoint him as the best PG ever at Iowa. Until then… Those two are at the top for me…
In all honesty, in 1980, Ronnie was injured and and missed a good part of tge season and the first 3-4 games of the Tourney. He did not play in the NCAAs until the semi-finals vs. Louisville when reinjured his knee..In his defense, I think Iowa might have beaten Louisville if he had been able to play the whole game but we will never know.
Fred was the only addition to a team that was like 5-9 the year before going 14-0. Freddy was the straw that stirred that drink in 1969-70 with all due respect. He made Calabria, Vidnovik, Jensen, JJ and McGilmre all better players.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: HoggI74

Ptguard5

Sophomore
Nov 26, 2025
89
157
33
Guy did get a little bit of run in the NBA with the Warriors though. Played 3 total games while being on a regular season roster for a couple weeks. Still more games than some other guys that we've had drafted.
Yep, no doubt Guy had some skills. They just did not get used much his last years under Tom. Always liked Guy a lot.
 

HawksRule25

All-American
Sep 8, 2023
5,025
6,814
113
You were too young to appreciate how good Fred was. ;)

In all honesty, in 1980, Ronnie was injured and and missed a good part of tge season and the first 3-4 games of the Tourney. He did not play in the NCAAs until the semi-finals vs. Louisville when reinjured his knee..In his defense, I think Iowa might have beaten Louisville if he had been able to play the whole game but we will never know.
Fred was the only addition to a team that was like 5-9 the year before going 14-0. Freddy was the straw that stirred that drink in 1969-70 with all due respect. He made Calabria, Vidnovik, Jensen, JJ and McGilmre all better players.

Lester played in all of the NCAA games in 1980 up to including Louisville - when he got hurt. :)

---------------------------------- MP Pts Ast
3-6-1980 vs Va Commonweath ....32 17 8
3-8-1980 vs NC State ...................... 28 17 4
3-14-1980 vs Syracuse .................... 35 9 7
3-16-1980 vs Georgetown .............39 8 9
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,167
3,945
113
It's not blasphemy. It's just premature, at best. Did you ever see Lester or Andre Woolridge play at Iowa? Downtown Freddie Brown? How about Murray Wier of Waterloo?

Stirtz, especially recently, has been outstanding. Bennett is one of the best point guards Iowa has ever had. But the best ever? That might be a step too far. Let's revisit that when the season is over.
I doubt many here saw Wier play. That was 70-80 years ago in the late 40's. And for the record Wier was from Grandview, Iowa. As I mentioned before My late father in law played with Wier at Muscatine high school in the 40's.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ivan D

o_Terrykohawk

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2002
589
1,436
93
Pre knee injury Ronnie Lester was a Guy who You would be talking about in the same light as an Isiah Thomas type talent, Stirtz is skilled but He is now where the talent Ronnie Lester was . He was destined to be an NBA HOF type talent till that knee .
Back in the day there was a lot of discussion comparing Isiah Thomas and Ronnie Lester. Since Magic would have close insight on the two, I will take his word a healthy Ronnie was the best.
 

HawkInDenver

Senior
Apr 16, 2024
468
905
93
Hard to argue against Lester given the final 4 run and him being an All American.
Armstrong is up there in my mind -had a great career and led Iowa to the Elite Eight in '86 (they won 30 games that year!).

We've had a lot of great point guards over the years -Stirtz is definitely one of them!
 

twindman

Junior
Sep 1, 2010
148
231
43
I think to be fair to Stirtz, you would have to admit his supporting cast is nowhere near as good as Lester's, Brown's, etc. With better teammates it would take pressure off Bennett (yielding more open shots) AND increase his assist numbers. I watched all of these others I was in school during Freddy's time - that team was fantastic. Fred spent like 15 years and Johnson 17 years in the NBA.
 

joelbc1

All-American
Sep 5, 2007
3,958
5,058
113
Lester played in all of the NCAA games in 1980 up to including Louisville - when he got hurt. :)

---------------------------------- MP Pts Ast
3-6-1980 vs Va Commonweath ....32 17 8
3-8-1980 vs NC State ...................... 28 17 4
3-14-1980 vs Syracuse .................... 35 9 7
3-16-1980 vs Georgetown .............39 8 9
He missed several games during that season though… my mistake on the NCAA. Tourney…He injured himself vs. Dayton (8 game of the season) and missed the next 16 games).
 
  • Like
Reactions: HawksRule25

MAKhawks

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2001
1,417
2,169
113
Ronnie took us to the final four. Andre led the league in points and assists. If Stirtz does one of those two things, then I will gladly annoint him as the best PG ever at Iowa. Until then… Those two are at the top for me…

And a B1G Regular Season Championship. Yes it was a different era (seven less teams) and Minnesota cheated but got the acknowledgment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LaQuintaHawk

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
5,589
11,347
113
You were too young to appreciate how good Fred was. ;)

In all honesty, in 1980, Ronnie was injured and and missed a good part of tge season and the first 3-4 games of the Tourney. He did not play in the NCAAs until the semi-finals vs. Louisville when reinjured his knee..In his defense.
This is incorrect. He played the last several regular season games and every tournament game until getting injured vs Louisville.
 

joelbc1

All-American
Sep 5, 2007
3,958
5,058
113
This is incorrect. He played the last several regular season games and every tournament game until getting injured vs Louisville.
Again, he missed 16 game after being injured in the 8th game…according to the University. He must have made it back just in time for the Tourney…I admitted that gaff…
Just my opinion that Ronnie is probably regarded as the “best” guard but that was because of his longevity (4 years)…my preference though lay with Fred Brown…one (man) made a huge difference in 5 other guys as that Iowa team made huge progress from the ‘69 to ‘70 teams. And Fred was the only difference in these two teams.
 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
985
2,012
93
When you get older you may have fans comparing point guards to Stirtz. You seem to get it. This comparison stuff starts to get silly.
Starts to get silly? Nope. If you watched Ronnie Harmon play, and watched Bennet Stirtz now, there is no comparison. (both fine players, but please.....)

You think Bennett Stirtz is taking Iowa to the Final Four? Cause Harmon wasn't surrounded by studs either, and Iowa made the Final Four, and won a share of the Big Ten title his Junior year. The dream died when his knee died. That's how good Ronnie Harmon was.

He had a growth spurt in high school that caused him knee pain, and that pretty much continued apparently. 5'6" to 6'2" between sophomore and junior year.

He was an All-American as a Junior at Iowa, and missed 16 games as a Senior with knee issues. Iowa won a share of the Big Ten title his junior year, the last time that has happened. Kenny Arnold and the boys came together without him his last year, were 10-8 in the Big Ten, and when he played late in the season.......well, the rest is history.

Iowa lost to eventual champ Louisville 80-72. Lester was 4-4 from the field and 2-2 from the line, when he was injured 12 minutes in. That's how good Ronnie Lester was.

I wasn't old enough to remember Freddy Brown and Company, but for me it's Ronnie Lester AINEC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skydog0784a!

joelbc1

All-American
Sep 5, 2007
3,958
5,058
113
This is incorrect. He played the last several regular season games and every tournament game until getting injured vs Louisville.
Ronnie played the last 3 regular season games (Iowa finished in about 4th place at 10-8( and then played the four NCAA games before re-injuring himself in the semis).
 
  • Like
Reactions: LaQuintaHawk

HoggI74

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2015
2,113
3,447
113
Andre W was one of the best, especially since he nearly always drove to his right, if I remember correctly .
So did Ronnie. As I said he's a legend because of the FF, but Stirtz is being defended in ways Ronnie never saw. ( refs called a much, much tighter game back the, watch any you tube. Touch fouls by today's standards. ) They're picking him up 40 feet from the basket and he still dominates.
Too soon and probably not quite right given Ronnie’s run to the final four
If Ben can get Iowa a Big tourney crown and a sweet sixteen let’s talk.
Was Eli Manning a better QB than Dan Marino because he has 2 rings?


Who's this Ronnie Harmon guy? ;)
 

Hawk48

All-Conference
Jun 10, 2005
1,031
1,568
113
I was too young to remember Ronnie. The old boys get real mad if you talk about anybody over him and I respect that. He must have been that damn good.
he was the best PG in college at the time IMHO.
 

hawkeyemark18

Senior
Aug 16, 2019
256
450
63
Starts to get silly? Nope. If you watched Ronnie Harmon play, and watched Bennet Stirtz now, there is no comparison. (both fine players, but please.....)

You think Bennett Stirtz is taking Iowa to the Final Four? Cause Harmon wasn't surrounded by studs either, and Iowa made the Final Four, and won a share of the Big Ten title his Junior year. The dream died when his knee died. That's how good Ronnie Harmon was.

He had a growth spurt in high school that caused him knee pain, and that pretty much continued apparently. 5'6" to 6'2" between sophomore and junior year.

He was an All-American as a Junior at Iowa, and missed 16 games as a Senior with knee issues. Iowa won a share of the Big Ten title his junior year, the last time that has happened. Kenny Arnold and the boys came together without him his last year, were 10-8 in the Big Ten, and when he played late in the season.......well, the rest is history.

Iowa lost to eventual champ Louisville 80-72. Lester was 4-4 from the field and 2-2 from the line, when he was injured 12 minutes in. That's how good Ronnie Lester was.

I wasn't old enough to remember Freddy Brown and Company, but for me it's Ronnie Lester AINEC.
Interesting response. We obviously come from the same generation and I pretty much agree with you. I have never watched a better basketball player in my lifetime than Ronnie Lester.

Stirtz has the possibility of achieving great things in his last season due to great coaching. And in my mind we never had a better coach at Iowa following Lute Olson until we hired Ben. Just a totally different situation as you say and Stirtz plays off the ball some as opposed to Lester. I just enjoy the present moment and this team has started playing very good basketball triggered by great defense and Stirtz at the helm.
 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
985
2,012
93
Interesting response. We obviously come from the same generation and I pretty much agree with you. I have never watched a better basketball player in my lifetime than Ronnie Lester.

Stirtz has the possibility of achieving great things in his last season due to great coaching. And in my mind we never had a better coach at Iowa following Lute Olson until we hired Ben. Just a totally different situation as you say and Stirtz plays off the ball some as opposed to Lester. I just enjoy the present moment and this team has started playing very good basketball triggered by great defense and Stirtz at the helm.
Here's to hoping we find more Ronnie Lester's and Bennett Stirtz's moving forward. 🙂 (and some bigs would be great too!)
 

IowaFarmBoy2

All-Conference
Oct 22, 2023
1,503
1,016
113
Agreed. Ronnie also was a consensus All-American. In my 63 years I'd say 1. Lester 2. Woolridge. 3 Stirtz 4. Brown
Andre could only go one direction. He was a tank. Lester could breakdown great Ds before the 3 pt shot.

Brown/lLester, BJ.

After that it gets tough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Big Z

Hawkeye1984

Senior
Jul 29, 2022
305
546
93
Lil Lick? That’s my vote.
 

IowaFarmBoy2

All-Conference
Oct 22, 2023
1,503
1,016
113
You were too young to appreciate how good Fred was. ;)

In all honesty, in 1980, Ronnie was injured and and missed a good part of tge season and the first 3-4 games of the Tourney. He did not play in the NCAAs until the semi-finals vs. Louisville when reinjured his knee..In his defense, I think Iowa might have beaten Louisville if he had been able to play the whole game but we will never know.
Fred was the only addition to a team that was like 5-9 the year before going 14-0. Freddy was the straw that stirred that drink in 1969-70 with all due respect. He made Calabria, Vidnovik, Jensen, JJ and McGilmre all better players.

He did not miss those tourney games
 

IowaFarmBoy2

All-Conference
Oct 22, 2023
1,503
1,016
113
I think to be fair to Stirtz, you would have to admit his supporting cast is nowhere near as good as Lester's, Brown's, etc. With better teammates it would take pressure off Bennett (yielding more open shots) AND increase his assist numbers. I watched all of these others I was in school during Freddy's time - that team was fantastic. Fred spent like 15 years and Johnson 17 years in the NBA.
Lester had Arnold. Beyond that they were average but over achievers. Bobby H was good
 
  • Like
Reactions: hawkeyemark18

twindman

Junior
Sep 1, 2010
148
231
43
Lester had Arnold. Beyond that they were average but over achievers. Bobby H was good
Oh, I think kevin boyle, Krafcisin, Waite and Brookins were above average. K and Waite were pretty good size and between the two, they averaged almost 14 pts and 11 rebounds. We currently don't have anything like that.
 

IowaFarmBoy2

All-Conference
Oct 22, 2023
1,503
1,016
113
I corrected myself… read thru the thread, please.
He did muss 16 regular season games..and injured himself in the semi-finals.But “thanks” mom…
That requires memory
Oh, I think kevin boyle, Krafcisin, Waite and Brookins were above average. K and Waite were pretty good size and between the two, they averaged almost 14 pts and 11 rebounds. We currently don't have anything like that.
The Big was loaded Even Wisconsin with Wesley Mathews was a tough out as Magic found out. Brookins should have been better and showed what he could do in the tourney.

Itwas was still the Lester and Arnold show to put them above average.

Boyle was an extreme over achiever. Waite numbers came from teams having to be all over Lester and Arnold. Iowas 87 teams was loaded. This one wasnt. Could you imagine Lester going against a spread out D of today?
 

IowaFarmBoy2

All-Conference
Oct 22, 2023
1,503
1,016
113
The shot by 8th place Wisconsins Mathews that put Iowa in a 3 way for the Big title in 79

 

hawkeyemark18

Senior
Aug 16, 2019
256
450
63
Oh, I think kevin boyle, Krafcisin, Waite and Brookins were above average. K and Waite were pretty good size and between the two, they averaged almost 14 pts and 11 rebounds. We currently don't have anything like that.
I really liked the duo of K and Waite up front and Lute could really coach and got the most out of them. I didn't consider either of those two as above average bigs. I still remember Boyle saying one time that with Ronnie Lester playing seemed like riding a wave :)

This team has a different makeup. We don't have the size that team did but we have the three point line and some guys who can really shoot. Aside from the bigs I think Stirtz has more around him and at times he can just facilitate or play off the ball.
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2005
2,167
3,945
113
Oh, I think kevin boyle, Krafcisin, Waite and Brookins were above average. K and Waite were pretty good size and between the two, they averaged almost 14 pts and 11 rebounds. We currently don't have anything like that.
??? "between the two they averaged 14 and 11? I would think were getting that and more most games "combined " between Folgeras and Cam. Special K was a pretty good player, (started his career at UNC), but had knee issues. Waite was a pretty average player, (although had the huge follow up and one in the tourney, against Gtown?).
 

hawkeyemark18

Senior
Aug 16, 2019
256
450
63
??? "between the two they averaged 14 and 11? I would think were getting that and more most games "combined " between Folgeras and Cam. Special K was a pretty good player, (started his career at UNC), but had knee issues. Waite was a pretty average player, (although had the huge follow up and one in the tourney, against Gtown?).
Good post. It gets to why comparisons between players or teams from different eras get shaky pretty quickly. In Lute Olson and now Ben McCollum we have had the two best Iowa basketball coaches in my lifetime. Lute coached when we didn't have the three point line. Ben coaches a great deal of cutting to the basket to open the three point line and he wants bigs who can shoot as opposed to Lute's bigs who mostly stayed inside.
 
Last edited:

twindman

Junior
Sep 1, 2010
148
231
43
I forget, but I thought Waite and K didn't play together all that much. Is that right????
 

HMB Trumpet

Senior
Mar 19, 2018
398
481
63
They did some but I don't recall if they played together all the time or not. Probably not with fouls.
Usually both of them were in the starting lineup, probably because many teams had big front lines. Twin Towers. In the 1980 tourney, though, Lute started Brookins instead of Waite. That moved the 6’6” Boyle to PF. Vince was 6’5” and definitely a wing.