It’s not over

198hamilton

All-Conference
Jul 28, 2008
1,807
2,433
0
Wait a minute, if the BOG voted the contract down wouldn't it have been at a meeting that required 48 hours notice?
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,888
3,378
66
There has been some conflicting info that Hobbs did NOT even present it to the BOG.

In that case, could a binding offer ever have even been made to GS or was it only at the stage of discussion as to terms only?

To me a key point, as Hobbs is charged with the search and presenting candidates with recommendation to the BOG. Please stop with the he knew where the votes were etc. Not his role. Did he kill it before final authority to make it binding or not?

If so, did GS pull out because he knew a binding offer was not going to come and sensed the purpose of negotiations was to keep the ball in the air until other currently working coaches could be contacted?
 

ruman

Heisman
Nov 30, 2001
12,876
10,043
98
OK Financial Wizzard. Barchi wants sports free standing before we get full B1G share. Schiano is making HUGE monetary demands with strict timelines. Salary and Asst pool dont seem to be an issue (outside of length and guarantees possibly). Where do you propose the monies (3 to 4 times what the original plans were calling for and those were down the road a bit with Practice field being bigger priority and Hale center to be empty and ready for upgrades next year or so) come from? I hear donors large and small complaining that Hobbs couldnt get it done but I dont see anyone stepping forward with more money Just threats to stop donating. I will leave it here and you give me your solution to this problem
These are not idle threats - the donation spigot is going to run dry in a big way
 

FrankZ_RU93

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
25,571
11,243
113
It was touched on in another thread so it's out now but apparently there is a call today with Barchi, Brown, and about 30 former players. Their "requests" plus the money drain might be more than leadership is willing to stomach

What time is this call?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leonard23

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,216
90,383
113
It was touched on in another thread so it's out now but apparently there is a call today with Barchi, Brown, and about 30 former players. Their "requests" plus the money drain might be more than leadership is willing to stomach
So does that mean that this is not on Hobbs, but the unwillingness of the BOG to commit to the spend?
 

PeteGiam07

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2007
28,766
1,218
0
There has been some conflicting info that Hobbs did NOT even present it to the BOG.

In that case, could a binding offer ever have even been made to GS or was it only at the stage of discussion as to terms only?

To me a key point, as Hobbs is charged with the search and presenting candidates with recommendation to the BOG. Please stop with the he knew where the votes were etc. Not his role. Did he kill it before final authority to make it binding or not?

If so, did GS pull out because he knew a binding offer was not going to come and sensed the purpose of negotiations was to keep the ball in the air until other currently working coaches could be contacted?

I read somewhere Hobbs never presented the 8-year deal to the BOG just a 6-year deal. Can't remember where that came from though.
 

ATIOH

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2004
986
1,078
0
I tried telling folks you get good info and don't make **** up.


Uh, what?? I was holding off on doing this, but with all the follow up posts and my ****** mood today...

Here’s a small sample of @vkj91 posts in the last 48 hours. Going back and forth between - just my guess the deal is dead, to they’re still negotiating, to I heard definitively this was dead a week ago ********, to this is not over, to Greg never wanted to come, to donors aren’t wedded to Schiano, to former players don’t do or mean ****, to former players and donors are putting the squeeze on (a day after it’s reported publicly), to...

Hard to believe the same person wrote all of this. The only thing consistent over the last week (and past years) is not liking Schiano.

Well that’s 3 minutes I’ll never get back.



That makes me think deal is dead and he’s setting up his excuses. Purely my opinion....

It’s not anti GS. It’s anti 8 guaranteed years and yes, that’s the hold up

You guys are just mad that saint Greg really never wanted to come back here.

I knew this deal was dead last week and all the spin won’t change it was schiano who killed it

I’m gonna go with this is not over.

So the donors are gonna put their wallets away?

Good get the nfl players to pay for all his demands. Maybe they can supply the private jet.

there is a call today with Barchi, Brown, and about 30 former players. Their "requests" plus the money drain might be more than leadership is willing to stomach
 

RUforlife

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2002
3,444
4,218
0
They are not going to hire Schiano at this point no matter what, it would be seen as a total humiliation and capitulation and he and the boosters would be perceived as having way to much power. The best you are going to get is that they agree to spend some money on the next candidate. Schiano to Rutgers is dead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerzeyguy

rucoe89

All-American
Jul 31, 2001
13,479
7,602
113
Problem is all the scuttlebutt has rendered Hobbs powerless...he is a dead man walking So hiring an AD would mean hiring a Schiano puppet since no real solid AD will work with an autonomous coach...especially onevhe had no say in hiring.
And 5 years later this board will be complaining about how all the other sports are being starved and non-competitive.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,368
98
Uh, what?? I was holding off on doing this, but with all the follow up posts and my ****** mood today...

Here’s a small sample of @vkj91 posts in the last 48 hours. Going back and forth between - just my guess the deal is dead, to they’re still negotiating, to I heard definitively this was dead a week ago ********, to this is not over, to Greg never wanted to come, to donors aren’t wedded to Schiano, to former players don’t do or mean ****, to former players and donors are putting the squeeze on (a day after it’s reported publicly), to...

Hard to believe the same person wrote all of this. The only thing consistent over the last week (and past years) is not liking Schiano.

Well that’s 3 minutes I’ll never get back.
yes and you can see the difference between my opinion and when I have actual info. And again with the "I don't like Schiano" crap. I have tons of respect for Schiano and what he did while here. That doesn't change the fact, I personally don't believe he should be given an 8 year deal, or that he is some amazing head coach, or that he's the best coach we could get, or that he didn't negotiate like someone who really wanted the job. I still truly think if he wanted the job he'd be signed already. IF he was truly set on being here he wouldn't have wanted his buyout clause to be so ridiculous. I think both sides over played their hands. It also doesn't change the reality that his NFL players don't donate crap and the call and their "demands" has nothing to do with money.
 

Leonard23

Heisman
Feb 2, 2006
30,404
12,644
113
Wait a minute, if the BOG voted the contract down wouldn't it have been at a meeting that required 48 hours notice?
That's not how this works. They informally poll. If the votes are there, then they have a formal meeting and vote.
So does that mean that this is not on Hobbs, but the unwillingness of the BOG to commit to the spend?
Sounds like both, if the biggest donors are blaming Hobbs and the BOGs didn't take action to hire GS regardless of Hobbs input.
 

RUbot

All-Conference
Feb 2, 2002
1,377
1,485
113
These are not idle threats - the donation spigot is going to run dry in a big way


Will be hard to tell a difference from the trickle that it was from our ridiculously stingy fanbase. Go have a look at the back of the latest game program and the feeble number of donors we have at even the lowest donation level noted. Oher programs survive and thrive on the willingless of their fanbase to supplement the revenue sources for the program. Really no wonder our administration doesn't have the guts to commit to the demands and financial commitments GS is looking for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: czxqa

MOBFreehold

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2014
5,531
3,849
113
Typically an AD doesnt survive one bad football coach hire, your Hobbs guy must have pictures of someone or the Humanities Dept really likes him.

Ash was hired what 10 days after he got here...you really still believe Hobbs hired him? Brown has driven the football bus. Hundred percent behind Ash and now pushing Schiano and probably making back room promises that are tough to keep
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoobyCow

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,628
62,000
113
yes and you can see the difference between my opinion and when I have actual info. And again with the "I don't like Schiano" crap. I have tons of respect for Schiano and what he did while here. That doesn't change the fact, I personally don't believe he should be given an 8 year deal, or that he is some amazing head coach, or that he's the best coach we could get, or that he didn't negotiate like someone who really wanted the job. I still truly think if he wanted the job he'd be signed already. IF he was truly set on being here he wouldn't have wanted his buyout clause to be so ridiculous. I think both sides over played their hands. It also doesn't change the reality that his NFL players don't donate crap and the call and their "demands" has nothing to do with money.

I sure as hell hope this call involves them opening their wallets.
 

Knightmoves

Heisman
Jul 31, 2001
30,973
17,085
113
Why would Barchi take a phone call w Greg Brown and former FB players?

Barchi doesn’t want direct contact w the FB program.

Is Barchi acting as interim AD? Sounds fishy to me.
 

Leonard23

Heisman
Feb 2, 2006
30,404
12,644
113
 

Wolv RU

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2003
7,761
2,218
113
yes and you can see the difference between my opinion and when I have actual info. And again with the "I don't like Schiano" crap. I have tons of respect for Schiano and what he did while here. That doesn't change the fact, I personally don't believe he should be given an 8 year deal, or that he is some amazing head coach, or that he's the best coach we could get, or that he didn't negotiate like someone who really wanted the job. I still truly think if he wanted the job he'd be signed already. IF he was truly set on being here he wouldn't have wanted his buyout clause to be so ridiculous. I think both sides over played their hands. It also doesn't change the reality that his NFL players don't donate crap and the call and their "demands" has nothing to do with money.

Could not agree more. Especially with the concept that both sides overplayed their hands.

Hobbs really underestimated the Schiano momentum that had built up since late October. Schiano's reported demands could never realistically have been met.

The backlash/consequences for both I think were not expected. Maybe that will be enough to drive both sides back to the table.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vkj91

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,368
98
Could not agree more. Especially with the concept that both sides overplayed their hands.

Hobbs really underestimated the Schiano momentum that had built up since late October. Schiano's reported demands could never realistically have been met.

The backlash/consequences for both I think were not expected. Maybe that will be enough to drive both sides back to the table.
Only at Rutgers could you shut down communication with all candidates for almost a month only to walk away.
 

MOBFreehold

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2014
5,531
3,849
113
Only at Rutgers could you shut down communication with all candidates for almost a month only to walk away.

Well their top two guys had same agent and he told Davis to take a walk in order for Greg to be able to make his demands and hopefully achieve them. I have to think Davis will change agents because in any other search he would have still kept his foot in the door and possibly already been hired after Schiano walked or was shown the door whichever side you want to believe
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,368
98
Well their top two guys had same agent and he told Davis to take a walk in order for Greg to be able to make his demands and hopefully achieve them. I have to think Davis will change agents because in any other search he would have still kept his foot in the door and possibly already been hired after Schiano walked or was shown the door whichever side you want to believe
I heard jones never really withdrew his name
 

Ole Cabbagehead

All-American
Apr 21, 2011
8,075
6,323
0
Could not agree more. Especially with the concept that both sides overplayed their hands.

Hobbs really underestimated the Schiano momentum that had built up since late October. Schiano's reported demands could never realistically have been met.

The backlash/consequences for both I think were not expected. Maybe that will be enough to drive both sides back to the table.


Hobbs did this to himself. He made it so that Schiano was the only candidate. As a result, Schiano has become a symbol of the school's commitment to football.

The fans see the school's unwillingness to meet Schiano's demand as an unwillingness to commit to the football program. The players seemingly see it the same way. Had the interviews been done at the end of the year (or better yet at the end of last year), with all candidates at once it would have played out differently. If they interviewed everyone, and it wound up not being Schiano due to too many unreasonable demands, the fan base would have stomached it a lot better if it came at the same time a new coach was announced.
 
Last edited:

Ole Cabbagehead

All-American
Apr 21, 2011
8,075
6,323
0
I heard jones never really withdrew his name

That is the obvious play here if Schiano is unworkable. Call Butch Jones today, and offer him what Schiano turned down. Make the announcement tomorrow that you have a deal in principle. If you cannot get Jones, make the same offer to Bret Bielema.

Who knows, we may wind up better off. If Hobbs tries to hire Anthony Campanile or the Rams guy he will be friggin tarred and feathered. We are talking a full on mob outside his office with pitchforks and everything. I think the inclusion of those names in the NJAM piece makes all of the reporting HIGHLY suspect. The qualifications were clearly prior HC experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wolv RU

krup

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
70,133
10,066
0
Will be hard to tell a difference from the trickle that it was from our ridiculously stingy fanbase. Go have a look at the back of the latest game program and the feeble number of donors we have at even the lowest donation level noted. Oher programs survive and thrive on the willingless of their fanbase to supplement the revenue sources for the program. Really no wonder our administration doesn't have the guts to commit to the demands and financial commitments GS is looking for.
That's horses**t.

Hobbs has cost Rutgers more in annual ticket/parking/seatgift revenue from its peak than Schiano was asking for his pool of assistant money. Anyone with a brain could see that keeping Ash last offseason was going to cost more in lost revenue than Ash's annual salary, and Rutgers administration is surprised.
 

gtbb3115

All-Conference
Jul 12, 2016
2,333
1,920
113
yes and you can see the difference between my opinion and when I have actual info. And again with the "I don't like Schiano" crap. I have tons of respect for Schiano and what he did while here. That doesn't change the fact, I personally don't believe he should be given an 8 year deal, or that he is some amazing head coach, or that he's the best coach we could get, or that he didn't negotiate like someone who really wanted the job. I still truly think if he wanted the job he'd be signed already. IF he was truly set on being here he wouldn't have wanted his buyout clause to be so ridiculous. I think both sides over played their hands. It also doesn't change the reality that his NFL players don't donate crap and the call and their "demands" has nothing to do with money.
This is why I feel the way I do.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start