Is Lebby about to repeat 2025?....

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
60,871
32,210
113
I'm not sure about that but if we somehow only win 5, I would fire him. I think we will win 6 even without Kamario. Possibly 7 or 8 with him.
Agree about the 2nd part. If we get a few players back healthy soon, 7 wins is definitely still in the table. Could win 6 even without them. On the fence about firing him if we only won 5 without them. Ordinarily it would be a no brainer to fire him. But if we have to keep him to keep Kamario, man that would be a hard trigger to pull.
 

FactCheckerBot

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2025
640
1,076
93
On T&L’s latest episode, it is discussed that Lebby is the reason the team is in the shape it is in. We could possibly be 6-0 with a healthy K1. We could also be 5-1 with a serviceable QB2. But instead, Lebby had 2 huge mis-evaluations on transfer QBs and a horrible OL that got QB1 hurt in the first place. This on top of previous two years should provide all the motivation/reason the AD needs to find better options at HC.
 

Chesusdog

All-American
May 2, 2006
5,162
5,605
113
Ive been critical of him, but if Taylor and Bothwell can't play this weekend then I don't hold it against Lebby. We knew October was gonna be brutal, but we are in as good or better position than most predicted for this year. We need more talent and depth but you can't tell me we're not looking more like our aggressively average selves than we have in a long time.
 

msugolf

Senior
Dec 29, 2008
845
424
63
I think anyone with sense can see how this story ends. Lebby has proven he can’t build a roster and can’t hire quality coaches. He (or rather Kamario) will win just enough to bring him back. Or our alums fear of losing Kamario will bring him back.

Next year could be slightly better but I expect to still fall short of what we hope due to lack of surrounding pieces. 2028 will be a whole lot of the last 2-3 weeks. Next man up in 2029
 

RiceDawg

Sophomore
Aug 13, 2017
350
145
43
He did what he had to do in September to give him the breathing room for October. If we are 4-4 heading into the last four, he is still set up for a 7-5 season that assures him another year. 6-6 probably gets him back too, as long as the Egg Bowl isn't an embarrassing disaster.
I think we are going to win the Egg Bowl. Total gut feeling.
 

Howiefeltersnstch

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2019
2,957
3,601
98
My guess would be Lebby brings K1 back for Oklahoma and in the 2nd quarter we all realize it was too early as he limps off the field and into surgery. I kinda hope he holds him out until Texas even if they think he is good. We are in for an uphill climb without him. And why no talk about Fluff ? These backups will improve as the season goes on but not nearly fast enough. I honestly expected 9 maybe 10 wins this year. That dream is fading fast. 7 is looking more likely.
 

Howiefeltersnstch

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2019
2,957
3,601
98
Forget 2025. This team is currently playing like 2024. And they played that badly against Bama even with KT.

I've been patiently waiting for Lebby to prove he can be a successful head coach. He can't.
If K1 can run he isnt K1. He is not gonna play good until he is 90% healed. Him being a statue that cant push off when passing is a loss waiting to happen. Plus higher risk for further injury
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,376
13,203
113
I think anyone with sense can see how this story ends. Lebby has proven he can’t build a roster and can’t hire quality coaches. He (or rather Kamario) will win just enough to bring him back. Or our alums fear of losing Kamario will bring him back.

Next year could be slightly better but I expect to still fall short of what we hope due to lack of surrounding pieces. 2028 will be a whole lot of the last 2-3 weeks. Next man up in 2029
Yep, worst case scenario is playing out
 
  • Like
Reactions: RebChuck

POTUS

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
5,092
13,820
113
I've been saying since last year, we are going to improve but not so much that the haters will be satisfied. So 7-5 is the record. He'll be able to say he's improved every year, which he has. 2027 is the year. Retain K1. Improve the lines. Win 8-10 games. Which still won't satisfy some. But this has been visible on the horizon for a while. It's his MO at this point.
 

basedawg

Senior
Aug 22, 2012
1,048
821
113
I agree, we just need to get back on track offensive and score points! I don't think he will be fired after 3 years. just saying!
 
  • Like
Reactions: AROB44

TrueMaroonGrind

All-Conference
Jan 6, 2017
4,135
1,712
113
I don’t think so. We have already met last year with a TN Tech win. Auburn and Vandy are as winnable SEC games as you could ask for.

My hope is Oklahoma will be a get right game for the defense. If KT and Fluff play we can absolutely win. Getting just 1 game in October will be a shot in the arm for the final stretch.

PS. Hadad saying we could lose to TN Tech without K1 is wild. We lose that game and you can fire Lebby
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,376
13,203
113
I've been saying since last year, we are going to improve but not so much that the haters will be satisfied. So 7-5 is the record. He'll be able to say he's improved every year, which he has. 2027 is the year. Retain K1. Improve the lines. Win 8-10 games. Which still won't satisfy some. But this has been visible on the horizon for a while. It's his MO at this point.
If that scenario plays out, nobody will be complaining. Well, I take that back, the folks who are obsessed with Ole Miss will be crying about them beating us 3 times in a row. But 7-5 with retention of the roster will get us hype going into 2027. 8-10 wins has us likely in the expanded playoff.
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,417
2,951
113
If we repeat last year then firing is on the table. But we better have someone ‘better’ lined up otherwise I’d just as soon keep him for one more year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RebChuck

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
16,831
12,632
113
Vandy and Tenn tech are very winnable without KT. I think haveing Fluff without KT gives us a little better chance in a few of the other games.

I was just thinking, here we are basing decisions on keeping a coach or not by if we beat Vanderbilt and TN Tech but get totally exposed by the others. What a way to run a program................
 

Seinfeld

All-American
Nov 30, 2006
11,689
7,986
113
On T&L’s latest episode, it is discussed that Lebby is the reason the team is in the shape it is in. We could possibly be 6-0 with a healthy K1. We could also be 5-1 with a serviceable QB2. But instead, Lebby had 2 huge mis-evaluations on transfer QBs and a horrible OL that got QB1 hurt in the first place. This on top of previous two years should provide all the motivation/reason the AD needs to find better options at HC.
Something that Hadad also mentioned is that the team’s two most urgent portal needs were LT and a pass rusher, and Lebby completely whiffed on both.

No matter how you want to prioritize the team’s needs this offseason, aside from WR, why should fans have any confidence whatsoever on he and Arnett fixing them?
 

MSUDC11-2.0

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
11,045
17,875
113
So the consensus going into the year was we better win a lot in September because our October schedule is brutal.

Isn’t that kinda how it’s played out?

We still have 4 of our final 6 games at home, each of those against unranked teams.

We need Kamario back ASAP but I wouldn’t even say we’ve gotten off track yet. The runway to 7 or 8 wins is still very much there, and very realistic.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,376
13,203
113
I was just thinking, here we are basing decisions on keeping a coach or not by if we beat Vanderbilt and TN Tech but get totally exposed by the others. What a way to run a program................
I honestly don't think it's a decision at all. The administration is very committed to Lebby. Firing was never on the table unless we just completely tanked the season (which still could happen). But that's something where your hand must be forced. Barring some crazy lose out situation, or a mishandling of Taylor, Lebby will be back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,376
13,203
113
Something that Hadad also mentioned is that the team’s two most urgent portal needs were LT and a pass rusher, and Lebby completely whiffed on both.

No matter how you want to prioritize the team’s needs this offseason, aside from WR, why should fans have any confidence whatsoever on he and Arnett fixing them?
To ever think that we were going to fix a LT and DE issue in the portal, was a flawed concept to begin with. After QB those are the most sought after positions. It's not happening.

We actually did address those "needs", but the players just aren't as good as we wanted them to be.
 

msstatelp1

All-Conference
Aug 21, 2012
2,114
1,318
113
Like it or not if Lebby keeps improving we will be seen as a program that is slowly getting better. That will help us in getting better OL and DL. NIL will only do so much. We have to offer more than just $$$. “
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,671
8,026
113
2027 needs to have Lebby, Kamario and Fluff all back. I don't really care how things play out with our injuries this year.
Why Lebby? Make it make sense. I’m not saying don’t bring him back if we get to 8 wins or something, but he absolutely does not get a free pass at all just to preserve continuity.

KT and Fluff, sure. Love those guys. Do what we can to keep them.

But if they are both back in like 2 weeks, but we still stumble to 6-6, what is the incentive to bring back the coach who couldn’t do better than .500 with a generational talent at QB?

We already know that the price to keep KT in 2027 is going wayyyyyy up…..and that’s less available for supporting pieces. We need to stop acting like Lebby is the only offensive mind out there. Over half the damn SEC runs a similar system. It isn’t special.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "Everybody likes their team til you get hit in the mouth": Mississippi State group coming together with real test on the horizon
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State's Madison Francis named to All-SEC preseason group
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 7 Preview: Oklahoma Defense
  4. 04 Maroon and White Thomas Bassong's potential excites Mississippi State HC Chris Jans
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Former Mississippi State HC Jackie Sherrill given 2027 Paul "Bear" Bryant Lifetime Achievement Award