Indiana

Baxter48

All-Conference
Nov 2, 2015
1,181
1,412
103
If the transfer portal wasn’t in existence would Indiana be this successful?
 

BugsAreQualityProtein

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2021
2,558
1,201
103
Same with Vanderbilt. It will probably be their success that pushes CFB to institute some kind of enforceable rules with NIL and transfer portal.
 

itseasyas1-2-3

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2021
9,805
2,137
113
I’ll be interested to see what they do next year. They’ll have to find another top transfer QB to sustain success
Finding a high octane QB through the portal seems to be child's play for Cignetti. Last year the MAC kid who played very well til he injured his hand, this year Mendoza has been top notch.

Next year? He'll find a Big Sky or sub major conference kid that does what Cignetti requires. He isn't gonna bring in a guy that he has to change his offense for, he shops around to find the guy who is able to run that system, and he brings him in.
 

Zeke Husker

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2025
1,348
1,373
113
If the transfer portal wasn’t in existence would Indiana be this successful?
Remove NIL too, and they wouldn’t be anywhere close to this success. I’d see them as performing well enough to finish in the area of 4/5th in the big ten it doesn’t take a lot to get over the hump to that spot.
 

konaki

All-Conference
Oct 18, 2002
11,599
2,946
113
It's about what a head coaches culture is, you teach toughness you have a tough team you coddle players and they get beat by those tough coached teams every time. Indiana is coached by a coach who demands tough minded players who perform just that at practice and on the field. I like Matt Rhule as a salesman for the program but I do question his toughness as a coach. As a head coach he seems to want to be friends with players more than a coach who demands their best for their own good. jmo.
 

itseasyas1-2-3

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2021
9,805
2,137
113
Remove NIL too, and they wouldn’t be anywhere close to this success. I’d see them as performing well enough to finish in the area of 4/5th in the big ten it doesn’t take a lot to get over the hump to that spot.
It's not like CIgnetti went out and bought a high profile guy like Carson Beck, Dillon Gabriel or Michael Penix. He went into the bushes and found low profile guys that fit his system, plus, I presume he got them a helluva lot cheaper which allowed IND to sign maybe 1-2-3 more guys with some leftover money.

Mendoza is not even in the Top Ten of highest NIL QB's this year. Not 3-4 Million like a few. The number 10 guys gets $ 1.75 Million, that means Mendoza was purchased from the bargain bin.
 

B1G RED

Junior
Jun 2, 2022
295
335
63
Hard to say. Most of the time everybody thinks more money equal success, but Nebraska over the past decade has demonstrated that you can emulate the United States government and screw up everything with a lot of money.
 

Zeke Husker

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2025
1,348
1,373
113
It's not like CIgnetti went out and bought a high profile guy like Carson Beck, Dillon Gabriel or Michael Penix. He went into the bushes and found low profile guys that fit his system, plus, I presume he got them a helluva lot cheaper which allowed IND to sign maybe 1-2-3 more guys with some leftover money.

Mendoza is not even in the Top Ten of highest NIL QB's this year. Not 3-4 Million like a few. The number 10 guys gets $ 1.75 Million, that means Mendoza was purchased from the bargain bin.
My comment isn’t about the QB spot. It’s NIL period. Take it out and Indiana doesn’t recruit anyone much better than they have historically, at all positions.
 

huskerdude88

Junior
Jan 8, 2005
1,030
247
57
Our d-line is awful. Besides being slow and weak they are totally undisciplined. It's a game where we look to be making more mistakes than the other team and that never ends well for us.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: WHCSC

Truewooper

Senior
Jun 1, 2022
1,520
556
113
The transfer portal was a big help. He took all his best players from James Madison with him to Indiana and injected life into the program.
 

Ohana

Senior
Sep 26, 2025
894
994
93
Remove NIL too, and they wouldn’t be anywhere close to this success. I’d see them as performing well enough to finish in the area of 4/5th in the big ten it doesn’t take a lot to get over the hump to that spot.
if you took NIL 100% from every team , if you wanted to actually get the most out of yourself

you go to coaches who know what they are doing
 

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,415
4,007
113
I’ll bet Indiana fans are really sad to learn that Cignetti is only successful in the here and now, and might not have been as successful 20 years ago.

Really sucks to be them, I guess.
Right??? Ha

20 years ago, Cigs would have been there for two seasons and bolted.

Now, he will stay there until he retires because he can win there.
 

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,415
4,007
113
Cignetti and his staff are wicked good. Getting mostly unheralded players and turning them into what they are is big time coaching.
They also don't buy into this "oh my gosh, the Big Ten is so tough with tough coaches and tough players, just keeping a game close is a big deal" attitude.

Like all the rest of these ***** coaches in this conference do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GeorgeFlippin

itseasyas1-2-3

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2021
9,805
2,137
113
Yeah. It's easier to win when your transfer QB is under consideration to be the first pick in the draft.
So you think Mendoza wound up at IND by accident? You realize he was not even in the Top Ten QB's in the country for NIL?

If Cignetti found 2 low profile QB's from low profile colleges, you don't think he'll find another one next year? I do.
 

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,383
12,799
78
It's not like CIgnetti went out and bought a high profile guy like Carson Beck, Dillon Gabriel or Michael Penix. He went into the bushes and found low profile guys that fit his system, plus, I presume he got them a helluva lot cheaper which allowed IND to sign maybe 1-2-3 more guys with some leftover money.

Mendoza is not even in the Top Ten of highest NIL QB's this year. Not 3-4 Million like a few. The number 10 guys gets $ 1.75 Million, that means Mendoza was purchased from the bargain bin.
Mendoza while not the top name QB available last year appeared to me to be the most talented. Physically he was a rung above Beck.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: king_kong__

RBigredMax1

All-Conference
Jul 16, 2025
1,427
2,423
113
So you think Mendoza wound up at IND by accident? You realize he was not even in the Top Ten QB's in the country for NIL?

If Cignetti found 2 low profile QB's from low profile colleges, you don't think he'll find another one next year? I do.
Watched an interview on Cignetti and he spent a lot of time early in his career scouting players. He credited that time with allowing him to decipher the right attitude and talent that would fit his mold. He’s obviously mastered what that formula is. I’m extremely impressed by him and honestly I think it’s awesome he’s getting this well-deserved payday this late in his career.
 

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,383
12,799
78
James Madison was really good before the transfer portal. I wonder why?
Cignetti had a recruiting pipeline that ran through Bama. His association there got him some dudes. My personal belief that his connection with their S&C staff may have something to do with crappy teams suddenly becoming physically dominant.