IHSA Top 50 Programs

JAYC14

Sophomore
Nov 28, 2018
72
114
0
I love that the IHSA is releasing their top 50 programs to celebrate 50 years of the playoffs and state championships!
Any predictions on who the top programs will be?
I’m going with East St. Louis #3. Mount Carmel #2 and Joliet Catholic #1.
Catholic because of their 44 playoff appearances to Carmel’s 38.
Both programs have 20 trophies. (15 - 1st and 5 - 2nd).
Catholic also with an advantage by having a state title in all 6 decades.
Should be fun watching this countdown through the season.
 

Anon1754760634

All-American
May 29, 2001
76,845
9,142
113
I love that the IHSA is releasing their top 50 programs to celebrate 50 years of the playoffs and state championships!
Any predictions on who the top programs will be?
I’m going with East St. Louis #3. Mount Carmel #2 and Joliet Catholic #1.
Catholic because of their 44 playoff appearances to Carmel’s 38.
Both programs have 20 trophies. (15 - 1st and 5 - 2nd).
Catholic also with an advantage by having a state title in all 6 decades.
Should be fun watching this countdown through the season.
I was very honored to be able to contribute to that list
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
3,913
3,509
113
Interesting to see where Rochester and Driscoll Catholic end up.
it depends on the criteria. Both had amazing 10-15 year runs (Rochester still ongoing) but not sure if they're basing it purely on titles or consistency throughout the history of the IHSA playoffs which would hurt both schools. Same with schools like LWE who maybe haven't been around long enough.

Gonna be fun to see who is ranked where in the coming months.

Will there be different criteria for Catholic schools 😉
 
  • Like
Reactions: JAYC14

MC63

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
6,541
2,488
113
.
Both programs have 20 trophies. (15 - 1st and 5 - 2nd).
Is this nonsense starting over again?

Boy, this is going to make me popular all over again.

Those of you who've been around for a few years know my position on any school in Illinois comparing their program history and titles to Mt. Carmel's.

Thais is really getting old.
 
Last edited:

Kevin JCHS 81

All-Conference
Jul 16, 2005
1,893
1,503
0
Is this nonsense starting over again?

Boy, this is going to make me popular all over again.

Those of you who've been around for a few years know my position on any school in Illinois comparing their program history and titles to Mt. Carmel's.

Thais is really getting old.
Like a team that plays mostly 8A power teams and then collects 7A trophies?

7A is probably the weakest class of 4A through 8A. :)
 

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
310
355
63
it depends on the criteria. Both had amazing 10-15 year runs (Rochester still ongoing) but not sure if they're basing it purely on titles or consistency throughout the history of the IHSA playoffs which would hurt both schools. Same with schools like LWE who maybe haven't been around long enough.

Gonna be fun to see who is ranked where in the coming months.

Will there be different criteria for Catholic schools 😉
You also just described LA without mentioning them, which I agree with.
 

JCHillmen

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
3,377
1,350
0
It is an annoyance for anyone to dare compare their program's football to success to the esteemed MC!!

Looks like MC and JC are planning a nice pregame festivity to raise funds to help students in need at both Carmelite schools. I know most alums of these fine Carmelite schools are of similar mind in celebrating the other and not being so petty as to be counting trophies and trying to raise oneself up on a pedestal. It would be great if all alums and supporters of both schools showed the same grace, but there will always be some who don't fully understand or embrace the teachings of the programs that led to that wild level of success for both. Luckily it seems to be a loud minority of one who the others seem to roll their eyes at and move on.

When the position is that you "know my position on any school in Illinois comparing their program history and titles to Mt. Carmel" well then that just about sums it up. I can't fathom a stance where there is just absolutely no room for discussion or comparison. Especially when there is another program with more wins and another with an equal amount of titles.
 
Last edited:

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
310
355
63
It is an annoyance for anyone to dare compare their program's football to success to the esteemed MC!!

Looks like MC and JC are planning a nice pregame festivity to raise funds to help students in need at both Carmelite schools. I know most alums of these fine Carmelite schools are of similar mind in celebrating the other and not being so petty as to be counting trophies and trying to raise oneself up on a pedestal. It would be great if all alums and supporters of both schools showed the same grace, but there will always be some who don't fully understand or embrace the teachings of the programs that led to that wild level of success for both. Luckily it seems to be a loud minority of one who the others seem to roll their eyes at and move on.

When the position is that you "know my position on any school in Illinois comparing their program history and titles to Mt. Carmel" well then that just about sums it up. I can't fathom a stance where there is just absolutely no room for discussion or comparison. Especially when there is another program with more wins and another with an equal amount of titles.
Well said
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,335
9,280
113
Appreciate your protest. Where should they be ranked?
Top 25. From 1-5A, with rules written specifically for them, Althoff finds a way to get back to the top.

As the ihsa recap notes, our 89 and 90 schedules were mostly 6A and we were filled with D1 athletes. Football enrollment was referred to as the Althoff rule when it was first being developed and implemented. Schools like Harrisburg flipped their 💩 when we beat them twice in the quarters and semis in football, then beat them again in the finals for baseball. DiQuoin was another, Princeton pitched a fit too. Monitcello twice too.

We have done it by ground and pound and through the air. We have arguably three of the best ever running backs in IHsa history. Hickey Dale Thompson, Jason Ford, and Dierre Hill.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JAYC14 and USD24

MC63

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
6,541
2,488
113
there is another program with more wins and another with an equal amount of titles.
Both are certainly open to analysis -- which I have over the years

The majority of our wins were in the CCL - certainly the toughest league in the state's history.

are titles, we compete in the playoffs against teams within our ststure, No CCL or ESCC team z9except for the very tiny schools) should compete below 6A.

BTW, your guy was did the trophy counting.
 

wildkit_fan

Junior
Aug 22, 2007
483
358
55
I love that the IHSA is releasing their top 50 programs to celebrate 50 years of the playoffs and state championships!
Any predictions on who the top programs will be?
I’m going with East St. Louis #3. Mount Carmel #2 and Joliet Catholic #1.
Catholic because of their 44 playoff appearances to Carmel’s 38.
Both programs have 20 trophies. (15 - 1st and 5 - 2nd).
Catholic also with an advantage by having a state title in all 6 decades.
Should be fun watching this countdown through the season.
Obviously no agreed way to weight Champ vs Runner Up, so I just made up 3 pts for Champs, 1 for Runner Up and came up with these rankings (54 teams because of ties at 49):
RankTeamChampRunner UpPts
1​
Joliet (Catholic Academy)
15​
5​
50​
1​
Chicago (Mt. Carmel)
15​
5​
50​
3​
East St. Louis (Sr.)
10​
5​
35​
4​
New Lenox (Providence Catholic)
10​
4​
34​
5​
Rochester
9​
0​
27​
6​
Addison (Driscoll)
8​
0​
24​
7​
Wheaton (W. Warrenville South)
7​
2​
23​
8​
Park Ridge (Maine South)
6​
4​
22​
8​
Springfield (Sacred Heart-Griffin)
6​
4​
22​
10​
Lombard (Montini)
6​
3​
21​
11​
Sterling (Newman Central Catholic)
6​
2​
20​
11​
Wilmette (Loyola Academy)
5​
5​
20​
13​
Kankakee (McNamara)
5​
4​
19​
13​
Lena (L.-Winslow)
6​
1​
19​
15​
Morris
3​
8​
17​
15​
LaGrange Park (Nazareth Academy)
5​
2​
17​
18​
Metamora
3​
7​
16​
18​
Geneseo (Darnall)
4​
4​
16​
18​
Stillman Valley
5​
1​
16​
21​
Arcola
4​
3​
15​
21​
Bloomington (Central Catholic)
4​
3​
15​
21​
Carthage
4​
3​
15​
21​
Cary (C.-Grove)
4​
3​
15​
25​
Decatur (St. Teresa)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Woodstock (Marian)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Maroa (M.-Forsyth)
2​
8​
14​
28​
Wheaton (North)
4​
0​
12​
28​
Aledo
3​
3​
12​
28​
Frankfort (Lincoln-Way East)
3​
3​
12​
28​
Elmhurst (IC Catholic)
4​
0​
12​
33​
Belleville (Althoff Catholic)
3​
2​
11​
33​
Glen Ellyn (Glenbard West)
3​
2​
11​
33​
DuQuoin (H.S.)
2​
5​
11​
33​
Byron
3​
2​
11​
33​
Crystal Lake (Prairie Ridge)
3​
2​
11​
38​
Hampshire
3​
1​
10​
38​
Stockton
2​
4​
10​
38​
Galena (H.S.)
3​
1​
10​
38​
Tuscola
2​
4​
10​
38​
Wilmington
3​
1​
10​
43​
Freeport (Aquin)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Mt. Prospect (Prospect)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Lockport (Twp.)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Dakota
3​
0​
9​
43​
Forreston
3​
0​
9​
49​
Concord (Triopia)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Chicago (St. Rita)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Mt. Carmel
1​
5​
8​
49​
Peoria (Richwoods)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Oak Lawn (Richards)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Moweaqua (Central A & M)
1​
5​
8​
49​
Naperville (Central)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Batavia
2​
2​
8​
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,182
2,457
93
Both are certainly open to analysis -- which I have over the years

The majority of our wins were in the CCL - certainly the toughest league in the state's history.

are titles, we compete in the playoffs against teams within our ststure, No CCL or ESCC team z9except for the very tiny schools) should compete below 6A.

BTW, your guy was did the trophy counting.
The only team in the CCL that can brag is MC as ESL has beaten all others including MC once. The notion that somehow winning in the CCL is something superior is a laughable argument. A win is a win period.
 

Kevin JCHS 81

All-Conference
Jul 16, 2005
1,893
1,503
0
Like a team that plays mostly 8A power teams and then collects 7A trophies?

7A is probably the weakest class of 4A through 8A. :)
To the rest of the board.: Thank you for not totally bashing my semi ridiculous reply to MC63. :)

To MC63.: It's not MC's fault that they keep falling into the easiest class for padding the old trophy case.
 
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: WIU78 and Gene K.

MC63

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
6,541
2,488
113
The only team in the CCL that can brag is MC as ESL has beaten all others including MC once. The notion that somehow winning in the CCL is something superior is a laughable argument. A win is a win period.
That's rich.
 

ClownBaby

Heisman
Oct 26, 2006
22,617
77,615
113
Obviously no agreed way to weight Champ vs Runner Up, so I just made up 3 pts for Champs, 1 for Runner Up and came up with these rankings (54 teams because of ties at 49):
RankTeamChampRunner UpPts
1​
Joliet (Catholic Academy)
15​
5​
50​
1​
Chicago (Mt. Carmel)
15​
5​
50​
3​
East St. Louis (Sr.)
10​
5​
35​
4​
New Lenox (Providence Catholic)
10​
4​
34​
5​
Rochester
9​
0​
27​
6​
Addison (Driscoll)
8​
0​
24​
7​
Wheaton (W. Warrenville South)
7​
2​
23​
8​
Park Ridge (Maine South)
6​
4​
22​
8​
Springfield (Sacred Heart-Griffin)
6​
4​
22​
10​
Lombard (Montini)
6​
3​
21​
11​
Sterling (Newman Central Catholic)
6​
2​
20​
11​
Wilmette (Loyola Academy)
5​
5​
20​
13​
Kankakee (McNamara)
5​
4​
19​
13​
Lena (L.-Winslow)
6​
1​
19​
15​
Morris
3​
8​
17​
15​
LaGrange Park (Nazareth Academy)
5​
2​
17​
18​
Metamora
3​
7​
16​
18​
Geneseo (Darnall)
4​
4​
16​
18​
Stillman Valley
5​
1​
16​
21​
Arcola
4​
3​
15​
21​
Bloomington (Central Catholic)
4​
3​
15​
21​
Carthage
4​
3​
15​
21​
Cary (C.-Grove)
4​
3​
15​
25​
Decatur (St. Teresa)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Woodstock (Marian)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Maroa (M.-Forsyth)
2​
8​
14​
28​
Wheaton (North)
4​
0​
12​
28​
Aledo
3​
3​
12​
28​
Frankfort (Lincoln-Way East)
3​
3​
12​
28​
Elmhurst (IC Catholic)
4​
0​
12​
33​
Belleville (Althoff Catholic)
3​
2​
11​
33​
Glen Ellyn (Glenbard West)
3​
2​
11​
33​
DuQuoin (H.S.)
2​
5​
11​
33​
Byron
3​
2​
11​
33​
Crystal Lake (Prairie Ridge)
3​
2​
11​
38​
Hampshire
3​
1​
10​
38​
Stockton
2​
4​
10​
38​
Galena (H.S.)
3​
1​
10​
38​
Tuscola
2​
4​
10​
38​
Wilmington
3​
1​
10​
43​
Freeport (Aquin)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Mt. Prospect (Prospect)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Lockport (Twp.)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Dakota
3​
0​
9​
43​
Forreston
3​
0​
9​
49​
Concord (Triopia)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Chicago (St. Rita)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Mt. Carmel
1​
5​
8​
49​
Peoria (Richwoods)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Oak Lawn (Richards)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Moweaqua (Central A & M)
1​
5​
8​
49​
Naperville (Central)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Batavia
2​
2​
8​
The IHSA includes Wheaton Central with WWS basically it’s the same students in a different building. The 91 WC and 92 WWS teams had the same coaches and kids, so it should be 7 titles and 4 Runner ups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wildkit_fan

cornerrat

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2009
2,368
1,727
0
Obviously no agreed way to weight Champ vs Runner Up, so I just made up 3 pts for Champs, 1 for Runner Up and came up with these rankings (54 teams because of ties at 49):
RankTeamChampRunner UpPts
1​
Joliet (Catholic Academy)
15​
5​
50​
1​
Chicago (Mt. Carmel)
15​
5​
50​
3​
East St. Louis (Sr.)
10​
5​
35​
4​
New Lenox (Providence Catholic)
10​
4​
34​
5​
Rochester
9​
0​
27​
6​
Addison (Driscoll)
8​
0​
24​
7​
Wheaton (W. Warrenville South)
7​
2​
23​
8​
Park Ridge (Maine South)
6​
4​
22​
8​
Springfield (Sacred Heart-Griffin)
6​
4​
22​
10​
Lombard (Montini)
6​
3​
21​
11​
Sterling (Newman Central Catholic)
6​
2​
20​
11​
Wilmette (Loyola Academy)
5​
5​
20​
13​
Kankakee (McNamara)
5​
4​
19​
13​
Lena (L.-Winslow)
6​
1​
19​
15​
Morris
3​
8​
17​
15​
LaGrange Park (Nazareth Academy)
5​
2​
17​
18​
Metamora
3​
7​
16​
18​
Geneseo (Darnall)
4​
4​
16​
18​
Stillman Valley
5​
1​
16​
21​
Arcola
4​
3​
15​
21​
Bloomington (Central Catholic)
4​
3​
15​
21​
Carthage
4​
3​
15​
21​
Cary (C.-Grove)
4​
3​
15​
25​
Decatur (St. Teresa)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Woodstock (Marian)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Maroa (M.-Forsyth)
2​
8​
14​
28​
Wheaton (North)
4​
0​
12​
28​
Aledo
3​
3​
12​
28​
Frankfort (Lincoln-Way East)
3​
3​
12​
28​
Elmhurst (IC Catholic)
4​
0​
12​
33​
Belleville (Althoff Catholic)
3​
2​
11​
33​
Glen Ellyn (Glenbard West)
3​
2​
11​
33​
DuQuoin (H.S.)
2​
5​
11​
33​
Byron
3​
2​
11​
33​
Crystal Lake (Prairie Ridge)
3​
2​
11​
38​
Hampshire
3​
1​
10​
38​
Stockton
2​
4​
10​
38​
Galena (H.S.)
3​
1​
10​
38​
Tuscola
2​
4​
10​
38​
Wilmington
3​
1​
10​
43​
Freeport (Aquin)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Mt. Prospect (Prospect)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Lockport (Twp.)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Dakota
3​
0​
9​
43​
Forreston
3​
0​
9​
49​
Concord (Triopia)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Chicago (St. Rita)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Mt. Carmel
1​
5​
8​
49​
Peoria (Richwoods)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Oak Lawn (Richards)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Moweaqua (Central A & M)
1​
5​
8​
49​
Naperville (Central)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Batavia
2​
2​
8​
All.... Fwiw the Cyclones are at 6-6. Two 2nd place finishes before the nuns at Sacred Heart allowed the boys to join the girls . Alumni fought hard to call it Griffin-Sacred Heart but the nuns controlled the purse strings. (still do) I heard that first year the school went co-ed was lots of fun. Especially for the lads. Ratsy
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,182
2,457
93
False. Joliet Catholic is 1-0 vs ESL in the playoff era having defeated the Flyers in the IHSA 5A playoffs 45-8 in 1996.
JC is ESCC not CCL. I can edit my original response if that helps. I know what his post was referring to. I am good with pointing that out the L to JC. Again a loss is a loss just like a win is a win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: USD24

MC63

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
6,541
2,488
113
The only team in the CCL that can brag is MC as ESL has beaten all others including MC once. The notion that somehow winning in the CCL is something superior is a laughable argument. A win is a win period.
in four or five tries
 
  • Like
Reactions: kwamizee

zoocp

Redshirt
Nov 4, 2017
26
26
13
Top 25. From 1-5A, with rules written specifically for them, Althoff finds a way to get back to the top.

As the ihsa recap notes, our 89 and 90 schedules were mostly 6A and we were filled with D1 athletes. Football enrollment was referred to as the Althoff rule when it was first being developed and implemented. Schools like Harrisburg flipped their 💩 when we beat them twice in the quarters and semis in football, then beat them again in the finals for baseball. DiQuoin was another, Princeton pitched a fit too.

We have done it by ground and pound and through the air. We have arguably three of the best ever running backs in IHsa history. Hickey Dale Thompson, Jason, Ford, and Dierre Hill.
I'm getting close to calling Dierre the best now, at Althoff. Hickey had a better run blocking line, but played better overall competition, so I'm still unsure in an opinion . Also, I think Bester was every bit as good as Ford. Just a different type of back. Ford was a specimen though!
 
  • Like
Reactions: crusader_of_90

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,335
9,280
113
I'm getting close to calling Dierre the best now, at Althoff. Hickey had a better run blocking line, but played better overall competition, so I'm still unsure in an opinion . Also, I think Bester was every bit as good as Ford. Just a different type of back. Ford was a specimen though!
Ford trucked dudes as a freshman! He was a man among boys at 14.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zoocp67

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,335
9,280
113
Hickey had a better run blocking line, but played better overall competition.
I remember coming in at guard due to a helmet issue with the starter, 25 slant trap, he skimmed off my backside and bulldoezed All-American Linebacker Emerson Wells from Paducah Tilghman and took it to the house. Dierre will not play anyone like we did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zoocp67

Silver Rain

All-Conference
Jun 6, 2022
1,316
1,453
78
Obviously no agreed way to weight Champ vs Runner Up, so I just made up 3 pts for Champs, 1 for Runner Up and came up with these rankings (54 teams because of ties at 49):
RankTeamChampRunner UpPts
1​
Joliet (Catholic Academy)
15​
5​
50​
1​
Chicago (Mt. Carmel)
15​
5​
50​
3​
East St. Louis (Sr.)
10​
5​
35​
4​
New Lenox (Providence Catholic)
10​
4​
34​
5​
Rochester
9​
0​
27​
6​
Addison (Driscoll)
8​
0​
24​
7​
Wheaton (W. Warrenville South)
7​
2​
23​
8​
Park Ridge (Maine South)
6​
4​
22​
8​
Springfield (Sacred Heart-Griffin)
6​
4​
22​
10​
Lombard (Montini)
6​
3​
21​
11​
Sterling (Newman Central Catholic)
6​
2​
20​
11​
Wilmette (Loyola Academy)
5​
5​
20​
13​
Kankakee (McNamara)
5​
4​
19​
13​
Lena (L.-Winslow)
6​
1​
19​
15​
Morris
3​
8​
17​
15​
LaGrange Park (Nazareth Academy)
5​
2​
17​
18​
Metamora
3​
7​
16​
18​
Geneseo (Darnall)
4​
4​
16​
18​
Stillman Valley
5​
1​
16​
21​
Arcola
4​
3​
15​
21​
Bloomington (Central Catholic)
4​
3​
15​
21​
Carthage
4​
3​
15​
21​
Cary (C.-Grove)
4​
3​
15​
25​
Decatur (St. Teresa)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Woodstock (Marian)
4​
2​
14​
25​
Maroa (M.-Forsyth)
2​
8​
14​
28​
Wheaton (North)
4​
0​
12​
28​
Aledo
3​
3​
12​
28​
Frankfort (Lincoln-Way East)
3​
3​
12​
28​
Elmhurst (IC Catholic)
4​
0​
12​
33​
Belleville (Althoff Catholic)
3​
2​
11​
33​
Glen Ellyn (Glenbard West)
3​
2​
11​
33​
DuQuoin (H.S.)
2​
5​
11​
33​
Byron
3​
2​
11​
33​
Crystal Lake (Prairie Ridge)
3​
2​
11​
38​
Hampshire
3​
1​
10​
38​
Stockton
2​
4​
10​
38​
Galena (H.S.)
3​
1​
10​
38​
Tuscola
2​
4​
10​
38​
Wilmington
3​
1​
10​
43​
Freeport (Aquin)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Mt. Prospect (Prospect)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Lockport (Twp.)
3​
0​
9​
43​
Dakota
3​
0​
9​
43​
Forreston
3​
0​
9​
49​
Concord (Triopia)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Chicago (St. Rita)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Mt. Carmel
1​
5​
8​
49​
Peoria (Richwoods)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Oak Lawn (Richards)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Moweaqua (Central A & M)
1​
5​
8​
49​
Naperville (Central)
2​
2​
8​
49​
Batavia
2​
2​
8​

Is Loyola there yet?
 

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
310
355
63
Obviously no agreed way to weight Champ vs Runner Up, so I just made up 3 pts for Champs, 1 for Runner Up and came up with these rankings (54 teams because of ties at 49):


Is Loyola there yet?
After their extraordinary run in the last ten years, they are in 11th place acrobatics chart.