Time to take a look...we got some good ones boys
The problem here is anything regarding making it more difficult for privates will pass since the overwhelming majority of those voting are public.2.5 multiplier is absurd. And when that doesnt satisfy people, do we just increase it more?
Rosarie (Aurora) with 200 girls would have a classification enrollment of 1000. Give me a break.
Quadrant rule makes no sense. Boundried schools are capable of competing with non-boundried, but not until the semis? Which quadrant gets to play the non-boundried in the semis? A lot of ambiguity in the language of that proposal. A potential 2-2 quadrant split is mentioned at one point. Does this mean that non-boundaried schools could potentially be guaranteed 50 percent representation in the state tournament? This proposal reads like school yard home run derby rules....
The privates are eventually just going to do their own thing. Time to resurrect the Prep Bowl to its former pre-IHSA glory?![]()
May be harder if one of the proposals passes. There's one where it would require a super majority of 66.7% to pass proposals versus the simple majority we have now.The problem here is anything regarding making it more difficult for privates will pass since the overwhelming majority of those voting are public.
If it gets to the ballot. A lot of stuff never gets that far.The problem here is anything regarding making it more difficult for privates will pass since the overwhelming majority of those voting are public.
This is a mustMay be harder if one of the proposals passes. There's one where it would require a super majority of 66.7% to pass proposals versus the simple majority we have now.
The reasonings listed for the proposals on separation/limiting of private/public paths to finals, multiplier changes, transfers and residency sound like they have read this board.
Side note: shortening the games played for almost all other sports? WTH...not a fan. The language used for those sound like it was written with the help of a big IHSA twitter guy who is always stating #morethanJUSTgames
This is an expense reduction action especially now that shot clock operators also have to be paid in basketball. And the suburban conferences can no longer collude to fix the cost they pay officials across the board.This may be the one of the few proposals that I don't hate beside the common sense one on flag football. No way a soccer team should be playing 25 regular season games, and most don't.
It only makes sense if you win a ton of blowouts and can give a ton of minutes to 2nd string. Good rule to protect against unscrupulous coaches.
Both are great points and make sense. I suppose I just don't like it for the spring outdoor sports, which the weather sucks and can already hamper getting games in. Would prefer to not take more games away from those who want to play. Not sure it's needs to be a rule. Just because the limit is 35 games or whatever doesn't mean you have to play them. Play whatever you feel fits your situation best.This is an expense reduction action especially now that shot clock operators also have to be paid in basketball. And the suburban conferences can no longer collude to fix the cost they pay officials across the board.
Secondarily, it's a way to relieve the difficulty in finding officials (just because officials might be on every game doesn't mean there isn't a shortage).
As an official, I'd like to see teams take more practice time and get better by having fewer games as well. The quality of the game may improve.
Not necessarily. Those private schools are going to end up somewhere, and that somewhere is in the upper third of all tournament brackets. There’s a reason that this stuff usually gets shut down. I’ve got a friend that’s an A.D. at a larger public school. Do you think the majority of 6A, 7A, and 8A football schools want to have their bracket flooded with more private schools? Same thing for 3A and 4A in all other sports. Not to mention the large number of public schools that run competent athletic programs and compete just fine. Not every private school is Mount Carmel, Loyola, etc. Most athletic administrators with a brain are able to realize that.The problem here is anything regarding making it more difficult for privates will pass since the overwhelming majority of those voting are public.
You are 100 percent correct. And for what it’s worth, there’s never been more cohesion and unity amongst the CCL members. It’s no coincidence that the CCL/ESCC merge occurred prior to this year for all sports, not just football. The girls conferences did the same. Separation is obviously not the goal, but they’ll be ready for it if and when the time comes. And the IHSA will be left with an empty bag.Saying this as an enjoyer of high school sports across all conferences and regions of the state:
You push the private schools out, they will only become more powerful and desirable. I do not have answers to how to make things "more equitable" but do not underestimate the connections and reach that these Catholic/Private schools have in the Chicagoland area
I'm not sure I understand this statement. Are you saying that nobody will be drawn to the IHSA events if the private schools aren't part of it?... And the IHSA will be left with an empty bag.
Saying this as an enjoyer of high school sports across all conferences and regions of the state:
You push the private schools out, they will only become more powerful and desirable. I do not have answers to how to make things "more equitable" but do not underestimate the connections and reach that these Catholic/Private schools have in the Chicagoland area
Please explain how they would become more powerful and desirable?Saying this as an enjoyer of high school sports across all conferences and regions of the state:
You push the private schools out, they will only become more powerful and desirable. I do not have answers to how to make things "more equitable" but do not underestimate the connections and reach that these Catholic/Private schools have in the Chicagoland ar
Not speaking for him but the IHSA product would diminish w/o privates.I'm not sure I understand this statement. Are you saying that nobody will be drawn to the IHSA events if the private schools aren't part of it?
There would be no recruiting rules. Nothing stopping them for knocking on your public schools best players door and giving him a full scholarship to your school.Please explain how they would become more powerful and desirable?
How many private schools are barely keeping their doors open? You think they will be able to afford to provide every athlete they want with a scholarship?There would be no recruiting rules. Nothing stopping them for knocking on your public schools best players door and giving him a full scholarship to your school.
Imagine Lynch with no 30 mile radius, being able to recruit kids enrolled elsewhere, give athletic scholarships, etc…
Furthermore, it’s just human nature that when the standards are lowered, people lower their expectations. So, if privates leave, it’s easier to win a state championship so programs don’t work as hard.
There would be no recruiting rules. Nothing stopping them for knocking on your public schools best players door and giving him a full scholarship to your school.
Imagine Lynch with no 30 mile radius, being able to recruit kids enrolled elsewhere, give athletic scholarships, etc…
Furthermore, it’s just human nature that when the standards are lowered, people lower their expectations. So, if privates leave, it’s easier to win a state championship so programs don’t work as hard.
Beat me too it. Not sure where the influx of scholarship money is coming from if private schools leave the IHSA.How many private schools are barely keeping their doors open? You think they will be able to afford to provide every athlete they want with a scholarship?
Do you think public school administration cares now if they win state titles? They dont they will still provide the same amount of funding and coaching stipends with or without private schools associated with the IHSA.
The people that care about the Privates leaving the IHSA are on this message board. The vast majority of "normal" parents do not care.
Let the Privates leave they think they will have this big following, get large TV contracts, pack Solider Field. The world has changed those things are not going to happen.
Don't have to imagine because he already does this.There would be no recruiting rules. Nothing stopping them for knocking on your public schools best players door and giving him a full scholarship to your school.
Imagine Lynch with no 30 mile radius, being able to recruit kids enrolled elsewhere, give athletic scholarships, etc…
Furthermore, it’s just human nature that when the standards are lowered, people lower their expectations. So, if privates leave, it’s easier to win a state championship so programs don’t work as hard.
Have you not been following youth sports? Parents are spending ridiculous amounts of money for their kids to play on the best teams and get the best training. If publics/privates separate, the top end privates will become IMG like programs and parents will want their kids on these teams.How many private schools are barely keeping their doors open? You think they will be able to afford to provide every athlete they want with a scholarship?
Do you think public school administration cares now if they win state titles? They dont they will still provide the same amount of funding and coaching stipends with or without private schools associated with the IHSA.
The people that care about the Privates leaving the IHSA are on this message board. The vast majority of "normal" parents do not care.
Let the Privates leave they think they will have this big following, get large TV contracts, pack Solider Field. The world has changed those things are not going to happen.
The athletes remaining in the IHSA, and for whom the IHSA serves, would not believe that. And that's really all that matters.Not speaking for him but the IHSA product would diminish w/o privates.
So why would parents wait for a potential split? What's stopping them from turning Privates into IMG right now?Have you not been following youth sports? Parents are spending ridiculous amounts of money for their kids to play on the best teams and get the best training. If publics/privates separate, the top end privates will become IMG like programs and parents will want their kids on these teams.
There are privates that are well funded and there are others that are just holding on. The top ends one's are the one's I'm referring too.
Generally speaking, those same parents already have their kids playing at the top end privates.Have you not been following youth sports? Parents are spending ridiculous amounts of money for their kids to play on the best teams and get the best training. If publics/privates separate, the top end privates will become IMG like programs and parents will want their kids on these teams.
There are privates that are well funded and there are others that are just holding on. The top ends one's are the one's I'm referring too.
The IHSA doesn't allow athletic scholarships. If they are not in the picture, privates will now start giving them out.Beat me too it. Not sure where the influx of scholarship money is coming from if private schools leave the IHSA.
Also, what makes people think kids would just flock to private schools? I think leaving hurts them more than it helps. Right now there's around 500 schools playing football and non boundary schools make up about 15%, so that's 75 schools give or take, regardless of enrollment. Good luck filling schedules year in and year out. MC playing the same 9 teams every year isn't going to have the appeal you think it will.
Then there's the part everyone here always leaves out and that's EVEY OTHER SPORT. Who do teams outside the Chicagoland area fill there schedules with in swimming, tennis, soccer, etc.? Who does a school like Ottawa Marquette play in any of their sports? Or the handful of downstate non boundary schools?
If they want to take their balls and go to the NIPL I don't think the grass will be as green as some of you think it will be.
The IHSA.So why would parents wait for a potential split? What's stopping them from turning Privates into IMG right now?
Are you saying the quality of HS sports is much lower than what it was 20 years ago? If so, It's the exact opposite.Generally speaking, those same parents already have their kids playing at the top end privates.
From an adult's perspective, the quality of the product is already much lower over the last 20 years than it used to be ... across all the sports (I'm on the fence about if that's true about football but I think it has to be with the decline in participation).
But the kids who are currently participating don't know that and wouldn't (and shouldn't) care if they did know.
It isn't about us.
Then the private schools throwing around all this money they magically found when they left the IHSA will have to deal with all the parents of non athletes asking where their kids scholarship is.The IHSA doesn't allow athletic scholarships. If they are not in the picture, privates will now start giving them out.
I think parents with the means will have no problem paying for kids tuitions to come play with their kids. Just my opinion...
What are you not understanding???Then the private schools throwing around all this money they magically found when they left the IHSA will have to deal with all the parents of non athletes asking where their kids scholarship is.
This is a terrible hypothetical that would never happen. No private school has the funds to just start throwing around $15k or more full scholarships.
Academics, higher standards, better program, alumni base, etc....Beat me too it. Not sure where the influx of scholarship money is coming from if private schools leave the IHSA.
Also, what makes people think kids would just flock to private schools? I think leaving hurts them more than it helps. Right now there's around 500 schools playing football and non boundary schools make up about 15%, so that's 75 schools give or take, regardless of enrollment. Good luck filling schedules year in and year out. MC playing the same 9 teams every year isn't going to have the appeal you think it will.
Then there's the part everyone here always leaves out and that's EVEY OTHER SPORT. Who do teams outside the Chicagoland area fill there schedules with in swimming, tennis, soccer, etc.? Who does a school like Ottawa Marquette play in any of their sports? Or the handful of downstate non boundary schools?
If they want to take their balls and go to the NIPL I don't think the grass will be as green as some of you think it will be.
I don't know where you come up with some of this stuff. Let me see if I got the straight, so private schools are going to leave the IHSA and parents, who more than likely don't care at all one way or another if they're in the IHSA or not, are going to decide to give more money to the school to bring in more athletes? If that's case then why in God's name would they not just continue to pay their own child's tuition like they already do?What are you not understanding???
Parents now aren't allowed to pay for other students tuitions. Donors now can't give money and direct it towards athletic scholarships. Without the IHSA....that all changes.
Non-athletes would still get scholarships. Nothing there would change.
All of those things are subjective and based on what each family feels. Parents aren't going to pull their kids out of LWW and send them to Provi just because they're no longer in the IHSA.Academics, higher standards, better program, alumni base, etc....
If providence gives them free tuition...sure they would.All of those things are subjective and based on what each family feels. Parents aren't going to pull their kids out of LWW and send them to Provi just because they're no longer in the IHSA.
Again, you're not understanding. Your scenario of just moving money around is not at all what I'm saying. But, I don't care to discuss this further.I don't know where you come up with some of this stuff. Let me see if I got the straight, so private schools are going to leave the IHSA and parents, who more than likely don't care at all one way or another if they're in the IHSA or not, are going to decide to give more money to the school to bring in more athletes? If that's case then why in God's name would they not just continue to pay their own child's tuition like they already do?
In your scenario family #1 would donate money so family #2's star athlete could go to that private school and family #3 would donate money so family #1's kid could go to that school. It's just moving money around, not generating more. Family #1 isn't going to pay their tuition AND the tuition for family #2 just because thst school is no longer in the IHSA.
I am understanding. These donor are already giving money to schools. They most likely already are providing scholarhips to these schools (yes academic and needs based ones which are alowed).What are you not understanding???
Parents now aren't allowed to pay for other students tuitions. Donors now can't give money and direct it towards athletic scholarships. Without the IHSA....that all changes.
Non-athletes would still get scholarships. Nothing there would change.