Ignatius 31 ICCP 14 - Final

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
315
360
63
Ic will have a hard time making the playoffs
…I know. They’re a good squad but their schedule is tough. I don’t want to get it started but…if teams like Rochester had to play the caliber of competition that a school like IC is, they’d be on the bubble too
 

Gestalt45

Sophomore
Oct 26, 2023
175
135
43
…I know. They’re a good squad but their schedule is tough. I don’t want to get it started but…if teams like Rochester had to play the caliber of competition that a school like IC is, they’d be on the b
Does anyone else think the coaches lost these players (figuratively) when they asked Loyola to play their second string last year? IC had some D1 athletes last year and I gotta think the message that sent to the whole team was demoralizing
 

PowerI66_

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2012
3,943
2,894
0
Does anyone else think the coaches lost these players (figuratively) when they asked Loyola to play their second string last year? IC had some D1 athletes last year and I gotta think the message that sent to the whole team was demoralizing
I think their main problem is that surrounding schools got better which provided more options. Supply and demand
 
  • Like
Reactions: JCHillmen

Stilllurking

Junior
Jul 23, 2020
393
377
36
I think their main problem is that surrounding schools got better which provided more options. Supply and demand
Just look at York. For almost a decade before their current run, York's best season was 4 wins. I'm sure there are Elmhurst kids on the current team that might have been at IC a few years ago.
 

JCHillmen

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
3,377
1,350
0
I think their main problem is that surrounding schools got better which provided more options. Supply and demand
Agreed. They had a really statistically unlikely compilation of talent for a school of their size over the last 7-10 years. They will still be good, but this is likely just a reversion back to a more realistic level of talent for a school of that size.

And the CCL/ESCC treating them as if they are St. Ignatius or St. Rita likely isn't very helpful to them.
 

Gestalt45

Sophomore
Oct 26, 2023
175
135
43
Agreed. They had a really statistically unlikely compilation of talent for a school of their size over the last 7-10 years. They will still be good, but this is likely just a reversion back to a more realistic level of talent for a school of that size.

And the CCL/ESCC treating them as if they are St. Ignatius or St. Rita likely isn't very helpful to them.
What do you mean treating them like iggy and Rita? By scheduling them Loyola? Montini is same size and they’ve been in great games with Loyola. In all selfishly I just would’ve liked to see what a talented IC team could do against the ramblers
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
119
108
31
Just look at York. For almost a decade before their current run, York's best season was 4 wins. I'm sure there are Elmhurst kids on the current team that might have been at IC a few years ago.

IC wasn’t winning their championships with a bunch of kids from Elmhurst. I would elaborate but Bones got upset when I mentioned youth football in another post. Bottom line some wells dried up for ic where they got kids and they have more competition at other youth programs
 

JCHillmen

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
3,377
1,350
0
What do you mean treating them like iggy and Rita? By scheduling them Loyola? Montini is same size and they’ve been in great games with Loyola. In all selfishly I just would’ve liked to see what a talented IC team could do against the ramblers
I think they would have fit in nicely in the White. Laurence, Carmel, Fenwick, and Montini seem more appropriate for IC than SF, Naz, and Rita.

The most talented IC team of the last decade likely makes a game of it with the least talented LA team of the last decade. Any other combination, the results would have been not as bad as the second string game, but still pretty lopsided.
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,151
2,821
113
IC best team over their run was the 2016 version. That team in 3A was just ridiculously better than every other in the bracket.
Wilmington has a decent tradition and had one of their more talented teams that year, and they got absolutely taken apart by IC.
I believe two years after, they won 4A and running clocked the 5A champs during the regular season, but the 2016 squad was the best imho.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k1867 and Gene K.

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
119
108
31
Does anyone else think the coaches lost these players (figuratively) when they asked Loyola to play their second string last year? IC had some D1 athletes last year and I gotta think the message that sent to the whole team was demoralizing

No doubt it was a bad look. I get they are a small school team and would’ve been over matched. They also had no problem curb stomping much weaker programs over the years
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gestalt45
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: York Dukes
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Revisit Glenbard West
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Watch List: DE/TE Declan Davies
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Downers Grove North
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: Lyons Township