If Other Coaches Had the Same Talent

Status
Not open for further replies.

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
You serious, Clark?

That MSU team didnt have a single NBA player...Memphis had Derrick Rose, CDR, and a myriad of top talents.

Izzo is a fine coach but he's second tier. Cal is tier 1.

Ignore the Pansy's on the board right now. The kids come out when UK isn't 10-0.
 

tmuck

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2009
10,982
3,850
0
This troll only has like 10 posts since 2010. I'm thinking it's another one of those psycho obsessed UL clowns trying to pose as a UK fan. The good news is, On Saturday around 2 o'clock, he's gone.
 
Dec 3, 2010
175,779
16,400
0
That's the thing, though. You have to come up with a "what if" to try and compare Izzo to Cal.

Guess what? Recruiting is one of the most important parts, if not the most important part of the job, and Izzo on his best day couldn't out recruit Cal. That's not Cal's fault and he shouldn't be penalized for it. Izzo has no one to blame but himself.

My answer to your question would be; tough **** for Izzo, be better at his job, and go out and recruit better talent.


How does Izzo struggle with recruiting? Because he doesn't recruit at Duke's or UKs level?

So that means anyone who doesn't recruit like those two schools struggles at recruiting? Seems pretty stupid.

There are more than one way to skin a cat..Izzo wins with a mix of young and vertran talent...Cal goes for the one and dones. Neither is right or wrong...and both coaches have won at a consistent high level.

Having said that, Izzo needs to get a second national title. Last year was a dream making it to the Final Four without a single NBA player. Between this year and the next couple years, we have teams built to win it all. Whether we do or not we will have to wait and find out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CUT-NETS and wcc31

bucsrule8872

Heisman
May 30, 2005
24,397
29,352
0
Cal proved in 1996 what he could do with a team full of talented (yet underrated) 3-4 year players.

No one wants to talk about how he turned a couple of 3-star guards (Padilla and Travieso) into the best backcourt in the nation.

But Cal can't win without 5-star guys. LOL!
 

hoodro

Senior
Apr 1, 2010
1,803
866
91
How does Izzo struggle with recruiting? Because he doesn't recruit at Duke's or UKs level?

So that means anyone who doesn't recruit like those two schools struggles at recruiting? Seems pretty stupid
Where in that entire post did I say that Izzo struggles with recruiting? That's right, I didn't. The whole premise of this thread is comparing Izzo and Cal.

So, in doing so, I pointed out that when compared to Cal, Izzo is the inferior recruiter out of the two. Wouldn't you agree? Of course you would because you already did in your post.

The only thing that seems pretty stupid around here is your reading comprehension.
 

brianpoe

Heisman
Mar 25, 2009
27,769
21,825
113
Brian, is there ever any chance that you could be nice, instead of a horse's A$$. If you don't like the post, no one makes you respond to it. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and we don't need to call them ignorant. Where I come from, that would get someone hurt.

OLD STOLL FIELD GUY!


Well willie, Mr Big Time Donor, you obviously were not around to see his flaming of our players, coaches and program in general from the very first football game.

He has shown massive amounts of ignorance, I dont care where you come from, i could have questioned some of your most recent posts, but never have because you are a real UK fan. Cant say the same about this guy.

I still dont understand this one:

"Michaeluk, wise up! I'm a booster and the money I, and many boosters give helps with this program.Just ask Billy Clyde what happens when you don't show up for booster meetings."


You keep on policing the members and protecting the trolls.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
:joy::joy::joy:

Izzo is ousted almost every single time by tier one coaches when it matters. He's close to that top tier, but there's a few too many up there for him to stand on the elite surface. Cal and K are the elite of the elite. I'm sorry, laugh. I laugh too.
 

.S&C.

All-American
Jul 8, 2014
45,292
6,422
0
Great comeback, full of factual information to form a sensational, cogent rebuttal.

This place is a dumpster fire of homers who really aren't interested in discussing basketball.

There's a few that do nothing but run around throwing childish insults and half the time it's not even warranted. You caught one.

There's a few who actually think they're clever, but lame is all that comes out.
 

DwayneMeighan

Heisman
Oct 15, 2012
5,102
12,654
0
This place is a dumpster fire of homers who really aren't interested in discussing basketball.
Likewise. This place is also a dumpster fire of hilljacks that live vicariously through the team, haven't the first idea about the game of basketball, and only come here to ***** and complain about UK not always being "the bestest ever".
 

tmuck

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2009
10,982
3,850
0
SpartanJD said: ↑
You serious, Clark?

That MSU team didnt have a single NBA player...Memphis had Derrick Rose, CDR, and a myriad of top talents.

How many 4 and 5 star recruits for both teams coming out of High School?
Bump. Go back and look at both rosters from the 07-08 season, and see how many 4 and 5 star recruits for both. Granted, Rose was the best player on the floor, but top to bottom, talent wise, coming out of high school, both we're pretty equal, which was what the premise of this thread was about. Seems to me, Cal did better at developing the individual talent on his team. They slapped your team with equal or less talent 92-74. Hell, CDR was ranked in the 70's on this site.
 
Dec 3, 2010
175,779
16,400
0
Izzo is ousted almost every single time by tier one coaches when it matters. He's close to that top tier, but there's a few too many up there for him to stand on the elite surface. Cal and K are the elite of the elite. I'm sorry, laugh. I laugh too.

Huh? How is Calipari the elite of the elite and Izzo isn't? Weren't you guys just in the NIT a few years ago (and you play in a beyond pathetic conference)

Izzo is 2-0 vs Pitino in Elite 8 games. He owns Self. Beat #1 ranked Calipari last time he played...Beat Jim Calhoun in the FF last time we played...

Is also 2-0 vs UK in elite 8 games...

You kind of sound a little butthurt to be honest, don't know why.

Izzo is the second best coach in the country behind K. Izzo gets bonus points for coaching at a non 'blue blood 6' and for building MSU into a national power.

Anyone can take the reigns at UNC or UK and win at a high level. The name sells itself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FiveStarCat
Dec 3, 2010
175,779
16,400
0
SpartanJD said: ↑
You serious, Clark?

That MSU team didnt have a single NBA player...Memphis had Derrick Rose, CDR, and a myriad of top talents.


Bump. Go back and look at both rosters from the 07-08 season, and see how many 4 and 5 star recruits for both. Granted, Rose was the best player on the floor, but top to bottom, talent wise, coming out of high school, both we're pretty equal, which was what the premise of this thread was about. Seems to me, Cal did better at developing the individual talent on his team. They b!tched slapped your team with equal or less talent 92-74. Hell, CDR was ranked in the 70's on this site.


And Draymond Green was a 3 star...must mean he sucked in college.

That game was men vs boys. MSU had a great run to the S16 just to beat a VERY hot Pitt team in the second round.

But ok, keep harping on that one game to prove some faux point.
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,115
88,990
98
Any fan who would try to knock the coaching abilities and success of either Calipari or Izzo is a fool. PERIOD. Both are tremendous and at the top of their field.
 

UKGrad93

Heisman
Jun 20, 2007
17,437
22,789
0
Just a hypothetical here....

How many championships would these coaches have if they had the same players Cal has had the past 5 seasons?

Coach K
Billy Donovan
Tom Izzo
Rick Pitino
Mark Few
Hypothetical answer:

Coach K - 350
Billy Donovan - 12
Tom Izzo 18
Rick Pitino - 15 seconds (runner ups)
Mark Few - very few
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,866
47,105
113
Great comeback, full of factual information to form a sensational, cogent rebuttal.

This place is a dumpster fire of homers who really aren't interested in discussing basketball.
Rebuttal to what? Your warped opinion of Cal's success? Once again, only a moron would question his success at UK. A complete, total moron.
 

wild mandu

Senior
May 10, 2009
9,159
821
0
Rebuttal to what? Your warped opinion of Cal's success? Once again, only a moron would question his success at UK. A complete, total moron.

We can both go to the gutter. It's too easy.

Like, the girl in your picture is ugly. A plain Jane, nothin' happening dawg not worth tapping. But see, even though it's totally true, it's a hollow statement that doesn't really get us anywhere. We can do better. We can rise above.
 

ukbballrulez3

Redshirt
Apr 17, 2010
1,064
9
0
This troll only has like 10 posts since 2010. I'm thinking it's another one of those psycho obsessed UL clowns trying to pose as a UK fan. The good news is, On Saturday around 2 o'clock, he's gone.


I actually stopped coming to the board because it's full of hate and disgust. People get so upset over everything.

I wanted to try it out again and see if anyone actually preferred Izzo to Cal since Cal gets criticized (and rightfully so, this year) for his lack of COACHING ability compared to Izzo (not recruiting).

Apparently I'm going to have to hang it up again for a while, because the board hasn't changed.

You can be a UK fan and be critical of the team and coach, believe it or not. For example, I believe there are 3-5 other coaches in America who would have had NO PROBLEM winning the title with last year's squad, and John Wall's squad. Does that make me a hater or a fan of another team? No, just an honest observation that I believe sometimes Cal is a great recruiter but can lack in pressure coaching situations.

Does that mean I want Cal gone? No. I just wish he was a little better at the coaching aspect sometimes, which I think many (true) UK fans also hold the same sentiment.
 

wild mandu

Senior
May 10, 2009
9,159
821
0
I actually stopped coming to the board because it's full of hate and disgust. People get so upset over everything.

I wanted to try it out again and see if anyone actually preferred Izzo to Cal since Cal gets criticized (and rightfully so, this year) for his lack of COACHING ability compared to Izzo (not recruiting).

Apparently I'm going to have to hang it up again for a while, because the board hasn't changed.

You can be a UK fan and be critical of the team and coach, believe it or not. For example, I believe there are 3-5 other coaches in America who would have had NO PROBLEM winning the title with last year's squad, and John Wall's squad. Does that make me a hater or a fan of another team? No, just an honest observation that I believe sometimes Cal is a great recruiter but can lack in pressure coaching situations.

Does that mean I want Cal gone? No. I just wish he was a little better at the coaching aspect sometimes, which I think many (true) UK fans also hold the same sentiment.

Well what do we have here...a sensible post in Rafters. It's a damn Christmas miracle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ukbballrulez3

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,115
88,990
98
We can both go to the gutter. It's too easy.

Like, the girl in your picture is ugly. A plain Jane, nothin' happening dawg not worth tapping. But see, even though it's totally true, it's a hollow statement that doesn't really get us anywhere. We can do better. We can rise above.

What in the hell is wrong with you?
 

Montana81

Heisman
Aug 12, 2004
82,727
29,410
113
If other coaches had the same inexperience

Just a hypothetical here...

How many Championships/FFs would these coaches have had if they had the same inexperience as Cal the past five seasons?

Coach K
Billy Donovan
Tom Izzo
Rick Pitino
Mark Few

Would these coaches have won as much as Cal with this inexperience?

History would suggest no way in hell for Donovan. He had a mass exodus and went to back to back NIT's and barely made the tourney the 3rd year. Took him 4 seasons to recover and 7 just to get back to the final four.

Few there's just no way of knowing.

Izzo I might give a chance to.

Pitino younger teams have always struggled. His system seems like it takes a little longer to pick up.

Coach K proved he could to a degree last season. But they've also taken a bit of a step back this year.
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,115
88,990
98
I actually stopped coming to the board because it's full of hate and disgust. People get so upset over everything.

I wanted to try it out again and see if anyone actually preferred Izzo to Cal since Cal gets criticized (and rightfully so, this year) for his lack of COACHING ability compared to Izzo (not recruiting).

Apparently I'm going to have to hang it up again for a while, because the board hasn't changed.

You can be a UK fan and be critical of the team and coach, believe it or not. For example, I believe there are 3-5 other coaches in America who would have had NO PROBLEM winning the title with last year's squad, and John Wall's squad. Does that make me a hater or a fan of another team? No, just an honest observation that I believe sometimes Cal is a great recruiter but can lack in pressure coaching situations.

Does that mean I want Cal gone? No. I just wish he was a little better at the coaching aspect sometimes, which I think many (true) UK fans also hold the same sentiment.

[laughing] How many times have any coaches EVER had NO PROBLEM winning a title? The closest I can think of is Calipari in 2012. That was a pretty dramaless season and tournament.

I would like to hear these 3-5 coaches.

I find it absolutely hilarious that a mere 6 years ago all I heard was "you can't win with freshmen" and now 3-5 coaches could win big every year with Cal's teams.
 

wcc31

Heisman
Mar 18, 2002
27,115
88,990
98
Well what do we have here...a sensible post in Rafters. It's a damn Christmas miracle.

You don't handle adversity well, do you, champ? One loss in December and you're insulting people's wives/daughters/whoever that is. Grow up.
 

messecat

Redshirt
Oct 13, 2001
1,260
22
0
Hypothetical, @UKWinsAgainYep never posted would we ever miss him?

Football season was brutal with his Jeckyl and Hyde posts, none of which made any sense.

So glad to see that his ignorance will be flowing throughout bball season...


Didnt show up until we looked bad during football and this is his first post here...
Good answer for another stupid post!
 

wild mandu

Senior
May 10, 2009
9,159
821
0
You don't handle adversity well, do you, champ? One loss in December and you're insulting people's wives/daughters/whoever that is. Grow up.

One loss in December? Has nothing to do with basketball. He called me a moron and the girl is ugly.

What am I missing...champ?
 

Blueaz

Heisman
Jul 7, 2009
28,072
30,262
113
Cal proved in 1996 what he could do with a team full of talented (yet underrated) 3-4 year players.

No one wants to talk about how he turned a couple of 3-star guards (Padilla and Travieso) into the best backcourt in the nation.

But Cal can't win without 5-star guys. LOL!
LSU had chris Jackson, stanely Roberts and SHAQ on the same team...as juniors and seniors (I think)...that is the most talent on a college team ever
 

DwayneMeighan

Heisman
Oct 15, 2012
5,102
12,654
0
For example, I believe there are 3-5 other coaches in America who would have had NO PROBLEM winning the title with last year's squad, and John Wall's squad.
See, but that isn't an honest observation at all. That's your agenda driven observation There's not a single coach anywhere that has NO PROBLEM winning a title. It's not as easy as you want to dream it to be. There's a reason the best team doesn't always win. It's a one and done, crap shoot tournament, that is the most UNPREDICTABLE sporting event ever.

For example, Coach K coached a team with 5 lottery picks, including the #1 overall pick. They were also an experienced team with all kinds of chemistry for being in his system for multiple years, not freshman playing their first season in college and together as a team. He failed to win the title with that team. So, if he can't win the title with that team, how can you make an "honest" observation and claim that he would have NO PROBLEM winning with one of Cal's teams?
 

DwayneMeighan

Heisman
Oct 15, 2012
5,102
12,654
0
Well what do we have here...a sensible post in Rafters. It's a damn Christmas miracle.
That post was far from sensible. Saying 3-5 coaches would have NO PROBLEM winning a title with Cal's teams, when those same 3-5 coaches have failed to win a title when they had the best teams, teams just as good, if not better than Cal's teams isn't sensible, it's hypocritical.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Kentucky is a slight underdog against Indiana inside Lucas Oil Stadium
  2. 02 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  3. 03 KSR Football Playoff Viewing Guide: What games Kentucky fans need to follow in Week 11
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kentucky vs. Indiana: Preview, Odds & How to Watch
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Kentucky vs. Indiana and the latest in recruiting