If Jarrett Guarantano decommits..?

imbazza

Senior
Apr 22, 2008
4,462
432
0
This kid has all the signs of a "rotten apple" in the making.
Lets say JG eats crow and ask to come to Rutgers =>His ego will not let it happen. He will go pretty much go anywhere but Rutgers at this time. Down the road after sitting on the bench when he grows up maybe But to flip that coin would HC flood want to poison his own well? Think Not
I said after JG committed to UT that he would not graduate from Tenn. ( not because he goes pro early:joy:)
but when he gets bumped his ego/distain will spill over and he will get cut from the team. In truth he may not even make it that far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JQRU91

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,033
38,569
113
If he was recruiting for other schools while at RU, which it sounds like he was, his shoe color choice isn't the reason he wasn't asked back.

His old man is a legacy, so I won't say anything bad about the guy, but for those of us who knew him at RU, it isn't surprising how he his son handled the recruiting process.

I'm of the opinion it is best for all that he ended up elsewhere and that we have Russo.

Agreed. We really nailed it/lucked out with him. Cant wait to get him on the banks.
 

zappaa

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
76,005
93,147
103
Yes, I heard this from other places besides this board. That, I agree with.

But the part about RU asking him not to come back cause he wore Tennessee colors..not sure where that came from. It's my understanding RU recruited him up to when he committed, which is when they locked in Russo, hence why they told JG to stop coming around. Again, no inside info.

Mike
The claim is he was recruiting for Tennessee before he committed.
 
Sep 2, 2013
2,078
769
0
Womp, womp. Hope it was fun while it lasted.. Oh well, maybe he could transfer to UCLA or some junior college
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUMountie

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
Mike
The claim is he was recruiting for Tennessee before he committed.

Yes. I agree with that. But someone claimed he stopped recruiting him because he wore "orange" on a visit..that's where this whole thing started. Not sure if that's true.
 

HeavenUniv.

Heisman
Sep 21, 2004
135,536
16,405
0
Maybe I am being too sensitive,but I really thought Guarantano and his family walking around at the Rutgers Shootout wearing Tennessee gear was too much,especially with his Dad being an alumnus and player in Piscataway.---Thank you Michael Dare,Anthony Russo, and all the current players and commits for choosing RU !!!
 

RUboston

All-American
Sep 13, 2002
6,452
9,901
78
There is going to be fierce competition for the QB spot at every school, even more so at big time SEC schools like Tennessee. He had to know that going in, and that he was not going to be the only top QB recruit vying for the starting position. He gave TN a verbal commitment; he should stay there and compete and let the chips fall where they may. If he now goes looking for another place where he perceives there is less competition, that would say a lot about his confidence in his abilities and, more importantly, his compete level.
 

knightfan7

Heisman
Jul 30, 2003
97,472
71,188
113
Yes. I agree with that. But someone claimed he stopped recruiting him because he wore "orange" on a visit..that's where this whole thing started. Not sure if that's true.

IIRC, it was after he committed he and his entourage showed up at RU all decked out in Tennessee stuff. No idea whether or not anyone asked him to leave, stay, sell hot dogs, or handle R Vision interviews.
 

Virginiarufan

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2001
3,917
3,051
113
Tennessee isn't a big time SEC school. They are a school with a losing record over the last 5 years. The glory days are over and have yet to be rekindled. They are a has-been school at the moment, recruiting momentum or not.
 

RUboston

All-American
Sep 13, 2002
6,452
9,901
78
They are nonetheless an SEC school which attracts some big time recruits, including at QB.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,652
151,478
113
There is going to be fierce competition for the QB spot at every school, even more so at big time SEC schools like Tennessee. He had to know that going in, and that he was not going to be the only top QB recruit vying for the starting position. He gave TN a verbal commitment; he should stay there and compete and let the chips fall where they may. If he now goes looking for another place where he perceives there is less competition, that would say a lot about his confidence in his abilities and, more importantly, his compete level.

Guessing his confidence is based on hype and playing the branding game well. His stats are very mediocre where it all counts.
 

GSGS

Heisman
Aug 2, 2001
29,420
23,839
113
If TN's senior QB remains healthy this year and starts the whole season, jg may very well wind up honoring his commitment and signing with TN. However, if the senior gets injured and one of the 3 highly rated 2015 QB recruits establishes himself, jg will need to make a decision whether he looks elsewhere or risks riding the pines for his first 3 years in Tennessee.
 

KingHigh

All-American
Apr 12, 2005
21,293
9,216
0
Guessing his confidence is based on hype and playing the branding game well. His stats are very mediocre where it all counts.
At the elite 11, he was given a boost in his overall performance score because he jumped high. That is probably what put him over the edge into the elite 11. That he jumps high. That made up for all of his bad throws and interceptions. So he's got that going for him, which is nice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Abro1975

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,652
151,478
113
At the elite 11, he was given a boost in his overall performance score because he jumped high. That is probably what put him over the edge into the elite 11. That he jumps high. That made up for all of his bad throws and interceptions. So he's got that going for him, which is nice.

His career stats in the only ones that matter are 10 TD's and 12 interceptions. By comparison, Russo has thrown 21 td's and 2 interceptions. Oh, he also won the championship. Winners win.
 

DaveSNJ

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2001
6,317
2,087
113
I don't care what the kid wears, I don't care what is in a video they put together, I do care that he was at RU recruiting for another school. Why do folks have a tendency to engage the what ifs, so people can feel good about shutting the door on a 17 yr old. Russo is our guy, I believe I've read the staff told him he was our QB and we aren't recruiting any others in this class.

JG situation I could care less, I don't think the staff is going to care either. Why people on this board care - you feel jilted by a 17 year old, get over it. I didn't think too much of JG when his recruitment was "open", from what I saw of highlight film, and certainly think we have the better QB of the two. And certainly think Russo has his head on straighter than JG.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickyNewark51

NickyNewark51

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2015
2,729
1,000
0
I don't care what the kid wears, I don't care what is in a video they put together, I do care that he was at RU recruiting for another school. Why do folks have a tendency to engage the what ifs, so people can feel good about shutting the door on a 17 yr old. Russo is our guy, I believe I've read the staff told him he was our QB and we aren't recruiting any others in this class.

JG situation I could care less, I don't think the staff is going to care either. Why people on this board care - you feel jilted by a 17 year old, get over it. I didn't think too much of JG when his recruitment was "open", from what I saw of highlight film, and certainly think we have the better QB of the two. And certainly think Russo has his head on straighter than JG.
i'll stick with RUsso!!
 

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,033
38,569
113
Tennessee isn't a big time SEC school. They are a school with a losing record over the last 5 years. The glory days are over and have yet to be rekindled. They are a has-been school at the moment, recruiting momentum or not.

In all fairness... they've been on fire in recruiting the last couple of years and will be back on top soon. But it does look like JG will end up being part of the UF rebuilding project...
 

NickyNewark51

All-Conference
Apr 21, 2015
2,729
1,000
0
OTE="RUboston, post: 469569, member: 870"]There is going to be fierce competition for the QB spot at every school, even more so at big time SEC schools like Tennessee. He had to know that going in, and that he was not going to be the only top QB recruit vying for the starting position. He gave TN a verbal commitment; he should stay there and compete and let the chips fall where they may. If he now goes looking for another place where he perceives there is less competition, that would say a lot about his confidence in his abilities and, more importantly, his compete level.[/QUOTE]
i doubt QB will be his position when alls said and done?
 

RutgersUnion

Senior
Apr 15, 2006
2,843
967
113
I would be extremely surprised if our staff isn't recruiting JG hard until signing day. Even before Tennessee latest commitment.
 

RRRRUUUU

All-Conference
Nov 19, 2005
2,500
2,203
63
something I heard from a booster - A few days before JG was going to announce his commitment, Gary Nova gives him a call to help sell RU. JG says something to the effect of "I don't get why you're calling me BC nothing you say will impact my decision." This is what the high school kid says to the 4yr college QB starter. No thanks, he can ride the pine somewhere in the south.
 

knightfan7

Heisman
Jul 30, 2003
97,472
71,188
113
I would be extremely surprised if our staff isn't recruiting JG hard until signing day. Even before Tennessee latest commitment.

Conversely I'd be very surprised if there has been any conversation since the day Russo committed.

Admittedly I don't know what's BS and what isn't but everything I've heard says it ended badly.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,652
151,478
113
When a kid is openly recruiting for another school while on your campus, that bridge is in pieces. We have a better QB and no drama in Russo who is perfect for our system. The program dodged a bullet with the way this all played out. We don't need a hybrid wide receiver under center.

He is Tennessee's problem now. Without looking at the stats of their other QB's, simply because I can't be bothered, I bet none have stats nearly as awful as Garantano.
 

j10oreo

Junior
Nov 18, 2012
1,159
385
0
That story is blown out of proportion. He wore orange shoes, yes. But doubt he did it purposely.

Kids these days dont just throw on a raggidy pair of sneakers laying around. I'm certain he had other options to wear to RU practice other than a pair that has UT colors. I've never heard of someone show up somewhere and be like "dang, didn't mean to wear these pair of shoes"
 
Last edited:

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,652
151,478
113
Kids these days dont just throw on a raggidy pair of sneakers laying around. I'm certain he had other options to wear to RU practice other than a pair that has UT colors. I've never heard of something show up somewhere and be like "dang, didn't mean to wear these pair of shoes"


No doubt. A kid wearing earrings probably is putting a lot of thought into his shoe collection.
 

Obadiah Plainman

Redshirt
May 4, 2014
79
9
0
If he was afraid of competition, he wouldn't come here with Russo anyway. If he wanted to come here, I'd take him in a heartbeat.

He'll only decommitt, in my opinion, if he felt betrayed by Jones, who told him he'd be "the guy" at Tennessee. This isn't the case, it seems.

Tennessee also leads for the Number One QB for the 2018 class, Trevor Lawrence, as well.
 

MikeRU1766

Sophomore
Mar 7, 2015
627
199
0
Kids these days dont just throw on a raggidy pair of sneakers laying around. I'm certain he had other options to wear to RU practice other than a pair that has UT colors. I've never heard of someone show up somewhere and be like "dang, didn't mean to wear these pair of shoes"

Yeah I would have to agree with "J10oreo" here. Not all kids have fallen into this trap, but some of them have fallen into this trap about being all about "swag" and "gear" which are really just adjectives invented by a middle-aged marketing vice president so that they can get guys to obsess over their clothes as much as girls and pay way more for certain brands as well.

And if JG doesn't SCREAM being one of these "swag" suckers as I like to call them.... then I don't know who does. The kid probably has over 20 different pairs of shoes he could wear and on top of it he is the type of kid that obsesses over these decisions. There is NO DOUBT that he was wearing those shoes for a reason that day..
 

RutgersUnion

Senior
Apr 15, 2006
2,843
967
113
Conversely I'd be very surprised if there has been any conversation since the day Russo committed.

Admittedly I don't know what's BS and what isn't but everything I've heard says it ended badly.

Kids get hurt, kids dont qualify, kids decommit and some kids just don't pan out. Until NSD Russo will be recruited be other teams. Would be disappointing if our staff was putting all their eggs in 1 basket.
 

needmorecowbell

Heisman
Oct 28, 2007
9,693
10,851
78
His career stats in the only ones that matter are 10 TD's and 12 interceptions. By comparison, Russo has thrown 21 td's and 2 interceptions. Oh, he also won the championship. Winners win.
Well said. Rutgers QB recruiting board always had Russo over Guarantano. So far the play on the field has confirmed this rating. All Rutgers fans should be very very happy with Russo over Guarantano for many reasons.
 

ArminRU

Heisman
Aug 5, 2008
11,350
12,978
0
Let's put it this way.....JG is the next Jabu Lovelace (no off
Kids get hurt, kids dont qualify, kids decommit and some kids just don't pan out. Until NSD Russo will be recruited be other teams. Would be disappointing if our staff was putting all their eggs in 1 basket.

Let's put it this way.....JG is the next Jabu Lovelace (no offense Jabu)
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football PFF Grades + Snap Counts versus Nebraska
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers vs Penn State odds: Point spread released on Scarlet Knights, Nittany Lions
  3. 03 The Knight Report Football Every throw from Rutgers Football Quarterbacks versus Nebraska
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Nebraska Cornhuskers Edition - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Nebraska Postgame Press Conference