I may be channeling my inner Ron Polk...

HuskyBDawg

Sophomore
Nov 26, 2017
297
102
43
How many scholarships do you guys think baseball should have? What will be required to get the NCAA to make this change?
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,480
33,346
113
Baseball needs at least 20 scholarships, really closer to 25. It will never change though because the NCAA cares more about protecting the schools that have trouble funding 11.7 than it does about the game.
 

Xenomorph

Heisman
Feb 15, 2007
16,331
11,173
113
Can't Ole Miss raid Oxford city taxes again and put some drainage under that field?
 

HammerOfTheDogs

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
10,856
1,708
113
Limited scholarships isn't a bad thing

If anything, I think college football and basketball should follow the baseball model- strong NFL and NBA minor leagues, with limited scholarships (say, 7 in basketball and 25 in football).

You can still have exciting sports. However, it'll be with real student-athletes who actually go to class and study for a degree.
 

T-TownDawgg

All-American
Nov 4, 2015
4,831
5,008
113
I still admire Polk for marching right through gates of The Kremlin of college athletics with his torch and pitchfork; he did it for the sport. It was the right thing to do, even if the experience made him even more disillusioned with the People's Republic of NCAA, and other institutions for that matter. That bunch in Indianapolis seem to embrace the unrestrained corruption of the Thieves World, while holding on to antiquated traditions with an iron fist.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,480
33,346
113
That’s all fine. But he did it at the expense of our baseball program which he neglected to go tilt at windmills.
 

dawgoneyall

Junior
Nov 11, 2007
3,431
210
63
That’s all fine. But he did it at the expense of our baseball program which he neglected to go tilt at windmills.

Multiple place won national championships under the same rules.

His neglect of Mississippi State for the betterment of college baseball is something for which I will never forgive.

And then his attempt to hurt Cohen (thus MSU) -and did- when little the Napoleon didn't get his way is proof that Polk was more about himself than MSU.

He put MSU 10 years behind in the SEC when he returned with one goal....to fight the NCAA and had nothing to do with the betterment of MSU.

But this all started in approx 92 or 93.... his neglect.

In case you wonder....I have nothing for the man.
 
Last edited:

T-TownDawgg

All-American
Nov 4, 2015
4,831
5,008
113
I think he honestly thought he was done, retired, his best was behind him, and wanted to do something good for the sport collectively. Nevertheless, his actions when Cohen was hired, as I wholeheartedly agree with many, was a complete childish tantrum, which is still going to some degree. I simply hate to discount all of a man's positive accomplishments by his few worst decisions.

That said, I doubt many of disagree that some things need to change for the good of college baseball and the young men who sacrifice a lot to play it.
 

Go Budaw

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
7,321
0
36
How many scholarships do you guys think baseball should have? What will be required to get the NCAA to make this change?


Football has 85, which is enough to go almost 4-deep at every position on the field.

Basketball has 13 for men and 15 for women, enough to go 2.5 or 3 deep at every position.

I think 25 is a good number for baseball. That’s enough for a full two-deep roster, plus 7 pitchers (or, say, 1.5 deep roster and 10 pitchers).

Honestly, it’s not just the NCAA holding the sport back. Title IX is the main culprit. One solution out there which would fix everything (but most people wouldn’t like) would be to take some away from football and give to baseball. Honestly, 85 in football is probably too many. Look no further than Mullen’s roster management at MSU for the past 5 years. We haven’t even come close to hitting the 85 limit since 2014. We have been between 5-10 scholies short of the limit every year since then, and have still averaged close to a historical high in number of wins per season over that period. The crazy thing is that the #1 reason for us not hitting the number was literally running out of players to offer scholarships to, which happened countless times under Mullen. To me, that is a prine example of a sport that has too many schollies.

I think around 75 in football would be more than enough, which would allow for 21.7 in baseball without any impact to Title IX ratio. That is maybe not quite the ideal amount still, but would be a massive step forward.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,567
3,174
113
Football has 85, which is enough to go almost 4-deep at every position on the field.

Basketball has 13 for men and 15 for women, enough to go 2.5 or 3 deep at every position.

I think 25 is a good number for baseball. That’s enough for a full two-deep roster, plus 7 pitchers (or, say, 1.5 deep roster and 10 pitchers).

Honestly, it’s not just the NCAA holding the sport back. Title IX is the main culprit. One solution out there which would fix everything (but most people wouldn’t like) would be to take some away from football and give to baseball. Honestly, 85 in football is probably too many. Look no further than Mullen’s roster management at MSU for the past 5 years. We haven’t even come close to hitting the 85 limit since 2014. We have been between 5-10 scholies short of the limit every year since then, and have still averaged close to a historical high in number of wins per season over that period. The crazy thing is that the #1 reason for us not hitting the number was literally running out of players to offer scholarships to, which happened countless times under Mullen. To me, that is a prine example of a sport that has too many schollies.

I think around 75 in football would be more than enough, which would allow for 21.7 in baseball without any impact to Title IX ratio. That is maybe not quite the ideal amount still, but would be a massive step forward.

I agree that 85 for football is too many. That's why I never thought losing a few to penalties was a big deal. It would probaby hurt the "big" schools more though ... I suspect Alabama doesn't have much trouble filling 85 players with very few below a firm 4-star level, just because they want to play for Alabama.

Another way of looking at it is if baseball scholarships were increased, you might not see smaller schools (like East Carolina) competing.

Why does women's basketball get 15 scholarships and men only 13? Title IX? It might've made sense when they played half court with 6 players on the court, but it doesn't now.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,480
33,346
113
Yep. Should have let him retire the first time & moved on. He coasted through the 90s until he brought McMahon back & then he coasted through the 2000s. 15 wasted years.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  2. 02 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  3. 03 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know