I keep reading that our secondary is horrible

ezsoil

Junior
May 26, 2013
1,352
285
83
But yet opponents have only passed for 277 yards in two games on 24 completions out of 58 passes. Looking back at both games, while there were two plays, one in each game that a receiver had some space, there haven't been the classic blown coverage. If you are consider playing a zone and keeping the player in front of you when the team is up 40 as blown coverage ...lighten up. Just as Bob Shoop said it will be different as the safeties will be facing the QB...time will tell as we play better teams but so far, I can't complain about the secondary.
 

Felonious Junk

All-Conference
Oct 23, 2008
1,907
1,322
113
Why look at a statistic when you can see the play on the field with your eyes? Blindly using completion percentage to judge the quality of the defense or offense is completely shallow.

The reason that our secondary is being criticized is because they have been horribly out of position many times and also did a poor job of playing balls in the air. Our competition will only get stiffer as the year progresses so seeing our players out of position against weak opponents is concerning regardless of whether or not the QB delivering the ball was on target.
 
Jun 30, 2018
1,011
0
0
Why look at a statistic when you can see the play on the field with your eyes? Blindly using completion percentage to judge the quality of the defense or offense is completely shallow.
Unfortunately, this is how many people across this country come to form their opinions, on various topics. Scary, ain't it?
 

thf24

Redshirt
Jan 28, 2011
1,334
3
38
Why look at a statistic when you can see the play on the field with your eyes? Blindly using completion percentage to judge the quality of the defense or offense is completely shallow.

The reason that our secondary is being criticized is because they have been horribly out of position many times and also did a poor job of playing balls in the air. Our competition will only get stiffer as the year progresses so seeing our players out of position against weak opponents is concerning regardless of whether or not the QB delivering the ball was on target.

Other than Peters in game 1, I disagree they've been out of position. I actually think they've been pretty good in that aspect, particularly Dantzler. Ball skills, on the other hand, have been a little concerning; have to finish the job.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,518
33,395
113
Jury is still very much out on the secondary. They've looked a bit improved over last year. But we've played two pretty mediocre passing teams.
 

The Fatboy

Senior
Oct 18, 2005
2,782
744
83
I think its too early to make an assessment but the first game did give me pause. Game 2 they played much better. We will know in a couple more weeks exactly how good they are.
 

ezsoil

Junior
May 26, 2013
1,352
285
83
Why look at a statistic when you can see the play on the field with your eyes? Blindly using completion percentage to judge the quality of the defense or offense is completely shallow.

The reason that our secondary is being criticized is because they have been horribly out of position many times and also did a poor job of playing balls in the air. Our competition will only get stiffer as the year progresses so seeing our players out of position against weak opponents is concerning regardless of whether or not the QB delivering the ball was on target.

Yo homes..I didn't say a thing about completion percentage. 277 yards in two games that had huge leads is exceptional. Which plays have they been "horribly out of position many times" ? What was the result of those plays ? If you look at the overal scheme it's far better than anything we have had in recent years ..
 

MSUDC11

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
7,316
0
0
I think its too early to make an assessment but the first game did give me pause. Game 2 they played much better. We will know in a couple more weeks exactly how good they are.

I don’t think we’ll know how good they are until we play Auburn. But so far, I’m pleased. If we had let K-State, a bad passing team, throw for 300 yards, I would’ve been concerned. But we held them in check as we should have.
 

Coast Dawg

Redshirt
Feb 28, 2008
364
0
0
Front 7

But yet opponents have only passed for 277 yards in two games on 24 completions out of 58 passes. Looking back at both games, while there were two plays, one in each game that a receiver had some space, there haven't been the classic blown coverage. If you are consider playing a zone and keeping the player in front of you when the team is up 40 as blown coverage ...lighten up. Just as Bob Shoop said it will be different as the safeties will be facing the QB...time will tell as we play better teams but so far, I can't complain about the secondary.


I agree time will tell and it's too soon to make a firm judgment.

But if our front 7 is as good as all the hype, the pass coverage should be the main beneficiary
 

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,200
2,666
113
I'm concerned with our CBs. Just haven't seen anything yet to make me feel warm & fuzzy about that position... and haven't for a couple of years now. I do think they look a little improved, but hard to say based on competition.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,505
2,507
113
Other than Peters in game 1, I disagree they've been out of position. I actually think they've been pretty good in that aspect, particularly Dantzler. Ball skills, on the other hand, have been a little concerning; have to finish the job.

Agree with you. I'm sure a WR has been open on us a few times, but I haven't noticed our secondary out of position. KSU threw a jump ball against Dantzler to open the KSU game and Dantzer was all over it as was Abrams and this was against Zuber who is a great WR. There's your improvement against better quality competition.

I'm not saying we have the best secondary in the SEC, but I've only seen our secondary make a couple bad plays on the ball with it in the air and it was game 1. They seemed to improve on game 2 and I think Peters and Dantlzer have good ball skills. Dantzler is also only a soph mind you.
 

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,070
12,995
113
Hard to say how bad or good they are when the D Line is as good as they are. Our DB's should thank the line profusely every game if the line continues to play as well as they have. A good rush can make the backs look mighty good.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,505
2,507
113
Remember when UAB threw for like 400 yards on us?

Our secondary also held up on KSU's trick play, which usually burned us bad under the old regime.

Our guys have been in position on nearly every snap. They didn't make a play on a couple jump balls in game 1, but I definitely think our CBs have dramatically improved.
 
Sep 9, 2012
2,803
0
0
Our secondary can’t be considered good or bad yet- it is untested. We have smothered two teams with subpar QBs. Last year we dominated teams that had bad QBs, then gave up an abnormal amount of big plays to teams with good QBs. We just have to wait and see. The first real challenge will be Stidham.
 

Wizard.sixpack

Freshman
Sep 15, 2009
6,511
58
48
But yet opponents have only passed for 277 yards in two games on 24 completions out of 58 passes. Looking back at both games, while there were two plays, one in each game that a receiver had some space, there haven't been the classic blown coverage. If you are consider playing a zone and keeping the player in front of you when the team is up 40 as blown coverage ...lighten up. Just as Bob Shoop said it will be different as the safeties will be facing the QB...time will tell as we play better teams but so far, I can't complain about the secondary.

We haven't played a passing team yet.
 

Go Budaw

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
7,321
0
36
Yo homes..I didn't say a thing about completion percentage. 277 yards in two games that had huge leads is exceptional. Which plays have they been "horribly out of position many times" ? What was the result of those plays ? If you look at the overal scheme it's far better than anything we have had in recent years ..

Your fallacy is attributing all of those passing numbers to the secondary. Pass defense is 50% applying pressure to the QB and 50% coverage on the back end. We are top 5 in the nation at worst in our front 4, and the stats through 2 games have backed that up. So, the logical conclusion is that our secondary could be highly questionable even if our numbers are good. I think we’ve been a little better than I thought we’d be, but I’m still a little concerned because we haven’t even come close to facing a decent test.
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
But yet opponents have only passed for 277 yards in two games on 24 completions out of 58 passes. Looking back at both games, while there were two plays, one in each game that a receiver had some space, there haven't been the classic blown coverage. If you are consider playing a zone and keeping the player in front of you when the team is up 40 as blown coverage ...lighten up. Just as Bob Shoop said it will be different as the safeties will be facing the QB...time will tell as we play better teams but so far, I can't complain about the secondary.

Horrible is too harsh. They certainly need to get better at the zone coverage. Also, if, like last year, we arent getting the deep ball thrown correctly in practice, they arent getting the needed reps to defend it.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
two teams with subpar QBs

Stephen F Austin's QB, Foster Sawyer, was a borderline 4* QB out of HS, from Fort Worth, that signed and played a backup role with TCU initially over offers from Bama, Mizzou, OK State, SMU, and UCLA. And is now a senior. While he's certainly not Stitham, I imagine he ends up being one of the top QBs in the FCS this year.

It seems most, at least the ones commenting, are seeing something different in the back end than I am seeing sans the play or two for Peters in game one. Time will tell.
 
R

RPOdawg

Guest
Why look at a statistic when you can see the play on the field with your eyes? Blindly using completion percentage to judge the quality of the defense or offense is completely shallow.

The reason that our secondary is being criticized is because they have been horribly out of position many times and also did a poor job of playing balls in the air. Our competition will only get stiffer as the year progresses so seeing our players out of position against weak opponents is concerning regardless of whether or not the QB delivering the ball was on target.


No no they haven’t been “horribly out of position”. Do you even watch the games? Apparently not
 

bonedaddy401

Redshirt
Aug 3, 2012
4,664
22
38
We haven’t been horribly out of position. That’s a terrible, try hard take. If you had said our corners specifically have been the most suspect part of our defense I’d agree with you. But you didn’t and made a blanket statement that’s an over reaction and now we have to call you on it. Don’t try so hard buddy.
 

ezsoil

Junior
May 26, 2013
1,352
285
83
You specifically referenced 24/58. You know how percentages are calculated right?


Yo homes ....you are correct that is how they are calculated and no I didn't mention it...the reason being, the acurate metric to measuring passing efficiency is yards per attempt and yards per completion. That's the reason Keytaon had a great QBR after the first game while completing less than 50% of his passes. I stand by my assessment that the defensive secondary is one of the better in the conference. You, on the other hand can't give me examples of when the team was horribly out of position many times.
 

boatsandhoes

Junior
Sep 6, 2012
2,151
208
63
I’m not too worried about kstate or sfa. I’m not sure we will really be tested until AU. I guess FLA might some. the real answer is after AU game we will know the answer.
 

HumpDawgy

All-Conference
Apr 6, 2010
4,915
2,095
113
I was at the SFA game and they did appear slow to react to the ball in the air. That said, other than a couple jump balls where we were out of position, they didn't allow a lot of big plays. Against Kansas State I thought they played great. Landrews allowed the receiver to get behind him and the receiver made a great diving catch. That was the only semi-bad play in the secondary I remember.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White "Give us a chance, we can make the plays": Anthony Evans III speaks on getting the offense firing again
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State offense does enough to overcome errors, early nerves against Tennessee Tech
  3. 03 Maroon and White Rapid Recap: Mississippi State 34-16 Tennessee Tech
  4. 04 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  5. 05 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson