I Believe These Players Will Leave

gojvc

All-American
Feb 5, 2005
28,744
7,273
0
Allen, Fletcher, and Ware are in the same boat. Is there a way for them to become like Brooks and Toppin? Or do they feel they have already been discarded. Hard to imagine all 3 return.
The fact that those two questions even have to be asked tells you everything you need to know about the way in which Kentucky basketball is broken right now.
 

G-PIP

All-American
Mar 14, 2014
5,286
5,964
0
Next Season Roster:
Askew
Hickman
2G Transfer
2G Recruit
Mintz (I would not have expected this, but now sounds possible)
Allen
Brooks
Toppin
Hopkins
Ware
Collins
Tshiebwe
 
Dec 8, 2009
30
42
0
Why would you want 6-9 players to return from the worst team in Kentucky basketball history?

Outside of Toppin and Mintz, why would you want a repeat of this **** show?
We certainly don't want a repeat of this **** show but I would hope that with a year under their belt Calipari and staff could develop them. If we brought back half of the team next year and we still look like we do now, we have even bigger problems. I am frustrated by this season but I am not willing to write any of the freshmen off permanently because their freshman season didn't go well at all. If any decide to transfer, we all know they will be good contributors for their new schools later in their careers.
 
Mar 19, 2006
1,138
771
113
Because returning players who have played together and are older and have at least formed some sort of cohesiveness and bond by playing together will be better than yet another entirely brand new team?

Cmon man, is that a serious question? That’s been our problem for years- no longevity, no bond, no cohesiveness. You don’t think we’d be better by consistently returning at least a few serviceable guys?

I honestly don’t understand how you can’t see that.

Sure. Please re-read my post.

I mentioned Toppin and Mintz because they should be contributors, I would even maybe throw Brooks into the mix as serviceable. However, I see Toppin developing at a much faster rate at the same position.

Jackson, Boston, and Clarke will not be back and I am not sure how you can pin that on the coach. Jackson has developed into a lottery pick and Clarke and Boston were gone before the season started. We can debate the validity of those decisions, but it is reality.

There will be no minutes for Sarr next year.

Ware, Askew, and (probably) Allen will be back, but I am not sure you can make a case that they are serviceable on a contending team. That is the goal, right?

I would see them as complimentary in certain spots.

I guess it depends on what your definition of serviceable is.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Sure. Please re-read my post.

I mentioned Toppin and Mintz because they should be contributors, I would even maybe throw Brooks into the mix as serviceable. However, I see Toppin developing at a much faster rate at the same position.

Jackson, Boston, and Clarke will not be back and I am not sure how you can pin that on the coach. Jackson has developed into a lottery pick and Clarke and Boston were gone before the season started. We can debate the validity of those decisions, but it is reality.

There will be no minutes for Sarr next year.

Ware, Askew, and (probably) Allen will be back, but I am not sure you can make a case that they are serviceable on a contending team. That is the goal, right?

I would see them as complimentary in certain spots.

I guess it depends on what your definition of serviceable is.

Okay- I guess I’m confused as to how you think we will be better without returning those guys considering the underwhelming class we have coming in.

Keeping these guys around for 2-4 years would be great. It would also be more fun as a Kentucky fan because we could actually get to know the guys and develop some sort of continuity with them. If we are going to be a S16/ EE team regardless I’d rather do it with guys we’ve seen play for awhile as opposed to a brand new set of 2nd tier 5 stars and 4 stars.

Those guys will probably never be elite or even great. But they can be good/ average/ above average role players with experience which is something we constantly lack.

Basically we will probably be bad next year regardless. So it’s a matter of being 8-12 wins bad if we lose 9 guys or 16-14 / 17-13 / 18-12 bad if we are able to return them.

Cal is simply no longer getting the elite superstars anymore. Next years class outside of maybe Oscar won’t be world beaters their freshman year. So why not return players and start a trend of keeping guys 3-4 years?

EJ was never going to be great but I’d love to have him on this team. Hagans was never going to be great but I’d love to have him. NR etc etc etc
 
Dec 8, 2009
30
42
0
Sure. Please re-read my post.

I mentioned Toppin and Mintz because they should be contributors, I would even maybe throw Brooks into the mix as serviceable. However, I see Toppin developing at a much faster rate at the same position.

Jackson, Boston, and Clarke will not be back and I am not sure how you can pin that on the coach. Jackson has developed into a lottery pick and Clarke and Boston were gone before the season started. We can debate the validity of those decisions, but it is reality.

There will be no minutes for Sarr next year.

Ware, Askew, and (probably) Allen will be back, but I am not sure you can make a case that they are serviceable on a contending team. That is the goal, right?

I would see them as complimentary in certain spots.

I guess it depends on what your definition of serviceable is.
For 2020 to 2021 you are accurate but I think he was speaking generally. Without a doubt regardless of how horrible this season went Clarke, Boston and Jackson were gone. I would include Brooks in this category because he very nearly left after last season. Without getting into the specifics for these players, in a perfect world it would be nice if we entered 2021 with building blocks of Askew, Toppin, Allen, Fletcher and Ware. After seeing how 2020 played out obviously Fletcher won't be back, and I am sure the feeling is mutual.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
Probably the safest bet.


If the above occurs next year will not be great.

It may be better than this year but I see a 16-14 / 17-13 /19-12 type season if this comes to fruition.

Inevitably we will have the resident John Calipari defense squad say “Look y’all! Look how much we’ve improved!” But deep down we will know it’ll be an underwhelming season in which 6-9 more will leave after.
 
Mar 19, 2006
1,138
771
113
[/QUOTE]
We certainly don't want a repeat of this **** show but I would hope that with a year under their belt Calipari and staff could develop them. If we brought back half of the team next year and we still look like we do now, we have even bigger problems. I am frustrated by this season but I am not willing to write any of the freshmen off permanently because their freshman season didn't go well at all. If any decide to transfer, we all know they will be good contributors for their new schools later in their careers.

Here are the freshman that should return:

Askew
Ware

I think they can be fine complimentary players, but if you expect them to develop into championship caliber, I think you will be disappointed. There are far too many deficiencies in their games.

If this is writing them off, then so be it.

I really hope I am wrong, BTW.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

TortElvisII

Heisman
May 7, 2010
51,700
96,942
66
You are eating up all the negative comments on this board and posting a few for dessert.

Do you ever have anything basketball related or is everything just a put down? Make sure you stop by and get your commemorative we're 7 and 13 shirts.

 
Last edited:

Kywildcat_nation28

All-Conference
Jan 28, 2014
2,441
2,834
113
If a player transfer out after 1 season because he didn't get playing time he shouldn't play any where. That should make the individual work harder and be more determined to be up for a challenge! That's like quitting so if you go to the NBA and don't play what u gonna quit a d become a salesman?
 

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
Honestly? And I don’t mean it combatively and it’s just my opinion but someone like Askew who has the potential to be pretty good but never “great” may want to go somewhere where he will get better coaching. Someone who can work with his skill set and help him flourish as opposed to just kind of throwing him out to the wolves with no set offense whatsoever as John Calipari doesn’t really run an actual offense.
Sure. Just like most of the other point guards that have played for Cal and washed out in the NBA that needed better coaching. Like Derrick Rose, Tyreke Evans, John Wall, Brandon Knight, Tyrese Maxey, Deaaron Fox, Immanuel Quickely, Tyler Ulis and Shai Gilgeous- Alexander.
 
Dec 8, 2009
30
42
0


Here are the freshman that should return:

Askew
Ware

I think they can be fine complimentary players, but if you expect them to develop into championship caliber, I think you will be disappointed. There are far too many deficiencies in their games.

If this is writing them off, then so be it.

I really hope I am wrong, BTW.
[/QUOTE]
Complimentary players is fine with me. I would be delusional if I thought the returning players would lead us on a championship run. I am just tired of Cal always saying "well we're young!" when when he is the sole reason why we are always so young. Year over year there are guys that I wish he would have gotten to stick around, this is not just about 2020 going in to 2021 for me.
 

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
Next Season Roster:
Askew
Hickman
2G Transfer
2G Recruit
Mintz (I would not have expected this, but now sounds possible)
Allen
Brooks
Toppin
Hopkins
Ware
Collins
Tshiebwe


If that is close to our actual roster do you ( or others ) see that team as a threat to hang # 9 ? or reach a FF ? I dont . JMHO .
 

ManitouDan_anon

Heisman
Dec 7, 2006
20,073
32,434
0
This is the most logical point I've seen on this thread...and the only 1 person who offered an opinion was...basically stating why do we want 6-9 players to return and outside of Toppin/Mintz...the roster was a shitshow.

So i am still waiting for the Cal believers to truly believe a roster of
- PG Askew/Hickman....maybe Skyy Clark
- SG Mintz if he comes back, Skyy Clark maybe....Allen if does not transfer
- SF Toppin, Fletcher if he does not transfer
- PF Ware Hopkins....maybe Brooks comes back
- C Tshwhiebe and Collins

I think the roster above is your most likely 2021/22 roster. (and I argue one or both of Fletcher or Allen leaves).
1. So there are still huge PG problems IMO.
2. Not sure Mintz is a really good SG.
3. I see huge scoring issues abound in the combination of PG, SG and SF unless Skyy Clark is a re-incarnation of Jamal Murray (hint he's not)
4. I think we'll be dang good interior defense with Tschwiebe's size and Collins replaces Jackson's shotblocking

So is that a top 10 team....I don't see it.


Yep . We are headed towards a huge turnaround by the master , should easily be 19-10 next year . Or worse.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
Some are saying most are going to come back, there's absolutely zero chance of that happening, estimate we lose from 7-9 players. What's your prediction? Mine:

Jackson - NBA
Boston - NBA
Clarke - NBA
Saar - D/G League/Overseas
Mintz - D/G League/Overseas (possible return)
Brooks - D/G League/Overseas
Allen - Transfer (possible return)
Ware - Transfer
Fletcher - Transfer
I really like Jackson and think he is playing well, but to me, his game needs more than just putbacks. He cannot score in the post at all and he's almost 7 foot. Hasn't seemed to develop any kind of post game so far this year.
Now maybe, because the game has evolved into spread out and shoot it, he is highly coveted by the NBA because of his athletic ability and being able run the floor and alter shots and rebound, but I think he should work on that area of his game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

1STSergeant

Junior
Mar 7, 2020
336
217
43
Some are saying most are going to come back, there's absolutely zero chance of that happening, estimate we lose from 7-9 players. What's your prediction? Mine:

Jackson - NBA
Boston - NBA
Clarke - NBA
Saar - D/G League/Overseas
Mintz - D/G League/Overseas (possible return)
Brooks - D/G League/Overseas
Allen - Transfer (possible return)
Ware - Transfer
Fletcher - Transfer
 
Mar 19, 2006
1,138
771
113
Okay- I guess I’m confused as to how you think we will be better without returning those guys considering the underwhelming class we have coming in.

Keeping these guys around for 2-4 years would be great. It would also be more fun as a Kentucky fan because we could actually get to know the guys and develop some sort of continuity with them. If we are going to be a S16/ EE team regardless I’d rather do it with guys we’ve seen play for awhile as opposed to a brand new set of 2nd tier 5 stars and 4 stars.

Those guys will probably never be elite or even great. But they can be good/ average/ above average role players with experience which is something we constantly lack.

Basically we will probably be bad next year regardless. So it’s a matter of being 8-12 wins bad if we lose 9 guys or 16-14 / 17-13 / 18-12 bad if we are able to return them.

Cal is simply no longer getting the elite superstars anymore. Next years class outside of maybe Oscar won’t be world beaters their freshman year. So why not return players and start a trend of keeping guys 3-4 years?

EJ was never going to be great but I’d love to have him on this team. Hagans was never going to be great but I’d love to have him. NR etc etc etc

First of all, winning cures everything. The only people that were complaining about one and done prior to this year, were the psychos that expect UK to be in the Final 4 every year.

Would UK be better? Yes...but only marginally. No matter what, they are losing 57% (Boston, Clarke, Jackson, and Sarr) of the scoring off of this years historically horrible team.

Marginal improvement will not cut it with how bad this team is currently constructed. It needs a complete overhaul by UK's standards. I think that is what you meant here:

Basically we will probably be bad next year regardless. So it’s a matter of being 8-12 wins bad if we lose 9 guys or 16-14 / 17-13 / 18-12 bad if we are able to return them

I think you are also giving up on next year too soon. Collins and Tshiebwe should be more than adequate in the paint. Ware can be plugged in as a backup, but UK is going to need to add here. Maybe Hopkins can provide some help. <Insert One time transfer rule here>

Small forward should be in great shape with Toppin and Brooks.

Right now, the point guard position is again going to be a point of concern. Mintz MUST return, or UK is going to either have persuade Skyy Clark to reclassify or hit a home run with Hickman. If they can get two of Hardy, Sallis, Podziemski, and Keels to sign...backcourt problem solved.

Also, don't underestimate the one time transfer rule. The talent available to re-stock will be deeper than ever.

There is zero excuse for UK to be this poor. It took the perfect storm to get here(Last year's exodus, missing on Cunningham, COVID, losing Payne, poor player evaluation), but it wont take everything going right to get out of it, either.

But...they do need to figure out the point sooner rather than later.
 
Mar 28, 2014
381
649
0
Genuinely asking for the John Calipari defense squad...

If we lose 6-9 players off the worst team in Kentucky basketball history, will you still honestly believe John Calipari’s system isn’t broken? If we lose 6-9 players with what we have coming in do you honestly think we will be a good team next year?
As a Cal supporter, no. If we lose 6-9 players off this team and struggle again next year, I will believe the system is broken. Having said that, if we only lose 4 off this team, stay in top 15 next year, win either SEC Regular season or tourney title and go to at least elite 8, I will continue to support Cal and his system.
What would be your reaction to the above scenario?
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Playoff Viewing Guide: What games Kentucky fans need to follow in Week 11
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Kentucky vs. Indiana: Preview, Odds & How to Watch
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Sources Say goes LIVE to talk Kentucky vs. Indiana and the latest in recruiting
  5. 05 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: What to know about Thursday's update