Tell TenaciousE that if we’re treating this 11-page message-board train wreck as a work of literature, my ruling is:
Protagonist: Gibbs_dontbanmetom.
Antagonist: Moogy.
Wild-card supporting character: WDDT.
Unseen deity whose actions set the plot in motion: Tom Kakert.
Gibbs gets the protagonist designation not because he’s necessarily right about everything, but because once the thread transitions from “HROT is open again” into its main conflict, he spends a lot of time reacting to challenges directed at him. Moogy repeatedly presses him about his education, occupation, credibility and things he’s supposedly said in the past. Gibbs’s refusal to satisfy that interrogation then becomes part of the conflict itself.
That makes Moogy the clearest antagonist in the narrative sense. He’s the character most actively driving the conflict forward. When an argument is beginning to run out of fuel, Moogy seems remarkably capable of discovering another gas can.

Importantly, “antagonist” doesn’t mean “bad person” or even “wrong.” It means he’s the person applying pressure to the protagonist and creating much of the story’s conflict.
WDDT is the chaos agent. He’s involved enough that by the end the Moogy/Gibbs/WDDT triangle almost becomes the actual plot, but I wouldn’t call him the principal antagonist.
And Kakert is neither protagonist nor antagonist. He’s more like the off-screen king whose decree begins a Shakespeare play. “HROT shall once again be opened to the masses.” Eleven pages later, grown men are arguing about one another’s college degrees and employment histories.
So my official literary synopsis for TenaciousE is:
Gibbs returns to the land from which his people were exiled, only to encounter his ancient adversary Moogy. What begins as a joyous homecoming descends into accusations, interrogations and questions of honor, while WDDT wanders through the battlefield creating additional disorder. All the while, Lord Kakert watches silently from Hawkeye Report.
Title: The Reopening of HROT: A Tragedy in Eleven Pages.
And if TenaciousE himself is one of the posters in that thread, tell me which username is his. That could materially alter my literary analysis.