How would the 2014 team have finished?

BKCBully

Sophomore
Jul 19, 2013
363
109
28
The difference is Mullen had proven he could have success here even before he had a superstar at QB. Lebby at the point Kamario got hurt was 11-18 (3-15). Zero benefit of the doubt earned.

Dan would have run the piss out of the ball, played good defense, and still probably gotten the 2014 team to 8 wins at a minimum.
Let me remind you dan thought he could make Tyson lee and Tyler russel fit his offense. I LOVED DAN by the way.
 

BKCBully

Sophomore
Jul 19, 2013
363
109
28
I will say that Ohio State has gone 1-4 since their starting QB went out for the season. It makes a huge difference. However, we have looked absolutely hopeless since Kamario was hurt. We should’ve beaten Vandy even with a backup quarterback and losing 41-9 to Auburn was pathetic.
Dude I'm only 33 I've seen auburn beat us worse that that 29 times.
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,886
3,357
113
Let me remind you dan thought he could make Tyson lee and Tyler russel fit his offense. I LOVED DAN by the way.
I dont know how many games the 2014 team would have won without Dak, but I know they would not have gone 3/17 on third downs against Auburn.

Dan would have run the ball with Damian, and if he had to he would have burned Fitzgerald's redshirt (probably not, since Dan was loyal to upper classmen, but maybe). The team would still have been competent, would have played great D, and managed 6 or 7 wins. They would not have been a complete embarrassment.

A good offensive scheme gives you options. If the defense takes away one option, you switch tactics. Dan could run the ball non stop, or he could pass the ball all day -- he won 8 games with Tyler Russell, BTW.

Lebby throws deep passes. He gets fast receivers into 1 on 1 battles with corners and let's KT sling it out there. You know what other offensive coaches do that? ALL OF THEM.

The difference is, all the other OCs could have scored more than 2 TDs against this year's Vandy squad.
 

BKCBully

Sophomore
Jul 19, 2013
363
109
28
The difference is Mullen had proven he could have success here even before he had a superstar at QB. Lebby at the point Kamario got hurt was 11-18 (3-15). Zero benefit of the doubt earned.

Dan would have run the piss out of the ball, played good defense, and still probably gotten the 2014 team to 8 wins at a minimum.
How would 14 or 15 have gone with a backup qb . And let's compare 14 in that scenario to these last 2 with fluff only in part time. So then tell me how dan would've RAN
The difference is Mullen had proven he could have success here even before he had a superstar at QB. Lebby at the point Kamario got hurt was 11-18 (3-15). Zero benefit of the doubt earned.

Dan would have run the piss out of the ball, played good defense, and still probably gotten the 2014 team to 8 wins at a minimum.
Dan would've ran the piss out of the ball with Josh (im going pro robinson) Griffin shumpert and Holloway backing him up . And no passing attack?
 

GOOD_DAWG

Sophomore
Sep 1, 2012
224
141
43
If Damian had to take over after the lsu game? Don't even try to say we would've been decent. Think south Alabama. Anytime you're starting qb gets hurt... especially when he's the driving force and a heisman candidate. You get a pass. Some of yall just love to hate the man.
We are at the point where it’s not even worth posting about. People who are upset are (mostly) being obstinate and refuse to reason because they would rather ignore reality than have a discussion about what has occurred on the football field.

Once I saw the “it’s worse than Croom posts”- I knew that folks would rather throw a hissy fit than allow any nuance into the discussion. Not worth the energy unless someone will have a real discussion.
 
  • Downvote
Reactions: Crossroaddawg

The Cooterpoot

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
7,772
13,615
113
If Damian had to take over after the lsu game? Don't even try to say we would've been decent. Think south Alabama. Anytime you're starting qb gets hurt... especially when he's the driving force and a heisman candidate. You get a pass. Some of yall just love to hate the man.
Some of us see he's suck for 3 years now and can't recruit even fans to a game
 

Walkthedawg

All-Conference
Oct 3, 2022
1,222
2,202
113
If Damian had to take over after the lsu game? Don't even try to say we would've been decent. Think south Alabama. Anytime you're starting qb gets hurt... especially when he's the driving force and a heisman candidate. You get a pass. Some of yall just love to hate the man.
Now compare Lebby with Chris Relf.
 

MSUDC11-2.0

Heisman
Sep 29, 2022
11,315
18,526
113
How would 14 or 15 have gone with a backup qb . And let's compare 14 in that scenario to these last 2 with fluff only in part time. So then tell me how dan would've RAN

Dan would've ran the piss out of the ball with Josh (im going pro robinson) Griffin shumpert and Holloway backing him up . And no passing attack?
He would have probably rolled with RS freshman Nick Fitzgerald in 2015 and still gotten us to bowl eligibility.

Again, you don’t get to use the injury get out of jail free card when your record sucked before the QB got hurt. Mullen proved he could have pockets of success here without Dak. Lebby without Kamario is Chad Morris era Arkansas.
 

She Mate Me

Heisman
Dec 7, 2008
15,481
15,193
113
Obviously it's fact and not a joke

Auburn has beaten us by more points than the 32 this year 4 times in the last 33 years, not 29 times as you seem to believe.

Hell, we’ve beaten them 11 times in that span.

So yeah, you’re full of **** about that too.

All the KT injury did is make it very clear how 17’n good KT is and that Lebby is just as inept as he has appeared to be for three years now unless he has a future NFL star at QB (which is an extremely rare occurrence in Mississippi State history).
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,886
3,357
113
Lebby sucks balls but at the same time he aint getting fired this year. Probly not next year either. Post Kamario we will go in the dumpster Ahh gain and it will become too painful for Selmon to keep him. Screaming fire him is a waste of time
This is why I have completely given up hope. There is still a little piece of me hoping Lebby will get canned, but it's not going to happen. We will have some fun wins next year; it will end in disappointment.

I'm not screaming "fire him", but I reserve the right to mock anyone who thinks retaining him is a good idea.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,546
33,444
113
You done bumped yo head

It's pretty Miss Stake of our fans to act like it's the easiest thing in the world to do, to replace NFL QBs, I mean we should know right, we've had so many of them
Don’t be ridiculous. We were already 4-0 & had games remaining vs Kentucky, Arkansas, Vandy (combined sec record 4-22) & UT-Martin remaining. We’d win 3 of those for sure.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: She Mate Me

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
14,720
13,543
113
Don’t be ridiculous. We were already 4-0 & had games remaining vs Kentucky, Arkansas, Vandy (combined sec record 4-22) & UT-Martin remaining. We’d win 3 of those for sure.
Ah, I forgot about the assumption that we would be 4-0. Because without Dak we lose to UAB in week 2. I was there. And certainly don't beat LSU.

But OK, 4-0. Kentucky and Arkansas almost beat us, of course some of that was us being complacent and being the target. But we wouldn't win those games. So I'm saying 6-0 ceiling because Vandy was terrible that year.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,546
33,444
113
Ah, I forgot about the assumption that we would be 4-0. Because without Dak we lose to UAB in week 2. I was there. And certainly don't beat LSU.

But OK, 4-0. Kentucky and Arkansas almost beat us, of course some of that was us being complacent and being the target. But we wouldn't win those games. So I'm saying 6-0 ceiling because Vandy was terrible that year.
Well, if you want to compare that team to this one without Dak or KT all season the difference is even bigger. 6-6 vs 2-10. That 2014 team had a lot of talent at other positions & good OL & DL.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,837
8,278
113
The difference is Mullen had proven he could have success here even before he had a superstar at QB. Lebby at the point Kamario got hurt was 11-18 (3-15). Zero benefit of the doubt earned.
Without K1 playing half the game, against FBS:
2024: 1-10 (0-8)
2025: 2-5 (0-5)
2026: 0-5 (0-5)
Overall: 3-20 (0-18)

With K1 playing at least half the game (all have been FBS):
2025: 1-3 (1-2)
2026: 4-1 (2-1)
Overall: 5-4 (3-3)

That’s what’s so crazy about all this. Lebby has THREE total wins over FBS teams, in three seasons, without K1 being involved. Those wins are UMass (2024), USM (2025), and Arizona State (2025). But, even with K1, he’s just been barely over .500.

That’s how bad Lebby is. As good as Taylor is, we’re still just a 7-5 / 8-4 team at best if Lebby is still running the show with K1 healthy all season. It’s been proven. That’s why all this discussion about continuity just for continuity’s sake is a terrible idea. K1 isn’t good enough to get a Jeff Lebby coached team to a 24-team playoff. Nobody is.
 

Crossroaddawg

Senior
Oct 30, 2019
743
660
83
If Damian had to take over after the lsu game? Don't even try to say we would've been decent. Think south Alabama. Anytime you're starting qb gets hurt... especially when he's the driving force and a heisman candidate. You get a pass. Some of yall just love to hate the man.
If a man can win with Chris Relf I think he could’ve gamed up some dubs in that stretch with Damian. But keep carrying water for Jebby
 

Crossroaddawg

Senior
Oct 30, 2019
743
660
83
We are at the point where it’s not even worth posting about. People who are upset are (mostly) being obstinate and refuse to reason because they would rather ignore reality than have a discussion about what has occurred on the football field.

Once I saw the “it’s worse than Croom posts”- I knew that folks would rather throw a hissy fit than allow any nuance into the discussion. Not worth the energy unless someone will have a real discussion.
The thing is the program has looked like a Croom lead team for the majority of his tenure
 
  • Like
Reactions: Corby.sixpack

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,837
8,278
113
If Damian had to take over after the lsu game? Don't even try to say we would've been decent. Think south Alabama. Anytime you're starting qb gets hurt... especially when he's the driving force and a heisman candidate. You get a pass. Some of yall just love to hate the man.
This about the most horrid apples-and- oranges comparison imaginable.

First off - Damien Williams was light years better than Puckett / Swann. Not even close. Secondly, he wouldn’t have even been the long-term QB if Dak got hurt. Perhaps you forgot that there was another QB on that 2014 team. If Dak went down after LSU, and DW wasn’t ready, we simply would have pulled the redshirt off Fitzgerald (even if it took a game or two), and proceeded to win a few more.

You see, real coaches have a backup plan, AND a backup plan to the backup plan at the most important position on the field.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Crossroaddawg

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,886
3,357
113
Ah, I forgot about the assumption that we would be 4-0. Because without Dak we lose to UAB in week 2. I was there. And certainly don't beat LSU.

But OK, 4-0. Kentucky and Arkansas almost beat us, of course some of that was us being complacent and being the target. But we wouldn't win those games. So I'm saying 6-0 ceiling because Vandy was terrible that year.
The OP's hypothetical was we lose Dak after the LSU game, so, yeah, 4-0.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Everything Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said in Egg Bowl week press conference
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State PFF Grades from 34-16 win over Tennessee Tech
  3. 03 Maroon and White "Give us a chance, we can make the plays": Anthony Evans III speaks on getting the offense firing again
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State offense does enough to overcome errors, early nerves against Tennessee Tech
  5. 05 Maroon and White Rapid Recap: Mississippi State 34-16 Tennessee Tech