How would Rutgers do running an Army type offense?

miketd1

Heisman
Sep 26, 2006
59,714
13,917
66
If HS teams can run RPOs well, im sure a B1G team can.
My comment was specific to the Eagles offense and not to RPOs in general.

IMO, the Eagles are successful in running RPOs because they use RPOs mainly as a change-up. Run too many of them and defenses will catch on and begin to "sit" on them, especially since most RPOs are a single read. They have to be a single read by design in order to avoid having linemen (who are run-blocking) ineligible downfield.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,986
8,958
113
It wouldn't work at RU because the option requires the ability to block people, something that Georgia Tech and the service academies have mastered and RU has struggled with.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
27,144
19,426
113
G tech is still putting up good numbers this year on offense. they average 37.3 ppg and average 453 yards per game.

Well 63 against Bowling Green and 66 against the #2 trainwreck of the year, Louisville, skews those stats a little
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
Army's option has become entertaining to watch since players and coaching got better. There is a lot more running than passing, but the passing has increased and there are a lot of big strikes. You lose the shorter ticky-tacky passes. Army's WR are massively better than they used to be (blockers with hands of stone). Army's QB is really a RB who can throw, and the recent Army QBs break a lot of good sized runs. Games haven't been boring at all. Army owns 4th down and almost always goes for it and gets a first down. The "three and out" thing is gone. Averaging 5-6yds a carry opens-up 4th.

But Army plays a lot of weaker teams, and then once a year plays a big team not used to the option. Army has put scares in PSU, Oklahoma and Stanford. Running option in B1G every year could get stale. I know Meyer hated playing Navy and Army but Schiano is pretty much the best option killer around.

There were rule changes this year that make the option harder

Is college football’s new rule on cut blocks harming the triple option?

Short answer: we don’t know yet. Longer answer: there are signs that it’s hurting in a significant way.

https://www.sbnation.com/college-fo...t-block-rule-army-navy-air-force-georgia-tech
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
it only really works at service academies who run it out of need.
That said Monken is a great motivator as a head Coach.


He's a good fit at Army. Unlike prior coaches, he was never intimidated by the scene up there. Past coaches bent over backwards catering to "the mission". Monken is like "Hey I respect what you all are doing, but I'm here to coach winning football so don't mind me if that's where I focus"

Curious thing about Monken is that he "sees everything" - large and small. After a game, you could ask Schiano about some play that went wrong and Greg would say "I had the worst seat in the house, and will have to watch the film to know what happened." Monken never says that. He'll reply about how so and so was out of position and another guy was using his hands wrong. He doesn't miss much of anything
 
Last edited:
Nov 10, 2003
11,777
3,298
0
I think most high schools across the country now run some form of spread. The game is evolving, as always.

I think running an option attack could work to a point; but you would doom yourselves to missing out on much of the best high school offensive talent coming out of NJ. Just find yourself a Jeff Brohm.
And we're not already missing out on these kids???lmao, your kidding right???
 

Debtbubble

Heisman
Feb 15, 2016
5,029
13,172
0
Not true at all.

If you want to be competitive playing college football and don't care about recruiting/developing pro's on offense than it would work here too. It's dated in the modern game but Notre Dame, West Virginia and Nebraska all ran it in the late 80's. The Huskers ran it into the 90's. Syracuse ran the "freeze option" even with McNabb. Notre Dame's last national championship came running the option.

I'd hire Monken in a second but I doubt he'd take this job.


For 2 million a year with an escalation clause plus bonuses for bowl games?
 
  • Like
Reactions: tico brown

rutger80

All-Conference
Oct 14, 2013
2,477
1,762
0
Problem with the Georgia Tech (and other option-type offenses) is that if you fall behind, you're basically screwed. It's not an offense that can get you back into games, especially if you put the ball on the ground, which the Jackets tend to do.
It's rare for them to have a QB who can consistently throw and receivers who know that most of the time, they will only be blocking, not catching.

No to the option.
 

tico brown

Heisman
Oct 16, 2005
45,073
15,222
93
Problem with the Georgia Tech (and other option-type offenses) is that if you fall behind, you're basically screwed. It's not an offense that can get you back into games, especially if you put the ball on the ground, which the Jackets tend to do.
It's rare for them to have a QB who can consistently throw and receivers who know that most of the time, they will only be blocking, not catching.

No to the option.
Well, you can say that about all offenses if ball is on the ground or interceptions are thrown.
 

graystork

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2008
8,515
3,367
0
As a defender of the pro set, I think the bone has it's plusses and minuses. I love to watch the service academies play and frustrate the hell out of teams with better talent. I wonder what we could do with the better talent we should be able to get. With top notch talent, like Oklahoma, Texas, Alabama and Nebraska used to pull in, it's extremely tough to beat.

The knock on it is that familiarity is the key to beating it. So if you're forcing your conference mates to prepare for it once a year, eventually they'll get better at defending it. I don't think we'll ever be able to compete toe to toe with the Ohio States of the world on their terms. Could this level the playing field for us? I'm undecided.

Paul Johnson's record at Ga. Tech
2008 9-4
2009 11-3
2010 6-7
2011 8-5
2012 7-7
2013 7-6
2014 11-3
2015 3-9
2016 9-4
2017 5-6
 

BoogieKnight

Heisman
Oct 15, 2007
70,943
17,477
82
As a defender of the pro set, I think the bone has it's plusses and minuses. I love to watch the service academies play and frustrate the hell out of teams with better talent. I wonder what we could do with the better talent we should be able to get. With top notch talent, like Oklahoma, Texas, Alabama and Nebraska used to pull in, it's extremely tough to beat.

The knock on it is that familiarity is the key to beating it. So if you're forcing your conference mates to prepare for it once a year, eventually they'll get better at defending it. I don't think we'll ever be able to compete toe to toe with the Ohio States of the world on their terms. Could this level the playing field for us? I'm undecided.

Paul Johnson's record at Ga. Tech
2008 9-4
2009 11-3
2010 6-7
2011 8-5
2012 7-7
2013 7-6
2014 11-3
2015 3-9
2016 9-4
2017 5-6

It beats getting our *** kicked in the B1G. And before someone says “but 2014...” Ralph Friedgen was quoted as saying something along the lines of “I don’t like losing 49-3” on his way out the door following that season. So yeah, it happened that season too.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,449
13,339
113
As a defender of the pro set, I think the bone has it's plusses and minuses. I love to watch the service academies play and frustrate the hell out of teams with better talent. I wonder what we could do with the better talent we should be able to get. With top notch talent, like Oklahoma, Texas, Alabama and Nebraska used to pull in, it's extremely tough to beat.

The knock on it is that familiarity is the key to beating it. So if you're forcing your conference mates to prepare for it once a year, eventually they'll get better at defending it. I don't think we'll ever be able to compete toe to toe with the Ohio States of the world on their terms. Could this level the playing field for us? I'm undecided.

Paul Johnson's record at Ga. Tech
2008 9-4
2009 11-3
2010 6-7
2011 8-5
2012 7-7
2013 7-6
2014 11-3
2015 3-9
2016 9-4
2017 5-6

If you dont think we will ever be able to compete with the OSUs of the world on their terms, why defend the "Pro-Set"?

The triple option is the same philosophy as the Air-Raid (super fast pace/no huddle/4WR 1 RB/constant motion).

Try to out scheme/coach the oppenent instead of out muscle/skill them.
Go to an extreme and do something to unsettle the defense - make it so they cant guess where the ball is going each play.

And I can guarantee that the triple option would take more than 1 year to implement.
Can't go abandoning the offense just because it failed in the first year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoobyCow
Nov 10, 2003
11,777
3,298
0
Oklahoma,Nebraska,and Texas became National powers running various forms of the Wishbone. It could/would still be very successfully run with 2* and 3* kids because the Service Academies run it with smaller and less recruited players. I believe back in the Levell Edwards days at BYU, when he really kicked up the college approach to the passing game that other schools saw the future of college football. Kids wanted to play in that offense and I remember those high scoring Holiday Bowls played in December with BYU almost every year taking on the Big Boys. WE WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO RUN A CONVENTIONAL OFFENSE IN THE BIG TEN!!!
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,449
13,339
113
Oklahoma,Nebraska,and Texas became National powers running various forms of the Wishbone. It could/would still be very successfully run with 2* and 3* kids because the Service Academies run it with smaller and less recruited players. I believe back in the Levell Edwards days at BYU, when he really kicked up the college approach to the passing game that other schools saw the future of college football. Kids wanted to play in that offense and I remember those high scoring Holiday Bowls played in December with BYU almost every year taking on the Big Boys. WE WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO RUN A CONVENTIONAL OFFENSE IN THE BIG TEN!!!

Actually just heard a really good quote by Mike Leach of all people.

He said "run/pass" balance is crap. Its about balancing out between all your skill positions.

He specifically praised the wishbone. Said yhat it was super balanced because you didnt know who was getting the ball.

https://ftw.usatoday.com/2018/10/mike-leach-run-pass-balance-philosophy-washington-state-football
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
Good article on differences between the wishbone vs flexbone:


"The flexbone isn’t just a way to muck things up.

It often works.

'This offense is tried and tested, because it’s not a gimmick offense,” Niumatalolo said. “People think it’s a gimmick offense, but it’s based on numbers. It’s based on angles. It’s really what a lot of people now are doing out of the spread. They’re just doing it out of the gun. But people are running stuff; it's all numbers-based. When they spread out, if you don’t pick up the right numbers, they’re gonna run the bubble, or you take guys out to take away this, they’ll run the ball inside.'


Why Army and Navy run the triple-option flexbone offense
https://www.sbnation.com/college-fo...3464/army-navy-triple-option-offense-flexbone
 

graystork

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2008
8,515
3,367
0
Was just thinking about one of the most important requirements for this kind of offense. A quarterback who is "really a running back that can throw." And it's good to have more than one because they take a beating. Submitted for your consideration:
1. Isiah Pacheco - QB in high school, has already completed a halfback option
2. Jonathan Lewis - Two way QB now being converted to TE
 

graystork

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2008
8,515
3,367
0
If you dont think we will ever be able to compete with the OSUs of the world on their terms, why defend the "Pro-Set"?

The triple option is the same philosophy as the Air-Raid (super fast pace/no huddle/4WR 1 RB/constant motion).

Try to out scheme/coach the oppenent instead of out muscle/skill them.
Go to an extreme and do something to unsettle the defense - make it so they cant guess where the ball is going each play.

And I can guarantee that the triple option would take more than 1 year to implement.
Can't go abandoning the offense just because it failed in the first year.

Because I think the spread has become the most popular offense and everyone is preparing for it. The pro set requires different preparation as does the wishbone. I like the idea of forcing defenses to defend things they're not familiar with. After the debacle with Ash's first year offense, I also like an offense that takes pressure off the defense by chewing some clock. I'm not saying we should go to the triple option because it would require yet another complete revamp. In a perfect world, I think it could work for us in the Big Ten East.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,449
13,339
113
Because I think the spread has become the most popular offense and everyone is preparing for it. The pro set requires different preparation as does the wishbone. I like the idea of forcing defenses to defend things they're not familiar with. After the debacle with Ash's first year offense, I also like an offense that takes pressure off the defense by chewing some clock. I'm not saying we should go to the triple option because it would require yet another complete revamp. In a perfect world, I think it could work for us in the Big Ten East.

1. I wouldn't put the wishbone/TO/flexbone in the same catergory as the "pro-set". They are much more related to a spread offense in philosophy.

From the above article:
“This offense is tried and tested, because it’s not a gimmick offense,” Niumatalolo said. “People think it’s a gimmick offense, but it’s based on numbers. It’s based on angles. It’s really what a lot of people now are doing out of the spread. They’re just doing it out of the gun. But people are running stuff; it's all numbers-based. When they spread out, if you don’t pick up the right numbers, they’re gonna run the bubble, or you take guys out to take away this, they’ll run the ball inside.”


Both Spread and TO are based on taking advantage of mismatches and numbers.
The "proset" it is based on over powering the defense one on one. No mismatch or deceptions. You aren't looking for a schematic advantage - but a power/strength advantage.
I would highly doubt Rutgers ever has that in the Big Ten East.

Mike Leach - spread offense genius - recently praised the Wishbone for its innovation and balance. You never know where the ball is going among 5/6 skill positions on a play.
http://footballscoop.com/news/mike-leach-theres-nothing-balanced-50-run-50-pass-thats-50-stupid/

2. I would offer that an effective offense chews up clock and helps the defense. Fast or slow doesnt matter.
If you go 3 and out constantly, it doesnt matter. Yesterday is a perfect example - a bad pro-set tires out our defense. Just like a bad spread offense or any type of offense.

However, a fast effective offense can help the defense just as much as a slow effective offense. If the defense knows their offense can and will score, they can take more chances and not worry about giving up 24pts and thinking the game is already over. Defense can play aggressive and know their offense will cover for them if needed.

3. I wouldn't be opposed to the TO. At least it is something different and favors under talented teams - like Rutgers. Like a spread or even Air-Raid offense. But the middle of the road "pro-set" that is designed to be low scoring will never work -especially in the Big Ten East. How many times are we going to over power OSU, UM, MSU, PSU straight up?

But it takes years to perfect the TO. We could hire the Navy coach next year and I would assume we would still be bad for a year or two. Cost of doing business with getting the right system in place. Cant short change it.

Also, keeping something that isnt working just to keep continuity is a terrible philosophy. You are just delaying until something that might actually works gets in there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BoogieKnight

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,449
13,339
113
Also, what is the different preparation that the pro-set requires?

Only covering 2 WRs in space instead of 4?

Knowing the QB is never a threat to run or move out of the pocket?

Never having to worry about 2 RBs (Blackshear and Pacheo) being on the field at the same time and a threat to get the ball?

Knowing you can make substitutions and line up perfectly every play because the offense will never speed things up?
 

graystork

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2008
8,515
3,367
0
Dude you like the spread. We all get it. I don't and never have. You'll have to learn to live with that. I'm not gonna rehash this with you every time I post the words "pro set."
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,986
8,958
113
The common denominator among successful offensive systems is a mastery of the fundamentals. The service academies are effective with the triple option because their players and coaches have mastered the fundamentals of that system. As the Navy coach said, the option system they run is all about angles, numbers, and reads, and their players understand that thoroughly. Run based variants of the spread offense rely on similar concepts.

Contrast the success that the service academies have had with the triple option and other programs that have had similar success installing spread offenses with RU's disastrous attempts to install the spread offense under Ciarocca and Mehringer. Installing a new offensive system without addressing deficiencies in basic fundamentals and expecting a different result is a fantasy.
 
Last edited:

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,509
61,087
113
It wouldn't work at RU because the option requires the ability to block people, something that Georgia Tech and the service academies have mastered and RU has struggled with.
Actually it helps with blocking. You don't have to move people out of the way. Basically all the Olineman are asked to do is imped the Dlineman not hold blocks. It's designed where not everyone has to do their job, you take what the D gives you. What you need is TE's/WR's who can block, a smash mouth fullback, a fast RB and a QB who's not only smart but has a little shake in him.

You get the right teacher who knows how to recruit for it and it would level the playing field very quickly. It's not an offense seen often and asking today's players to stay disciplined for it is tough. Coaches don't spend much time teaching how to defend it, like they do a whole season defending the spread offense. Pro-style is simply too easy to defend without super athletes.
 

studed

All-Conference
Mar 4, 2006
76,604
3,607
113
Oklahoma,Nebraska,and Texas became National powers running various forms of the Wishbone. It could/would still be very successfully run with 2* and 3* kids because the Service Academies run it with smaller and less recruited players. I believe back in the Levell Edwards days at BYU, when he really kicked up the college approach to the passing game that other schools saw the future of college football. Kids wanted to play in that offense and I remember those high scoring Holiday Bowls played in December with BYU almost every year taking on the Big Boys. WE WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO RUN A CONVENTIONAL OFFENSE IN THE BIG TEN!!!
yep this is why purdue best years have been in a spread look. Joe tiller took purdue to a rose bowl. prdue only had 2 winning seasons in 18 years and then they hired a spread coach from wyoming. he went 87-62 as the head coach of purdue. Purdue goes into a funk after tiller and then they hire coach who runs a wide open offense and they are already back to going to bowl games.Now only wisconsin is the only team that is pro style all the time. Others teams in the league have mixed some spread things in. michigan in shotgun running the zone read, msu and iowa take majority of snaps out of shotgun, illinois went spread. Even Alabama went away from pro style. the spread makes the game easier. You have to run spread or wishbone in college football right now
 

Debtbubble

Heisman
Feb 15, 2016
5,029
13,172
0
Right now .500 and a bowl sounds incredible. Army coach would turn it around overnight. Stop the ticket sales collapse. Instantly inject fun and excitement into the program.

But it makes to much sense. Rutgers way is to let it collapse because some professors no one gives a F about complain they spent money.
 

ivan brunetti

Heisman
Nov 26, 2003
16,448
26,638
0
yep this is why purdue best years have been in a spread look. Joe tiller took purdue to a rose bowl. prdue only had 2 winning seasons in 18 years and then they hired a spread coach from wyoming. he went 87-62 as the head coach of purdue. Purdue goes into a funk after tiller and then they hire coach who runs a wide open offense and they are already back to going to bowl games.Now only wisconsin is the only team that is pro style all the time. Others teams in the league have mixed some spread things in. michigan in shotgun running the zone read, msu and iowa take majority of snaps out of shotgun, illinois went spread. Even Alabama went away from pro style. the spread makes the game easier. You have to run spread or wishbone in college football right now

When Tiller was running his spread, it was much more of a novelty. The entire B12 now runs some form of spread.

Navy's option offense is a novelty. Running a spread in 2018 is not.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,509
61,087
113
Right now .500 and a bowl sounds incredible. Army coach would turn it around overnight. Stop the ticket sales collapse. Instantly inject fun and excitement into the program.

But it makes to much sense. Rutgers way is to let it collapse because some professors no one gives a F about complain they spent money.
Your going to have a hard time luring Monken away from West Point. From the article I read he really seems to have embraced the lifestyle there. Loves his player's built in drive and discipline. Right now, he knows his job is about as secure as it's ever going to get being a head football coach. Could he want to someday try out the P5 ranks? Sure, but right now it's doubtful.
 

Debtbubble

Heisman
Feb 15, 2016
5,029
13,172
0
Your going to have a hard time luring Monken away from West Point. From the article I read he really seems to have embraced the lifestyle there. Loves his player's built in drive and discipline. Right now, he knows his job is about as secure as it's ever going to get being a head football coach. Could he want to someday try out the P5 ranks? Sure, but right now it's doubtful.

He’s making $500,000? Offer 2 million a year?

Anyway if something isn’t done soon there won’t be a football program worth worrying about anymore.

It will be a 10 year project to get to .500.
 

koleszar

Heisman
Jan 1, 2010
38,509
61,087
113
He’s making $500,000? Offer 2 million a year?

Anyway if something isn’t done soon there won’t be a football program worth worrying about anymore.

It will be a 10 year project to get to .500.
Not sure where you got your numbers but his 1st deal was for close to $1 mil. till 2020. He just signed a new deal so you have to figure they added some years. Numbers haven't been disclosed but if he's beating Niumatalolo(makes $2 mil.) over at Navy for the 1st time in 15 years you can bet his numbers are close to that. He's now proven himself and beating Navy carries a lot of weight.
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
Your going to have a hard time luring Monken away from West Point. From the article I read he really seems to have embraced the lifestyle there. Loves his player's built in drive and discipline. Right now, he knows his job is about as secure as it's ever going to get being a head football coach. Could he want to someday try out the P5 ranks? Sure, but right now it's doubtful.


When Monken took the job and spoke about it, it seemed to me that he understood what a mess Army was, and that it was a dangerous job. He wasn't running to the job like it was the chance of a lifetime. I think he felt he had to take the job because he knew what was wrong and how to fix it (having coached at Navy under P. Johnson). Now that he's had success, I don't see Army trying to underpay the guy anymore than Army is still sticking to lightweight players (they aren't). Monken isn't paid by gov funding, and I'm sure donations and revenue are both up.

If Rutgers wants to try to hire someone interesting the Army AD Boo Corrigan could be a better find than a coach. He was assistant AD at Notre Dame (where he graduated) for 5 years. He was in place for the hiring or Monken, and he saw all the blueprints. He's a football guy but he developed a lot of the other Army sports. He's a "marketing AD" first but he also worked on constructions.

Boo Corrigan - Staff Directory - Army West Point
https://goarmywestpoint.com/staff.aspx?staff=1
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod