Head of Officials Comments

BonesAndDones

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2009
128
18
0
Originally posted by crestcat:
Originally posted by Festivus Miracle:

The obvious dumb question here is, well, why not?

Originally posted by Festivus Miracle:

The obvious dumb question here is, well, why not?
It really is hard to believe they didn't, aren't they all getting it from the same place, that truck that gets all of the cameras.
No, they stated during the KY game that the NCAA does NOT use the live feed for review and I for one was shocked and confused?
 

fuzz77

All-Conference
Sep 19, 2012
12,163
1,423
0
Originally posted by Ugoff:
Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
I agree, they go to the monitor on EVERY questionable three pointer question, which only impacts 1 point. The NCAA is wildly inconsistent with officiating.
They don't stop the game on questionable 3-pointers unless it is a dead ball situation. It can be reviewed while play continues. You couldn't do the same with the shot clock.

With the shot clock, they should use the lights on the backboard and light up when the shot clock expires. The issue Saturday night was that the stadium was so loud that nobody heard the shot clock buzzer.

Officials are never going to be perfect, calls are going to be missed. I don't really think we want to stop the game and review everything. What's next, reviewing every block/charge? Every foul?
 

c1doc

Junior
Mar 23, 2007
1,234
266
0
Just let them do the Replays on the Jumbotrons at the Arena!! But they won't do that because the crowd would go crazy when they conveniently miss the call!!
 

cal=8

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2009
2,049
1,417
0
The problem is their not held accountable. They can do as they choose.

I can't believe no one is talking about when winslow stepped out of bounds right before okafor got a and 1. I rewinded and a ref was standing right there. He was clearly out of bounds, the commentators saw it and it was a 3 point gift. There was no way that ref didn't see it..

Bottom line is.. You meet duke in the finals, you better be at least 10 points better..
 
Dec 12, 2007
68,157
14,860
0
For him to even say "rocky finish" means he knows they were awful, Ryan was right, and the rest of the college basketball is right about Duke being the favorite sons. It's gotten so bad that they can't even deny it anymore, nor can Laettner. But Bilas still says officials are awesome and play no role in the outcome.
 

UofKBlue

Sophomore
Nov 16, 2009
3,440
166
0
Originally posted by RDCat07:
why not have another ref that is watching a monitor can review questionable calls while the game is live with out stoppage of the game then when there is a stoppage have 2 other refs review. there are many solution to this, and in fact any questionable scoring play should be reviewed (3 vs long 2, shot clock)
I agree with this. Why not have a 4th referee that is sitting on the sidelines with monitors in front of him? If there's a questionable call, he has the ability to "buzz" the refs for them to stop the game long enough for him to review video evidence. Seeing as to how it took CBS no longer than 30 seconds to see the call was horrible, it wouldn't even take that long for the 4th official to make the call from the sideline. No long stoppage....no huddling with the other refs to go over what was seen....nothing. Just make the call and go on with the game.
 

BigBlueFanGA

Heisman
Jun 14, 2005
26,435
23,456
0
It's amazing to me that Adams even made these admissions. This is really going to blow up with it coming on the heels of the nonsense in our game, then Ryan's statements after their loss.

The logical next questions, why didn't they see the angle seen on tv and what exactly do you mean by "rocky finish"?
 

Ugoff

Heisman
May 7, 2009
16,403
21,489
0
Originally posted by fuzz77:


Originally posted by Ugoff:

Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
I agree, they go to the monitor on EVERY questionable three pointer question, which only impacts 1 point. The NCAA is wildly inconsistent with officiating.
They don't stop the game on questionable 3-pointers unless it is a dead ball situation. It can be reviewed while play continues. You couldn't do the same with the shot clock.

With the shot clock, they should use the lights on the backboard and light up when the shot clock expires. The issue Saturday night was that the stadium was so loud that nobody heard the shot clock buzzer.

Officials are never going to be perfect, calls are going to be missed. I don't really think we want to stop the game and review everything. What's next, reviewing every block/charge? Every foul?
Any and all questionable clock issues should result in a stoppage in play and a review. Period.
 

BigBlueCatNation

All-Conference
Jan 31, 2006
77,495
4,426
113
You had to have known that was coming. Officials can spin it anyway they want to, which is why they need to be held accountable to the public/media
 

83Cat_rivals79182

All-Conference
Mar 31, 2009
6,292
1,802
65
Then they should put asterisks next to games that are decided by calls that were found to be erroneous. The shot clock two points is just total BS period. It turned the game.
 

irishcatdaddy

Freshman
Mar 27, 2009
1,755
96
0
I've seen some complain that reviewing calls prolongs the game...or do you review everything and drag out games.... Yet each team gets 5 timeouts and 2846 TV timeouts in a game. There were moments where a team calls a timeout and we go to commercial break... come back.....and 15 seconds later a foul is called and guess what...back to commercials..

Here's an idea.. in the NCAA tourney take away 2 timeouts leaving both teams with 3 and give each team one "challenge" timeout that they can call and ask for officials to review a questionable play at anytime before the final 2 mins.....

Or take away one timeout from each team and extend the reviewable window to 5 mins....

All I know is the game has to change cause the current formula... is not working
 

Hjack

All-American
May 22, 2002
79,219
5,607
0
Originally posted by Ugoff:
Originally posted by fuzz77:


Originally posted by Ugoff:

Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
I agree, they go to the monitor on EVERY questionable three pointer question, which only impacts 1 point. The NCAA is wildly inconsistent with officiating.
They don't stop the game on questionable 3-pointers unless it is a dead ball situation. It can be reviewed while play continues. You couldn't do the same with the shot clock.

With the shot clock, they should use the lights on the backboard and light up when the shot clock expires. The issue Saturday night was that the stadium was so loud that nobody heard the shot clock buzzer.

Officials are never going to be perfect, calls are going to be missed. I don't really think we want to stop the game and review everything. What's next, reviewing every block/charge? Every foul?
Any and all questionable clock issues should result in a stoppage in play and a review. Period.
No contest on the shot clock. This is not a judgement call. 0 or not. They just blew this.
 

TheDude73

Heisman
Jan 7, 2006
24,503
24,562
113
Originally posted by Ugoff:

I wonder if the saw the angle we saw on the shot clock violation.
If he didn't, his employee did. In one replay that night, there was a ref standing right there in front of the camera looking at the play, facing the backboard directly.

The problem may lie in the fact that the light/horn was malfunctioning - there was no light square around the backboard to help. Not making excuses for them, but that was something I noticed.
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
29,215
4,987
113
Originally posted by TheDude73:


Originally posted by Ugoff:

I wonder if the saw the angle we saw on the shot clock violation.
If he didn't, his employee did. In one replay that night, there was a ref standing right there in front of the camera looking at the play, facing the backboard directly.

The problem may lie in the fact that the light/horn was malfunctioning - there was no light square around the backboard to help. Not making excuses for them, but that was something I noticed.
What I noticed was the UK players all motioning that the basket was no good. The way they responded so quickly and completely without any forethought tells me that they all knew it was no good. Usually, one or two players will respond but that was unique.
 

Chuckinden

All-American
Jun 12, 2006
19,008
5,958
113
The NCAA just stated that they are not responsible for holding referees accountable. We just give three of our cronies a whistle and let the chips fall where they may.
 

Waterview Catfan

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2014
6,735
7
0
The Duke bias has come up all year long on this board, and while a few have agreed when me or another poster says it's real, more often than not the notion is shot down by someone(s) who is "more knowlegable". Let me say one more time, if you can't see it, you haven't watched Duke play in the last 25 or so years, or you yourself are biased period.
 

*dezyDECO*

All-Conference
Nov 9, 2014
7,658
2,469
62
Originally posted by Waterview Catfan:
The Duke bias has come up all year long on this board, and while a few have agreed when me or another poster says it's real, more often than not the notion is shot down by someone(s) who is "more knowlegable". Let me say one more time, if you can't see it, you haven't watched Duke play in the last 25 or so years, or you yourself are biased period.

Agreed.

From the NCAA Hall of Shame:


(NO Foul called here ^^^)
 

P3sOverseas

Redshirt
Jul 21, 2012
89
14
0
With the technology available today and the NCAA's budget (especially since most of it comes from March Madness), there's no reason to mess up easy calls. It took all of about 10 seconds to see we got screwed on the shot clock violation... rewind the video a few seconds, slow it down, clock hits 0 and it's still in his hands... call a stoppage, deduct 2 points, UK ball, full shot clock. There should be people "upstairs" reviewing this crap all game long. 50/50 calls, you can still go with the refs, but it's ridiculous that we put these games completely in the hands of 3 people who are demonstrably unreliable, corruptible, and liable to let the crowd or their emotions play a role in their decision making.
 

Dallas-Wild

Heisman
Feb 1, 2005
22,505
35,507
112
Originally posted by Noxium322:
I've noticed every time the refs walk over to the monitors they see a feed of themselves standing in front of the monitor waiting for the replays. The same shot tv viewers are seeing. This guy is FOS.
EXACTLY...total Bull Chit
 

ArtSmass

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2014
1,174
1,567
66
If they go buy a new mattress they'll get a free TV to use to review plays from now on. I think they're 36".
 

Lord_Crow

Junior
Mar 25, 2015
923
298
0
Originally posted by SilentsAreGolden:
But Bilas still says officials are awesome and play no role in the outcome.
Bilas is the most underhanded personality in sport. He 100% has an agenda that he oozes but couches it in such a way that many actually think this guy is objective... well he isn't. He is always at an angle carrying water for Duke and his favorite prey are the numbskulls like the ones that put up that horrendous "K is the GOAT" thread in here last night.

If you're a UK fan and you buy into Bilas then you are a rube that doesn't understand you're being manipulated by a lawyer. Bilas' words are very carefully chosen and parceled out carefully with the big picture in mind and that big picture is Duke.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football What happened on every Kentucky red zone possession against Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Stein Proud of Kentucky's Fight, but will not have a Loser's Mentality
  3. 03 KSR Football Instant Takeaways: Red zone miscues, porous pass defense help continue Kentucky's November losing streak
  4. 04 KSR Football Stein: Kentucky Must Finish Strong in the "Most Important Game of the Year"
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein says he "friggin' hates losing" in his postgame press conference