Head of Officials Comments

akaukswoosh

Hall of Famer
Jan 14, 2006
82,904
127,553
93
SXM College Sports @SiriusXMCollege · 23m 23 minutes ago




NCAA Head of Officials John Adams w/ @TimBrando: Refs didn't see the angle TV viewers saw on controversial out of bounds call last night.
SXM College Sports @SiriusXMCollege · 21m 21 minutes ago



NCAA Head of Officials John Adams also admitted to @TimBrando that the refs had a "rocky finish" in the last 5 minutes of the title game.
This post was edited on 4/7 12:45 PM by Smashcat
 

MWes11

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
12,025
10,106
0
No idea why the refs review calls on a freaking mini 12 inch tv screen. For calls that are going to impact a game, go to the back and look at a big screen to see it clear as day. How they missed the ball off Winslow I will never know.
 

jc2010

All-Conference
May 13, 2008
4,593
4,369
62
Originally posted by Festivus Miracle:

The obvious dumb question here is, well, why not?

Originally posted by Festivus Miracle:

The obvious dumb question here is, well, why not?
It really is hard to believe they didn't, aren't they all getting it from the same place, that truck that gets all of the cameras.
 

W_Heisenberg

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2013
2,435
1,075
0
Plus that's a BS answer...you have a baseline official for a reason, and the main reason is to watch what happens on/around the baseline/post.

When a player drives the line, he absolutely should have an eye on player body and foot.
 

akaukswoosh

Hall of Famer
Jan 14, 2006
82,904
127,553
93
Originally posted by MWes11:
No idea why the refs review calls on a freaking mini 12 inch tv screen. For calls that are going to impact a game, go to the back and look at a big screen to see it clear as day. How they missed the ball off Winslow I will never know.
Considering the millions the NCAA is bagging not to have even B+ technology is terrible and embarrassing.
Heck anybody with a damn ipad could watch the CBS stream and make the call. LOL
 

DS849

Junior
Feb 21, 2008
2,506
399
0
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
 

jc2010

All-Conference
May 13, 2008
4,593
4,369
62
Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
It really does seem stupid when they will go look and the monitor for five minutes to put two tenths of a second back on the clock, and then can't look at whether two points should count or not
 

barryn2000

Senior
Dec 8, 2006
21,194
642
0
Originally posted by Smashcat:
Originally posted by MWes11:
No idea why the refs review calls on a freaking mini 12 inch tv screen. For calls that are going to impact a game, go to the back and look at a big screen to see it clear as day. How they missed the ball off Winslow I will never know.
Considering the millions the NCAA is bagging not to have even B+ technology is terrible and embarrassing.
Heck anybody with a damn ipad could watch the CBS stream and make the call. LOL
It really is sad...hell, my 10 year old has a flatscreen TV, Xbox, Laptop, Ipod and an android phone....he's got more technology in his bedroom than Officials at a NC game?

A 10" monitor
 

Ugoff

Heisman
May 7, 2009
16,403
21,489
0
Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
I agree, they go to the monitor on EVERY questionable three pointer question, which only impacts 1 point. The NCAA is wildly inconsistent with officiating.
 

JBnTN

Redshirt
Dec 30, 2002
3,475
13
0
The whole purpose of replays is to get calls right. If they can't correct obvious errors, why waste time on having "reviews" at all?
 

jes95407

Redshirt
Mar 24, 2009
246
0
11
Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
This is what killed me concerning the shot clock violation in our game. The rules say its un reviewable because its not within the 2 min mark and Rafferty is screaming his heart out that it's un reviewable, but then right after that they break action and go to a commercial break for 5 minutes. Why can't the officials just quickly go check during the break just to make sure, what else are they standing around doing during this time?
 

Ugoff

Heisman
May 7, 2009
16,403
21,489
0
Originally posted by js40484:


Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
This is what killed me concerning the shot clock violation in our game. The rules say its un reviewable because its not within the 2 min mark and Rafferty is screaming his heart out that it's un reviewable, but then right after that they break action and go to a commercial break for 5 minutes. Why can't the officials just quickly go check during the break just to make sure, what else are they standing around doing during this time?
I think if they had tried to review that shot clock violation, Raftery would have yanked the plug on their monitor. The UK hate was off the charts this year.
 

*dezyDECO*

All-Conference
Nov 9, 2014
7,658
2,469
62
Originally posted by js40484:
Don't buy it. As usual, they saw what they wanted to see or not see....
^^^Bingo!


Now imagine if the refs had to give their lame excuses while sitting next to Bo Ryan last night.

That's Must-See-TV right there!
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,209
21,209
103
That may be what he is selling but I am not buying that BS. The officials saw the same angles we did on TV. I don't ever recall an instance where TV viewers had different viewing angles that what was made available to officials. Someone needs to call him out on his BS. I would have more respect if they just said between the three of them they just could come to a definitive determination that he actually touched it and that was what was needed to overturn the call.
 

larry the cable guy

All-Conference
Apr 4, 2006
7,152
2,287
0
Until officials are held accountable and the head of officials quits taking up for them every time they are wrong it will never get better. I agree with Jay Bilas that officials should have a governing body they have to answer to.
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
Irrelevant.

Coach K is GOAT. Just ask the guys who created that thread yesterday. He's a genuine wizard.
 

JMalone4UK

Heisman
Dec 2, 2001
8,779
11,993
113
Originally posted by DS849:
I guess a question I have is why not be able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5 minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or not. pick one not both
Whats it matter? Even when they do go to the monitor they get it wrong half the time anyways. By the way I do agree with you and have been saying the same myself. But if the officials look at the replay and still obviously get the call wrong there's not much you can do about it but laugh.




This post was edited on 4/7 1:19 PM by jmalone7us
 

*dezyDECO*

All-Conference
Nov 9, 2014
7,658
2,469
62
Originally posted by Smashcat:

SXM College Sports @SiriusXMCollege · 21m 21 minutes ago



NCAA Head of Officials John Adams also admitted to @TimBrando that the refs had a "rocky finish" in the last 5 minutes of the title game.

This post was edited on 4/7 12:45 PM by Smashcat
Translation: We just pissed away the ending of the Championship Game... but no biggie, since Puke got the benefit.

Tickets can now go on sale for the official NCAA authorized Coach K slurping booth.
 

knotonalog

Redshirt
Feb 28, 2015
617
2
0
DS849 posted on 4/7/2015...

I guess a question I have is why not be
able to go to monitors anytime of the game on a shot clock question
instead of the last 2 minutes. I mean a missed call in the first 5
minutes could affect the out come of a game. Either use the monitors or
not. pick one not both
______________________________________________________________________________________________________

I agree with the comment that a call in the first five minutes is important , however the team that was penalized on the missed call will have more chances to make it up if it happens early in game.

I think the more calls made available to review will just prolong the game. If you are going to review all calls, there is no need for the refs. What I'm saying is that I think over the long run the officials do a pretty good job. Nearly all calls are judgement calls and no three officials are going to please everyone. Its just part of the game that everyone is going to have to accept. Decisions have to be made by someone any way you look at it. More emphasis should be put on the training of our current refs to help them be better. jmho
 

Lumpy 2

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2011
1,944
1,106
0
Has he made any comments about the officiating in our game? It would be interesting to hear what he had to say about the shot clock violation and the non call on the out of bounds.
 

C1180

Sophomore
Dec 21, 2001
32,443
189
0
Let me just say that IMO that is a big wet crop of BS. Just some more if the Dukie bias Heck I had no dog in that fight but it was so easy to see that the officials were bias and Wisconsin had just knocked out my team.. Wisconsin had been one of the lowest fouling teams in the NCAA all year and suddenly they rack up a boatload of fouls in the second half of that game. Duke was definitely taken care of when it counted.

The truth is both of those teams were flop artist. The way that Duke PG kept jerking his head, flailing his arms and kicking out his legs I thought he had some type of neural disorder. OLE Kryzshitski should be a drama coach. Oh wait he is a drama coach.
 

*dezyDECO*

All-Conference
Nov 9, 2014
7,658
2,469
62
bigblueinsanity posted on 4/7/2015...

Not buying it. If they aren't looking at the angles we can see....then what are they looking at?
___________________________________________________________




Video of K wearing lingerie... batting his eyes and giving them a come-hither look.
 

Cawood86_rivals

Heisman
Feb 20, 2005
36,711
64,715
0
It's beyond question IMO that officiating is being controlled elsewhere. There are probably a hundred cameras and angles being filmed at the FF and these buffoons fail to see the most controversial calls. Hmmm...
 

Lumpy 2

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2011
1,944
1,106
0
Originally posted by Smashcat:

SXM College Sports @SiriusXMCollege · 23m 23 minutes ago




NCAA Head of Officials John Adams w/ @TimBrando: Refs didn't see the angle TV viewers saw on controversial out of bounds call last night.
SXM College Sports @SiriusXMCollege · 21m 21 minutes ago



NCAA Head of Officials John Adams also admitted to @TimBrando that the refs had a "rocky finish" in the last 5 minutes of the title game.
This post was edited on 4/7 12:45 PM by Smashcat
I've seen different times where they've went to the tv monitors to see if they showed a better angle when reviewing a play. If they didn't have a good angle on that play, why didn't they go to the tv monitor to see if they had a better angle?
 

RDCat07

Junior
Mar 26, 2014
514
355
0
why not have another ref that is watching a monitor can review questionable calls while the game is live with out stoppage of the game then when there is a stoppage have 2 other refs review. there are many solution to this, and in fact any questionable scoring play should be reviewed (3 vs long 2, shot clock)
 

Noxium322

All-Conference
Dec 3, 2011
1,648
1,537
0
I've noticed every time the refs walk over to the monitors they see a feed of themselves standing in front of the monitor waiting for the replays. The same shot tv viewers are seeing. This guy is FOS.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football What happened on every Kentucky red zone possession against Missouri
  2. 02 KSR Football Stein Proud of Kentucky's Fight, but will not have a Loser's Mentality
  3. 03 KSR Football Instant Takeaways: Red zone miscues, porous pass defense help continue Kentucky's November losing streak
  4. 04 KSR Football Stein: Kentucky Must Finish Strong in the "Most Important Game of the Year"
  5. 05 KSR Football Will Stein says he "friggin' hates losing" in his postgame press conference