Head Coach vs Glorified Coordinator

Bullldawg78

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2018
1,938
1,651
113
I was curious so looked at it of the 16 SEC Head coaches only 6 call either the Defensive or Offensive plays as opposed to just being more of a CEO of let's be honest multi-million dollar company. Which I feel is preferential gives you the ability to hold coaches to a standard if they aren't the right fit you can still find someone else (that runs your type preference of system).
So for your reading pleasure I listed their current rankings as well as where the opposite side of the ball ranks:

Defense Playcalling:
Clark Lea - 12th total defense, 14th Offense
Brett Venables - 5th total defense, 15th Offense

Offense Playcalling:
Steve Sarkisian - 12th total offense, 3rd Defense
Josh Heupel - 9th total offense, 4th Defense
Lane Kiffin - 1st total offense, 1st Defense
The Big Lebbyowski- 8th total offense, 14th Defense

Just find this interesting, perhaps if we were scoring Showtime style the defense would still be ranked low for us, but I think we have the equivalent right now of Showtime pace (3 and out) without Showtime results (any 17ing points).

Also as a side based on this and other factors I unfortunately think we lose at home to Vandy Saturday!
 
Last edited:

Bullldawg78

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2018
1,938
1,651
113
Lebby is going to be a very hot commodity as an OC. I’m hoping we see a 50% reduction in the buyout obligation after he lands his next gig. And I expect him to thrive as an OC who has no head coaching responsibilities. It’s who and what he is. It’s also exactly what he was when he was Peter Principled here.
I agree, he is a lifetime coordinator, don't feel he has the mental aptitude to be a CEO of a team.
 

FactCheckerBot

All-Conference
Dec 1, 2025
840
1,444
93
Nooooo…….just wait until next year. 😁
dont you put that evil on me GIF
 

AROB44

Junior
Mar 20, 2008
1,442
286
83
CEO of let's be honest multi-million dollar company.

Agree...it's like a multi million dollar company. And we have many on here who think they can make executive decisions on that level. I admit.... I have never reached that level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MagnoliaHunter

msudawg12

Senior
Dec 9, 2008
3,998
754
113
but I think we have the equivalent right now of Showtime pace (3 and out) without Showtime results (any 17ing points).

While, I am certainly in the boat of moving on from Lebby, this may be one of the bigger misconceptions of our current offensive state. We actually have the second lowest three and out rate in the conference. That is actually not a good excuse for our defensive state. injuries and depth on the other hand……
 
  • Like
Reactions: MagnoliaHunter

mcdawg22

Heisman
Sep 18, 2004
13,789
12,459
113
I realize that the landscape has changed in the last 18 years so looking at a UF OC Mullen in 2026 isn’t the same but can I ask what does everyone think is the difference between him SloMo, and Lebby? You can play the hindsight game all you like but I don’t see much difference in their resumes when they were hired. Was it because Mullen say how to win a NC and Meyer gave him a little leadership responsibilities? I’m just curious how you can vet that in the interview process. All three were QB/OC coaches with, at the time, different offenses. People say Moorhead looked good because of Barkley. Mullen had this guy named Tebow. I just feel like coaching hires are a complete crapshoot. Summrall and Golesh were supposed to be great hires yet Will Stein is looking down at them now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dorndawg

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,562
7,047
113
I realize that the landscape has changed in the last 18 years so looking at a UF OC Mullen in 2026 isn’t the same but can I ask what does everyone think is the difference between him SloMo, and Lebby? You can play the hindsight game all you like but I don’t see much difference in their resumes when they were hired. Was it because Mullen say how to win a NC and Meyer gave him a little leadership responsibilities? I’m just curious how you can vet that in the interview process. All three were QB/OC coaches with, at the time, different offenses. People say Moorhead looked good because of Barkley. Mullen had this guy named Tebow. I just feel like coaching hires are a complete crapshoot. Summrall and Golesh were supposed to be great hires yet Will Stein is looking down at them now.
It's definitely more luck than resume. The responsibilities of a HC aren't near comparable to being responsible for one side of the ball. If I had the resources to hire a proven HC (or even a promising HC with just a year or 2 on the resume) in a respectable league, I wouldn't be shopping coordinators unless there were something unique to the situation (alum, continuity, brings a load of talent with him, etc.)

Problem is - I don't get the impression we have the resources to attract a proven HC from a respectable league so we're left shooting craps with hungry coordinators. I hope someone calls be a dubmass and can prove that statement wrong though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mcdawg22 and patdog

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,059
12,970
113
I agree, he is a lifetime coordinator, don't feel he has the mental aptitude to be a CEO of a team.

This isn't directed directly at you 78 but since you mentioned it I'll use your thread to ask my question.

You and AROB44 have both used the term "CEO of the team" in this thread. If Lebby is the "CEO" what exactly is left for him to do when he's got these guys/gals on staff? These are football team job titles w/ pictures of the person that does some of them. What's left for Lebby to do except worry about running the on the field operations?

And these with pictures below are just the tip of the iceberg, it doesn't include the following people who are also already staff:

Senior Director of the DAWG Program, Director of Career & Professional Development / D.A.W.G, Director of Life Skills / D.A.W.G., Senior Director/Recruiting Strategy, Director/On-Campus Recruiting, On-Campus Recruiting Specialist, On Campus Recruiting Fellow, Assistant A.D./Football Creative Strategy, Senior Director/Football Content & Strategy, Executive Assistant to the Head Football Coach. Doesn't include any interns, student workers, etc etc etc.

1793716629104.png
1793716661110.png
1793716913742.png
 

Attachments

  • 1793716714398.png
    1793716714398.png
    22.5 KB · Views: 4

Bullldawg78

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2018
1,938
1,651
113
This isn't directed directly at you 78 but since you mentioned it I'll use your thread to ask my question.

You and AROB44 have both used the term "CEO of the team" in this thread. If Lebby is the "CEO" what exactly is left for him to do when he's got these guys/gals on staff? These are football team job titles w/ pictures of the person that does some of them. What's left for Lebby to do except worry about running the on the field operations?

And these with pictures below are just the tip of the iceberg, it doesn't include the following people who are also already staff:

Senior Director of the DAWG Program, Director of Career & Professional Development / D.A.W.G, Director of Life Skills / D.A.W.G., Senior Director/Recruiting Strategy, Director/On-Campus Recruiting, On-Campus Recruiting Specialist, On Campus Recruiting Fellow, Assistant A.D./Football Creative Strategy, Senior Director/Football Content & Strategy, Executive Assistant to the Head Football Coach. Doesn't include any interns, student workers, etc etc etc.

View attachment 1514844
View attachment 1514845
View attachment 1514852
I understand. My simple answer would be he is in charge of making sure these people are doing their jobs correctly and we're getting what we expect out of their performance. If not, he needs to look for somebody else and replace them, as well as being the face of the program.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Corby.sixpack

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,825
8,259
113
I realize that the landscape has changed in the last 18 years so looking at a UF OC Mullen in 2026 isn’t the same but can I ask what does everyone think is the difference between him SloMo, and Lebby? You can play the hindsight game all you like but I don’t see much difference in their resumes when they were hired. Was it because Mullen say how to win a NC and Meyer gave him a little leadership responsibilities? I’m just curious how you can vet that in the interview process. All three were QB/OC coaches with, at the time, different offenses. People say Moorhead looked good because of Barkley. Mullen had this guy named Tebow. I just feel like coaching hires are a complete crapshoot. Summrall and Golesh were supposed to be great hires yet Will Stein is looking down at them now.
The hires are always a crapshoot. But you have a much higher floor when going after a proven HC than a coordinator. As far as Sumrall and Golesh, I think those were good hires, too, and both have already shown improvement in Year 1. Stein was obviously a great hire, but he’s had a bit of luck too with a lot of close wins in OT, etc.

We’ve had success with the position coach / coordinator route exactly 1 time (Mullen), and failed at least 5 times across multiple eras (Lebby, Arnett, Moorhead, Croom, Felker). Moreover, those failures would be unanimously be considered to be the 5 worst football coaches at MSU in the past 50+ years, in whatever order you want to place them.

When we’ve actually landed a proven head coach, we’ve generally been successful every time. Leach, Sherrill, and Bellard were all generally successful hires, by MSU standards. Bellard was the most questionable of the 3, but our program was a damn joke for decades when he took over, and he still was not that far below .500 for his tenure. If that’s the floor for hiring a proven HC, sign me up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ckDOG

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,059
12,970
113
I understand. My simple answer would be he is in charge of making sure these people are doing their jobs correctly and we're getting what we expect out of their performance. If not, he needs to look for somebody else and replace them, as well as being the face of the program.
Ultimately yes, its definitely his responsibility. But also I would think that's the "Chief of Staffs" duties if you look at job descriptions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bullldawg78
Feb 25, 2017
358
713
93
I agree with what many of you are saying. I think it is time to move on from a head-coach that is acting as a coordinator too. Find a head coach, no matter the level he has coached at, that 1.) sets the right culture/expectations 2.) knows how to run a program 3.) knows how to build fan support and then go find him innovative coordinators that he can lead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scdog1

Bullldawg78

All-Conference
Aug 30, 2018
1,938
1,651
113
I agree with what many of you are saying. I think it is time to move on from a head-coach that is acting as a coordinator too. Find a head coach, no matter the level he has coached at, that 1.) sets the right culture/expectations 2.) knows how to run a program 3.) knows how to build fan support and then go find him innovative coordinators that he can lead.
What She Said GIF by The Free Mama
 

BigDogFan

Freshman
Oct 12, 2016
111
62
28
I agree with what many of you are saying. I think it is time to move on from a head-coach that is acting as a coordinator too. Find a head coach, no matter the level he has coached at, that 1.) sets the right culture/expectations 2.) knows how to run a program 3.) knows how to build fan support and then go find him innovative coordinators that he can lead.
I agree with you for the most part but isn't this what Norvell was when he was hired at FSU. Sometimes this works and sometimes it doesn't - more than likely has a better chance to work. We only have to this point of his first season at Kentucky but Will Stein looks like he could be a coordinator who works out as a HC.
 

GiantInternetAsshole

All-Conference
Sep 22, 2026
1,247
1,142
113
Lebby is going to be a very hot commodity as an OC. I’m hoping we see a 50% reduction in the buyout obligation after he lands his next gig. And I expect him to thrive as an OC who has no head coaching responsibilities. It’s who and what he is. It’s also exactly what he was when he was Peter Principled here.
Another financial consideration that has to be taken into account.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,567
3,174
113
This isn't directed directly at you 78 but since you mentioned it I'll use your thread to ask my question.

You and AROB44 have both used the term "CEO of the team" in this thread. If Lebby is the "CEO" what exactly is left for him to do when he's got these guys/gals on staff? These are football team job titles w/ pictures of the person that does some of them. What's left for Lebby to do except worry about running the on the field operations?

And these with pictures below are just the tip of the iceberg, it doesn't include the following people who are also already staff:

Senior Director of the DAWG Program, Director of Career & Professional Development / D.A.W.G, Director of Life Skills / D.A.W.G., Senior Director/Recruiting Strategy, Director/On-Campus Recruiting, On-Campus Recruiting Specialist, On Campus Recruiting Fellow, Assistant A.D./Football Creative Strategy, Senior Director/Football Content & Strategy, Executive Assistant to the Head Football Coach. Doesn't include any interns, student workers, etc etc etc.

View attachment 1514844
View attachment 1514845
View attachment 1514852
Why do we need all these positions? What do they do on a daily basis?
 
Feb 25, 2017
358
713
93
I agree with you for the most part but isn't this what Norvell was when he was hired at FSU. Sometimes this works and sometimes it doesn't - more than likely has a better chance to work. We only have to this point of his first season at Kentucky but Will Stein looks like he could be a coordinator who works out as a HC.
Yeah it can work out, as it did with Dan Mullen for us; however, I think it takes a coordinator with a different approach than Lebby. It was clear from day one that Mullen was in charge and looking to shake things up.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  2. 02 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout
  3. 03 Maroon and White Chris Jans proud of Mississippi State's "must-win" performance on the road at UCF
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Injury Update: QB AJ Swann and S Isaac Smith to miss Senior Day game
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Tennessee Tech Players to Know