No offense, but we had no offense before Mullen. What is there not to like? We have racked up yardage and points like never before since 2009.
I never liked it..I didn't like it at Utah, and I didn't like when UF won a championship with it (they didn't win two championships with it...they didn't actually run this offense with Leak). I don't like the QB being in the shotgun all the time (which Mullen is tweaking a little), and I don't like the QB taking so many hits. I think the offense has a low ceiling, and will always be stopped by premier defenses. It does operate well against inferior competition, but almost any other offense would also as long as you have the right personnel. I always hear that the spread option allows you to get the ball to your playmakers "in space", but in 9 years I've never really seen that. Yes, we break big plays every now and then, but who doesn't?
I will admit that one of my concerns with Mullen's offense was that it would only work with a Tim Tebow type of QB, and I believed that those only come along once in a generation or so. It turns out that Mullen can find plenty of QBs with the right skill set to run his offense, so that is less of a concern. We haven't even seen too many injuries at that position, except for Dak and Russell back in 2013.