Give Fitz much credit...

stpaulcat

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
35,628
1,118
113
for hiring Braun, whether serendipitous or not. As long as the Cats continue to be Cardiac, there is hope.
 
Last edited:

Alaskawildkat

Senior
Dec 28, 2005
20,868
647
113
Let's face it, this team is playing both for Braun and his predecessor. Would not be surprised when the Cats win their bowl game that the game ball is given to Coach Fitzgerald.
 

DaCat

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
26,018
2,600
113
Let's face it, this team is playing both for Braun and his predecessor. Would not be surprised when the Cats win their bowl game that the game ball is given to Coach Fitzgerald.
Especially if it helps in the recruitment of his second son.
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,224
451
83
Most of all they are playing for each other. The Cats against the world mantra is real.
If we post a season winning record, I say offer the reigns to braun. And if he stays, I think A LOT of the current players who still have eligibility will stay too. Let Braun poach a bunch of his top peers at places like ndsu and sdsu for oc, dc, lb, etc for his new staff- and players too, if they are interested. Then, hit the transfer portal ferociously to fill the rest. And hope to Gosh that the kids get into admissions swiftly. I think if this happens, we could overcome the trauma and drama of the summer scandals. My view is that nu football's glass is half full and very well could get fuller sooner than later....
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,224
451
83
Most of all they are playing for each other. The Cats against the world mantra is real.
Braun has done a better job than Purdue's hc from illini. And Purdue has had top 25 national recruiting classes the past 5 years that brome brought in. I think this is rather remarkable!
 

Sheffielder

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2004
10,194
1,037
113
If we post a season winning record, I say offer the reigns to braun. And if he stays, I think A LOT of the current players who still have eligibility will stay too. Let Braun poach a bunch of his top peers at places like ndsu and sdsu for oc, dc, lb, etc for his new staff- and players too, if they are interested. Then, hit the transfer portal ferociously to fill the rest. And hope to Gosh that the kids get into admissions swiftly. I think if this happens, we could overcome the trauma and drama of the summer scandals. My view is that nu football's glass is half full and very well could get fuller sooner than later....
I will agree *BUT* one of those wins has to come over Wisconsin or Iowa, who currently represent upper-tier Big Ten programs.

Minnesota does not. Maryland does not. Neither do Illinois or Purdue. Although UTEP and Howard were not guaranteed wins, if you think they earn someone a head coaching job, then Fitz's coaching mediocrity over the past few seasons did some lasting damage.

I like Braun, and the Maryland win has definitely made me closer than ever to potentially wanting him in the head coaching seat next year...but no, I'm not ready to award a multi-year Big Ten heading coaching contract to someone on the record of beating UTEP, Howard, Minny, Maryland, Illinois, and Purdue, and then some MAC or WAC team in a bowl game.
 

jimmyNU

Redshirt
Sep 12, 2005
286
0
0
I was thinking about the team's 4-4 record yesterday. Rather, I was wondering if Fitz could have gotten this team to 4-4 by this point in the season. My answer is no. Fitz was a great coach, but his teams in recent years were defined by low energy and overly cautious strategy.

I am impressed with the Braun has managed to do, and I think he's the right guy for a long-term contract.
 

DaCat

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
26,018
2,600
113
I will agree *BUT* one of those wins has to come over Wisconsin or Iowa, who currently represent upper-tier Big Ten programs.

Minnesota does not. Maryland does not. Neither do Illinois or Purdue. Although UTEP and Howard were not guaranteed wins, if you think they earn someone a head coaching job, then Fitz's coaching mediocrity over the past few seasons did some lasting damage.

I like Braun, and the Maryland win has definitely made me closer than ever to potentially wanting him in the head coaching seat next year...but no, I'm not ready to award a multi-year Big Ten heading coaching contract to someone on the record of beating UTEP, Howard, Minny, Maryland, Illinois, and Purdue, and then some MAC or WAC team in a bowl game.
Would you rather have someone who loses to SIU and Miami of Ohio in the same year?

Like many others on this board have expressed, if Braun doesn't get the head coaching job after going 7-6 as in your scenario, I fear there will be a flood of transfers out and we will be resetting from ground zero.
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,224
451
83
When has Purdue ever had top 25 recruiting classes?
I went to purdue for grad school. 😩 according to the posters on their websites this is absolutely true when brohm was their coach. Have you seen all the stars they have signed? They also got many more on paper bigger stars than nu in the portal. I remember a stud dt that we missed out on because of a "business " decision he got more money from pu...my point is that Braun is doing MUCH more with far less AND in dire circumstances 🤔!
 

mickbula

Senior
Jul 1, 2011
3,224
451
83
I will agree *BUT* one of those wins has to come over Wisconsin or Iowa, who currently represent upper-tier Big Ten programs.

Minnesota does not. Maryland does not. Neither do Illinois or Purdue. Although UTEP and Howard were not guaranteed wins, if you think they earn someone a head coaching job, then Fitz's coaching mediocrity over the past few seasons did some lasting damage.

I like Braun, and the Maryland win has definitely made me closer than ever to potentially wanting him in the head coaching seat next year...but no, I'm not ready to award a multi-year Big Ten heading coaching contract to someone on the record of beating UTEP, Howard, Minny, Maryland, Illinois, and Purdue, and then some MAC or WAC team in a bowl game.
Get ready to yell loudly from the stands...because if the kids keep improving and play o like vs MD and d like vs neb there is a chance it might happen
 

Sheffielder

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2004
10,194
1,037
113
Get ready to yell loudly from the stands...because if the kids keep improving and play o like vs MD and d like vs neb there is a chance it might happen
For whatever it's worth, I'm definitely rooting for Braun. Obviously if he wins it means we're winning; I just don't want to give him a a big contract (or worse: a half-assed contract) because we're caught up in the moment and suddenly think 5-7 means we're going to the Rose Bowl next year.

But in general I like his mojo, I liked Fitz's strategy to pluck a proven gold-standard winner from the FCS, and the players definitely seem to like him by all accounts.
 

Sheffielder

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2004
10,194
1,037
113
Would you rather have someone who loses to SIU and Miami of Ohio in the same year?
Those shouldn't be our only two options. That goes back to a comment I made earlier - Fitz's abysmal coaching performance over the past three seasons should not make us thankful for someone who can actually achieve minimum levels of performance and beat teams like these without a constant fear of losing to them.
 
Aug 31, 2003
15,265
638
113
I was thinking about the team's 4-4 record yesterday. Rather, I was wondering if Fitz could have gotten this team to 4-4 by this point in the season. My answer is no. Fitz was a great coach, but his teams in recent years were defined by low energy and overly cautious strategy.

I am impressed with the Braun has managed to do, and I think he's the right guy for a long-term contract.
This is all Fitz's staff. Did Fitz call the plays? Does Braun call the plays?
 

Katatonic

Sophomore
Oct 23, 2004
86,854
134
0
Eh, Fitz only ended up doing what some of us called upon him to do (hire a winning DC from the lower level), but only after destroying all the momentum the program had.
 

Katatonic

Sophomore
Oct 23, 2004
86,854
134
0
So what?

Excuse me for not having posted in over a week.

If you want to elaborate on why you disagree, go right ahead, but don't try to silence others... (you can always just ignore my post).
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,888
892
73
Especially true since the players nearly outnumbered the spectators on Saturday. We were relatively loud tho.

I am over the fitz thing. Braun is rebuilding from the ashes, just like Walker had to do.
Rebuilding from Ashes? The cupboard wasn’t exactly bare when Walker took over. The fact remains that he only won a title with Barnett’s recruits.
 

EvanstonCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
50,888
892
73
For whatever it's worth, I'm definitely rooting for Braun. Obviously if he wins it means we're winning; I just don't want to give him a a big contract (or worse: a half-assed contract) because we're caught up in the moment and suddenly think 5-7 means we're going to the Rose Bowl next year.

But in general I like his mojo, I liked Fitz's strategy to pluck a proven gold-standard winner from the FCS, and the players definitely seem to like him by all accounts.
It sure beat taking somebody who only failure at the NFL level
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,587
4,859
113
So what?

Excuse me for not having posted in over a week.

If you want to elaborate on why you disagree, go right ahead, but don't try to silence others... (you can always just ignore my post).
You are right, I should just ignore the beatings of this dead horse.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,587
4,859
113
Rebuilding from Ashes? The cupboard wasn’t exactly bare when Walker took over. The fact remains that he only won a title with Barnett’s recruits.

Saint Barney was 0-8 in the B1G the year he left. I would say Walker rebuilding from the ashes is appropriate and similar to what Braun faces.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,587
4,859
113
Be happy to have it return. In the ole days, post game pages would have a whole page of new threads with many engaging. Now, well, you can see what it has become. There has been a lunker sighting tho…
I don’t participate in the game day thread Bob. I have read a few after the game for Yuks and giggles. This week no.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Behind Enemy Lines: Minnesota
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Northwestern at Ohio State PFF Grades Analysis
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota