Game Thread: Northwestern vs. No. 9 Illinois

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,393
329
83
IU is shooting lights out and pretty much anything they toss up is going in so pretty hard to beat that if Cats aren't doing the same thing.
 

jensberg

Junior
Jul 28, 2006
3,248
237
63
This has been a terrible game. We have played horrendous and Illinois has played absolutely fantastic and is shooting over 60%.

It has been a tough game to watch and there should certainly be some concern after a game like this. But it’s one game where zero went our way. If we come out with a similar effort against MSU, I’ll start to worry. But for now, it’s a game we played awful and our opponent played as well as they could.

Gotta get better at a lot, but I think we have the guys to do it. Moving on.
But the lack of height is not something that's going to go away. The only position we have height is the center position and none of them are particularly good players. As mentioned previously Illinois is taller than us at all of the wing and guard positions by a considerable amount. There are other teams that will have the same advantage.
 

ballerog711

Redshirt
Sep 23, 2022
898
0
0
Clayton, Mullins, Hunger, Martenelli and Berry. Let them finish the game, make mistakes and learn.

Clayton just rejected a screen p, got to the basket and proved he is a true NU hooper by missing the layup. Gets taken out as it's not part of the play.
 

Secho99

Sophomore
Dec 12, 2001
1,881
147
63
NIT bound (I hope)
It’s dangerous to assume anything (good or bad) about an NU team based on one game.

We were 10-2 last year at this time, then got blown out at home by Ohio State. I don’t think anyone here reasonably thought at that point that we’d win an NCAA tournament game.

Illini made everything tonight and we didn’t, they’re the best team in the league other than Purdue. I think we’ll be alright, it was always going to be a fight to get 10 B1G wins again.
 

AdamOnFirst

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
12,260
3,424
113
Should be a rockin’ home crowd on Saturday night against Sparty. Big game against another bubbly team, bounce back.
 
Sep 27, 2008
622
0
0
It’s dangerous to assume anything (good or bad) about an NU team based on one game.

We were 10-2 last year at this time, then got blown out at home by Ohio State. I don’t think anyone here reasonably thought at that point that we’d win an NCAA tournament game.

Illini made everything tonight and we didn’t, they’re the best team in the league other than Purdue. I think we’ll be alright, it was always going to be a fight to get 10 B1G wins again.
I won't count them out but this team needs a wakeup call and fast.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,570
4,845
113
Gotta love underwood’s team chuckin up 3 balls up 30.
Who cares? Never showed up. Where is the 🧙‍♂️ that got all the credit for the turnaround? I guess we miss Chase and Robbie on Defense because we sure didn’t play any at all. Luka Donic couldn’t miss either.
 
Sep 27, 2008
622
0
0
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,393
329
83
Who cares? Never showed up. Where is the 🧙‍♂️ that got all the credit for the turnaround? I guess we miss Chase and Robbie on Defense because we sure didn’t play any at all. Luka Donic couldn’t miss either.
Last year's game at Assembly Hall:
Chase put up 3 for 14, with 3 personal fouls, 3 turnovers, and 4 steals
Robbie was 1 for 3, 2 defensive rebounds, 1 block, and 3 personal fouls

This year:
Berry put up 6 for 10, with 2 personal fouls, 1 turnover, and 2 steals
Brooks was 3 for 12, with 2 personal fouls, 4 defensive rebounds, 1 offensive rebound, 1 assist, and 2 turnovers

So I'm not sure we missed last year's guys tonight, unless you want to claim they were the reason IU shot 29% from 3 last year (although Chase was guarding Shannon, who hit 4 of 5 from 3, so...)

Cats just didn't play well in either game outside of Boo.
 

Sec_112

Junior
Jun 17, 2001
6,636
256
83
Hopefully ... HOPEFULLY that's a one night thing.

1) I'm not trying to make any excuses for that defense. It was bad all over the court. But I'd be surprised if we see another performance this year like Domask's.
2) I also hope we don't see another offensive performance like tonight's first half. There were plenty of good missed scoring opportunities from 10 ft or less.

I'm not going to disagree with anyone who wants to tell me how lousy the defense and rebounding are. I'm just hoping this was also a demonstration of how infortunately talented the friggin Illini are as well as the potential for how mediocre the Cats can be. I'm becoming more concerned it's only the latter.
 

PurpleWhiteBoy

Redshirt
Feb 25, 2021
5,303
0
0
Lots of bad real-time takes tonight, lads.

Nobody in purple had a good night. Collins in particular. We really didn't do anything different at any point during the game - on either offense or defense. Its okay, its only one beatdown, but my fear is that the coach will be like a bunch of you folks and (amazingly) blame Nicholson for the loss. (He played 14 minutes.)

Its like a few of you guys went to your first hockey game and blamed the goalie for every goal allowed, then criticized him for not scoring.

Tonight Audige would have made a difference - guarding Domask - but we weren't going to win this one.
 

NUCat320

Senior
Dec 4, 2005
19,469
495
0
Lots of bad real-time takes tonight, lads.

Nobody in purple had a good night. Collins in particular. We really didn't do anything different at any point during the game - on either offense or defense. Its okay, its only one beatdown, but my fear is that the coach will be like a bunch of you folks and (amazingly) blame Nicholson for the loss. (He played 14 minutes.)

Its like a few of you guys went to your first hockey game and blamed the goalie for every goal allowed, then criticized him for not scoring.

Tonight Audige would have made a difference - guarding Domask - but we weren't going to win this one.
Nicholson had a real rough start that set the tone for a real rough game. Boo intentionally looked to him on the first possession, and Big Matt was just a step too slow.

No individual is responsible for a 30-point beatdown, but Nicholson was visibly bad while the game was still worth watching.

Illinois looks like a top ten team.
 

GatoLouco

Junior
Nov 13, 2019
5,758
260
63
I went to bed with 10 min to go. It was 4 AM for me though.

Board wildly overreacting, kind of expected.

We can go back to being more fluid like we were against ASU. They’re not a great team but had a couple of good wins after being decimated by us.

I guess the point is they we did not become incapable of competing yesterday. Keep fighting, we are capable of 12
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,570
4,845
113
Lots of bad real-time takes tonight, lads.

Nobody in purple had a good night. Collins in particular. We really didn't do anything different at any point during the game - on either offense or defense. Its okay, its only one beatdown, but my fear is that the coach will be like a bunch of you folks and (amazingly) blame Nicholson for the loss. (He played 14 minutes.)

Its like a few of you guys went to your first hockey game and blamed the goalie for every goal allowed, then criticized him for not scoring.

Tonight Audige would have made a difference - guarding Domask - but we weren't going to win this one.
Yes there are a lot of bad takes. However, there is just no way you can spin this wasn’t a horrendous game for Big Matt. I like the man and think he can be valuable to our defense, but yesterday he was unplayable. The first half he didn’t collect a stat other than a foul! He was slow on his doubles, his screens were weak, and he made no effort to roll to the rim, after the screen. He wasn’t the reason we lost, but he was flat out bad. Hate to be so harsh on the kid, but he has to decide if this will ever happen again and not put it in the hands of CCC.

As Hummel said, we WILL double down low. That is what the 🧙‍♂️ teaches. If we are painfully slow on rotations, we will lose. We don’t have the defensive stopper in Chase anymore, so there weren’t an abundance of options to stop Luka Donic once he got going.

As far as offense, we are usually playing 4 on 5. Big Matt is so limited from the outside that Hawkins just backed off and camped out waiting for Boo to drive. Hunger is better offensively but was a pylon on defense yesterday. Barney is clearly bothered by the hand/finger problem and lacks the aggression we saw most of last year.

The good news it was just one game and drastic personnel changes would be foolish. I still think this team gets to 10 B1G wins. We have to get our defense straight as it was horrible. We miss Chase and Robbie ( gasp) on the defensive end. There are two sides to the game.
 

Baz=Heisman

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2023
726
0
11
No overreaction because Matt has been so bad all year but I’d start Hunger against MSU. Let Matt come in if we have the lead for defensive purposes.
 

AdamOnFirst

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
12,260
3,424
113
Lots of bad real-time takes tonight, lads.

Nobody in purple had a good night. Collins in particular. We really didn't do anything different at any point during the game - on either offense or defense. Its okay, its only one beatdown, but my fear is that the coach will be like a bunch of you folks and (amazingly) blame Nicholson for the loss. (He played 14 minutes.)

Its like a few of you guys went to your first hockey game and blamed the goalie for every goal allowed, then criticized him for not scoring.

Tonight Audige would have made a difference - guarding Domask - but we weren't going to win this one.
I barely commented on big Matt tonight, but unfortunately he’s been bad this year and his minutes have reflected it. It’s very very disappointing.
 

Sec_112

Junior
Jun 17, 2001
6,636
256
83
The play from all three 5s is pretty obvious.

But Langborg's defense is right up there on my list of concerns. He's constantly losing his man and a step slow on rotation. His minutes can't be limited by his defense, but I don't blame Collins either for pulling him the way he was playing.

I love the potential consistency of Langborg, but unfortunately his limits are starting to show. It's also not going to be too long before the league figures out all they need to limit him is have him put the ball on the floor.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,393
329
83
I've seen Langborg do some good stuff putting the ball on the floor. He took some rough fade aways last night, and he sometimes plays outside himself, but he isn't the worst ball handler on the team.

Cats scored 66, which is pretty much par for the team this season outside a couple of big nights. We were missing a bigger night from either Langborg or Barnhizer, but otherwise I think offensively this is where the team lives.

So yeah, this was mostly a defensive failure, but I'm hopeful most of the conference won't consist of players who are both bigger and more athletic than our boys. They can work with one or the other, but both is obviously too much.
 

AdamOnFirst

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
12,260
3,424
113
The play from all three 5s is pretty obvious.

But Langborg's defense is right up there on my list of concerns. He's constantly losing his man and a step slow on rotation. His minutes can't be limited by his defense, but I don't blame Collins either for pulling him the way he was playing.

I love the potential consistency of Langborg, but unfortunately his limits are starting to show. It's also not going to be too long before the league figures out all they need to limit him is have him put the ball on the floor.
This has been the obvious problem with Langborg from the moment he came here. He was always going to be a defensive liability to some extent, and while he is a solid offensive player, he isn’t actually an elite shooter who can outscore infinite defensive shortcomings on any given night. We have yet to fully learn how severe his defensive shortcomings are, and last night was a down data point we’ll have to keep an eye on.
 

stpaulcat

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
35,624
1,112
113
I've seen Langborg do some good stuff putting the ball on the floor. He took some rough fade aways last night, and he sometimes plays outside himself, but he isn't the worst ball handler on the team.

Cats scored 66, which is pretty much par for the team this season outside a couple of big nights. We were missing a bigger night from either Langborg or Barnhizer, but otherwise I think offensively this is where the team lives.

So yeah, this was mostly a defensive failure, but I'm hopeful most of the conference won't consist of players who are both bigger and more athletic than our boys. They can work with one or the other, but both is obviously too much.
Did NU get ANY defensive rebounds? It seemed like every time NU missed a shot, Illinois got the rebound.
 

SmellyCat

Senior
May 29, 2001
7,335
404
83
Seems that all of the offensive rebounds they got were in a single possession, but they actually got eight offensive boards throughout the game. Some of them must have been in the second half when I was no longer 100% focused on the game.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,393
329
83
Did NU get ANY defensive rebounds? It seemed like every time NU missed a shot, Illinois got the rebound.
Cats had 8 OR and 16 DR vs 9 and 26 for the orange guys. The obvious problem is the other team scored on almost every one of their rebounds and the Cats only did once or twice.
 

AdamOnFirst

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
12,260
3,424
113
Cats had 8 OR and 16 DR vs 9 and 26 for the orange guys. The obvious problem is the other team scored on almost every one of their rebounds and the Cats only did once or twice.
That and a percentage issue. Illinois got those 9 offensive rebounds on only 21 misses. Cats had 8 on 36 misses. 43% vs 22% offensive rebound percent is... not good.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Northwestern working to support, improve QB Nicco Marchiol ahead of Minnesota
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  3. 03 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota
  4. 04 Wildcat Report The 3-2-1 after Northwestern's loss to Ohio State
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Three Wildcat commits crack new Rivals300