GAME 20 PENN STATE: A Disgrace

biazza38

Heisman
Nov 18, 2012
14,696
18,148
81
Coaches can't shoot for players but coaches can show Derek Simpson film of himself shooting a three pointer and help him understand that if he's off balance with his feet the shot is going to be off balance. Like... what is this? It's a wide open three pointer, what are you doing with your feet my dude? Splaying them out and then landing like THAT? And you think that shot has a prayer?

If the staff is doing this and Simpson isn't working on it, then yeah, that's on him.



THIS!!!! Every time I see him shoot I can’t help but think “wtf does this staff do.” It’s not rocket science and it’s something the casual fan can notice a mile away. There’s no reason for him to STILL be shooting like this.
 

motel00

Junior
Mar 8, 2007
1,001
370
0
The only question now is which one of the bottom four spots in the Big Ten standings will we occupy.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Scangg

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
Hawk always respect your takes but 100% disagree with you as Pike runs zero offense no back screens no off the ball movement his coaching is based on a high screen and pick and roll which Cliff doesn’t do well or the guard breaking down the defense and kicking the ball out which our guards who are too small can’t do
And when we actually kick it out our guys can’t shoot anyway and this falls back on Pike for his lack of recruiting

I think Hawk’s take that this offense is better than last year’s is beyond ridiculous. But the atrocious offense is a personnel issue not an x and o coaching issue. You could nit pick a few substitution issue here or there that could provide marginal improvement but the bottomline is we are (collectively as a team) historically bad at putting the ball in the basket. Only 5 D1 teams in the entire country miss a higher percentage of their shots.

I don’t understand how some are not grasping exactly how bad 38.7% from the field is as a team. Our 7 WIN 2015-16 TEAM put the ball in the basket 41.8% of the time! Think about that for a minute….
 

rob kight

All-American
Oct 22, 2020
5,052
6,433
113
Lots of bad last night.
2 things that should have been adjusted during the game by coach and weren’t:
1. Every time the point guard came over mid court, they double teamed. Meaning someone was open, but we never took advantage of that.
2. Every time Cliff got the ball he was immediately double or triple teamed and many times resulted in turnover. Yet we keep forcing it in with no adjustments.

And as pointed out, we go up 6-7 points and essentially replace the whole team on the floor. PSU takes advantage and never looks back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FastMJ and biazza38

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
Some of this is an amplifying effect. These are all supporting players - but without anyone to support, they become less than the sum of their parts. It's like an Avengers team that's all Hawkeyes and Black Widows without any heavy hitters.

Yes - absolutely. To be fair - if you even just swappped Miller for J-Mike on last year’s roster I think we make the tournament. We desperately needed a role playing thrasher. I missed Tez last year and believe Davis could’ve filled that role well. It’s not that the guys we have can’t contribute as complements to others (it’s what you said - were missing the guys to complement). Being an 18 mpg thrasher spark plug is different from being relied on as a frosh to run the offense as PG.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
The team (before last night's debacle) averages 2 more PPG than last year's team, once you subtract the nonsense of Central Connecticut State and Rider etc.

The numbers are the numbers, the goal (I believe) is not to be the most efficient team, it is to actually score more points per game.

If you or others disagree with the actual numbers, then that's fine. But this notion that RU was some sort of scoring outfit that was way more effective last year vs this year, is simply not true.

Can you give this up already please? It’s just plain wrong and you must know it at this point. Forget comparison to last year’s NIT team, this might be the worst offensive team in RU history. As I just pointed out - our rock bottom 7 win team (2015-16) put the ball in the basket an astounding 3.1% more of the time.

And by the way, the meaningless metric you’ve been pointing to no longer even supports the current team as their average ppg output is now down to 66.8. The 15-16 team averaged 67.7 ppg. The 22-23 team averaged 67.9 ppg.
 

BossNJ

All-American
Oct 6, 2020
10,081
9,136
113
Lots of bad last night.
2 things that should have been adjusted during the game by coach and weren’t:
1. Every time the point guard came over mid court, they double teamed. Meaning someone was open, but we never took advantage of that.
2. Every time Cliff got the ball he was immediately double or triple teamed and many times resulted in turnover. Yet we keep forcing it in with no adjustments.

And as pointed out, we go up 6-7 points and essentially replace the whole team on the floor. PSU takes advantage and never looks back.
Every team aggressively collapses on Cliff because they don’t fear our shooters. If we made them pay for that with any consistency we’d be a far more effective offense.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Can you give this up already please? It’s just plain wrong and you must know it at this point. Forget comparison to last year’s NIT team, this might be the worst offensive team in RU history. As I just pointed out - our rock bottom 7 win team (2015-16) put the ball in the basket an astounding 3.1% more of the time.

And by the way, the meaningless metric you’ve been pointing to no longer even supports the current team as their average ppg output is now down to 66.8. The 15-16 team averaged 67.7 ppg. The 22-23 team averaged 67.9 ppg.
And we're less than halfway through the conference schedule!
 

fatsam98

Heisman
Mar 23, 2005
44,248
40,240
113
Coaches can't shoot for players but coaches can show Derek Simpson film of himself shooting a three pointer and help him understand that if he's off balance with his feet the shot is going to be off balance. Like... what is this? It's a wide open three pointer, what are you doing with your feet my dude? Splaying them out and then landing like THAT? And you think that shot has a prayer?

If the staff is doing this and Simpson isn't working on it, then yeah, that's on him.



Quite a few people around me yelled "set your feet!" on that one. Like what are we doing here?? How is that a shot with half the shot clock left.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FastMJ

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
Quite a few people around me yelled "set your feet!" on that one. Like what are we doing here?? How is that a shot with half the shot clock left.
It's a perfectly good shot to take, just... not like that. Everyone says we don't run offense but here out of a horns set Mag had the ball at the top of the key and made a good dribble handoff for Simpson, who did an decent job of coming off it. He could've gotten a little closer but overall not bad. And he's open and has time and shoots like that. I'll take that ten times out of ten over Simpson isoball, but that can't be the shooting form.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cshelley

fatsam98

Heisman
Mar 23, 2005
44,248
40,240
113
Can you give this up already please? It’s just plain wrong and you must know it at this point. Forget comparison to last year’s NIT team, this might be the worst offensive team in RU history. As I just pointed out - our rock bottom 7 win team (2015-16) put the ball in the basket an astounding 3.1% more of the time.

And by the way, the meaningless metric you’ve been pointing to no longer even supports the current team as their average ppg output is now down to 66.8. The 15-16 team averaged 67.7 ppg. The 22-23 team averaged 67.9 ppg.
His posts get more absurd by the minute. There are 362 Div1 teams. Here's where we rank in a few important offensive categories this season (last season in brackets for comparison)

PPG: 296 (231)
FT%: 341 (247)
EFG%: 357 (299)
3P%: 345 (285)
Off Eff: 326 (189)
 
  • Like
  • Sad
Reactions: Scangg and RW90

rufeelinit

All-Conference
May 16, 2010
12,647
4,351
0
Every team aggressively collapses on Cliff because they don’t fear our shooters. If we made them pay for that with any consistency we’d be a far more effective offense.
Also Cliff struggles to find the open person and make pass out of the double. Again lack of development is very noticeable particularly when it come to Cliff. You think the former Roselle Catholic coach who is now running a program down here in Monmouth County will think twice before send Pike another big?
 
  • Like
Reactions: BossNJ

RU84

All-Conference
May 6, 2003
1,520
1,468
48
Can you give this up already please? It’s just plain wrong and you must know it at this point. Forget comparison to last year’s NIT team, this might be the worst offensive team in RU history. As I just pointed out - our rock bottom 7 win team (2015-16) put the ball in the basket an astounding 3.1% more of the time.

And by the way, the meaningless metric you’ve been pointing to no longer even supports the current team as their average ppg output is now down to 66.8. The 15-16 team averaged 67.7 ppg. The 22-23 team averaged 67.9 ppg.
Hawk was comparing PPG vs power 5/6 competition. His point was last years team's feasted more off the weaker teams than this years squad.
 

Goku

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
8,530
1,469
0
Overall terrible game. My son is 20 months, I let him stay up since we were playing psu, a sure win, so I thought. But I quickly covered his eyes and brought him upstairs and put him down in his crib. I wanted to save him from nightmares.

But can we go back to Hyatt, how it was him vs the rim on the breakaway and missed a layup. Bruh.
I missed the game and have not watched the highlights yet, and don't want to. But I just watched the Hyatt miss on youtube.

O
M
G

honestly, it had to get that bad. We have seen so many missed layups from this team that it had to get this bad maybe so that it gets better.

I swear, was there some Pedro Cerrano voodoo put on the team last night?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Pdabs

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
His posts get more absurd by the minute. There are 362 Div1 teams. Here's where we rank in a few important offensive categories this season (last season in brackets for comparison)

PPG: 296 (231)
FT%: 341 (247)
EFG%: 357 (299)
3P%: 345 (285)
Off Eff: 326 (189)

I know - I just can’t anymore. Your right the advanced stats are actually even worse than the straight up FG% I’ve been pointing to try and dumb it down (just the straight up percentage of time we put the ball in the basket). We rank 355th in that.

Caleb was supposedly a huge liability on offense and yet the math says he’d upgrade our offensive efficiency significantly with his output from last year. That says a lot.
 

fatsam98

Heisman
Mar 23, 2005
44,248
40,240
113
It's a perfectly good shot to take, just... not like that. Everyone says we don't run offense but here out of a horns set Mag had the ball at the top of the key and made a good dribble handoff for Simpson, who did an decent job of coming off it. He could've gotten a little closer but overall not bad. And he's open and has time and shoots like that. I'll take that ten times out of ten over Simpson isoball, but that can't be the shooting form.
Just saying, I don't expect an off-balance 3 with 13 seconds left. I think we are saying the same thing haha
 
  • Like
Reactions: kcg88

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
I think Hawk’s take that this offense is better than last year’s is beyond ridiculous. But the atrocious offense is a personnel issue not an x and o coaching issue. You could nit pick a few substitution issue here or there that could provide marginal improvement but the bottomline is we are (collectively as a team) historically bad at putting the ball in the basket. Only 5 D1 teams in the entire country miss a higher percentage of their shots.

I don’t understand how some are not grasping exactly how bad 38.7% from the field is as a team. Our 7 WIN 2015-16 TEAM put the ball in the basket 41.8% of the time! Think about that for a minute….
Pike cleans his plate on D. I think he leaves a little on the table on the offensive end. It is 95% (or so) personnel for sure.

You coach HS hoops....

1. wouldn't you have a few plays where you can start the 5 high and set a back screen to either get Cliff the ball in motion towards the basket OR make it easier for him to establish low post position?
2. do you call set plays to your team on EVERY offensive possession? Do your kids have 20+ plays? I am the 1st guy for structure, but shouldn't most of what we do flows more from concepts than actual set plays sent from the bench every possession.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
Hawk was comparing PPG vs power 5/6 competition. His point was last years team's feasted more off the weaker teams than this years squad.

All I know is the simple math right now says last year’s team averaged over a point more per game over a full season compared to the current team’s average which reflects less than half a season’s worth of BIG games (a larger percentage cupcake games). It’s a useless metric, but even if you want to look at it, it does not support an argument of this year’s team being better at offense. This team is in the running for worst ever offensive team at RU. Sorry but his argument is just trash.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Right, even if you look at something like e.g. Massey Ratings which is purely a per game based rating system we are #194 on offense this year vs #145 last year. It's absolutely the wrong way to look at it (I like Massey Ratings but it's a general sports rating system not basketball specific) and somehow Hawk doesn't understand the concept of possessions OR the concept of not having had the same level of competition so far this year (due to being only <50% through the B1G schedule).

He's either doing some kind of bit or is just unimaginably unimformed for someone who claims to be some kind of basketball expert.
 

Saint Puppy

All-Conference
Sep 4, 2013
4,597
2,425
113
We shot 34% overall and 6% from 3. You are going to lose to just about anyone (except maybe Stonehill) shooting like that.
Exactly - and we were in the game until the last couple of minutes which tells you how bad Penn State was too. They were bad and we were atrocious!
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
We are averaging 68.1 possessions per game
Last year we averaged 65.8 possessions per game

Last year the average D1 team averaged 1.041 per possession
This year the average team is averaging 1.051 per possession
So if we are averaging only 1 less PPG marry that with 2.3 more possessions and a game where teams are scoring about a point more per game.

If you want to try and do apples to apples.

closer to 4 points per game we are under last year
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scangg

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
I missed the game and have not watched the highlights yet, and don't want to. But I just watched the Hyatt miss on youtube.

O
M
G

honestly, it had to get that bad. We have seen so many missed layups from this team that it had to get this bad maybe so that it gets better.

I swear, was there some Pedro Cerrano voodoo put on the team last night?
yes
 

bethlehemfan

Heisman
Sep 6, 2003
15,474
17,076
113
Right, even if you look at something like e.g. Massey Ratings which is purely a per game based rating system we are #194 on offense this year vs #145 last year. It's absolutely the wrong way to look at it (I like Massey Ratings but it's a general sports rating system not basketball specific) and somehow Hawk doesn't understand the concept of possessions OR the concept of not having had the same level of competition so far this year (due to being only <50% through the B1G schedule).

He's either doing some kind of bit or is just unimaginably unimformed for someone who claims to be some kind of basketball expert.
We are way worse and it’s evident by using you eyes. But yes the stats make it obvious even for people who can’t see it live.
 

RUDiddy777

Heisman
Feb 26, 2015
34,058
38,588
113
You seem to be confused about what a fact is. Let me ask you a question. Can you run an effective offense if your guards cant bring the ball up the court against pressure? I realize you haven’t watched the team but do you understand what the roster is? You’re smart enough to understand the issue if you watch.

11/22 on FTs
1/17 from Deep.
17/50 on FGs.
20 Turnovers!!!
20 ******* Turnovers.

My son’s rec league is coached by a dad and most of the kids are terrible. I’d wager they shoot better. Unless Pike was out there chucking up bricks and passing to the opponent, he doesn’t deserve all of the blame for this.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
Pike cleans his plate on D. I think he leaves a little on the table on the offensive end. It is 95% (or so) personnel for sure.

You coach HS hoops....

1. wouldn't you have a few plays where you can start the 5 high and set a back screen to either get Cliff the ball in motion towards the basket OR make it easier for him to establish low post position?
2. do you call set plays to your team on EVERY offensive possession? Do your kids have 20+ plays? I am the 1st guy for structure, but shouldn't most of what we do flows more from concepts than actual set plays sent from the bench every possession.

I don’t know. I’m sure your right. There are things we could do to make modest improvements. But at the end of the day, Pike focuses on D every year and the offense under him historically (while not great) normally isnt this bad.

The reality is - 1) we have no reliable outside shooters. 2) our guards aren’t very good at executing feeds in to Cliff. I’m sure Pike has tried many things but it’s hard to blame on coaching when we saw Paul, Geo and Caleb feed him in the post for years. 3) Hyatt is very streak - he is our high scorer.
 

RUBOB72

All-American
Aug 5, 2004
23,385
7,924
0
We sucked tonight, but this team is better than that, which makes me wonder whether there are chemistry problems on the team. Our effort wasn't there, we didn't get any loose balls, and guys just look like they didn't want to be out there. Hyatt and Mag being benched most of the 2nd half. Something is just not right. Have heard a few other knowledgeable folks wondering the same thing. Pike needs to sort this out as we're headed towards his worst season since coming here. This performance was LittleJordanPage-esque. Not sure I'll be going to the next home game, as I want no part of that again.
Of course there is a chemistry and a talent issue going on. The backcourt is where I see it most JMike and Simpson with only one who is a facilitator somewhat. It isn’t Derek… Derek could be similar to Baker but he does not shoot well enough… simple facts are: free throws…outside shooting from within 12-15’ … 3 pt shooting… off and on rebounding… and being bullied is all related… who has Pike designated the leader of the offense? Anyone know the answer to that?
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,545
13,917
78
What about answer to #2 for curiousity sake

On this team? Too many set plays in the halfcourt sets would be problematic for a number of reasons. At the top of the list is youth. You can’t ask frosh and sophomores to memorize so many plays while there are adjusting to the speed of the game. Recipe for disaster. Another, perhaps even more important reason, is we don’t have type of guards who can adjust when a play doesn’t go as planned. Several of our turnovers yesterday were a result of the D reading a back door or other scheme and picking off a pass from one of the guards.

With the guys we have - simplying is the only realistic option. It also results in higher usage for Simpson and Davis because they lack the natural distribution skills to find Cliff and Hyatt.

Where I think there could be room for real improvement on design plays is IMO on the inbounds plays. Even with our abysmal shooting, we should be able to find Cliff and Hyatt more than we do. And certainly we shouldn’t struggle as much to get the ball in period. If anything has been disappointing on the x and o front in my view it’s been that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Greene Rice FIG

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
On this team? Too many set plays in the halfcourt sets would be problematic for a number of reasons. At the top of the list is youth. You can’t ask frosh and sophomores to memorize so many plays while there are adjusting to the speed of the game. Recipe for disaster. Another, perhaps even more important reason, is we don’t have type of guards who can adjust when a play doesn’t go as planned. Several of our turnovers yesterday were a result of the D reading a back door or other scheme and picking off a pass from one of the guards.

With the guys we have - simplying is the only realistic option. It also results in higher usage for Simpson and Davis because they lack the natural distribution skills to find Cliff and Hyatt.

Where I think there could be room for real improvement on design plays is IMO on the inbounds plays. Even with our abysmal shooting, we should be able to find Cliff and Hyatt more than we do. And certainly we shouldn’t struggle as much to get the ball in period. If anything has been disappointing on the x and o front in my view it’s been that.
Almost every possession last night they were yelling out or writing on white board set plays. One was even called Penn St.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Almost every possession last night they were yelling out or writing on white board set plays. One was even called Penn St.
Maybe they were just reminding them who the opponent was. Problem is our players thought that was who they were supposed to pass the ball to.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano talks Penn State game week
  3. 03 The Knight Report Almost Six Years Later, Rutgers - Houston Signifies a Pivotal Moment Once Again
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half