For you HS coaches or the opinionated

Uncle Ruckus

All-American
Apr 1, 2011
15,528
7,069
113
Why can’t kids go both ways anymore in HS? I’m not that old, and while I didn’t do it every game, I started both sides some and a lot of my teammates did. Teams we played did. Teams in bigger classifications than us did. Why can’t they do it? They don’t run or practice any less than we did. It bothers me.
 

Rayburn8

Redshirt
Feb 26, 2013
433
0
16
Why can’t kids go both ways anymore in HS? I’m not that old, and while I didn’t do it every game, I started both sides some and a lot of my teammates did. Teams we played did. Teams in bigger classifications than us did. Why can’t they do it? They don’t run or practice any less than we did. It bothers me.

A, some players do.

B, most schools have enough players to let the specialize one way or the other.

C, If you are a top player, why risk injury spending extra time at a position you won't play in college. IE: Brandon Turnage mostly spending time at safety and not WR this year.

It is an unnecessary risk that most players don't want to or have to take.
 
R

RPOdawg

Guest
Why can’t kids go both ways anymore in HS? I’m not that old, and while I didn’t do it every game, I started both sides some and a lot of my teammates did. Teams we played did. Teams in bigger classifications than us did. Why can’t they do it? They don’t run or practice any less than we did. It bothers me.

One big reason is because of safety. With all of the CTE issues that’s been going on lately coaches and athletic trainers are under a microscope. Another big reason I think is kids are bigger, stronger, faster and it’s not as easy to play both ways as it use to be. Usually you’ll see a teams best athlete play both ways at mid level and smaller schools. These 5A and 6A teams have enough kids.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,506
33,382
113
A few other reasons:
More games now. Back then you played 9-10 games plus maybe a bowl game. Schools today are playing 11 and even 12 game regular seasons plus 4-5 more games in the playoffs.
More players. My high school usually had about 40 players on roster back in the 80s. The school is the same size but routinely has over 70 now.
The game today is played at a much faster pace than it was back then. Back in the 80s, there was no 25-second clock in HS end zones so delay of game was rarely enforced and nobody had ever heard of a no huddle offense.
 

Miketice

Redshirt
Sep 2, 2013
1,198
0
0
Why can’t kids go both ways anymore in HS? I’m not that old, and while I didn’t do it every game, I started both sides some and a lot of my teammates did. Teams we played did. Teams in bigger classifications than us did. Why can’t they do it? They don’t run or practice any less than we did. It bothers me.

I did too. I'm not sure that wasn't a Scott county thing. My Soph year( Forest 86 )we literally had 24 players.
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
Why can’t kids go both ways anymore in HS? I’m not that old, and while I didn’t do it every game, I started both sides some and a lot of my teammates did. Teams we played did. Teams in bigger classifications than us did. Why can’t they do it? They don’t run or practice any less than we did. It bothers me.

Because, obviously, you are a better person than they are.
 

Uncle Ruckus

All-American
Apr 1, 2011
15,528
7,069
113
I should have been more clear. It’s not that they don’t choose not to, or coaches choose them not to. It’s that they physically can’t do it. They physically struggle to go both ways.
 

TNT.sixpack

Redshirt
Nov 4, 2014
820
49
28
I’ve seen it in baseball as well. The experience we had was that it was a hard-headed coach with an ego who thought he was a college coach and coached like that. You can’t do that in a small school - the numbers don’t allow it if u still plan to be competitive. My son (and several others) were seen as pitchers-only. Ridiculous. My son never once played any other position after his freshman year, including first base -he was 6’5”. And he never batted even though he finished his freshman year batting over .400. Head scratcher.
 

o_dawgnabit

All-American
Oct 13, 2016
5,104
8,263
113
It depends more on the team. My senior year we had a good mix. None of our Olinemen went both ways which was pretty normal for the teams in my region. But other than that, it was a good blend. It's also smarter to if you have the team that can do it.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball "When you win these type of games, you're gonna learn and grow": Mississippi State tops Tulsa in Jackson
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State vs. Tulsa: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball in Jackson
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Keys to Victory for Mississippi State vs. Tennessee Tech
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Recruiting Top 10 2027 QB Gavin Hampton and Bulldog commit highlights mental and physical improvements to his game
  5. 05 Rivals Basketball Recruiting Exclusive: NC State, Virginia Tech, South Carolina & more pursuing 4-star Micah Gunter