If a guy being ranked the "#4 QB guru" in college football "does not mean he... would be a good choice as a QB coach" then there's no such thing as a job qualification in any way, shape or form.
Do you hire people? Do you base your hiring decisions on nothing at all?
Whether he would want to come here or not is a legitimate conversation to have. But to suggest that he wouldn't be any good as a QB coach is ludicrous.
He is a guy that works part time with a few prospects, not a guy that it grinding all year long as member of a B1G coaching staff.