It seems obvious, but all things being equal, you have a 7.1 percent chance of winning a championship in a 14-team conference and a 12.5 percent chance winning in an 8-team conference. So, nobody in the Big Ten should expect to win titles at the same clip Nebraska and Oklahoma did in the 1970s and 1980s.
Further, both Nebraska and Oklahoma got to claim conference titles in years where there were ties:
If that criterion (claiming a title despite a tie in the standings) stood in the division-play era of college football, Nebraska would have all these years with titles in a 6-team division and a 12- or 14-team league:
- 1969: Nebraska and Missouri — Nebraska claims a title because it tied Mizzou, even though we lost the head-to-head matchup
- 1972: Nebraska wins because Oklahoma cheated (surprise!) and forfeited games
- 1975: Nebraska claims a title because it tied OU, even though we got spanked 35-10 by OU
- 1976: Oklahoma, OSU and Colorado tie
- 1978: Nebraska and OU tie and OU claims a title despite losing to Nebraska
- 1984: Nebraska and OU tie and NU claims a title despite losing to OU
- 1991: Nebraska and CU tie and NU claims a title despite tying Colorado 19-19
- 1996: North Division champion
- 1997: Big XII champion
- 1999: Big XII champion
- 2000: North Division co-champion
- 2001: North Division co-champion
- 2006 North Division champion
- 2008: North Division co-champion
- 2009: North Division champion
- 2010: North Division co-champion
- 2012: Legends Division champion
We claimed a lot of championships back in the Missouri Valley days (1907-1918, 1921-1927) when we were competing with between four and six other schools, and in the Big Six (1928-1947).
TLDR version: Unless we start counting titles as I noted above for division and co-championships, we'll unlikely ever reach the heights that we did in the Big 8 or any of its predecessor conferences.
- We claim a MVC title for 1907 despite having played just one conference game.
- Between 1910 and 1917, that's eight seasons, we played a total of only 23 conference games — fewer than 3 per year on average — and claimed all eight conference titles.
- Between 1928 and 1940, we won 9 of the 13 possible titles in a six-team conference.
- Devaney won four straight again from 1963-1966, and then four more from 1969-1972 in an eight-team conference.
I think, too, if we're being honest, the Big Ten right now is a far stronger conference than the Big 12 was when we were running the table in it. We had Oklahoma kind of down and out for most of the 90's, Texas was pretty good, Okie State got ok, and Missouri and K State were sometimes pretty good, but I think right now the Big Ten is VERY tough. And we're still in the weaker of the two divisions, and thats our only real advantage there.