First base ump doesn't understand that the tie goes to the runner.

dawgatUSM

Redshirt
Apr 6, 2008
3,835
27
48
I think he missed that call and a call on Frost earlier in the game. But it's impossible to tell for sure because ESPN doesn't show replays, apparently.

Boy he sure was on top of that bang-bang play where Wes' foot supposedly came off the bag, though. (sarcasm)
 

Forrest4Moore

Sophomore
Nov 14, 2011
610
169
43
There is no rule in baseball that says a tie goes to the runner. Probably the most known myth of a rule in sports, so I don't fault you. Just more of an FYI.

A runner is either safe or out. Completely a judgement call. There is no such thing as a tie in baseball.

Also, the hand is not part of the bat. Another rule that is greatly misunderstood. If the ball hits your hand, it is an HBP, awarded with granting you first base.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
If the ball is caught at the exact same time as the runner hits the bag, then he's safe. Whether the umpire misses it or not is another question....but if it's a tie play, the runner made it there safely. Period. It's not like if the ball is caught at the same time as the runner hitting the bag, the umpire gets the decision of who to reward....he's safe if he gets there at the exact same time. Not a myth, but sometimes not called correctly.<div>
</div><div>ETA: I'm NOT saying it is a rule in the rule book...simply saying that safe is safe, and unless the ball is caught BEFORE the runner hits the bag, he's safe.</div>
 

kbanes.sixpack

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
6
0
0
But surely, "tie goes to the runner" is a myth. It does not exist anywhere in the rule book.

There are interpretations of a couple of different rules that are inconsistent on the ruling, and as a consequence, most umpires will go on the assumption that a tie is not possible. That assumption is made because to consider the alternative (that a tie is possible) is not covered in the rules. There is more leverage in the rule book to indicate that a runner is out in the case of a tie, than there is that he is safe.

Personally, I can't believe that any Ump would ever admit that a tie exists, since he is an automatic loser in an argument at that point.

Kevin Banes
 

Optimus Prime 4

Redshirt
May 1, 2006
8,560
0
0
the bag must be tagged "before" the runner arrives to be out, therefore logic says that a tie is safe.

There is no rule that states that a tie goes to the runner. Well at
least not in those exact words. The portion of the rule in section 6.05
that applies to this
states, "A batter is out when after he hits a fair ball, he or first
base is tagged before he touches first base." Since the rule states
"before", it is easy to assume that a tie does in fact go to the runner.

But, since this is a judgment call you won't win an argument by yelling
"a tie goes to the runner".
 

Forrest4Moore

Sophomore
Nov 14, 2011
610
169
43
for a runner to be out, the throw has to beat him to the bag.

However, it also states that for a runner to be safe he has to beat the throw to the bag.

So, one can infer from that that a tie does not exist. And a tie is not "supposed" to go to the runner every time as an unwritten rule. It is all up to the umpire and his discretion. He was either safe or out. The rule does not allow for a tie. Period.

As for your ETA, it works both ways. Unless the runner touches the bag BEFORE the ball is caught, he's out.

ETA: http://www.hardballtimes....oes-to-the-runner/ This article interviews an MLB crew chief on the subject. He basically says that is completely a judgement call by the umpire, as if a tie doesn't exist in baseball.
 

RonnyAtmosphere

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2007
2,883
0
0
..I've watched alot of baseball games, & 95% of the time if it is a tie, the runner is called out.


I don't know the official rule; I just know what I see.
 

Forrest4Moore

Sophomore
Nov 14, 2011
610
169
43
Seems 95% of the time the Umps reward the defense for good plays that result in an extremely close play.

For the record, I thought both Frost and Frazier were clearly safe on their close plays today.
 

kbanes.sixpack

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
6
0
0
Rule 6.05 (j) A batter is out when, after a third strike or after he
hits a fair ball, he or first base is tagged before he touches first
base.

Rule 7.01 A runner acquires the right to an unoccupied base when he
touches it before he is out. He is then entitled to it until he is put
out, or forced to vacate it for another runner legally entitled to that
base.

Rule 7.08 (e) Any runner is out when he or the next base is tagged before he touches the next base....

All we know for sure is that he is out if he or the base is tagged before he gets there, and that he gets the base if he touches it before either he or the base is tagged. That's all. Any other determination is speculation/interpretation that is not specified in the rules.

The only two ways to resolve this is to either modify the rule to allow for a tie, and then define the outcome of a tie, or allow for instant replay and continue with the "tie doesn't exist" theory.

Neither is going to happen any time soon, although MLB will eventually get instant replay. For every other league (minors, college, high school, little league) ties will not exist.
 

MM4MSU

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
113
0
16
On an attempted double play, when the ball is flipped or thrown to 2nd, the runner will always be called out if throw beats him, even if whomever is covering obviously does not have foot on the base.

Michael M
(MSU '73)
 

TXDawg.sixpack

All-Conference
Apr 10, 2009
2,647
2,706
113
I've known several baseball umpires over the years and this is how they've all described the call at first base.<div>
</div><div>Given that the umpire can not watch both the bag and the 1B's glove at the same time, the ump will typically WATCH the bag and LISTEN for the ball to impact the 1B's mitt. Further given that light travels faster than sound, in the rare instance where the ball hits the mitt at the exact same time as the runner's foot hits the bag, the ump's eye will see the foot fractionally before his ear hears the ball and he will therefore call the runner safe. Coincidentally, this also leads to the myth of "tie goes to the runner."</div>
 

gravedigger

Redshirt
Feb 6, 2009
1,654
0
0
other way around.

A tie would be an out.

However, any decent umpire will tell you there is no such thing as a tie.
 

gravedigger

Redshirt
Feb 6, 2009
1,654
0
0
I dont like the rule much, but I do if it's ok for a baserunner to hit an indefensable fielder trying to make a play.
 

topbulldawg

Freshman
Jan 27, 2008
524
83
28
If you want to get technical, it is virtually impossible for a tie. At some fraction of time, the runner gets there. At some fraction of time, the ball gets there. The likelyhood they are 100 percent is almost completely impossible.

Now, what most people call a tie is when it is so close it is hard to tell whether he was out or safe. This is a pure judgement call, just like a called strike. As a former umpire, this call is purely reactionary based on how you see it. The umpire is not sitting there thinking whether it is a tie.
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,551
7,022
113
And for all the calls that are so close you can't tell with the human eye, I'm sure it ends up being 50/50 over the long run.
 

formerpolkie

Redshirt
Jun 5, 2008
176
0
0
aside after we worked a game together and explained an important fact to me. Hegaveme some relevant advice.Umpires can only call a certain number of outs and the game is over. We can call safe and be there all damn day. And we get paid the same amount either way. He summed it up by saying, "when there is doubt, call them out".
 

ckDOG

All-American
Dec 11, 2007
10,551
7,022
113
It's as if the umpire gets distracted by paying too much attention to the bat and forgets he can call the pitch a strike.
 

rawdawg14

Redshirt
Sep 2, 2010
210
0
0
Several of you are spot on. The way the rule book is written, ties do not exist. It is completely a judgement call. "tie goes to the runner" is, in fact a myth the term should be "tie goes to the ump"
 

saltslugs

Redshirt
Oct 9, 2009
1,500
0
0
There's no reason to even discuss this. Technically, a tie would represent one moment over an infinite quantity of time or (1/Infinity). As any mathematician will tell you, one divided by infinity equals zero. So, a tie cannot exist. Put another way, there is always, to some decimal point, a difference in time between any twooccurrences.
 

drt7891

Redshirt
Dec 6, 2010
6,727
0
0
I have done umpiring for several years and this is exactly what I was told. Most knowledgeable coaches (and I use that term loosely) appreciate consistency FAR more than "tie goes to the..." stuff. As long as you call both sides fairly, most coaches will not show their ***.<div>
</div><div>With that said, I always gave a "tie" situation to the defense... however, those were few and far between at first base... mostly coming when I'd call in a 2 man crew and was in the middle of the infield having to look at first base at a 90 degree angle. There were also tight calls at third a lot and those are MUCH closer than any I can remember at first base. I can't recall a tie with no one on and positioned just inside the foul line. </div>
 

drt7891

Redshirt
Dec 6, 2010
6,727
0
0
Bunts are far tougher than check swings, to me because the bat is already over the plate and that's what I get caught being focused on. With younger players especially, they have a tendency to jab at the ball, even if it's ever so slightly... and if they do, it's an automatic strike. However, several times I've been caught watching for the jab closer than I have the location of the pitch... and I would always have to remind myself that I can appeal to the base umpire for jabs and, in some cases, check swings... for location, there is no appeal.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
20,562
3,170
113
both are which are wrong. It's either 12 noon or 12 midnight. Noon and midnight are infinitesimally small points in time which are neither morning or afternoon.<div>
</div><div>
</div>
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State 88-46 Alabama State: Bulldogs beat the Hornets in annual Kids' Day game
  2. 02 Maroon and White Basketball Mississippi State at UCF: How, Where, and When to Watch Men's Basketball on the road
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Sanfrisco Magee's "detail" and consistency carrying Mississippi State offense through tough times
  4. 04 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes