IMO it's reasonable to say both Cal and Pitino are great coaches with comparable results while at UK that speak for themselves. To me it's how it unfolded and how it felt, in their tenure at UK, that is the difference. The following has nothing to do with ethics or character issues, rather my opinion of their time while coaching at UK.
To me, the storyline of Pitino's time here was easily more exhilarating and meaningful. We rose from the ashes of probation and almost immediately became competitive again with very average players. And we did this with a handful of KY boys that would run through brick walls for the program. We soon began winning SEC titles with mediocre talent before we should have. We took that Duke team to the brink in one of the all time classic college games. And this all ended up with subsequent final fours and arguably the best college team of all time.
With Cal, we started from a significant low spot but not what I'd call the ashes. We began getting transcendent players and dominated right away. We were left several times, however, feeling that something was left on the table when we didn't come a way with a deep tourney run or a title. But here we came right back next year with great new players and a real shot at doing something special. And often we did. Then came the huge disappointment of '15. No championships are a guarantee but this left many questioning the results, for whatever reason. Then a steady dose of fresh new faces but lesser results. Some years in this period will be considered good, a success, however other seasons as underachieving, not finishing up to realistic expectations. Rinse and repeat.
The tangible results - records - are comparable. To me, and this is just my opinion, the 90's run with Pitino read like a great novel. It had it all and unfolded as you would expect a great story to. Conversely, Cal's run, while winning a lot, left me feeling somewhat empty, sensing a lack of connection to the team that felt at times like I was watching someone else's team.
Here's an important similarity. Both era's are now over never to return. And, I feel that the next era under Cal bodes well for my ability to connect to and enjoy UK basketball like I haven't in a while.