dUKe may have problems on "D" this year.....

HICATFAN

All-American
Aug 15, 2001
9,181
8,473
113
Just sayin'
:joy:
From Larry Vaught

Can rule changes really curtail ‘flopping’ this season?
Curtis Show, coordinator of Big 12 men’s basketball officials, explained at the Big 12 Media Day in Kansas City this week about plans the rules committee has made to hopefully curtail flopping .

“They’re tired of the acting, tired of the drama. We want to play real basketball. We don’t want players to have to embellish or fake in order to get calls. We put in some specific items to talk about,” Shaw said.

“You get one delay a game warning of any kind, including a flop.”

Shaw said the NCAA rules committee has left little doubt that it wants flopping to stop.

“You’re not going to kill a play if a guy is in transition for a layup. You’re not going to kill a play if a guy is flopped on a charge, getting ready to dunk. You’re going to wait till the play ends or it’s a dead ball,” Shaw said. “You could flop, get stepped on, get dunked on, and get called for a technical foul. It’s a severe penalty to get it out of the game, okay?

“There’s three types (of flopping): Jump shooters falling without being touched; players trying to draw a charge and getting minimal, if any, contact; and then the head snap. On all three of these, they are judgment. There may be some contact. We’ll see the one where we’re taking a charge. He may brush him. It doesn’t matter if there’s some contact. We have to rule whether the contact was sufficient for that act.

“In the case of the head bob, you may even have a foul called because the guy did go out and hand check him, but then he embellishes it by throwing the head back. You may have a foul, and he’ll still get a warning or technical foul for the flopping, okay?”

AlohaCat
 
Jan 30, 2018
16,155
24,636
0
I hope this works and refs take it to heart. This would help us. Our players seem to play through contact and Cal knows the refs will screw us when they can so he tells them to finish the play even if your hit. Guys flopping like it's a charge if called would really help us because our guys finish the ply more times than not. I haven't seen our guys flop, but OP is right this would crush Dook if actually put into play.
 

Duke Bluu

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2017
3,612
2,486
113
Love it that K teaches guys to take the charge. I learned that at a young age. It’s a great play. Shane Battier was a master at it.
 

bgood4UK

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2014
54
169
0
Taking a charge is actually a terrible play. It’s exploiting a bad rule that awards poor defensive effort and punishes players for being physically superior.
This is exactly correct. The charge call was not meant to be used as it is currently. It should only be for when an offensive player uses illegal force to create space for advantage or when the offensive player is extremely out of control and crashes into legal guarding defenders. Instead, what is being called, and being taught, is for defenders to seek out every opportunity to draw contact and flop to the ground, all while never actually attempting to make a basketball play. It is beyond maddening to me when a defender rushes in front of someone going for a dunk or layup just so they can get run over....without even trying to block the shot or guard in any way. It severely devalues superior athletes that are able to attack the rim if defenders are rewarded for not making a legit basketball play.
 

NC Weasel

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
18,602
2,027
0
Actually, nothing wrong with taking a legit charge. The issue is FLOPPING, not playing defense and having an offensive player "bull" his way to the rim.

Flopping is BS. It's also risky to the knees of the players behind the play. Players who when in the lane, are often either looking up or toward other players.

Plus, flopping is meant not to fool your opponent but to actually fool the "game judge". The very person both teams seek fairness from. The true nature of sport is centered on its rules, sportsmanship, the belief in a fair match. Hence flopping is no better than cheating. Play your opponent not the referee.
 

Montana81

Heisman
Aug 12, 2004
82,727
29,410
113
Actually, nothing wrong with taking a legit charge. The issue is FLOPPING, not playing defense and having an offensive player "bull" his way to the rim.

Flopping is BS. It's also risky to the knees of the players behind the play. Players who when in the lane, are often either looking up or toward other players.

Plus, flopping is meant not to fool your opponent but to actually fool the "game judge". The very person both teams seek fairness from. The true nature of sport is centered on its rules, sportsmanship, the belief in a fair match. Hence flopping is no better than cheating. Play your opponent not the referee.

I agree but like 90% of charges called are bad calls that reward a flop. And sadly that’s probably not an exaggeration.

Grant Williams last season was probably the worst offender I’ve ever seen and that’s really saying something considering some of the guys duke has had and how much their defense around the basket has revolved around that play the last 25 years. Williams was rewarded with conference player of the year over more deserving guys like PJ, Waters and the guard from auburn.
 

UKCAT5FAN

All-Conference
May 9, 2010
5,285
3,822
113
Just sayin'
:joy:
From Larry Vaught

Can rule changes really curtail ‘flopping’ this season?
Curtis Show, coordinator of Big 12 men’s basketball officials, explained at the Big 12 Media Day in Kansas City this week about plans the rules committee has made to hopefully curtail flopping .

“They’re tired of the acting, tired of the drama. We want to play real basketball. We don’t want players to have to embellish or fake in order to get calls. We put in some specific items to talk about,” Shaw said.

“You get one delay a game warning of any kind, including a flop.”

Shaw said the NCAA rules committee has left little doubt that it wants flopping to stop.

“You’re not going to kill a play if a guy is in transition for a layup. You’re not going to kill a play if a guy is flopped on a charge, getting ready to dunk. You’re going to wait till the play ends or it’s a dead ball,” Shaw said. “You could flop, get stepped on, get dunked on, and get called for a technical foul. It’s a severe penalty to get it out of the game, okay?

“There’s three types (of flopping): Jump shooters falling without being touched; players trying to draw a charge and getting minimal, if any, contact; and then the head snap. On all three of these, they are judgment. There may be some contact. We’ll see the one where we’re taking a charge. He may brush him. It doesn’t matter if there’s some contact. We have to rule whether the contact was sufficient for that act.

“In the case of the head bob, you may even have a foul called because the guy did go out and hand check him, but then he embellishes it by throwing the head back. You may have a foul, and he’ll still get a warning or technical foul for the flopping, okay?”

AlohaCat



That is a disaster waiting to happen. If you're going to have this rule, you can only have it with plays when there is no contact. Period! You can be stopping a game or having officials make this kind of judgement during the game. You're going to end up calling a foul, then calling a T on a player for flopping, THEN you're going to have to dump the coach for going nuts. How can you credibly judge a flop with contact?? You have a 6'10 player coming down the lane trailing on a break, then a 6'2 guy steps over to try and take the charge. So, you're telling me that officials are supposed to judge just how much of an impact that the bigger guy has on the little guy???? That's crazy!! Just place the rule in for players that flop without contact. That's it. You can expect officials, or anyone else for that matter, to judge contact movement when you have such a discrepancy in player sizes. As an official, the hardest thing to judge is intent and it opens way too much for debate. It too easy for coaches to argue with plenty of credibility and it is too difficult to ask officials to be consistent. There is no way for this to be enforced consistently. I guess we will wait and see but I think it's going to be a disaster and it will end up costing some team big, I guarantee it. Not sure what they were thinking but it's crazy. It's ok to have this for plays with no contact but this rule is too difficult to enforce and too difficult to be consistent. Just got home from a 12 hr shift, so not sure if it makes sense or not but I'll elaborate tomorrow. lol. This is craziness but I guess it will be fun to watch since it's probably going to cripple UL and Duke. So, actually..... I'm all for this rule! Love it!!
 
Last edited:
Jul 9, 2004
93,075
38,060
0
I hate secondary charge calls. The person not in the play gets to just slide in and act as if he was actually playing defense on the guy with the ball going to the basket. If the guy guarding you can't keep you in front of him then you've done your job and he hasn't. You shouldn't be penalized unless you actually discarded the guy guarding you in some way. Unfortunately, I don't think this will ever be taken out of the game.
 

ScrooDook92

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2019
1,772
1,231
0
This could be a great thing for UK, if they actually enforce the new rule. But that's a big IF in my opinion. I think what we will see is selective enforcement.
This is such a subjective thing. For me it's all but killed the game. When did the flop get started? Players falling all over the place like a bad game of line-the-dominoes. I don't remember seeing it as a teen back in the 90's. Do you think they will tend to check the camera later in games?
 

cats#1again

All-Conference
Nov 27, 2011
8,011
4,587
0
This is just another judgment based rule which will be enforced exclusively at the whim of the refs. Another tool to let them control the outcome of the game.
You're spot on.
The problem is this, the majority of the teams that are coward enough to flop are the ones the refs don't want to see it from anyway. They won't call this on Duke. We know this already. It will only harm teams. Can u imagine a close game being decided by a ref thinking something was a flop, and it wasn't??
 
  • Like
Reactions: chroix

littlecreek

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2010
2,131
3,045
0
I doubt this will be enforced on Duke. Also, I see this being like the targeting call in football. The refs are so self conscious about missing it that they call it when it’s not even really targeting, just really aggressive football.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blueaz

3kidsandme

Heisman
Jan 12, 2013
7,345
10,353
113
Not gonna make much difference for UK. Some of these flops called are so obvious and they still get called against us. If you couldnt see the flopping before what's gonna change now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pickle_Rick

yoshukai

Heisman
Dec 21, 2002
30,922
44,356
102
I think the circle under the basket has already hurt coach k’s defensive philosophy. I’m not sure what year it was implemented, but have they been to a final four since?
 

TomTraubertsBlues

All-American
Oct 13, 2014
5,004
8,433
113
Taking a charge is actually a terrible play. It’s exploiting a bad rule that awards poor defensive effort and punishes players for being physically superior.

A secondary defender should NEVER be rewarded with a charge call. If you have to slide over because your teammate couldn't guard his man, that should rule your team out for being able to just slide over and fall down. That is not defense. Never has been.
 

TomTraubertsBlues

All-American
Oct 13, 2014
5,004
8,433
113
Duke last went to the Final Four the same time UK did.

Just like last year. Even after beating us by 350 in the first game, and with the best player ever to draw a breath, not to mention Barrett and Reddish, you guys still got no further that we did. K is finally learning that winning it all with OADs aplenty isn't that easy.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Women's Basketball After scoring 5k+ points in high school, Maddyn Greenway is learning a new role at Kentucky
  2. 02 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  3. 03 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Tricky Spots for CFP Teams
  4. 04 On3 Basketball LSU President says he has instructed Will Wade to not play RJ Luis
  5. 05 KSR Football Missouri has a Big Kicking Problem