Do you agree with these rankings?

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,511
3,080
113
Miles s/b further up even though he has a reputation for being a block head. Probably 4th or 5th.
 

coach66

Junior
Mar 5, 2009
12,720
347
83
Mark Richt is too high. Great person but let's face it, he has underachieved.

I hope they keep him because I feel like Georgia and LSU are two most likely schools to come after Mullen at some point.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,500
2,503
113
I think they got it right...I would make a few changes:
1. Saban
2. Malzahn
3. Spurrier
4. Pinkel +1
5. Mullen +2
6. Richt -3
7. Freeze
8. Les Miles
9. Kevin Sumlin +1
10. Butch Jones -1
11. Bret Beilmea
12. Mark Stoops +1
13. Jim McElwain -1
14. Derek Mason

There's some really good coaches in the SEC. I actually think Stoops is a pretty good coach. Bert grew on me a little this year, although I still don't like the guy. Butch Jones is one I think could make the biggest jump this year.

I have to move Richt down based on his lack of really competing for a national championship anytime in recent memory with all the talent, resources and recruiting base he's got.
 

57stratdawg

Heisman
Dec 1, 2004
148,782
24,668
113
I don't get why Malzahn is so far ahead of Sumlin. Malzahn is 20-7 at Auburn in two years, Sumlin is 28-11.

If Auburn goes 8-4, they'll have almost identical records after 3 years.
 

UpTheMiddlex3Punt

All-Conference
May 28, 2007
18,265
4,440
113
I would definitely put Pinkel above Richt. He's done more with less and won their (very weak) division 2 of the 3 years they've been in the SEC.
 

RebelBruiser

Redshirt
Aug 21, 2007
7,349
0
0
Never been a big believer in the ability to accurately rank coaches. Obviously, you can't do it just on wins and losses, because the jobs aren't the same. It's a lot tougher to win at Vandy than at Florida/LSU, which is why you could argue James Franklin was always vastly underrated by most of these lists before he left for PSU.

Also, fit with the job is important. Some guys will do really well at one place, but struggle at another, not because the job is tougher but because their style doesn't fit as well. Then you've got years on the job too. How do you rank a guy who has been a head coach for 20 years against someone who is in their 2nd season on the job? Do you rank based off what you believe their value is or what their current value is, since you can't really gauge a guy's program building and sustaining abilities after only a couple years.

All that said, if there was one group I'd be curious to see rank coaches, it would be the ADs. If you phrased it in a way to ask the ADs to rank the coaches in order of the ones they would hire if they were given a free pick, that would be an interesting list.

You'd probably have to have them rank the other 13 coaches excluding their existing one, just to be safe, but I would love to see those 14 ballots. I bet you'd find some interesting orders in there.

ETA: I say all that in my typical long-winded fashion to essentially say I agree with DS, that if you're going to do this, you've really only got No. 1 and 14 that you can feel comfortable with in the ranking. Past that, it's a grab bag based on how you decide to value coaches.
 
Last edited:

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,674
16,709
113
Depends on whether or not you taking into consideration their previous accomplishments. If this is about "who would I rather have as my coach TODAY", I would move Spurrier and Richt further down on the list. I'd bump Bielema to 7th.

1. Saban
2. Malzahn
3. Pinkel
4. Mullen
5. Freeze
6. Miles
7. Bert Bielema
8. Jones
9. Spurrier
10. Sumlin
11. Richt
12. McElwain
13. Stoops
14. Mason
 
Last edited by a moderator:

BiscuitEater

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2009
4,178
0
36
Okay ..

Here is my list. I based it off performance at current SEC School only, focused on most recent history. And, it takes into account school resources and just how historically tough it is to coach at that specific school. (ie Spurrier & Mullen get higher rankingss at USCe & MSU than someone like Richt at Georgia).

Fire away!

1. Nick Saban, Alabama 91-17 (8 years)
Clear #1; consistently has ‘best’ talent to work with; this year will show if he can stay on top

2. Gus Malzahn, Auburn 20-7 (2 years)
Has innovated the offense; clear #2

3. Steve Spurrier, USCe 84-45 (10 years)
Resurrected a losing program; will fall from #3 with another ‘bad’ year;

4. Gary Pinkel, Missouri 113-66 (14 years)
Getting to the SEC final two years in a row puts him in the top 4

5. Dan Mullen, MSU 46-31 (6 years)
No one can discount what Dan has done at State; he is no ‘fluke’

6. Hugh Freeze, Ole Miss 24-15 (3 years)
Likewise, Freeze has overcome the Nuttt fiasco; yet to finish ahead of MSU in West puts him behind Dan

7. Mark Richt, Georgia 136-48 (14 years)
Consistently has best talent in the East; consistently doesn’t take advantage of said talent

8. Les Miles, LSU 103-29 (10 years)
Clear recruiting advantage in LA; has #2 talent in West

9. Kevin Sumlin, Texas A&M 28-11 (3 years)
Last year moved him down the list; Aggie alums have invested big $$ in the program and are watching

10. Butch Jones, Tennessee 12-13 (2 years)
Has recruited well; still needs to ‘prove’ it on the field

11. Jim McElwain, Florida First Year
Ranking based purely on speculation of 'how' he will perform in '15

12. Bret Bielema, Arkansas 10-15 (2 years)
Last year showed improvement; this year will be interesting

13. Mark Stoops, Kentucky 7-17 (2 years)
Has fans enthused; showed better recruiting; still has not won on the field

14. Derek Mason, Vanderbilt 3-9 (1 Year)
Has not energized the base like Franklin; only has two years left to show improvement
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State