Discussion from a group text regarding John Cohen...

dawgstudent

Heisman
Apr 15, 2003
40,791
23,216
113
Let's say Mike Leach struggles the next 2 seasons and is fired, would John Cohen still be AD and make the next football hire?

My point is that would be 1.5 years removed from a baseball national championship and I think he still would have enough equity to remain as AD. The other side of the coin is baseball is a non-revenue sport and Cohen would have made 2 bad football hires. You can't have him making a 3rd hire on the sport that pays the bills.
 
Last edited:

maroonmadman

Senior
Nov 7, 2010
2,530
853
113
Cohen has a natty under his belt, something no other AD at State ever had. That being said he probably will have to get caught in bed with a live boy or a dead girl before he gets canned.
 

dorndawg

Heisman
Sep 10, 2012
9,490
11,059
113
Just as likely if not more so we will be making a men's and women's basketball coach hire during that time period.. We good with him making all 3?
 

Willow Grove Dawg

All-American
Nov 3, 2016
8,590
6,418
113
Two failed football coaching hires should doom every AD in the Power 5 except maybe Vandy, Rutgers, Illinois, Kansas, & Oregon State - but Cohen will survive even if Leach fails
 
Last edited:

preacher_dawg

All-Conference
Nov 12, 2014
2,818
2,336
113
The football hires have not been Rick Ray hires in which everyone was going "what the..." when they were hired. I think he survives.
 

Smoked Toag

Redshirt
Jul 15, 2021
3,262
1
0
Natty has cache for now. If Leach is pitiful enough to be fired in 2 years and is fired, well, at least Cohen had the balls to do that, and while the hire didn't work, Leach was a proven coach. Hard to blame Cohen for attempting to finally answer the question about whether MSU can throw the football or not.

But further, Leach won't struggle enough to get fired in year 3. He may not meet all our expectations, but he'll go 6-6 or better. He'll likely do that this year.
 

MSUDC11

Redshirt
Aug 23, 2012
7,316
0
0
Given that the decision is in Keenum's hands, and he does not strike me as a guy that will be in a hurry to run off an AD that contributed to us winning a national title, I expect Cohen to be here a while regardless of what happens with Leach. Not that I necessarily agree with that, but it's what I expect.
 
Last edited:

Dawgzilla

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
5,406
0
0
If Leach is a total failure, I don't think Cohen makes the next hire. I doubt he would be fired, but there would be a committee formed to make the next hire.

And we would hire someone with a run first philosophy.
 

Maroonthirteen

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
1,975
0
0
The confidence of the dink and dunk.... errr Air raid isn't high among the text group.

But what if the post game press conferences are funny.
 

BlueRidgeMtns

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2016
5,662
3,581
113
I'd say he survives to make the 3rd football hire if Leach doesn't pan out.

But I also feel like we're going to look like a totally different team this year on offense.
 

thatsbaseball

All-American
May 29, 2007
18,476
7,601
113
I've had the opinion for a while that Cohen has some very strong alumni (cigar boys whatever) that have his back. Whoever they are I don't think Keenum wants any part of pissing them off thus Cohen's job security may not be strictly based on "performance".
 

Jeffreauxdawg

All-American
Dec 15, 2017
8,891
8,006
113
Should stay. I think Leach was the oh **** hire after Joe Judge got the NY Giants job out of the blue. Even if Leach doesn't pan out, at least Cohen took a swing. Moorhead not panning out was a black mark, but almost everyone thought it was a good hire at the time (myself included.)

I'm still intrigued by what could have been with Judge. He's probably an NFL lifer now, but he strikes me as having all the traits of a great football coach and might have spent a long time at State if he built it up. Hate that he is in NY. 17 the Giants.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,311
5,867
113
Let's say Mike Leach struggles the next 2 seasons and is fired, would John Cohen still be AD and make the next football hire?

My point is that would be 1.5 years removed from a baseball national championship and I think he still would have enough equity to remain as AD. The other side of the coin is baseball is a non-revenue sport and Cohen would have made 2 bad football hires. You can't have him making a 3rd hire on the sport that pays the bills.

Cohen can't make the next football hire if Leach fails. I think Leach was a good hire. Cohen took a team that was ready to win and went unconventional with Moorhead. If it's true that Fordham had scholarship advantages, that was a reallly bad 17up. If Fordham didn't have scholarship advantages, that was ok. Then Cohen went unconventional again, offering somebody with essentially zero college experience who had never called plays before. That, to me, was something he didn't have credibility to do after Moorhead. I am a Judge fan, but that could have been disastrous and we couldn't afford to roll the dice like that. Now we've gone unconventional for a third time in a row. I think this is his best hire, so I won't fault him if Leach doesn't work out. But if Leach doesn't work out, the Judge move to me means Cohen can't be trusted with the football hire again. Hire a consultant. Have them drive the process.
 

Dawgg

Heisman
Sep 9, 2012
10,535
10,793
113
I think if Cohen had made another OC/DC first time Power 5 HC hire and it didn't pan out, then he would be on more of a hot seat, but he didn't.

On paper, Leach is specifically a great hire for Mississippi State. He came in with over a decade and a half of being a head coach at the Power 5 level and a history of overachieving at schools that aren't perennial powers and maintaining a disciplined team.

And baseball is a non-revenue sport, but it's sacred here. If Leach doesn't pan out, Cohen survives.
 

Dawgzilla

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
5,406
0
0
agree with all of this. and I still can't believe the Giants hired Judge. I think he would have been a homerun hire for us.

I don't know whether Judge would have worked out for us, but I still can't believe a guy I hadn't heard of in 15 years went from the next MSU HC, to HC of the Giants in less than 24 hours. That was a bizarre couple of days.

And this may just be semantics, but I think a "homerun hire" is a well known name that everyone assumes will succeed. I'm not sure it's a "homerun" when you have to wait a few years to see what happens.
 

Smoked Toag

Redshirt
Jul 15, 2021
3,262
1
0
agree with all of this. and I still can't believe the Giants hired Judge. I think he would have been a homerun hire for us.
Why? Just curious more than anything, I'm not arguing or disagreeing. He obviously has some intangible factor for him to be selected as an NFL head coach, but his resume (in 2019) didn't scream out college head coach or anything. Matter of fact, it looked like......Croom's. And funny enough, the things I'm ASSUMING that Judge would be good at (discipline, recruiting) were what Croom was supposed to do well.

Of course, Croom never really executed those things, he spent more time trying to be an offensive savant and recruiting kids that ran down defenders who intercepted them. Perhaps Judge would have delegated properly, but I still don't see the 'home run' part of it, at least not clearly.
 

Leeshouldveflanked

All-American
Nov 12, 2016
14,591
9,725
113
Football pays for everything. Baseball is basically a glorified club sport that 80 percent of the NCAA doesn’t even try to compete and only a handful of programs even try to make money. MSU not already having a Natty was probably more of an indictment on Polk fighting with the NCAA than recruiting at baseball. Cohen really needs Leach to work out.
 

Smoked Toag

Redshirt
Jul 15, 2021
3,262
1
0
I don't know whether Judge would have worked out for us, but I still can't believe a guy I hadn't heard of in 15 years went from the next MSU HC, to HC of the Giants in less than 24 hours. That was a bizarre couple of days.

And this may just be semantics, but I think a "homerun hire" is a well known name that everyone assumes will succeed. I'm not sure it's a "homerun" when you have to wait a few years to see what happens.
Yeah, I mean if using the definition, Leach was truly the home run hire.
 

NTDawg

Senior
Mar 2, 2012
2,274
947
113
Let's say Mike Leach struggles the next 2 seasons and is fired, would John Cohen still be AD and make the next football hire?

My point is that would be 1.5 years removed from a baseball national championship and I think he still would have enough equity to remain as AD. The other side of the coin is baseball is a non-revenue sport and Cohen would have made 2 bad football hires. You can't have him making a 3rd hire on the sport that pays the bills.


Keenum will not fire Cohen. If you think differently then you don't know Keenum very well.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
15,331
7,759
113
Its much harder for a team with the resources to win a baseball natty than a football natty. Bama competes against about 7-8 programs who can win it. State competes against 20-25. And then you dont even have to have the resources to win one. A 4 seed won the CWS in 2008. And Fresno State doesnt even care.
 

Cooterpoot

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2012
4,239
2
0
Cohen has a lifetime job barring some crazy ****. Name all the ADs we've fired in your lifetime.
This is MSU. Mediocrity is the standard outside of baseball and we've got a baseball guy running the show.
 
Sep 1, 2011
2,571
289
83
Let's say Mike Leach struggles the next 2 seasons and is fired, would John Cohen still be AD and make the next football hire?

My point is that would be 1.5 years removed from a baseball national championship and I think he still would have enough equity to remain as AD. The other side of the coin is baseball is a non-revenue sport and Cohen would have made 2 bad football hires. You can't have him making a 3rd hire on the sport that pays the bills.


Cohen needs help in managing an SEC football program. You cannot deny he knows baseball. The thing is, baseball doesn't need a lot of promotion at MSU. Especially when you go to the CWS the last 3 years. But, in the SEC, you have to market football 24/7, 365, and we just don't. Byrne and Stricklin ran rings around Cohen from an excitement and marketing campaign standpoint. The JoeMo debacle and Covid have our football program in a stagnant to declining position, and we simply just can't lose as many donors as other schools. Throw in the fact that we may see even more 11 am or TH night starts when OU and TX get in the mix, and we really need a jumpstart.
 

anon1787432961

Heisman
Mar 4, 2008
15,854
14,328
113
Let's say Mike Leach struggles the next 2 seasons and is fired, would John Cohen still be AD and make the next football hire?

My point is that would be 1.5 years removed from a baseball national championship and I think he still would have enough equity to remain as AD. The other side of the coin is baseball is a non-revenue sport and Cohen would have made 2 bad football hires. You can't have him making a 3rd hire on the sport that pays the bills.

From what I have seen, the SEC Network contract now pays the bills, and we get that win or lose. But success in football dictates PR and enrollment as well as gifts to the university. We can't be embarassingly bad, we just need to be competitive (6 and 6 or better) and go to a bowl game. Just my perspective and I know many here expect much more than that.
 

Trojanbulldog19

All-American
Aug 25, 2014
10,164
5,966
113
Honestly baseball is the only thing he has gotten right and that's because he knows baseball. Everything else has decline under his watch. In my opinion if leach sucks it up, Cohen shouldn't be making any more hires and should be demoted to like associate AD of baseball or something. The thing as senior AD it's not just about one sport. It's about all of them and running a multimillion dollar sports business from top to bottom. That includes game day atmosphere and everything else.
 

codeDawg

Redshirt
Nov 13, 2007
2,102
0
36
Let's say Mike Leach struggles the next 2 seasons and is fired, would John Cohen still be AD and make the next football hire?

My point is that would be 1.5 years removed from a baseball national championship and I think he still would have enough equity to remain as AD. The other side of the coin is baseball is a non-revenue sport and Cohen would have made 2 bad football hires. You can't have him making a 3rd hire on the sport that pays the bills.

CFB is going to change dramatically over the next 5 years. Leach runs the kind of system that can sneak up and have success while other teams are distracted. I don’t think what happens on the football field will have as big of an impact on what happens with the AD as what is happening in the conference / NCAA.
 

AssEndDawg

Freshman
Aug 1, 2007
3,183
54
48
I think he lives. Moorhead was a failed hire, so definitely one strike. But even if Leech fails, I have a harder time calling that a failed hire. It may not work, but I was 100% on board with trying it. The bottom line is that we are never going to line up 11 on 11 with Alabama playing Alabama's style of football and come out on top. So even if Leech fails I think a lot of people will consider it more of an experiment worth trying.

At the end of the day we hired a Baseball coach to be our AD on the promise he would bring us a baseball national championship. He did. That gives a little grace. But another bad hire will probably be the end no matter what happens in baseball (if Leech fails that is).
 

Eleven Bravo

Junior
Aug 31, 2018
625
283
63
I’ve been watching this stuff (MSU Sports) for a long, long time. John Cohen would have to do something like getting caught with a guy or an underage girl for this not to be his job for as long as he wants it. People thinking (hoping) he’s gonna get fired for making a couple bad coaching hires can be prepared to be disappointed. That’s not the way things generally work at our school. LT (ya’ll remember him) stayed for many years longer than he should have been allowed to. His big deal was spending as little money as possible, and that worked for him for many years. You can be sure that Cohen is very close to the small group of powerful people who really run the show. He’s a lot smarter guy and a much better politician than some people think he is. His job is all about politics (no, not the kind of politics where you run for something and get elected every so many years) and he is very savvy at endearing himself to the right people. That’s the way AD’s all work at Mississippi State-and probably most other places, too. I’m not saying that’s right or wrong-but that’s the way it is.
 

Bill Shankly

Redshirt
Nov 27, 2020
2,095
0
0
Cohen can not be allowed to hire another football coach, PERIOD. Baseball is nice, but it's a minor sport. Football is what pays the bills.
 
Sep 1, 2011
2,571
289
83
Cohen can not be allowed to hire another football coach, PERIOD. Baseball is nice but football is what pays the bills.

He has done nicely in baseball, but let's not act like he is the only AD at MSU to give us a chance at a natty in baseball. The others just fell a little short, but we were more than good. But, he has **** the bed otherwise, and until MSU decides to quit hiring retreads and newbies, we will continue to suck.

Is there any reason to think we would not still be good in baseball if someone else was running the dept?
 
Last edited:

BigDawg0074

Senior
Oct 12, 2016
1,424
798
113
He’s not going anywhere for at least three years. Mess around and get another natty or two and he’s locked in for ten. Football will pay the bills regardless because we spend everyone else’s money. The city will suffer a bit though because nobody will show up and spend money to watch them lose.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Mississippi State Soccer hosts Samford in NCAA Tournament on Friday
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State Week 12 Preview: Who carries the load?
  3. 03 Maroon and White Basketball Bulldogs prepare for mid-major test against Tulsa in Jackson
  4. 04 On3 Football Mississippi State RB Fluff Bothwell re-signs with Bulldogs for 2027
  5. 05 Maroon and White "There will be an opportunity for Brodie": Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby sets freshman up for Saturday runout