Courtside views

Catreporter

Senior
Sep 4, 2007
5,117
680
113
I didn't see either exhibition game but so far I am pleasantly surprised by this team. I guess LA Pratt was pretty bad in the preseason but he's been good in these three warmup wins. Nice drives, a threat from three and hitting his free throws. West is a star, we knew that, but Phoenix Gill has been a pleasant find. He is a threat from the corner with the three and has some floor skills Glad he hung in there this year. Karasinski hasn't played the last two games but we will need him going forward. Gelo made some nice shots tonight. Hope he can get confident with that because we will need him to score some. Rebounding is going to be a huge challenge for this team., but the defense has been pretty good otherwise. Will be very interesting to see what they do against DePaul Friday night.,
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,390
327
83
Gelo needs to give up on the threes and work on his Brooks/Nick short game. He was decent within about 10 feet or so on his turn around jumpers. He should keep practicing the three, but man I wouldn't have him take a shot unless it's a blowout one way or the other.
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,866
1,541
113
I didn't see either exhibition game but so far I am pleasantly surprised by this team. I guess LA Pratt was pretty bad in the preseason but he's been good in these three warmup wins. Nice drives, a threat from three and hitting his free throws. West is a star, we knew that, but Phoenix Gill has been a pleasant find. He is a threat from the corner with the three and has some floor skills Glad he hung in there this year. Karasinski hasn't played the last two games but we will need him going forward. Gelo made some nice shots tonight. Hope he can get confident with that because we will need him to score some. Rebounding is going to be a huge challenge for this team., but the defense has been pretty good otherwise. Will be very interesting to see what they do against DePaul Friday night.,
Basically the team has three good guards and overall pretty weak inside, Gonna be a long season
 

Max_Power

Senior
May 29, 2001
3,145
602
101
Basically the team has three good guards and overall pretty weak inside, Gonna be a long season

One of the things that has baffled me over the last few years is Collins failure to recruit a true rebounding big man. Not a tweener like Singleton but an actual guy who is athletic and goes out an grabs rebounds and that's his thing. I am fine with the 1-3 on this team and the core of a pretty solid team is there at 1-3, however, there is nothing at 4-5 and nothing on the roster to help this year and maybe next. Heck, even BU's center on NU would be an upgrade and that's more a comment on how bad the NU bigs are right now. This has nothing to do with Ghai sitting on the bench as he is so raw I am not sure if he helps but heck, there were points last night where I was thinking that even the threat of rebounder / shot blocker on the floor would probably help.

So three games in - here is my take - this is a roster that will struggle because they do not rebound at all. They may win a game against a good team if the 1-3 positions go nuts but they will be destroyed in conference play because they are so small. The silver lining is that this team is not as bad as I thought (regardless of record) and really one or two portal additions could solve 90% of the issues with the team, which 1-3 are: 1) rebounding; 2) rebounding and 3) rebounding.
 

Catreporter

Senior
Sep 4, 2007
5,117
680
113
They will have to hit a lot of threes to beat good teams. Krasinski needs to be healthy for that and maybe Hodge can give us some more depth up front and we need the Englishman back, even if he isn't that good, but yes this will probably be a long year when we get to Big Ten play. On the other hand, Collins and the staff have done a good job coaching this team through the first three games after the disaster that apparently was the Iowa State exhibition (I didn't see it) .
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,390
327
83
Per that CBS sports article:

Numerous big-man-needy teams entered free agency with $4 million earmarked for a star center. That wasn't enough. Many of the best bigs in free agency earned close to a $5 million payday.
If they're also right that NU is in the $7.1 to $9.9 million range, Collins didn't have the spend he needed for a competent, proven big.
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,866
1,541
113
One of the things that has baffled me over the last few years is Collins failure to recruit a true rebounding big man. Not a tweener like Singleton but an actual guy who is athletic and goes out an grabs rebounds and that's his thing. I am fine with the 1-3 on this team and the core of a pretty solid team is there at 1-3, however, there is nothing at 4-5 and nothing on the roster to help this year and maybe next. Heck, even BU's center on NU would be an upgrade and that's more a comment on how bad the NU bigs are right now. This has nothing to do with Ghai sitting on the bench as he is so raw I am not sure if he helps but heck, there were points last night where I was thinking that even the threat of rebounder / shot blocker on the floor would probably help.

So three games in - here is my take - this is a roster that will struggle because they do not rebound at all. They may win a game against a good team if the 1-3 positions go nuts but they will be destroyed in conference play because they are so small. The silver lining is that this team is not as bad as I thought (regardless of record) and really one or two portal additions could solve 90% of the issues with the team, which 1-3 are: 1) rebounding; 2) rebounding and 3) rebounding.
Often the top rebounders tend to be the PFs, But they need the centers to block out and hold position so others can grab the rebounds. We have no one that can do that, And the guy we brought in to do that (McEldon) decided to go on sabatical. So all we got is Soulis and he does not yet appear to be up to the task being more of a tweener. Other than that we are 6'8" and shorter.

You can do the shorter faster lineup but they have to be more proficient at scoring and need more depth than we have right now
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,866
1,541
113
They will have to hit a lot of threes to beat good teams. Krasinski needs to be healthy for that and maybe Hodge can give us some more depth up front and we need the Englishman back, even if he isn't that good, but yes this will probably be a long year when we get to Big Ten play. On the other hand, Collins and the staff have done a good job coaching this team through the first three games after the disaster that apparently was the Iowa State exhibition (I didn't see it) .
You forgot about IL State
 

Catdude

Freshman
Aug 27, 2001
1,035
66
48
Any team with competent big guys (so basically every team in the Big 10) is going to give us major problems. We don’t have the size or athleticism to defend around the basket, so it’s going to be a huge and constant challenge to stop guys down low and rebound.
Depaul will be a good year if we can be competitive with a major conference team. As others have said, it looks like our best hope is to shoot the lights out and work really hard to get enough stops on defense. There is so little margin for error.
 

Max_Power

Senior
May 29, 2001
3,145
602
101
They will have to hit a lot of threes to beat good teams. Krasinski needs to be healthy for that and maybe Hodge can give us some more depth up front and we need the Englishman back, even if he isn't that good, but yes this will probably be a long year when we get to Big Ten play. On the other hand, Collins and the staff have done a good job coaching this team through the first three games after the disaster that apparently was the Iowa State exhibition (I didn't see it) .
Iowa state smothered the guards, which is what I see happening a lot in the Big10.
 

Sec_112

Junior
Jun 17, 2001
6,636
255
83
Iowa state smothered the guards, which is what I see happening a lot in the Big10.
1) I'm in the ballpark with you. I think poor Jake is going to get killed in the B10. And don't get wrong: It's not his fault. If I were an opposing coach, I'd just double him all over the court and dare someone else to beat me. So far, Pratt and Karasinski would be the only concerns, and I wonder if both are streaky.

2) I agree with what everybody says about the fives. The only minor hope I want to offer the thread is that the double-team switches are starting to improve and become more synced. I don't think that's going to swing things on defense. But 🤞🤞🤞
 

Napcat

Redshirt
Nov 23, 2016
208
36
28
On the bright side, LA Pratt has scored more points in the first three games than any other player in Northwestern history. Jake West is off to a great start as well. Hopefully Karasinski can maintain his form when he returns. I like what Gill and Ciaravino bring to the table. Center position will be by committee. Let’s pack the house on Friday and make it to 4-0.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CoralSpringsCat

NJCat

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2016
22,015
2,175
113
Hopefully Krasinski can maintain his form when he returns. I like what Gill and Ciaravino bring to the table.
+1 for getting Gello'sname spelled correctly.

-1 for Karasinski. As a fellow Polack I feel obliged to stick up for Jack, especially since I had an uncle named Jack (which was short for Francis, a forerunner of reverse Polish notation).
 
  • Like
Reactions: CoralSpringsCat

Catreporter

Senior
Sep 4, 2007
5,117
680
113
After watching some other BIG teams on TV tonight, we'd better enjoy a few wins now because the conference season will be ugly. Singleton and Paige would have made this team more competitive, for sure, but boy, some of these teams ae loaded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catmandoo78

Catmandoo78

Junior
Nov 12, 2025
502
292
63
After watching some other BIG teams on TV tonight, we'd better enjoy a few wins now because the conference season will be ugly. Singleton and Paige would have made this team more competitive, for sure, but boy, some of these teams ae loaded.
I watched Illinois tonight and they’re stacked. Mirkovich is their best player and he’s out with a broken foot and they were missing another starter so they had to play almost exclusively freshmen and still almost won on the road at #16 Texas Tech. (Side note, it’s interesting, in the age of transfer portal Undie only took one transfer this year. Most their additions were high schoolers, with most of them not being very highly ranked. But he did a good job with the eval because those kids looked good last night).

MSU beat a top 10 Duke team. Izzo still has it. They’re really really good.
 

CappyNU

Senior
Mar 2, 2004
5,392
725
113
DePaul has at least one 7-footer on the court at all times, and 3 of them on the roster in total, so we're going to get a taste real quick of what conference play will be like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EagerFan

No Chores

Senior
Jul 2, 2006
7,014
770
113
I watched Illinois tonight and they’re stacked. Mirkovich is their best player and he’s out with a broken foot and they were missing another starter so they had to play almost exclusively freshmen and still almost won on the road at #16 Texas Tech. (Side note, it’s interesting, in the age of transfer portal Undie only took one transfer this year. Most their additions were high schoolers, with most of them not being very highly ranked. But he did a good job with the eval because those kids looked good last night).

MSU beat a top 10 Duke team. Izzo still has it. They’re really really good.
You're absolutely right. Duke was ranked #2 prior to the game with MSU
 

rogerkim

Junior
Jan 22, 2020
1,033
212
63
Ghai's education begins Friday.
It might get ugly, but I'm hoping CCC goes ahead and just throws him in the deep end this year and take his lumps so that he will be ready next year.

One thing that Collins said in the last post-game presser is that he didn't play Ghai because the other team went "small ball". Not sure I fully understand or agree with that strategy. In the past, I don't remember Big Ten opponents not playing their big men just because we went out there with a "small ball" lineup - on the contrary, they would use that as an opportunity to punish us by abusing our lack of height with their big men. So why can't we do the same on the rare occasion when we have a size advantage? It would seem to be especially good to get Ghai some minutes/experience/confidence when he is the tallest man on the court. Anybody have an explanation on this for me?
 

CappyNU

Senior
Mar 2, 2004
5,392
725
113
It might get ugly, but I'm hoping CCC goes ahead and just throws him in the deep end this year and take his lumps so that he will be ready next year.

One thing that Collins said in the last post-game presser is that he didn't play Ghai because the other team went "small ball". Not sure I fully understand or agree with that strategy. In the past, I don't remember Big Ten opponents not playing their big men just because we went out there with a "small ball" lineup - on the contrary, they would use that as an opportunity to punish us by abusing our lack of height with their big men. So why can't we do the same on the rare occasion when we have a size advantage? It would seem to be especially good to get Ghai some minutes/experience/confidence when he is the tallest man on the court. Anybody have an explanation on this for me?
In this case, I think it would do Ghai a disservice to get abused on the defensive end by smaller quicker guys that he can't guard. I think it would be a different scenario if you're talking about a 5th-year Matt Nicholson, who can dominate offensively and has enough awareness on defense to be able to handle a smaller quicker guy effectively, even if he can't fully keep up. Just my opinion though, not sure why CCC has gone with his approach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macarthur31

macarthur31

Junior
Nov 9, 2006
1,766
390
83
It might get ugly, but I'm hoping CCC goes ahead and just throws him in the deep end this year and take his lumps so that he will be ready next year.

One thing that Collins said in the last post-game presser is that he didn't play Ghai because the other team went "small ball". Not sure I fully understand or agree with that strategy. In the past, I don't remember Big Ten opponents not playing their big men just because we went out there with a "small ball" lineup - on the contrary, they would use that as an opportunity to punish us by abusing our lack of height with their big men. So why can't we do the same on the rare occasion when we have a size advantage? It would seem to be especially good to get Ghai some minutes/experience/confidence when he is the tallest man on the court. Anybody have an explanation on this for me?
I wonder if Ghai goes up against Federiko during practice, and that gives CC enough data he needs to assess if Symon can handle a small ball 5 at this point. Also, I'm intuiting that Ghai's pivot game is still emerging, and that he's not dominant there enough to compensate for the fact that he'd get outrun on defense by a small ball 5. Or put it this way, if he already was a finished product offensively, he'd be at another program.
 

Max_Power

Senior
May 29, 2001
3,145
602
101
Not that I know this to be a certainty, but I believe the answer to that is $$$$
I would disagree. I actually have issues with Collins' recruiting lately but in reality its more the product of Singleton leaving. I see the vision for the next 2 years of Jake West and I think that the issues can be quickly fixed through the portal as long as the core players stay.
 

Max_Power

Senior
May 29, 2001
3,145
602
101
He’s 100% gonna leave. All these dudes are mercenaries now. The game is gone.
I think he gives NU a chance first in the portal to get him help. If nothing materializes I support him leaving bc no one should have to play 2 on 5 (LA is the only other remotely complete player in the roster). Ciaravino is not a good player for a bad team. I’ve seen enough of Karasinki to make me believe Gill should start. Federico could be ok in two years and center is a black hole swallowing the rest of the roster as it expands.
 

GatoLouco

Junior
Nov 13, 2019
5,758
260
63
I watched just the first 5 minutes and boy, are we in for a fun time yelling at the TV to box out and get some rebounds.

Here are my thoughts, based on watching 2 full games and not even a quarter of the DePaul game:
  • If a B1G roster is composed of say a core 7 players, we have 5 of them who are B1G (or borderline) players. West, Prat, Karasinski, Ciaravino and Gill
  • The problem is that every team is composed of 2 or 3 players above the remaining. And those are the ones who sustain being good or not. In the spots 1-3 of a competitive B1G team, we only have 1 player who could compete, West. Others are players who could make the roster of competitive teams in 4-7 (or less) positions, less minutes, more rotational roles
  • The overall quality of the front court is atrocious. I don't know what word to use here, but it's dramatic. Of the players I mentioned as B1G quality only Ciaravino can be, borderline, front court
  • The quality of the backcourt is decent, but when the other team can swarm a guy like Karasinski, who is not fast enough to get lose when no one is sagging on guarding him, we are in trouble. The mediocrity of the front court relfects heavily on the space our backcourt has. We are in doo doo.
I've been very critical of Collins in the past when I thought he absolutely butchered a season with a tournament quality roster. But I never doubted his recruiting talent, always thought he batted way above average for our expectations. That's why I have a hard time putting any of the blame on him here. The roster is very unbalanced, but I have no idea what he was working with. Especially when the numbers $$$$ for big man are what they are.

Still think we are not as bad as the sky is falling. But we will not win more than 5-7 in conference.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: hdhntr1

GatoLouco

Junior
Nov 13, 2019
5,758
260
63
5 to 7 in conference would be quite an over achievement for this group. I'm not sure we can beat anybody in the Big Ten with this roster.
7 is a stretch for sure. But, for as much as a team might stink, in the last 4 years only 5 teams failed to win 5 games.
 

prez77

Senior
Dec 27, 2024
885
414
57
DePaul has recently been really bad and would be in the bottom echelon if they were in the Big10. We just lost to them by 20.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,390
327
83
One of my bigger concerns for the future is that maybe halfway thru the second half against DePaul, it seemed to me that West had mostly given up on anyone else doing anything on offense, and started playing a lot of 1 on 5. He was reasonably successful, but him losing faith in his team is not a good thing.

I get it tho, when he tried to get them involved it often led to someone else taking a bad shot or turning the ball over.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota
  3. 03 Wildcat Report The 3-2-1 after Northwestern's loss to Ohio State
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Three Wildcat commits crack new Rivals300
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Recruit Roundup: WR Moseley scores three TDs, QB Phifer accounts for four