Collins has to go

jensberg

Junior
Jul 28, 2006
3,247
237
63
The assessment of the talent they brought in is obviously the problem. The players they let go are better than the ones they brought in by far.
 

MCC_Cat

Junior
May 29, 2001
1,586
311
83
The assessment of the talent they brought in is obviously the problem. The players they let go are better than the ones they brought in by far.
Like waaaay, way better. Jayden Reid was AP NATIONAL player of the week last week for Memphis. And he was ours. I'm sure Collins taught him some good lessons though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baz = Heisman

Catmandoo78

Junior
Nov 12, 2025
502
292
63
Gosh, I honestly am starting to think he will not survive this season. They may only win like 12 games total. I never thought he’d get fired but if it gets bad enough, there may be no choice. You can’t lose by 20 to Columbia in an empty home gym. If you have many more nights like this, it’s hard to see it coming back without a HUGE influx of NIL.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Cataria

NUCatswin

Redshirt
Apr 18, 2018
465
46
27
Gosh, I honestly am starting to think he will not survive this season. They may only win like 12 games total. I never thought he’d get fired but if it gets bad enough, there may be no choice. You can’t lose by 20 to Columbia in an empty home gym. If you have many more nights like this, it’s hard to see it coming back without a HUGE influx of NIL.
12 games? We have 3 wins right now, we only have 4 games left against non p5 and one of those is Dayton. I’d be shocked if we get 10 and even that’s a stretch
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCC_Cat and NJCat

wildcatpn

Junior
Oct 26, 2005
3,405
322
83
Like waaaay, way better. Jayden Reid was AP NATIONAL player of the week last week for Memphis. And he was ours. I'm sure Collins taught him some good lessons though.
Many on this board said that Reid wasn’t good enough to play in the B1G. Too small, too out of control blah blah blah.
 

zeek55

Senior
Nov 21, 2010
3,741
456
83
Yeah, it feels like this is the end of the CCC era.

He had his years but this has run long enough; need any kind of change in direction at this point. Desperately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baz = Heisman

prez77

Senior
Dec 27, 2024
885
414
57
Gosh, I honestly am starting to think he will not survive this season. They may only win like 12 games total. I never thought he’d get fired but if it gets bad enough, there may be no choice. You can’t lose by 20 to Columbia in an empty home gym. If you have many more nights like this, it’s hard to see it coming back without a HUGE influx of NI
Gosh, I honestly am starting to think he will not survive this season. They may only win like 12 games total. I never thought he’d get fired but if it gets bad enough, there may be no choice. You can’t lose by 20 to Columbia in an empty home gym. If you have many more nights like this, it’s hard to see it coming back without a HUGE influx of NIL
12 games? We have 3 wins right now, we only have 4 games left against non p5 and one of those is Dayton. I’d be shocked if we get 10 and even that’s a stretch
Unless something miraculous occurs internally or we face someone with a lot of injuries, I think the over-under is a 7 win season.
 

CappyNU

Senior
Mar 2, 2004
5,392
725
113
Well, he didn’t suddenly forget to Coach. This is a power play and this season is collateral damage.
Are you suggesting he chose the transfers this year knowing this roster would be a lost year with the intention of forcing the university to give him more if they want to win in the future?
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,390
327
83
It would be nice if the NCAA required transparency in publishing player salaries across the D1 so everyone can understand what is happening. As a player, I'd love to know the numbers when negotiating my own salary.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,562
4,814
113
Are you suggesting he chose the transfers this year knowing this roster would be a lost year with the intention of forcing the university to give him more if they want to win in the future?
I am suggesting he didn’t have enough money to compete and he knew it. This is what the resources bought. It’s not an intentional tank where he deliberately brought in poor players.

it’s come to Jesus for the Athletic department. They either up the resources to a competitive level of they fire CCC. I believe he has no intention staying at NU if the resources a 1/3 or 1/4 of the top teams in conference. John Wooden isn’t going to win under those circumstances. Either way, firing CCC and not increasing the payroll won’t make NU competitive. It just won’t.
 

Styre

Senior
Oct 14, 2004
7,846
570
113
I am suggesting he didn’t have enough money to compete and he knew it. This is what the resources bought. It’s not an intentional tank where he deliberately brought in poor players.

it’s come to Jesus for the Athletic department. They either up the resources to a competitive level of they fire CCC. I believe he has no intention staying at NU if the resources a 1/3 or 1/4 of the top teams in conference. John Wooden isn’t going to win under those circumstances. Either way, firing CCC and not increasing the payroll won’t make NU competitive. It just won’t.

Why is that an either/or?
 

prez77

Senior
Dec 27, 2024
885
414
57
I mean, that’s probably all still true…
It's not binary. Reid could certainly play but he wouldn't have been a good running mate for West in my opinion and he's not a lead guard on a team with a winning record in conference play. Surrounded by a lot of talent, he could be a starter on a middling BIG10 team.
 

Styre

Senior
Oct 14, 2004
7,846
570
113
We aren’t going to win like this, so the powers to be have to make a decision on the direction going forward.

Right, but why can't the decision be "hire a new coach and give him an improved NIL budget?" I'm not saying I want Collins gone but there's no reason NU can't act differently than it has in the past.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xxxbobxxx

Catmandoo78

Junior
Nov 12, 2025
502
292
63
It’s not all NIL related. Whatever we have in NIL, it’s guaranteed that Columbia has 1/4 to 1/2 of that. And they kicked our butts. Case in point, we used our money to poach Soulis from them! And they still killed us (I know he didn’t play, but the point is he’s off their roster).

Collins clearly lost without James next to him
 

Styre

Senior
Oct 14, 2004
7,846
570
113
Why not increase the NIL for the only coach who has taken us to the Big Dance(and thrice at that)?

We're in a fundamentally different era now, and the qualities that enabled Collins to make NU history might not be qualities that enable him to succeed in the NIL era. If that's true, it takes nothing away from the amazing work he's done here but it does mean we might be better suited to look elsewhere.

All that said, I'm not advocating for any position other than increasing the NIL budget. More than willing to let the season play out and hopefully see things improve.
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,866
1,541
113
Are you suggesting he chose the transfers this year knowing this roster would be a lost year with the intention of forcing the university to give him more if they want to win in the future?
I would suggest that he chose what he could afford with our NIL budget, He has the added issue that some of that budget is tied up in a couple players that are not currently available, With a supposedly decent BIG costing $3-4 mill, that was not in our budget
 

hdhntr1

All-Conference
Sep 5, 2006
38,866
1,541
113
It’s not all NIL related. Whatever we have in NIL, it’s guaranteed that Columbia has 1/4 to 1/2 of that. And they kicked our butts. Case in point, we used our money to poach Soulis from them! And they still killed us (I know he didn’t play, but the point is he’s off their roster).

Collins clearly lost without James next to him
It is an Ivy league team where the degree means even more that at NU, So they stay until they have that degree and that means that they have been playing together for 2-3 years. This year the NU team hasn't even figured out each others names.

The loss of James is potentially legit
 
May 29, 2001
7,346
377
56
Wow. Losing to Columbia at home by 20 cements that this team is a disaster. Was Mark Jackson too focused on football to allow this slide with the basketball program to happen?

I don’t see any hope for improvement over the upcoming games esp conference games will be blowouts. Sorry to see the program collapse under Collins but agree the new players attained do not match those that left. Maybe a coaching change is inevitable but also would like to see Collins finish the season.
 

EagerFan

Junior
Dec 24, 2010
3,390
327
83
I feel obligated to point out that after Collins took us to the dance, his next three season conference win totals were 6, 4, and 3, followed by a 6 and a 7, and then back to back dances. After the third dance, he went to 7 and then 5, so it might not be the ahistorical shocker if this year turns into a 3 or a 4 win season before he gets this new world sorted, learns to survive without James, and we start going back up.

Maybe we shouldn't be too quick to call for his head.

I've been miserable watching all of these home games, and I'll be complaining about the entire season I'm sure, but I'm willing to give him and his team time to right the ship. NIL support moving NU into at least the B1G average team salary doesn't seem like too much to ask and even without a big donor getting generous, the school makes enough money from conference revenue sharing to bump up its own contribution, and that should help. But he does have some work of his own to do.
 

docrugby1

Senior
Jun 16, 2010
7,026
645
88
I believe that the consensus opinion was that CC was behind the exodus of Paige, Reid, Windham, et al. Singleton may have been an NIL issue.
Last year's team under performed because the coaching staff did not adjust anything to accommodate the strengths or weaknesses of the players.
Reid was a very good offensive player but struggled defensively.
Paige was the most talented big in recent history with shot blocking ability, excellent passing and offensive skills . NU did not even attempt to utilize his strengths but had him chasing guards 20' from the basket.
Kropp was asked to play out of position at center center. He will likely develop into a quality forward.
Windham had demonstrated ability in 24-25 but was relegated to the end of the bench last year- why?
Green was supposedly a shooter but not in NU's offense
Singleton , highly rated, was almost invisible offensively but the potential was there.
Martinelli and the above players should have been a better team.
James' retirement surprised me but I believe the reason is now obvious.
 

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,562
4,814
113
Right, but why can't the decision be "hire a new coach and give him an improved NIL budget?" I'm not saying I want Collins gone but there's no reason NU can't act differently than it has in the past.
It could be. The most important part at this stage is having resources to be competitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Styre

Purple Pile Driver

All-Conference
May 14, 2014
29,562
4,814
113
It’s not all NIL related. Whatever we have in NIL, it’s guaranteed that Columbia has 1/4 to 1/2 of that. And they kicked our butts. Case in point, we used our money to poach Soulis from them! And they still killed us (I know he didn’t play, but the point is he’s off their roster).

Collins clearly lost without James next to him
So now CCC only won because of James? The same James that folks complained about on here when our Bigs could only dunk and box out? Visions of Hank and Fitz dancing in my head.
 

jschufreider

Sophomore
Aug 13, 2005
303
109
38
Gosh, I honestly am starting to think he will not survive this season. They may only win like 12 games total. I never thought he’d get fired but if it gets bad enough, there may be no choice. You can’t lose by 20 to Columbia in an empty home gym. If you have many more nights like this, it’s hard to see it coming back without a HUGE influx of NIL.
12 wins? I’m afraid we’ve already won all the games we’re going to win this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NJCat
Aug 31, 2003
15,261
633
113
I believe that the consensus opinion was that CC was behind the exodus of Paige, Reid, Windham, et al. Singleton may have been an NIL issue.
Last year's team under performed because the coaching staff did not adjust anything to accommodate the strengths or weaknesses of the players.
Reid was a very good offensive player but struggled defensively.
Paige was the most talented big in recent history with shot blocking ability, excellent passing and offensive skills . NU did not even attempt to utilize his strengths but had him chasing guards 20' from the basket.
Kropp was asked to play out of position at center center. He will likely develop into a quality forward.
Windham had demonstrated ability in 24-25 but was relegated to the end of the bench last year- why?
Green was supposedly a shooter but not in NU's offense
Singleton , highly rated, was almost invisible offensively but the potential was there.
Martinelli and the above players should have been a better team.
James' retirement surprised me but I believe the reason is now obvious.
You make a pretty good case that Collins is stubborn and instead of working with the players he had, decided to run them off and gamble on a complete re-roll of talent from the portal.
 

Catmandoo78

Junior
Nov 12, 2025
502
292
63
I feel obligated to point out that after Collins took us to the dance, his next three season conference win totals were 6, 4, and 3, followed by a 6 and a 7, and then back to back dances. After the third dance, he went to 7 and then 5, so it might not be the ahistorical shocker if this year turns into a 3 or a 4 win season before he gets this new world sorted, learns to survive without James, and we start going back up.

Maybe we shouldn't be too quick to call for his head.

I've been miserable watching all of these home games, and I'll be complaining about the entire season I'm sure, but I'm willing to give him and his team time to right the ship. NIL support moving NU into at least the B1G average team salary doesn't seem like too much to ask and even without a big donor getting generous, the school makes enough money from conference revenue sharing to bump up its own contribution, and that should help. But he does have some work of his own to do.
If you’re losing at home by 20 to a team that literally doesn’t have NIL, I’m not sure you can say it’s too early to call for someone’s head.

I personally don’t think it’s time yet. But he’s won 12 conference games total in the last two years and it’s pretty clear he’s not adding many to that total this year. I don’t think that people saying “hey, enough of this let’s move on” are being unreasonable.

You could make a case (and I’m not saying this, but the internet has been so I’ll just throw it out there) that he’s a Boo merchant. He fell backwards into Boo and rode him to two NCAAT appearances… and outside of those years, his program has been a DISASTER for a decade. That’s the case people have made, and I am beginning to disagree with it less and less.
 
Aug 31, 2003
15,261
633
113
If you’re losing at home by 20 to a team that literally doesn’t have NIL, I’m not sure you can say it’s too early to call for someone’s head.

I personally don’t think it’s time yet. But he’s won 12 conference games total in the last two years and it’s pretty clear he’s not adding many to that total this year. I don’t think that people saying “hey, enough of this let’s move on” are being unreasonable.

You could make a case (and I’m not saying this, but the internet has been so I’ll just throw it out there) that he’s a Boo merchant. He fell backwards into Boo and rode him to two NCAAT appearances… and outside of those years, his program has been a DISASTER for a decade. That’s the case people have made, and I am beginning to disagree with it less and less.
He liked Boo and stuck with him and developed him. That's a success story and he deserves credit. But I also remember the Vassar ordeal when he tried to run him off the team. In the era of NIL, now he has a green light to do this with the entire roster.
 

SDakaGordie

Junior
Dec 29, 2016
2,626
305
73
If you’re losing at home by 20 to a team that literally doesn’t have NIL, I’m not sure you can say it’s too early to call for someone’s head.

I personally don’t think it’s time yet. But he’s won 12 conference games total in the last two years and it’s pretty clear he’s not adding many to that total this year. I don’t think that people saying “hey, enough of this let’s move on” are being unreasonable.

You could make a case (and I’m not saying this, but the internet has been so I’ll just throw it out there) that he’s a Boo merchant. He fell backwards into Boo and rode him to two NCAAT appearances… and outside of those years, his program has been a DISASTER for a decade. That’s the case people have made, and I am beginning to disagree with it less and less.
Internet BS of the highest order. A few years ago, we were two injuries away (Matt and Ty) from success we’ve never seen before. And are you forgetting Brooks and Matt as part of this “disaster”? Mart may be one of the greatest success stories ever. But the point of it all is - we don’t get brand name players very often if ever, we are never deep enough to withstand injuries, and yet Collins still made us very successful at times and always competitive (despite poorer records at times) save this year (likely due to NIL). Our ride at NU is bumpier than any other school for the reasons we all know - I vote to hold on (again) through the downs with someone who has proven he has the ups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hdhntr1

Catmandoo78

Junior
Nov 12, 2025
502
292
63
Internet BS of the highest order. A few years ago, we were two injuries away (Matt and Ty) from success we’ve never seen before. And are you forgetting Brooks and Matt as part of this “disaster”? Mart may be one of the greatest success stories ever. But the point of it all is - we don’t get brand name players very often if ever, we are never deep enough to withstand injuries, and yet Collins still made us very successful at times and always competitive (despite poorer records at times) save this year (likely due to NIL). Our ride at NU is bumpier than any other school for the reasons we all know - I vote to hold on (again) through the downs with someone who has proven he has the ups.
I’m not forgetting anything. I’m just conveying a narrative, one that I noted I disagree with.

That being said, at the end of the day, the record is what it is. We don’t get to put asterisks on a decade plus of history. And it’s really hard for me, and many fans, to waive away the down years. The years of relevance and competitiveness are really fun. But the dramatic backslides into below .500 overall and 5-15 in conference play are just brutal.

The lows are just SO low. That’s what concerns me. I have a hard time understanding how a good coach can bottom out so violently, with relative frequency.
 

Sec_112

Junior
Jun 17, 2001
6,636
255
83
Internet BS of the highest order. A few years ago, we were two injuries away (Matt and Ty) from success we’ve never seen before. And are you forgetting Brooks and Matt as part of this “disaster”? Mart may be one of the greatest success stories ever. But the point of it all is - we don’t get brand name players very often if ever, we are never deep enough to withstand injuries, and yet Collins still made us very successful at times and always competitive (despite poorer records at times) save this year (likely due to NIL). Our ride at NU is bumpier than any other school for the reasons we all know - I vote to hold on (again) through the downs with someone who has proven he has the ups.
I'm not sure Jackson should completely, positively, faithfully retain Collins, SD. Hopefully, there will be an open and honest post-season discussion between MJ and CC about what "went" wrong and whether both of them can adjust in the new world. CC isn't blameless in this whole thing. I wonder how much of a role his post-season meetings have in these departures. I wonder if he's an NIL-era type of guy. But none of us have a clue about those details.

And as I've said, NU is clearly not blameless either. Hopefully the two of them can agree on STRONG, IMPACTFUL changes. A tweak here and there is going to bring the same mediocre (and worse) results.

But I'm not sure this is the highest level of internet BS. I'm loving how Reid and Page are improving after every loss. Either people didn't watch last season or they're forgetting Reid's ole defense and Page's ongoing battles with his effort. Gee, with them, NU could've a .500 team. Whopee. No big loss.

But my personal favorite is the SCREAM for wholesale changes but not at the cost of how NU runs its athletics or the temptation to keep pace with NIL and be competitive. So just get another body and hope for the best despite the CLEAR dive since open NIL has begun. If that's not an old school NU mindset and 90% of the problem since the 60s, I don't know what is.
 

Sec_112

Junior
Jun 17, 2001
6,636
255
83
I’m not forgetting anything. I’m just conveying a narrative, one that I noted I disagree with.

That being said, at the end of the day, the record is what it is. We don’t get to put asterisks on a decade plus of history. And it’s really hard for me, and many fans, to waive away the down years. The years of relevance and competitiveness are really fun. But the dramatic backslides into below .500 overall and 5-15 in conference play are just brutal.

The lows are just SO low. That’s what concerns me. I have a hard time understanding how a good coach can bottom out so violently, with relative frequency.
I don't totally disagree with the issue that the lows are SO low. It's a reasonable point. But it's NU. And the asterisks are tourney invites. You can't highlight the losing seasons on one hand and just sweep away three NCAA tournaments on the other if you want to be objective.

But it's clear some people don't want that. P*ssing all over this guy after five games is just ridiculous. Yes, it's going to be a bad season. And catch me on the right day, and I can give you many more reasons than you see here why Chrissy has problems. But in the end, he's done his job and far more. He's been here 13 years!! He even stayed with Derrick Gragg who undercut him a few times. And with fan support like this - as we've seen this week - I give the guy a standing ovation for legging it out this long. He has more-than-earned a respectful evaluation.
 
Wildcat Report

Latest

  1. 01 Wildcat Report Northwestern embarrassed by Columbia, 75-53
  2. 02 Wildcat Report Notebook: Braun looks to snap three-game losing streak at Minnesota
  3. 03 Wildcat Report The 3-2-1 after Northwestern's loss to Ohio State
  4. 04 Wildcat Report Three Wildcat commits crack new Rivals300
  5. 05 Wildcat Report Recruit Roundup: WR Moseley scores three TDs, QB Phifer accounts for four