College basketball is really broken

Bluedog1

Senior
Jan 4, 2012
773
854
93
I do watch old Youtubes of Joe B`s teams as well as Sutton and Pitino`s. I also rewatch the the 2012 championship game and when we beat the cards in 12` in the final 4. I am not complaining, it is what it is. I love the Cats and cheer for them regardless. I have enjoyed watching all this young talent. I just wish the ones who have little chance in the league would stay more than one year. Its all good though their decision not mine.. their life and I do wish them all well.
 

billCgmx

All-American
Apr 9, 2015
3,060
6,725
0
Just wish the NBA would allow these kids to enter the NBA out of high school.. The NBA is using colleges as feeder systems to scout players for their league.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pygmy*Sasquatch

JesusCal91

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2019
2,665
1,991
0
The idea of being “loyal” to an institution that can make money off you when you can’t is so outdated. These kids owe us nothing. Be glad we have them for however long we do.

We owe them nothing either. I’m supposed to celebrate when some puke like Vanderbilt pulls the crap he did or anyone that scores 4 points in a game wants to leave after a year? Screw that
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Susan2361
Nov 27, 2009
21,246
21,450
0
College basketball continues to become a shell of its former self. Honestly, if winter wasn't so blah in this state and I lived somewhere warm with outdoor activities to do in the winter, I might not even take the time to watch any more. Love Cal and UK, but not the sport itself nearly as much as I used to. The shoe companies, the NCAA, ESPN, the NBA and the OAD rules have taken a big dump on college basketball.
 

mktmaker

All-Conference
Jun 5, 2001
3,967
2,423
0
There are a lot of good posts in this thread.

I agree with more than one side of this discussion.


I certainly am glad that the following players performed in Lexington...and did not go directly from high school to the NBA or G-League:

John Wall
DeMarcus Cousins
Brandon Knight
Anthony Davis
MKG
Julius Randle
Karl-Anthony Towns
Jamal Murray
Fox & Monk
...and several others

We knew that they were likely to go pro after one season...but I surely enjoyed watching them play -- in a Kentucky uniform.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CatfanMike47

billCgmx

All-American
Apr 9, 2015
3,060
6,725
0
We owe them nothing either. I’m supposed to celebrate when some puke like Vanderbilt pulls the crap he did or anyone that scores 4 points in a game wants to leave after a year? Screw that

I understand why you are frustrated. But if we are going to call ourselves a 'Players First' program and tell recruits that coming here will get you on the fast track to the NBA, then you can't be surprised when players leave early.

On the flip side of this, how many elite recruits have we landed because we offer freshmen an opportunity to display their skills and make it to the next level? If Cal isn't willing to change the way he recruits, then you have to take the good with the bad.
 

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
My folks would have been fine with me riding the pine on a scholarship and coming away with a four year degree even if I only played a minute a game and never scored a point.
Your folks might have been fine with you riding the pine but if you are a true athlete you want to be playing. I played college basketball and I sure never wanted to sit on the bench. I wanted to be in the game playing.
 

Jkwo_rivals113955

All-American
Apr 6, 2007
28,225
7,410
0
We owe them nothing either. I’m supposed to celebrate when some puke like Vanderbilt pulls the crap he did or anyone that scores 4 points in a game wants to leave after a year? Screw that
Okay, so nobody owes anybody anything. Fair. Now, for other people with which you have no connection or debt, do you call them "pukes" for exercising pre-arranged options which are spelled out in their contracts/agreements which don't involve you in the first place?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandy Eggo
Jan 9, 2007
15,353
13,412
0
We owe them nothing either. I’m supposed to celebrate when some puke like Vanderbilt pulls the crap he did or anyone that scores 4 points in a game wants to leave after a year? Screw that

Those cases are absolutely exceptions. The vast majority of one and doners we've had here have been productive players for us. Either way, if a kid decides to leave after a year and it's a bad decision so be it... Every one has the right to try and go get paid when they want to. It's America.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals

anon1763419335

All-American
Feb 10, 2006
23,231
5,077
113
so much hypocrisy and delusion in this thread. the same folks who rant on about they only care about the program and not the players are the same ones that get super pissed when a player makes a decision for himself.

so many people claiming to love the sport and what it used to me. just laughable. if you love the sport, it shouldnt matter who is in the jerseys or for how long. but of course it is not about that. the only interest some have in the sport is that its grounded in "amateurism". john wall, davis, KAT, fox, etc....only worth watching if they arent making money. its why so many dont watch the NBA they say. fast forward a couple of decades, the kids are finding out they have a voice and control and are leveraging it. going to the NBA, overseas, gleauge, transfer....they have options and are taking advantage of it.

and that is what people dont like. fans no longer feel like they have any control. they never really had it to begin with, but they felt like they did. these 19-20 year olds that are empowered to make decisions pisses people off.

college basketball has had plenty of opportunity to evolve and better itself. it chose not too. if players could make money of their likeliness, pocket 50k - 100k a year, someone like a herro might decide to stay a 2nd year and work to be a lottery pick. instead you get what you get now and with the new NBA rule in a few years, the drain of talent will cripple the sport, making it more niche than it already is.
 

Ky_Bred_Cat

All-Conference
Dec 28, 2014
2,201
4,090
113
It's amazing to me how few of you are willing to call out, or even seem to recognize, the NCAA for the fraud it is and that it is the problem with major college sports.

The NBA is a business. Everything it does, any move it makes, how it generates revenue, are all based on business realities. It's all about generating a return as it should be. Like the NBA or not, agree with their policies or not, they can't be faulted for operating with profit as the motive.

The NCAA does all the same things BUT is also forced to dishonestly promote itself as an amateur endeavor in order to maintain control of the enterprise. Without the amateur status facade, the NCAA looses control of their billion dollar business.

Just follow the money. Do you think the NCAA wants to loose the 1AD superstars straight to the NBA? Heck no they don't. Not when they can profit off them for a year first. The 1AD might go away at some point but it's not like the NCAA is in a hurry to correct that 'problem.' Do you think they care more that some fans don't like it? Um, no.

The problem with college basketball and why nothing makes sense is the perverted, dishonest system it's operating in, not the NBA. So many arguments about college basketball are circular and end where they start with no solution because the real issue is being left out - it's a lie! Everything makes more sense if you recognize this. The NCAA hopes and needs it's fans to keep their heads in the sand so they can continue on with the amateur status ruse.

What's next once the amateur status sham is finally over? It won't be the good ole days as they are long gone. It will be some for profit model where the best available players play as mercenaries for the strongest or most aggressive programs. Sound familiar?
 
Last edited:

billCgmx

All-American
Apr 9, 2015
3,060
6,725
0
I'm sure the NCAA doesn't want to lose these OAD stars but it's the NBA enforcing this rule to not allow high schoolers into the NBA. But what could the NCAA do if the NBA allows HS players to enter the draft. The NCAA can't force those players to attend college.

The NBA loves the OAD rule. It allows the NBA to use colleges as a feeder system to scout prospective players without NBA teams "wasting" picks on unknown high school talent.

But if anyone really wants to take the time to research this subject, you will see that it's the NBA Players Association who is real power behind the one-and-done rule and keeping high schoolers out of the NBA.
 

CB3UK

Hall of Famer
Apr 15, 2012
65,361
110,228
78
We owe them nothing either. I’m supposed to celebrate when some puke like Vanderbilt pulls the crap he did or anyone that scores 4 points in a game wants to leave after a year? Screw that
Thats my thing. This set up is a symbiotic relationship. Cal has sold the fans on this players first stuff and what's best for them and all that. Thats fine. Its their life, not mine. But Im not going to sit here and pretend this is anything othet rhan exactly what it is. A semi pro feeder waystop. If Cal were still at Memphis and doing this same system, theyd be there instead of here. It's that simple. The fact thay we have the resources and fan support we do makes it that much more appealing and that much easier a sell. But Im not going to pretend like I give a rip about the NBA fortunes. I dont. The NBA is miserable to watch. I care about watching college players play college ball for UK. That's it
 

JesusCal91

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2019
2,665
1,991
0
Thats my thing. This set up is a symbiotic relationship. Cal has sold the fans on this players first stuff and what's best for them and all that. Thats fine. Its their life, not mine. But Im not going to sit here and pretend this is anything othet rhan exactly what it is. A semi pro feeder waystop. If Cal were still at Memphis and doing this same system, theyd be there instead of here. It's that simple. The fact thay we have the resources and fan support we do makes it that much more appealing and that much easier a sell. But Im not going to pretend like I give a rip about the NBA fortunes. I dont. The NBA is miserable to watch. I care about watching college players play college ball for UK. That's it

I love cal and everything he’s done but too many of these kids are not getting the right advice or just not listening
 
  • Like
Reactions: CB3UK and KyFaninNC

CB3UK

Hall of Famer
Apr 15, 2012
65,361
110,228
78
I love cal and everything he’s done but too many of these kids are not getting the right advice or just not listening
Agreed. If they're happy in the G league or overseas, its absolutely their life. Only a handful have been ready to leave early and contribute in a big way. The rest absolutely benefit by staying and honing their skillset to maximize their stay in the NBA and maximizing their contracts and generational money making potential. No ones gonna convince me a lot of these guys wouldnt havr been better off staying. If its about the kids, then lets be real about what really benefits them. And frankly if youve lived in poverty forever, whats one more year for an even bigger and more sustained payday. Everyone wins yet its heresy to suggest it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

Bluedog1

Senior
Jan 4, 2012
773
854
93
You have to realize times have changed. Years ago players did not go to the NBA after 1 year in college and the NCAA was much more restrictive on transfers. The whole college basketball landscape has changed. If you want to go back to the old days then get out your VHS tapes and watch Rupp and Joe B Hall tapes.

I acknowledged that times have changed in my original post and that I do still enjoy watching all the young talent come in. I am not complaining just wishing the kids who dont need to be one and done come back and get better.. thats all i was saying..
 
  • Like
Reactions: kl40504_rivals

KentuckyCat420

Heisman
Sep 16, 2006
39,255
29,528
72
Any person claiming kids should be able to go straight to the NBA out of high school clearly don’t remember how broken things were when that was allowed.

Cal has said it before, there needs to be a combine where the NBA picks the 2-5 kids each year who will be drafted in the 1st round. Too many lives get ruined when every HS kid thinks there good enough to go pro and are allowed to do it.

One and done created a lot of problems but it is not worse than what it was before it. A happy medium needs to be found and it will take the NBA, NCAA, and High School basketball to put their heads together for it to ever happen. Therefore, it’ll never happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Susan2361

Harrelson55

Sophomore
Feb 1, 2017
109
154
0
The problem is alot of us so called fans. These players don't owe you anything. I cant stress this enough.

This goes out to all the people who get flustered when a kid shows off a new car or Brad Calipari not wearing a Kentucky jumpsuit on the bench.

Some of you have an unhealthy obsession and won't let these kids just enjoy themselves. Nobody should be angry about Keldon showing off his new car. That's selfish and stupid.

As for college basketball. It is deeply flawed. But the NCAA is crooked and backwards. It is what it is. Yet we continue to watch.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,602
7,295
113
Any person claiming kids should be able to go straight to the NBA out of high school clearly don’t remember how broken things were when that was allowed.

Cal has said it before, there needs to be a combine where the NBA picks the 2-5 kids each year who will be drafted in the 1st round. Too many lives get ruined when every HS kid thinks there good enough to go pro and are allowed to do it.

One and done created a lot of problems but it is not worse than what it was before it. A happy medium needs to be found and it will take the NBA, NCAA, and High School basketball to put their heads together for it to ever happen. Therefore, it’ll never happen.
How broken were they, when the VAST majority of kids drafted straight out of high school went on to be successful players?

The only thing that was broken was that the NBA had to calculate how much to gamble on potential, with less info available, which made for more draft volatility. But that's an NBA problem. The historical perspective is that they didn't gamble ENOUGH. Kevin Garnett went too low, Tracy McGrady went too low, Kobe Bryant went too low, Amare Stoudemire went too low, and so did at least 10-12 other guys I can name (which makes up almost half of the high school players selected from 95-05). The list of names of guys who went too high is way, way shorter.

Another mythology is "stay in school longer and set yourself up better for the NBA" . That's a big maybe. By my quick count, right around half of the players who made at least 10 million dollars this past year either played one year in college, or none at all. You're asking players to give up something that's right there in front of them for an abstraction that may or may not occur years in the future.

I actually agree that college basketball is broken, but I don't think there's any way to fix it without radically altering what it is.Until you do that, the gulf between 7 figure coach salaries, billion dollar TV contracts, and unpaid players is going to make college unappealing to almost every player with a sliver of pro potential.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
We owe them nothing either. I’m supposed to celebrate when some puke like Vanderbilt pulls the crap he did or anyone that scores 4 points in a game wants to leave after a year? Screw that


Hmm. I tend to agree to an extent but what? Vanderbilt literally sat most of his rookie season in the NBA due to injury. Was he just lying and making it all up lol?
 
Jul 11, 2007
2,406
777
0
You have to realize times have changed. Years ago players did not go to the NBA after 1 year in college and the NCAA was much more restrictive on transfers. The whole college basketball landscape has changed. If you want to go back to the old days then get out your VHS tapes and watch Rupp and Joe B Hall tapes.

You have to realize times have changed. Years ago players did not go to the NBA after 1 year in college and the NCAA was much more restrictive on transfers. The whole college basketball landscape has changed. If you want to go back to the old days then get out your VHS tapes and watch Rupp and Joe B Hall tapes.
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
You have to realize times have changed. Years ago players did not go to the NBA after 1 year in college and the NCAA was much more restrictive on transfers. The whole college basketball landscape has changed. If you want to go back to the old days then get out your VHS tapes and watch Rupp and Joe B Hall tapes.



Wut?
 
  • Like
Reactions: blubo

Susan2361

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2015
1,747
3,247
0
The problem is alot of us so called fans. These players don't owe you anything. I cant stress this enough.

This goes out to all the people who get flustered when a kid shows off a new car or Brad Calipari not wearing a Kentucky jumpsuit on the bench.

Some of you have an unhealthy obsession and won't let these kids just enjoy themselves. Nobody should be angry about Keldon showing off his new car. That's selfish and stupid.

As for college basketball. It is deeply flawed. But the NCAA is crooked and backwards. It is what it is. Yet we continue to watch.
I agree, to a point, but we don't owe them anything either. While they are here and in a KENTUCKY uniform, they DO owe us certain things. When they signed their LOI for KY, they I essence, signed a contract with the university to play for them and give their best. To some of these kids, a championship doesn't mean as much as prepping for the NBA. That's where I have a problem. This is not an NBA farm team or a prep school for the NBA. All I ask is for them to concentrate on UK while they are here and winning a title. I don't follow the NBA, so when they leave here, I don't keep track as much. I know this may sound harsh and I don't mean it to be, but I care about UK as a whole, NOT each individual player's life after college. I am not their parent. I don't know them. I DO wish the best for them. So they do owe us something while they are here. But you're correct in that they don't owe us anything after they leave. But we DON'T owe them anything either. They get a full scholarship which also includes the best training and medical care available in the free world, in return for their play for the University of Kentucky. Sorry to ramble, but I get tired of some posters saying they don't owe us anything. That's why I say it's partially true. And it's a two way street, in that we don't owe them anything either except maybe loyalty besides the things I have already listed above. But after they leave, we DON'T owe them just like they DON'T owe us. Simple.

GO CATS!!!!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: KFuqua

morgousky

Heisman
Sep 5, 2009
23,959
43,171
0
Okay, so nobody owes anybody anything. Fair. Now, for other people with which you have no connection or debt, do you call them "pukes" for exercising pre-arranged options which are spelled out in their contracts/agreements which don't involve you in the first place?

I’ve always thought the “owe them” conversation is bizarre. I mean in real life I’ve never heard it used, but here it’s used daily. Who says this, it’s not about owing someone anything. Players have a responsibility to perform to their best, fans have a responsibility to support them if they are. That’s about where that conversation ends.

It’s always been a strange comment to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Susan2361

Susan2361

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2015
1,747
3,247
0
I’ve always thought the “owe them” conversation is bizarre. I mean in real life I’ve never heard it used, but here it’s used daily. Who says this, it’s not about owing someone anything. Players have a responsibility to perform to their best, fans have a responsibility to support them if they are. That’s about where that conversation ends.

It’s always been a strange comment to me.
THANK YOU. I totally agree. I just made a long (sorry) comment above trying to explain in a weird way that I, in essence agree. If they don't "owe" us then we don't "owe" them. It comes down to they play and we support them while they're here. Period.
 

KentuckyFlyer

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2007
3,632
1,532
113
So isn’t it also selfishness for you wanting kids to stay and winning for your favorite team instead of maybe going out and those kids trying to make a better life for themselves?
I dont know that i call it selfish either way.. the kids and the colleges both receive great benefits. The kids get hyper exposure to the NBA allowing them to make millions one day in the future and the colleges collect huge monetary profits that comes from these high profile kids playing until they are READY. The all caps on the word READY is the problem. If the kids were truly READY I dont think anyone would have a problem with the present system. Did any one complain then AD went? or Wall or Bledso? or Jones? No, because they were truly ready, they and we knew it so the move made perfect sense. But now these guys are leaving and we all know they are not even close to ready. Thats the rub. So we complain and justifiably so in my opinion. The kids use the colleges to get to the NBA and thats fine, but we want titles too! and 80% of the players that are going to the NBA before they are ready could deliver those titles AND gain monetarily at the same time by improving their stock the following year. For every one kid that makes the jump susessfully 15 end up in Europe or the lesser leagues or not playing at all. If they stayed that second year they might have made in the NBA and we might have 12 titles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Susan2361

Jakarii

All-Conference
Jan 29, 2016
4,640
3,048
0
Hopefully they do. College basketball was supposed to be about the players but now it’s about everyone else first. Fans want it their way, coaches want it their way and all the athletes want us fairness. The brokenness is the fans and coaches and adults who are all greedy and really don’t care about the athletes only what the athletes can do for their pockets or for their team in a fans case. So yes the ncaa is broken but it’s because of the adults (fans coaches)


There is zero logical reason for not letting kids transfer us they made the wrong chose in schools just like a regular student is able to. And you can tell fans only care about themselves and not for what’s best for the athletes because they say nothing about regular students transferring schools!!!


It really is and somewhere down the line there is a missing track which will cause this whole thing to collapse.

If the NCAA ever allows a player to transfer without sitting out a year it will go total free agency. Add that to one and done and college basketball is finished.as we know it.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Milan Momcilovic plays the most minutes but has the smallest offensive role, according to KenPom
  2. 02 KSR Football KSR Staff Predictions: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kentucky has 'a long way to go as a team', but Mark Pope is seeing progress going into Indiana
  5. 05 KSR KSR Staff Predictions: Kentucky vs. Indiana