College basketball is really broken

TNCatfanforever

Heisman
Apr 3, 2003
22,080
13,960
62
I suppose this accounts for much of my frustration or “grumpiness” as the kids on here say. The one and done rule and now the transfers have ruined a lot of what was good about college basketball. Last year I think I read some place there were nearly 400 transfers. Is loyalty gone? Old men like me grew up when our freshman were not eligible but we loved our freshman teams as we knew what we had the next year. Kids stayed 4 years and they became our heroes. No we were not winning a title every year. I don’t really remember a title until 1978. I remember crying after the 66 title game. I remember the hurt after 75. Those guys became like family. Now they come for 10 months and are gone. Kids seem to be using Colleges and fans for their own selfish gains rather than loyalty. So for me if they use the school and fans and don’t deliver a title every so often there is frustration. They want fans to pay for autographs and buy their NBA jerseys but they have no loyalty. They announce one day at a time they are testing the waters only to showing off new cars. The cars are fine but don’t leave fans hanging for a week only to do that. I hope this makes a little sense. If not just ignore it.
 

TFCat11

Heisman
Mar 25, 2019
6,483
12,105
108
I suppose this accounts for much of my frustration or “grumpiness” as the kids on here say. The one and done rule and now the transfers have ruined a lot of what was good about college basketball. Last year I think I read some place there were nearly 400 transfers. Is loyalty gone? Old men like me grew up when our freshman were not eligible but we loved our freshman teams as we knew what we had the next year. Kids stayed 4 years and they became our heroes. No we were not winning a title every year. I don’t really remember a title until 1978. I remember crying after the 66 title game. I remember the hurt after 75. Those guys became like family. Now they come for 10 months and are gone. Kids seem to be using Colleges and fans for their own selfish gains rather than loyalty. So for me if they use the school and fans and don’t deliver a title every so often there is frustration. They want fans to pay for autographs and buy their NBA jerseys but they have no loyalty. They announce one day at a time they are testing the waters only to showing off new cars. The cars are fine but don’t leave fans hanging for a week only to do that. I hope this makes a little sense. If not just ignore it.
Well, it is a slow “news” night.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1704802562

jgodek

All-Conference
Jan 25, 2013
1,015
1,507
113
I don’t agree kids are using colleges. In fact, it’s the other way around when you look at the money these kids bring in...

It’s the NBA’s fault for forcing kids to be removed one year from high school before entering the draft. I believe NCAAF would be the same exact way if they didn’t force kids to stay 3 years before entering the draft.

And yes, to answer your question- loyalty is gone. Welcome to 2019.
 

irishcat1965

Heisman
Apr 22, 2012
21,867
47,107
113
So isn’t it also selfishness for you wanting kids to stay and winning for your favorite team instead of maybe going out and those kids trying to make a better life for themselves?
No because it’s all about him and living vicariously through the players. So when he isn’t happy, it’s Cal’s fault or the players’ fault.
 

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,728
87,931
113
Boy, the way Glenn Miller played. Songs that made the hit parade. Guys like us we had it made...Those were the days.

And we knew who we were then. Girls were girls and men were men. Mister we could use a man like Herbert Hoover again.

Didn't need no welfare state. Everybody pulled his weight. Gee, our old La Salle ran great.

Those were the days.
 

marshalfan

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2005
6,149
1,148
0
I don’t agree kids are using colleges. In fact, it’s the other way around when you look at the money these kids bring in...

It’s the NBA’s fault for forcing kids to be removed one year from high school before entering the draft. I believe NCAAF would be the same exact way if they didn’t force kids to stay 3 years before entering the draft.

And yes, to answer your question- loyalty is gone. Welcome to 2019.
The kids are using college basketball and the schools are using kids. My employer is using me and I am using my employer. No one is forcing the kids to go to school but it is there best option. They could go overseas and soon the G league will be an option. If the kids quit coming and choose the G league or go overseas the schools will have to up the ante, it is supply and demand. It is bothersome to me to hear that kids get nothing from the schools, tell that to someone that has to work at a menial job to work themselves through school or the person that comes out owing over $100,000
 
Last edited:

catman15

All-Conference
Mar 28, 2009
2,028
2,183
113
Well what were the people who were stuck in that system that didn't work out in their best interest supposed to do? It's like explaining Santa isn't real to kids around here with the 1 and done thing. I know you want it to be different but it isn't. People are welcome to their opinions but yall are beating a dead horse over and over every day on here waiting for him to nay
 

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
I suppose this accounts for much of my frustration or “grumpiness” as the kids on here say. The one and done rule and now the transfers have ruined a lot of what was good about college basketball. Last year I think I read some place there were nearly 400 transfers. Is loyalty gone? Old men like me grew up when our freshman were not eligible but we loved our freshman teams as we knew what we had the next year. Kids stayed 4 years and they became our heroes. No we were not winning a title every year. I don’t really remember a title until 1978. I remember crying after the 66 title game. I remember the hurt after 75. Those guys became like family. Now they come for 10 months and are gone. Kids seem to be using Colleges and fans for their own selfish gains rather than loyalty. So for me if they use the school and fans and don’t deliver a title every so often there is frustration. They want fans to pay for autographs and buy their NBA jerseys but they have no loyalty. They announce one day at a time they are testing the waters only to showing off new cars. The cars are fine but don’t leave fans hanging for a week only to do that. I hope this makes a little sense. If not just ignore it.
Most of the so called grumpiness you talk about comes from you and people like you. You have to realize times have changed. Years ago players did not go to the NBA after 1 year in college and the NCAA was much more restrictive on transfers. The whole college basketball landscape has changed. If you want to go back to the old days then get out your vhs tapes and watch Rupp and Joe B Hall tapes.
 

Glenn's Take

Heisman
May 20, 2012
13,081
15,428
113
The one thing a lot of you don't understand is that the good ole days are coming back. If the NBA ever makes the G League a true developmental league college basketball will be where college baseball is now. Anyone watched a college baseball game yet this year?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerMoving

TFCat11

Heisman
Mar 25, 2019
6,483
12,105
108
Boy, the way Glenn Miller played. Songs that made the hit parade. Guys like us we had it made...Those were the days.

And we knew who we were then. Girls were girls and men were men. Mister we could use a man like Herbert Hoover again.

Didn't need no welfare state. Everybody pulled his weight. Gee, our old La Salle ran great.

Those were the days.
Encore Encore!!
 

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
The one thing a lot of you don't understand is that the good ole days are coming back. If the NBA ever makes the G League a true developmental league college basketball will be where college baseball is now. Anyone watched a college baseball game yet this year?
Not there yet.
 

TNCatfanforever

Heisman
Apr 3, 2003
22,080
13,960
62
The one thing a lot of you don't understand is that the good ole days are coming back. If the NBA ever makes the G League a true developmental league college basketball will be where college baseball is now. Anyone watched a college baseball game yet this year?
College baseball is really good in the SEC except the Cats are struggling but they will be back. The state produces some really good baseball talent
 

Wildcatfan66

Heisman
Mar 27, 2007
9,938
12,668
113
I suppose this accounts for much of my frustration or “grumpiness” as the kids on here say. The one and done rule and now the transfers have ruined a lot of what was good about college basketball. Last year I think I read some place there were nearly 400 transfers. Is loyalty gone? Old men like me grew up when our freshman were not eligible but we loved our freshman teams as we knew what we had the next year. Kids stayed 4 years and they became our heroes. No we were not winning a title every year. I don’t really remember a title until 1978. I remember crying after the 66 title game. I remember the hurt after 75. Those guys became like family. Now they come for 10 months and are gone. Kids seem to be using Colleges and fans for their own selfish gains rather than loyalty. So for me if they use the school and fans and don’t deliver a title every so often there is frustration. They want fans to pay for autographs and buy their NBA jerseys but they have no loyalty. They announce one day at a time they are testing the waters only to showing off new cars. The cars are fine but don’t leave fans hanging for a week only to do that. I hope this makes a little sense. If not just ignore it.
Well stated - good post.
 

kybassfan

Heisman
Jul 1, 2005
20,032
16,368
113
I suppose this accounts for much of my frustration or “grumpiness” as the kids on here say. The one and done rule and now the transfers have ruined a lot of what was good about college basketball. Last year I think I read some place there were nearly 400 transfers. Is loyalty gone? Old men like me grew up when our freshman were not eligible but we loved our freshman teams as we knew what we had the next year. Kids stayed 4 years and they became our heroes. No we were not winning a title every year. I don’t really remember a title until 1978. I remember crying after the 66 title game. I remember the hurt after 75. Those guys became like family. Now they come for 10 months and are gone. Kids seem to be using Colleges and fans for their own selfish gains rather than loyalty. So for me if they use the school and fans and don’t deliver a title every so often there is frustration. They want fans to pay for autographs and buy their NBA jerseys but they have no loyalty. They announce one day at a time they are testing the waters only to showing off new cars. The cars are fine but don’t leave fans hanging for a week only to do that. I hope this makes a little sense. If not just ignore it.

Don’t mean to be a smart *** but welcome to 2019. There is no loyalty anywhere. Not to the work place, family, friends. It’s society these days. The amazing thing would be if they were loyal. To expect loyalty to a fan base with a small but very annoying, disgruntled and ungrateful segment versus the lure of the NBA, to expect loyalty is laughable. Add common sense to the equation, the money will win every time.

We have people wailing over the fact that the sun came up.
 

TFCat11

Heisman
Mar 25, 2019
6,483
12,105
108
Don’t mean to be a smart *** but welcome to 2019. There is no loyalty anywhere. Not to the work place, family, friends. It’s society these days. The amazing thing would be if they were loyal. To expect loyalty to a fan base with a small but very annoying, disgruntled and ungrateful segment versus the lure of the NBA, to expect loyalty is laughable. Add common sense to the equation, the money will win every time.

We have people wailing over the fact that the sun came up.
Indeed! Welcome to the machine, 2019, A Basketball Oddity.
 

MakinMusic_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 21, 2006
10,725
3,613
66
Don’t blame college basketball. It’s business. It’s the NBA. It’s the culture we created over the past 30 years. There is no corporate loyalty any longer. No one stays at a company like they did many years ago. It’s just the way it is. It’s better for the average person, these kids. I don’t blame them at all. It’s where we are in the world. They would be foolish not to take the money and run. College educations are not what they were 20 years ago. The entrepreneurial landscape has changed so many things.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
Players don't owe the college **** for as much money as they bring in to their school as well as name recognition. Would you even know a school like Wichita State even existed if it wasn't for their basketball team, for example? Do you even know Boise State exists if not for their football team? I sure as hell very likely don't for either. Hell, I've lived in Virginia my entire life and wouldn't know the names of most of the schools I know of within the state if it weren't for sports.

Not only do these teams bring in income, but successful basketball (and football) teams drive admissions and market the school, giving them marketing opportunities that wouldn't otherwise exist. And it also helps reduce the costs of admissions recruiting efforts. Every app they get from someone that applies because the football or basketball team just had an amazing year is one app they don't have to recruit to get. And recruiting a new student is a heck of a lot more expensive than it is to retain a current student.

You know how nearly every game on ESPN has an advertisement run for the school at least once each game? The schools get that ad time free of charge. Name me a single other instance where they going to be able to advertise their school from hundreds of thousands to millions of people at zero cost.
 
Last edited:

CB3UK

Hall of Famer
Apr 15, 2012
65,361
110,228
78
The one thing a lot of you don't understand is that the good ole days are coming back. If the NBA ever makes the G League a true developmental league college basketball will be where college baseball is now. Anyone watched a college baseball game yet this year?
Yes. Two nights ago. We played Louisville.

You bandwagon basketball only fans dont speak for most of the fan base.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blubo

Glenn's Take

Heisman
May 20, 2012
13,081
15,428
113
Yes. Two nights ago. We played Louisville.

You bandwagon basketball only fans dont speak for most of the fan base.
All I'm saying is that I bet you are in the minority on that even on this message board, much less fans across the country. I was revering to how relevant the sport will be. Just like I said elsewhere about boxing. It used to be huge and now it isn't at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

marshalfan

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2005
6,149
1,148
0
That's a strawman argument because no one (worth listening to) is saying that kids receive literally nothing.
You basically picked out a very small point in post. The bottom line the players know basically what they are signing up for and they do have other options. I agree the major stars are not getting a good deal. College sports were originally started for students that also wanted to play a sport. It has become that the sport is the only reason some are attending college.
 
Last edited:

Susan2361

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2015
1,747
3,247
0
You're right...the players don't owe us anything.. But on the flip side we don't owe them anything either.I don't like the NBA and I don't follow it. So once these players leave UK, I forget about them. I wish them well, but they are not KY anymore. The are Celtics ,Suns, etc. They don't wear blue, they wear orange, green, etc. They use KY for a year, and we use them for entertainment for a year. So yeah, the loyalty, or lack of, goes both ways.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blubo and KyFaninNC

kl40504_rivals

Heisman
Oct 5, 2018
15,258
11,184
0
You're right...the players don't owe us anything.. But on the flip side we don't owe them anything either.I don't like the NBA and I don't follow it. So once these players leave UK, I forget about them. I wish them well, but they are not KY anymore. The are Celtics ,Suns, etc. They do t wear ue, they wear orange, green, etc. So yeah, the loyalty, or lack of, goes both ways.
If they stayed 4 years how would you feel. Based on what you said they would still be dead to you once they went to the NBA. I guess once any player leaves Kentucky you have no more use for them. Nice take.
 

Susan2361

All-Conference
Apr 22, 2015
1,747
3,247
0
If they stayed 4 years how would you feel. Based on what you said they would still be dead to you once they went to the NBA. I guess once any player leaves Kentucky you have no more use for them. Nice take.
I didn't say they would be dead to me. I just said I don't like or watch the NBA so I wouldn't be following their careers as close. Big difference. And with the four year players, you get to know them a little bit. That's another difference than those who come here for a few months. Like someone else said, when they are here just a few months, I barely have time to learn their numbers. So it's not just me. Just a question...how many of these kids that are here a few months, come back and support UK? There are a few, yes. But some of you act like we the fans owe them everything for coming to UK and playing for a few months but we cant expect anything from them.
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,184
21,143
103
So isn’t it also selfishness for you wanting kids to stay and winning for your favorite team instead of maybe going out and those kids trying to make a better life for themselves?

So how were things different before jumping to the league as an 18 or 19 year old became the thing to do. A “better life” has always been there yet it was rare for a player to leave college or skip college all together. MJ played college for 3 years.

Where does the line get drawn? Pretty soon the fawning will trickle down to the 16 year old phenoms. Why should they “risk” two more years of playing high school ball when they could be making a better life for themselves. Seems unfathomable now perhaps but so did players skipping college completely for the longest time.
 

ruppcat

All-American
Jan 1, 2003
3,698
5,185
0
The kids are using college basketball and the schools are using kids. My employer is using me and I am using my employer. No one is forcing the kids to go to school but it is there best option. They could go overseas and soon the G league will be an option. If the kids quit coming and choose the G league or go overseas the schools will have to up the ante, it is supply and demand. It is bothersome to me to hear that kids get nothing from the schools, tell that to someone that has to work at a menial job to work themselves through school or the person that comes out owing over $100,000
My folks would have been fine with me riding the pine on a scholarship and coming away with a four year degree even if I only played a minute a game and never scored a point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blubo

BIGBLUE402

Senior
Jan 1, 2011
6,931
737
0
So how were things different before jumping to the league as an 18 or 19 year old became the thing to do. A “better life” has always been there yet it was rare for a player to leave college or skip college all together. MJ played college for 3 years.

Where does the line get drawn? Pretty soon the fawning will trickle down to the 16 year old phenoms. Why should they “risk” two more years of playing high school ball when they could be making a better life for themselves. Seems unfathomable now perhaps but so did players skipping college completely for the longest time.

It changed when the NBA started drafting on potential instead of results. If the NBA was drafting Like they do now back then I’m sure the players would leave early then too. Or some would stay because the money wasn’t as good then as it is now.

So if the NBA ever starts drafting kids as sixteen years old I’m sure it would start the trend of players leaving for the NBA then
 
  • Like
Reactions: jackcarlson

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
If they stayed 4 years how would you feel. Based on what you said they would still be dead to you once they went to the NBA. I guess once any player leaves Kentucky you have no more use for them. Nice take.
What is wrong with that? I am a fan of UK,not the player. Once they leave UK, I do not follow them are care about what they do, I wish them well in life.
 

Cats_2010

Heisman
Jan 8, 2010
12,184
21,143
103
It changed when the NBA started drafting on potential instead of results. If the NBA was drafting Like they do now back then I’m sure the players would leave early then too. Or some would stay because the money wasn’t as good then as it is now.

So if the NBA ever starts drafting kids as sixteen years old I’m sure it would start the trend of players leaving for the NBA then

I completely understand that which is why I despise the NBA. It use to be a professional basketball league now anyone who can jump and dribble can be drafted and paid and see if they pan out. Certainly don’t blame the kids at all but I’m done with the NBA for what they have done to college basketball.
 

John Henry

Hall of Famer
Aug 18, 2007
35,574
172,795
113
The one thing a lot of you don't understand is that the good ole days are coming back. If the NBA ever makes the G League a true developmental league college basketball will be where college baseball is now. Anyone watched a college baseball game yet this year?
The more I think about this the more I like the idea of a strong G League. We can weed out a lot of corruption and cheating. What school would cheat for a third class ball player? All great things come to an end. (Where have you gone Joe DiMaggio) College basketball has changed and is never going back. So we move on.

It is obvious a player should take the millions and leave early. All of us would advise our son to take the money. We understand that but if you are paying $5,000 a year for season tickets you would like to have a little stability in your program. But that is not possible now so if players would rather play for pay in a NBA farm system go for it. As it stands right now UK is nothing more than an NBA feeder system. That is who we are and the system is the reason. So let the top players go pro out of high school and maybe Kentucky can land one of those G League teams. We all would win because fans who are in favor of one and done have teams to follow and those of us who like college basketball can watch our school play. Probably at a reduced cost. The players may not be as good as we like but if we win games who cares? They are amateurs. And they would stay more than one year.

Winners all.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Basketball Milan Momcilovic plays the most minutes but has the smallest offensive role, according to KenPom
  2. 02 KSR Football KSR Staff Predictions: No. 16 Kentucky at Missouri
  3. 03 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Kentucky has 'a long way to go as a team', but Mark Pope is seeing progress going into Indiana
  5. 05 KSR KSR Staff Predictions: Kentucky vs. Indiana