Let's say Lebby is let go at some point this season. Who would you rather have as a HC? Brian Kelly or Kalen Deboer if bama fires him for going 8-4 or 9-3?
I say Deboer
I say Deboer
Coaching carousel hypothetical
- Thread starter civildawg88
- Start date
A better question would be would you rather have Brian Kelly’s defensive coordinator or Kalen Deboer’s wide receivers coach?
Obviously either would be a huge upgrade over Lebby, but DeBoer has the better resume without the "baggage"
Best of both worlds: we hire DeBoer’s wide receivers coach as our defensive coordinator.
If DeBoer is fired by Bama then there's a good chance he lost to Miss State and Lebby saved his job. Just saying.
I'd honestly rather we win some games this year and Lebby turns out to be a good offensive coach who is learning from past mistakes so he finally hired a good defensive coach and finally learned how to recruit offensive linemen who can work in this league, so he can stay and be successful here.
That would be much preferable and easier than hiring one of those retreads who hasn't been super successful recently. I know Deboer made the playoff, but ask any Bama fan and they think they're going in the wrong direction. Not sure how that translates to success in STK.
That would be much preferable and easier than hiring one of those retreads who hasn't been super successful recently. I know Deboer made the playoff, but ask any Bama fan and they think they're going in the wrong direction. Not sure how that translates to success in STK.
Uh I'd take Deboer who has won largely at every stop he's made at every level except at the place that skimped on NIL because they thought they could get by on simply being Bama over the guy who underachieved everywhere while generally being very unlikeable.
Edit to add: Plus I would rather avoid having Brian Kelly, whose recklessness killed a student videographer, anywhere near our program. That's a stink that hasn't washed off.
Last edited:
If DeBoer goes 8-4 at bama, he is bad and would probably do worse than Lebby here.
Reminds me of Jimbo Fisher. Everyone was begging us to go get him, but if you can't win at A&M with all the resources in the world, what the 17 can you do here? It seems so obvious to me.
It's maybe a little early to call it with Deboer at Bama, he may turn it around this year, but I'll have to see it.
Worse than Lebby may be a stretch, but yeah. As much as I hate Brian Kelly, I'd take him in a minute if he'd come here.
Yea but what accent would he adopt. There is a distinct difference between let’s say a Itawamba or a Tishomingo county accent than a Noxubee county or a Webster county accent.
the thought of saying B.Kelly (just typing it) makes me want to vomit.
I would have said DeBoer.....but legitimate point, if he can only do 8-4 @ Bama, he may not be a better option than Lebby
All that to say, I'm pulling for Lebby, and think he gets some traction this year
I would have said DeBoer.....but legitimate point, if he can only do 8-4 @ Bama, he may not be a better option than Lebby
All that to say, I'm pulling for Lebby, and think he gets some traction this year
I'm not even sure Saban could attract all the players he did in the current days of pay for play. They don't have unlimited money.
I would say Deboer also but tho Kelly couldn't seem to figure it out at LSU a coach with a .725 winning percentage is not too shabby. It would be a miracle if either wound up here. Naturally the vast majority of the posters here would be preschitting Kelly before ever made it to campus.
that's why saban retired. He knew bama's days of glory were coming to an end now that everyone could pay their players and bama doesn't have the uber rich alumni like others.
Bull. It had a lot more to do with him being 71 years old than anything else.
My concern with both would be a matter of hunger. Just don't want another coach collecting a check.
DeBoer.
He'd be willing to coach at State if the price is right, just to get a shot at beating Bama.
He'd be willing to coach at State if the price is right, just to get a shot at beating Bama.
I would take a coach who is confident(see arrogant) enough to know he can win at Mississippi State. And by win, I mean consistently 8-4 with the occasional 9-3 and rare 10-2 but even more rare 6-6. Give me that and I’ll be back to buying season tickets and maybe even giving $25 per month to The Excellence Fund!
Mississippi State fans love big name coaches. I'm going to go out on a limb and say our next head coach will be a name 50-60% of the posters here and 95% of the fan base has never heard of.
I wouldn't discount Jimbo Fisher's name coming up in coaching searches in December. He's recently made it abundantly clear that he wants back in the game.
I don't see the appeal for DeBoer, maybe I'm overlooking something but he doesn't impress me
fair enough, maybe I'm just tainted by the 20-8 at Bama. Success at most schools but will have him on the Hot Seat in Tuscaloosa.
Brian Kelly is a wash. The last thing that I want to hear is a fake mississippi accent talking about how he loves fried catfish and deer hunting.
Candle would be on my short list and whatever coach takes their G6 team to the playoffs. I know some G6 coaches names will come along during the season. I would love for Lebby to figure it out and win 7 or 8 games this year and remain our head coach.
Why in the world would that happen? Haven't you heard, Pete Golding is better than Kiffin anyway.