Charles Barkley's view on One and Done

JCBU_246

Heisman
Apr 18, 2020
10,813
28,714
113
The article was 2 years old, but he resonated with what a lot of us feel

“I would make some of these kids stay in school for two years because I think we defeat the purpose of the NBA draft,” he told The Athletic. “The way the draft is designed is for bad teams to get some help. I would make it mandatory to stay in school for two years because I think it makes a big difference.”
 

JCBU_246

Heisman
Apr 18, 2020
10,813
28,714
113
I’ve always though the NBA adopting the MLB rule would be best. Let the kids who want to go to the NBA, go. Those that go to college then have 3 years before they can enter.
I agree, and it would definitely revive the sport if the NBA adopted it, but what do we know? Not like we're their revenue 🤷‍♂️
 

CHAPDAV3

Junior
Dec 31, 2007
320
284
0
it would revive the sport.
Man it sounds great. But basketball is so much smaller than baseball. In terms of rosters. It will be hard to tell a kid these days. If you go straight to the NBA. You have no commitment the Ncaa. Than tell all the others you will have to stay 3 years in school. Baseball can get away with it because of just the volume of players. Hard to come in and take a vet's spot on a team. I could see 2 years. But 3 in a game were you have a small window to cash in. Man kids these days will fight that. Or just go elsewhere for a year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

kyjeff1

Heisman
Sep 8, 2012
52,125
73,712
113
The NBA is making the rules and they don't give a **** about college basketball. That's the problem.
They set the rules based on what is best for them and since they have a developmental league with zero restrictions, college basketball gets the shaft.
Our problem is, we have a coach that caters to it, he gets off on it and UK pays the price for it.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,943
63,131
113
I never quite understood why the NBA keeps a rule around that totally guts College Ball (their main feeder system). What, is getting Anthony Davis and Zion after 2 years instead of 1 that big of a deal? You'd think the NBA, being comprised of hundreds of personnel and players who had ties to the college game at one point, would at least try to help preserve the sport, and not totally strip it down just to get some guy's a year early.

Don't see why a 2AD rule wouldn't still work for all parties, even if we let kids go from HS.
 
Last edited:

rick64

Heisman
Jan 25, 2007
25,423
35,853
113
Until the NBA changes the age requirements, we're stuck with the current situation.

Cal encourages all his players to go through the process to get feedback and information on where they stand. Then they can make a decision hopefully consulting with him and their family. So if they're not pretty confident they'll go in the 1st round and choose to go anyway, then Cal supports that decision and does whatever he can to help. I think sometimes though the player listens to his hangers on and family more than Cal, and leave too early.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1629204751

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
30,647
74,129
113
I never quite understood why the NBA keeps a rule around that totally guts College Ball (their main feeder system). What, is getting Anthony Davis and Zion after 2 years instead of 1 that big of a deal? You'd think the NBA, being comprised of hundreds of personal and players who had ties to the college game at one point, would at least try to help preserve the sport, and not totally strip it down just to get some guy's a year early.

Don't see why a 2AD rule wouldn't still work for all parties, even if we let kids go from HS.
the nba has made college its own personal minor leauge. **** the NBA and **** Chromedome silver
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
look at the level of power players have in the NBA

you'd think as a player in the NBA, the last thing you'd want is more competition each year for your job

but they have done nothing to slow it down and many players actively support a player coming out of high school into the league.

I guess they don't think that kid will ever be as good as they are as a pro.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,943
63,131
113
You'd also think the 30 NBA teams are tired of rolling the dice on some of these 1-year players.

Boston is likely going to screw some team over if he goes 14th.. or, the other side of it, he could fall the Celtics at say 40th, turn into a star, and it will be a steal. Neither of those are really ideal when you're trying to create a competitive landscape. Boston with a 2nd year would really tell us who he is.
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,943
63,131
113
the nba has made college its own personal minor leauge. **** the NBA and **** Chromedome silver

I don't like Silver's political pandering. But he's been unquestionably a great commish for the NBA, and almost no argument can be made for any of the other major commissioners to be ahead of him. But he's got some choice to make next year. Tell the players to "shut it and play" or let them keep protesting and and wearing special jerseys (the latter already seemingly nixed).
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football SEC Availability Report: What to know about Thursday's update
  2. 02 KSR Football Chops Comes Home: The Man Behind the Meme
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball After scoring 5k+ points in high school, Maddyn Greenway is learning a new role at Kentucky
  4. 04 KSR Podcasts 11 Personnel: Tricky Spots for CFP Teams
  5. 05 On3 Basketball LSU President says he has instructed Will Wade to not play RJ Luis