Casey Thompson

Dicky Broseph

All-American
Dec 18, 2018
4,057
7,491
113
The kid puts up FCS numbers better than our QBs HIGH SCHOOL numbers and people want to second guess him.
 

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,506
20,868
113
Naw, I made a kind of "meh" comment about him and was met with a flurry of outraged posts. There was a whole thread about how great he is because some list somewhere had him rated as a top 5 qb transfer.

You have made a negative comment about every single player mentioned, only to see most land at big time programs. As for the Akron kid, I don’t recall the outrage you are talking about, feel free to share. I do think he would have been a nice second QB (like Purdy) if we take two.
 

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,506
20,868
113
The kid puts up FCS numbers better than our QBs HIGH SCHOOL numbers and people want to second guess him.

There are a couple on this board that are going to trash any and every possible recruit, Coach, etc. Just to take that with a grain of salt. Ward is super talented and would be a great get, but it doesn’t seem like we are in the running for him right now.
 

Dicky Broseph

All-American
Dec 18, 2018
4,057
7,491
113
That is about the dumbest comparison you can make
We are talking about level of competition, he is putting up madden numbers at the collegiate level at a young age . Our prospective qbs don’t have better HS tape than the tape he put together up against far greater competition smart guy.
 

Tjlskers526

Sophomore
Aug 23, 2021
890
155
43
We are talking about level of competition, he is putting up madden numbers at the collegiate level at a young age . Our prospective qbs don’t have better HS tape than the tape he put together up against far greater competition smart guy.
Well you can bookmark this if you want and show me how well he does against real competition. Either way.. he isn't coming to Nebraska... The FCS has guys put up Madden numbers every season this is nothing new and I can bet none of you know who any of them are and none of you know who any of the previous seasons FCS QB studs are either.. Only reason everyone is drooling over him now is because he's in the portal
 
Aug 18, 2016
16,626
10,902
113
Well you can bookmark this if you want and show me how well he does against real competition. Either way.. he isn't coming to Nebraska... The FCS has guys put up Madden numbers every season this is nothing new and I can bet none of you know who any of them are and none of you know who any of the previous seasons FCS QB studs are either.. Only reason everyone is drooling over him now is because he's in the portal
Who are the FCS QBs that transferred to P5 schools that didn’t put up good numbers? It is like trying to prove a hypothetical.

of course the reason he is in the discussions is because he is in the portal. The discussions mostly center on transfer QBs, it wouldn’t make a ton of sense to talk about QBs that aren’t transferring at all.
 

oldjar07

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2009
9,458
2,000
113
Dude was 5-7 against a schedule much kinder than NU’s. He is highly likely to not be an upgrade from Martinez. And is far from a lock to start over Smothers, should he transfer.
Texas's defense was absolute *** for much of the season, so can't blame the qb for that. Casey Thompson would be a huge get and upgrade from Martinez.
 

Tjlskers526

Sophomore
Aug 23, 2021
890
155
43
Who are the FCS QBs that transferred to P5 schools that didn’t put up good numbers? It is like trying to prove a hypothetical.

of course the reason he is in the discussions is because he is in the portal. The discussions mostly center on transfer QBs, it wouldn’t make a ton of sense to talk about QBs that aren’t transferring at all.
There hasn't been any that I can find or think of..... And obviously that is why he is in the discussion, but to say he is the best choice because he performed well in the FCS (when it happens every year), then try to compare his stats against someone's high school stats.

Just not sold on the hype is all.. But it won't really matter because he isn't coming here
 

tpmcg_rivals137159

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2002
10,437
1,024
0
with our recent history of looking off talent, this crowd can sure affirm that by looking gift horses in the mouth.
Thompson would be a great get.
Purdy, too.
I’d take the Glantz kid, too.
we gotta get off the mat, folks!
 

NikkiSixx_rivals269993

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2013
9,783
2,445
0
It's amazing, after four years of hell with AM, plus another losing year with Tanner Lee, to make it 5 straight losing years with 50% or worse winning QB's, the audience here is salivating at the bit to bring in another 50% winning QB, full of excuses, injuries, and more ifs and buts.

For a position that is so important to the success of the team, I think it would be real prudent for Whipple to do his due diligence here..

None of us have been able to really evaluate him, but I'm looking for a change, another direction, not to jump into year 6 to run a similar (50% winner QB) playbook again.
 
Last edited:

beaglehusker

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2006
13,178
3,891
0
It's amazing, after four years of hell with AM, plus another losing year with Tanner Lee, to make it 5 straight losing years with 50% or worse winning QB's, the audience here is salivating at the bit to bring in another 50% winning QB, full of excuses, injuries, and more ifs and buts.

For a position that is so important to the success of the team, I think it would be real prudent for Whipple to do his due diligence here..

None of us have been able to really evaluate him, but I'm looking for a change, another direction, not to jump into year 6 to run a similar (50% winner QB) playbook again.
I get your argument, really I do, but seriously you can't base your argument soley on an FCS win record. None of us know the competitive nature of any of the three. You have to be able to look at things objectively, not just win loss record.
 

timnsun

All-American
Jan 25, 2008
13,815
7,519
3
It's amazing, after four years of hell with AM, plus another losing year with Tanner Lee, to make it 5 straight losing years with 50% or worse winning QB's, the audience here is salivating at the bit to bring in another 50% winning QB, full of excuses, injuries, and more ifs and buts.

For a position that is so important to the success of the team, I think it would be real prudent for Whipple to do his due diligence here..

None of us have been able to really evaluate him, but I'm looking for a change, another direction, not to jump into year 6 to run a similar (50% winner QB) playbook again.
So if whipple brings in one of these QBs, does that mean he didn’t do his due diligence?
 

NikkiSixx_rivals269993

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2013
9,783
2,445
0
So if whipple brings in one of these QBs, does that mean he didn’t do his due diligence?
I'm just saying I hope he does his homework and Scott keeps his nose out of things. I trust Whipple quite a lot based off what he said in his press conference. He goes by 'feel', or intuition about the right guy. I don't have confidence that Scott won't over ride him though.
 

timnsun

All-American
Jan 25, 2008
13,815
7,519
3
I'm just saying I hope he does his homework and Scott keeps his nose out of things. I trust Whipple quite a lot based off what he said in his press conference. He goes by 'feel', or intuition about the right guy. I don't have confidence that Scott won't over ride him though.
Thanks for clarifying. I know Scott is the head coach, but Whipple has been coaching since Scott was in diapers. I am hoping that would carry some weight. Time will tell.
 

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,506
20,868
113
A QB who wins 50% of his games would be a massive improvement.

That whole premise is so stupid. Like bad QB’s like Mertz and Petras are somehow better than a guy like Taulia because they play for teams with good defenses and special teams. Their teams win in spite of them and we are supposed to think they are winners. Yet there are some QB’s who win less but are much better players who’s teams would never win without them.
 

Baxter48_rivals204143

All-Conference
Sep 22, 2010
8,892
2,089
0
There are a couple on this board that are going to trash any and every possible recruit, Coach, etc. Just to take that with a grain of salt. Ward is super talented and would be a great get, but it doesn’t seem like we are in the running for him right now.
Like antirowyourboat
 

artguy68

Junior
Nov 3, 2008
1,722
328
0
You have made a negative comment about every single player mentioned, only to see most land at big time programs. As for the Akron kid, I don’t recall the outrage you are talking about, feel free to share. I do think he would have been a nice second QB (like Purdy) if we take two.
Sorry, you are thinking of someone else. I haven't commented on any transfers except the Akron kid, Purdy in this thread, and Thompson, who I just said would be the best fit, which is not negative. Apology accepted.
 

antirowboat

Redshirt
Jan 30, 2021
1,938
13
0

Only an idiot would complain about Nebraska getting one of the better QB's in college football out of the transfer portal. Go to ESPN and go through the top 40 rated QB's by QBR and Thompson is one of the better ones. Led the Big 12 in passing touchdowns this season.
 
Sep 29, 2001
75,439
12,977
0
I'm content to let the new QB whiz Whipple figure it all out. I would think he knows a little more about evaluating a QB than most armchair coaches here on RSS. :)
 

Redblood23

All-Conference
Jan 17, 2004
5,702
1,995
113
Lol @ those acting like CT is an elite QB, he's average at best. I mean nothing against the kid but pump your breaks on the hype. The thing is that you have to look at how he's going to fit within the scheme Frost/Whipple comes up with but he's definitely not Pickett in any sense of the word.
 

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,506
20,868
113
Lol @ those acting like CT is an elite QB, he's average at best. I mean nothing against the kid but pump your breaks on the hype. The thing is that you have to look at how he's going to fit within the scheme Frost/Whipple comes up with but he's definitely not Pickett in any sense of the word.

Average at best? You have to be kidding. The kid led the Big 12 in passing TD’s and did it playing through injury. He is a very good QB any possible way you slice it.
 

Husker_12

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2001
1,742
1,308
113
Lol @ those acting like CT is an elite QB, he's average at best. I mean nothing against the kid but pump your breaks on the hype. The thing is that you have to look at how he's going to fit within the scheme Frost/Whipple comes up with but he's definitely not Pickett in any sense of the word.
Average QB's don't throw 29 td's and 9 int's...average would be the young inexperienced QB's currently on the roster. Good luck keeping your job with Smothers/HH. If we get him that means Whipple has vetted him, let him develop and game plan around his skill set. The kid can play.
 
Last edited:

JOHNNY N

Heisman
Sep 24, 2003
109,994
39,220
0
Lol @ those acting like CT is an elite QB, he's average at best. I mean nothing against the kid but pump your breaks on the hype. The thing is that you have to look at how he's going to fit within the scheme Frost/Whipple comes up with but he's definitely not Pickett in any sense of the word.
He is much better than average. That's just a terrible take. Lofl.
 

NebChicago

Sophomore
Oct 14, 2009
3,565
141
0
There are 8 starting QBs in he NFL right now that did not play football for a P5 team. That is 1/4th of the entire league.
1. Wentz
Lol @ those acting like CT is an elite QB, he's average at best. I mean nothing against the kid but pump your breaks on the hype. The thing is that you have to look at how he's going to fit within the scheme Frost/Whipple comes up with but he's definitely not Pickett in any sense of the word.
how many elite qbs are in the portal?
 

Headcard

Heisman
Feb 2, 2005
192,506
20,868
113
After seeing how noncommittal Williams was last night about staying at OU, I wonder if Thompson is waiting on that situation and hoping to end up at OU if Williams bails.
 

BHeinDaHuskers

All-American
Oct 12, 2004
27,309
8,667
113
After seeing how noncommittal Williams was last night about staying at OU, I wonder if Thompson is waiting on that situation and hoping to end up at OU if Williams bails.
I think you are right, I think OU might be a wild card in this, but seeing TOS giving the crystal ball to Nebraska makes me feel better.
 

Husker88

Senior
Dec 9, 2017
2,187
425
83
Solid showing for our B10 brethren thus far.

Purdue/Tenn both want to be there and win this game.
 
Jun 16, 2004
3,113
824
113
I'd be ecstatic to add a 3 TD to 1 INT qb to the roster with experience in a power 5 conference. Absolutely ecstatic.
 

NikkiSixx_rivals269993

All-Conference
Sep 14, 2013
9,783
2,445
0
Lol @ those acting like CT is an elite QB, he's average at best. I mean nothing against the kid but pump your breaks on the hype. The thing is that you have to look at how he's going to fit within the scheme Frost/Whipple comes up with but he's definitely not Pickett in any sense of the word.
don't listen to the morons.. they are the same ones that told you there was no way Eichost was running the program through Riley, and also the same ones chest thumping about how AM was a heisman finalist.. they probably mean well, but have a history of being wrong.
 

jkeb

All-Conference
Nov 14, 2005
3,193
1,422
113
It's a game of musical chairs and we have to wait for the better programs to pick over the portal so we can take their leftovers. Where are our million dollar NIL deals? We talk a good game but we are just pretending to be a blueblood at this point.