CampFire

MountaineerWV

Sophomore
Sep 18, 2007
26,324
191
0
First off, horrible situation. Secondly, the dude is an IDIOT for driving his car through it.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
I read some interesting points of view on this topic today. The southern fire was mostly chaparal, so mitigation there is a non-factor. In the north, it was a mix of different areas, chaparal being one kind. They also said that some of the burned area had timber taken off it in the last few years. The main contributing factors were a lack of rain and high winds in both regions.
 

WVU82_rivals

Senior
May 29, 2001
199,091
693
0
California Today: 100 Million Dead Trees Prompt Fears of ...
The more than 100 million trees that died in California after being weakened by drought and insect infestations have transformed large swaths of the Sierra Nevada into browned-out tree cemeteries

102 million dead California trees 'unprecedented in our ...
The number of dead trees in California's drought-stricken forests has risen dramatically to more than 102 million in what officials described as an unparalleled ecological disaster that heightens ...
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
I read some interesting points of view on this topic today. The southern fire was mostly chaparal, so mitigation there is a non-factor. In the north, it was a mix of different areas, chaparal being one kind. They also said that some of the burned area had timber taken off it in the last few years. The main contributing factors were a lack of rain and high winds in both regions.
I think the point is obvious though. Fires are a natural occurance there. Mitigation is just a common sense measure.
 
Last edited:

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
I think the point is obvious though. Fires are a natural occurance there. Mitigation is just a common sense measure.
Agreed where it makes sense. Raking the forest floor doesn't make sense. The leaves and pine needles hold moisture and tend to keep the trees healthier. Raking, outside of raking stuff way from your home, doesn't help. The chaparal is a completely different animal. I only know what I read about that, and it doesn't sound like there's much you can do interms of mitigation there.

I'll add that wind blown embers in a dry environment will make fires spread very quickly. Once a fire starts, that's the real danger. The conditions in CA were perfect for fires. They were in a long dry spell, and it was really windy.
 

dave

Senior
May 29, 2001
60,598
814
113
Agreed where it makes sense. Raking the forest floor doesn't make sense. The leaves and pine needles hold moisture and tend to keep the trees healthier. Raking, outside of raking stuff way from your home, doesn't help. The chaparal is a completely different animal. I only know what I read about that, and it doesn't sound like there's much you can do interms of mitigation there.

I'll add that wind blown embers in a dry environment will make fires spread very quickly. Once a fire starts, that's the real danger. The conditions in CA were perfect for fires. They were in a long dry spell, and it was really windy.
They have a sensible plan to clear the forests of fuel and they dont follow it.
 

atlkvb

All-American
Jul 9, 2004
82,425
5,997
113
I read some interesting points of view on this topic today. The southern fire was mostly chaparal, so mitigation there is a non-factor. In the north, it was a mix of different areas, chaparal being one kind. They also said that some of the burned area had timber taken off it in the last few years. The main contributing factors were a lack of rain and high winds in both regions.

This is largely true as to the ignition points, however restrictions on clearing other areas of brush and dead timber fed fuel for these fires. That was entirely avoidable. Wind and lack of rain are of course nature and can't be controlled by Men.
 

atlkvb

All-American
Jul 9, 2004
82,425
5,997
113
I'll add that wind blown embers in a dry environment will make fires spread very quickly. Once a fire starts, that's the real danger. The conditions in CA were perfect for fires. They were in a long dry spell, and it was really windy.

All true. In years past out there, they prepared for dry spells and anticipated the seasonal Santa Ana winds that blow hot dry air around by clearing brush and building breakwalls into the tundra in case of wild fires. All of that stopped in the late 90's when environmentalists started insisting the brush clearing was harming natural habitats and should be stopped. Nice move!
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
All true. In years past out there, they prepared for dry spells and anticipated the seasonal Santa Ana winds that blow hot dry air around by clearing brush and building breakwalls into the tundra in case of wild fires. All of that stopped in the late 90's when environmentalists started insisting the brush clearing was harming natural habitats and should be stopped. Nice move!
No one builds miles long fire breaks, and that's what they would need to avoid the wind problem. A big chunk of the forest that burned ha recently been timbered. I have no idea how well those folks cleaned up after themselves, but it's not like those areas hadn't seen a saw in ages.
 

atlkvb

All-American
Jul 9, 2004
82,425
5,997
113
No one builds miles long fire breaks, and that's what they would need to avoid the wind problem. A big chunk of the forest that burned ha recently been timbered. I have no idea how well those folks cleaned up after themselves, but it's not like those areas hadn't seen a saw in ages.

Ironically, nature has developed this self administered way to do a lot of that (clearing) without our help. We haven't always been around to "manage" the clearing of dry tinder, and similar to how the Oceans largely self clean, Forests are managed by nature the same way through sporadic wild fires. The problems come when we start building valuable property in areas that shouldn't have them because of the danger. Like beach front homes in hurricane zones, and expensive villas constructed near heavily wooded areas. Sometimes we ask for more trouble than we can easily avoid.
 

mule_eer

Freshman
May 6, 2002
20,439
59
48
Ironically, nature has developed this self administered way to do a lot of that (clearing) without our help. We haven't always been around to "manage" the clearing of dry tinder, and similar to how the Oceans largely self clean, Forests are managed by nature the same way through sporadic wild fires. The problems come when we start building valuable property in areas that shouldn't have them because of the danger. Like beach front homes in hurricane zones, and expensive villas constructed near heavily wooded areas. Sometimes we ask for more trouble than we can easily avoid.
I agree on the choices for development. If you hide your cash in a tinder box, don't be surprised if it burns up one day.