Cal against ranked teams since 2015

seccats04

Heisman
Dec 6, 2004
14,848
24,573
113
2015-16: 3-2
2016-17: 6-5
2017-18: 2-4

Since our 38-1 team, Cal is 11-11 versus ranked teams (11-12 now if you wanna throw in the Duke shellacking). He needs to step his game up if he wants to keep calling us the top program in college basketball. I think his model is broken especially if he can't get top 5 talent. We're getting top 10-20 talent and they still leave after a year or two and a lot of them struggle most of the year and then bolt. Very frustrating.
 
Dec 21, 2001
5,265
11,768
0
2015-16: 3-2
2016-17: 6-5
2017-18: 2-4

Since our 38-1 team, Cal is 11-11 versus ranked teams (11-12 now if you wanna throw in the Duke shellacking). He needs to step his game up if he wants to keep calling us the top program in college basketball. I think his model is broken especially if he can't get top 5 talent. We're getting top 10-20 talent and they still leave after a year or two and a lot of them struggle most of the year and then bolt. Very frustrating.

I think that is what most people are trying to point out and when they do they are bashed for “hating” Cal. 95% of the people pointing this out don’t want Cal gone but are accused of just that or feeling “entitled”. Facts are facts and these don’t lie. It’s not like UK is now SW Louisiana but UK has slipped a little and it is not a 1 game anomaly.

Don’t know that the model is broken because it was always based on getting top 5 talent and Duke just kicked our *** with the model. I don’t think we will get beat in recruiting by 1 team every year like Duke this year but it is going to be more difficult to amass talent year in year out now that almost everyone is in the one and done game. That is going to require adjustment or I think those numbers likely won’t improve much.
 

OHIO COLONEL

Heisman
Feb 11, 2009
14,803
59,401
0
As far as won/loss record, Cal is closing in on Tubbys record his last 4 years. While Cal gets better players than did Tubby, he is doing less with them.
True, but to be fair,Tubby's players were 4 year players while Cal loses them after a year for the most part. Hard to have a 'team' when you have constant turnover. About the time they gel...it's time to start over.
 
May 6, 2004
15,086
11,447
0
yeah but that's still a serious title contender every other year, which I'm good with if it means taking lumps during the regular season so be it.



what's the alternative, build teams like Nova/UNC, sure that's great and all but people neglect to remember the 3-5 years it takes to build those teams which are dominant back to back years. do it like Kansas? what are they really accomplishing other than Big 12 titles? do it like Duke? Yeah, he's been beating Cal at his own game lately for whatever reasons.
 

Catzman

Heisman
Apr 29, 2002
17,529
14,705
113
2015-16: 3-2
2016-17: 6-5
2017-18: 2-4

Since our 38-1 team, Cal is 11-11 versus ranked teams (11-12 now if you wanna throw in the Duke shellacking). He needs to step his game up if he wants to keep calling us the top program in college basketball. I think his model is broken especially if he can't get top 5 talent. We're getting top 10-20 talent and they still leave after a year or two and a lot of them struggle most of the year and then bolt. Very frustrating.


We got Washington and Richards, top 10-20 talent to stay and they still get inconsistent. People get mad that we dont get the elite 10-20 talent to stay but the ones that do never really amount to anything anyway. WCS was helpful his junior year. Poythress was alwaysba glorified roll player. Washington is a poor mans Poythress. Richards is too raw. We got guys like Herro and Quickley and Hagans who are not OAD talent as well. Cals going after guys who are supposed to be here. They either blow up like SGA and cant stay because the offers too good, or stay and dont help anymore than a top 5 freshman OAD would. Would you rather have Davis/Cousins/KAT year after year or WCS/Richards/Dakari? Best option is both, but he cant help when a guy like SGA blows up. SGA should be the PG on this team.
 

JeepCSC_anon

Sophomore
Nov 17, 2005
178
136
0
yeah but that's still a serious title contender every other year, which I'm good with if it means taking lumps during the regular season so be it.



what's the alternative, build teams like Nova/UNC, sure that's great and all but people neglect to remember the 3-5 years it takes to build those teams which are dominant back to back years. do it like Kansas? what are they really accomplishing other than Big 12 titles? do it like Duke? Yeah, he's been beating Cal at his own game lately for whatever reasons.
Just to be clear, UNC has appeared in 6 of the last 8 ACC Tourney finals, won the ACC regular-season 4 of the last 8 years, and finished in the Kenpom top 10 5 times during that stretch. Our “rebuilds” during that stretch aren’t really so severe.
 
Last edited:

TJ-Cat

Junior
Mar 13, 2009
345
349
63
Some of you are so blind. Good grief. Has absolutely nothin to do with it.
I may be "blind" as you say, so tell us your thoughts on the matter. What am I "blind" to or of? That was only my theory as to why recruiting is down and thus the poor record the last few years against the top 25. I'm not saying that is the only reason, but I truly believe it hurt at least a little to get beat while undefeated on such a huge stage. With that being said I believe Cal will be back on top of the recruiting world again soon and I certainly haven't given up on this season yet.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
yeah but that's still a serious title contender every other year, which I'm good with if it means taking lumps during the regular season so be it.



what's the alternative, build teams like Nova/UNC, sure that's great and all but people neglect to remember the 3-5 years it takes to build those teams which are dominant back to back years. do it like Kansas? what are they really accomplishing other than Big 12 titles? do it like Duke? Yeah, he's been beating Cal at his own game lately for whatever reasons.


what are we really accomplishing at the moment?
 

Mike-D

Heisman
Jul 14, 2001
50,607
76,080
113
I may be "blind" as you say, so tell us your thoughts on the matter. What am I "blind" to or of? That was only my theory as to why recruiting is down and thus the poor record the last few years against the top 25. I'm not saying that is the only reason, but I truly believe it hurt at least a little to get beat while undefeated on such a huge stage. With that being said I believe Cal will be back on top of the recruiting world again soon and I certainly haven't given up on this season yet.

No team or program in history has went 38-1, and suffered from it in recruiting. If you recall, Duke had already started out recruiting Kentucky by that point. We had the #2 class in 2014 behind Duke prior to their title run that year. Capel was already at Duke doing his work. We had also just lost Antigua the prior 2013-14 season. The evidence is right there in front of everyone. We’ve had the #1 class one time since then. 2015. And 1 top 5 recruit, a bust in Skal. No top 5 dudes since 2015. So one dude since Antigua left.
 
May 6, 2004
15,086
11,447
0
what are we really accomplishing at the moment?

hopefully building a serious contender, top 5 team by the end of the year, which is what Fox/Monk/Adebayo and company were at the end of the year.

I mean yeah, I think this year probably goes like last year, but we were still a top 15 team in the end... which isn't good enough for me either, but look at what the UNC fan said about his team... he celebrated them being top 10 or ACC champs their other years where they weren't a real threat to win the title. our fans only think of other teams' successes over ours, not their own struggles they have and they put way too much emphasis on regular season games which are ultimately meaningless if you play well in the tournament you overcome any under seeding effects by the second week.
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
UK is batting 1/13 on offered top 5 players since 2015. If we lose out on Stewart, McDaniels, Wiseman, and Carey, we'll be for 1/17 on commitable offers. The one player? Skal.

During that time, 0/3 on Final Fours. Teams before that point with top 5 kids? 4/6 in Final Fours.

Correlation or causation? The sample size is trending toward causation, folks.
 

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
46,007
102,440
113
I wish our Mods would just start deleting these stupid threads. Get up today and half the forum is how bad Cal is or how bad the team is after only 2 games. This team is not bad and Cal will get it going. I mean most of Cal 's teams start slow and then by SEC Mid-Season will be ready for a Tourney run.

Can't blame fans at this point. Losing the Duke the way we did is like finding out your wife slept with your best man right before your honeymoon. Expectations are completely reversed in a matter of minutes.
 
Last edited:

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
I wish our Mods would just start deleting these stupid threads. Get up today and half the forum is how bad Cal is or how bad the team is after only 2 games. This team is not bad and Cal will get it going. I mean most of Cal 's teams start slow and then by SEC Mid-Season will be ready for a Tourney run.

most of Cal's teams start slow? I don't think anyone would have said that in 2015 or even 2016

the idea that you're now making a statement that says "most" speaks volumes. Its probably more reflective of recent teams than overall history.
 

TJ-Cat

Junior
Mar 13, 2009
345
349
63
No team or program in history has went 38-1, and suffered from it in recruiting. If you recall, Duke had already started out recruiting Kentucky by that point. We had the #2 class in 2014 behind Duke prior to their title run that year. Capel was already at Duke doing his work. We had also just lost Antigua the prior 2013-14 season. The evidence is right there in front of everyone. We’ve had the #1 class one time since then. 2015. And 1 top 5 recruit, a bust in Skal. No top 5 dudes since 2015. So one dude since Antigua left.
I agree that Antigua leaving hurt recruiting too. And as to my point, I don't think recruits who watched the game suddenly decided against UK. What I meant was I think the loss hurt Cal so bad that it has affected him and in turn his recruiting. Either way I still think he is without a doubt the best coach for this job and I believe he has us back on top sooner rather than later.
 

DonkeyDwayne

Junior
Oct 5, 2018
1,168
380
0
Very true, but Cal chose this path. If it stops working, time to try something different, what say you.
Cal has never been a great evaluator of talent. Any one can pick the best player or players at a certain position. But once you get past the very best, he gets lost. Not sure you want him coaching “average” players and hoping for great results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cgreen423

DonkeyDwayne

Junior
Oct 5, 2018
1,168
380
0
I agree that Antigua leaving hurt recruiting too. And as to my point, I don't think recruits who watched the game suddenly decided against UK. What I meant was I think the loss hurt Cal so bad that it has affected him and in turn his recruiting. Either way I still think he is without a doubt the best coach for this job and I believe he has us back on top sooner rather than later.
What has hurt recruiting is the lack of WWW in the stands.
 

sk73

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2013
3,253
3,351
113
Some of you are so blind. Good grief. Has absolutely nothin to do with it.
I agree. Its a silly direction to go. The only people around that was a part of the 2015 team are the coaches. What, the OP thinks the coaches bring it up daily in practice. I bet Cal spends a few minutes each practice moaning about the Fox, Monk team losing on a last second shot to go to the final four too.
That 2015 loss to Wisconsin took so much out of the entire program. I think recruiting is still suffering because of it!
You are joking, right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mike-D
A

anon_q409idbs5m40a

Guest
Can't blame fans at this point. Losing the Duke the way we did is like finding out your wife slept with your best man right before your honeymoon. Expectations are completely revered in a matter of minutes.
Suddenly, the KU game doesn't look so good. I"d hate to lose to them four times in a row.
 
A

anon_q409idbs5m40a

Guest
Can't blame fans at this point. Losing the Duke the way we did is like finding out your wife slept with your best man right before your honeymoon. Expectations are completely revered in a matter of minutes.
I actually knew a guy that experienced that. His wife told him "it just happened".
 

Cali-Hawk

All-Conference
Aug 14, 2014
10,871
2,161
0
As a KU fan who was greatly bothered by Cal’s start at UK, it seemed to me that that rate of FF appearances was unlikely to continue regardless of the talent level. Furthermore, not only did Cal get top-5 guys, several of them were all-timers in terms of immediate impact. Not every class has a Wall or Anthony Davis and now you have Duke signing a lot of those guys. All those factors add up.
 

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
Cal has never been a great evaluator of talent. Any one can pick the best player or players at a certain position. But once you get past the very best, he gets lost. Not sure you want him coaching “average” players and hoping for great results.
He has proved that the last 3 years.
 

BLUEVADER

All-Conference
Jun 18, 2015
2,515
2,063
3
I think wat is deflating as well is we thought we had the team to get rid of the ghost of the WiSKy FF loss and the FOX/Monk team L.. It seems as of now that is a pipe dream. and those 2 teams should of brought titles home to Lexington.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheEgyptianMagician

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
I'm not going to fault Cal for his talent appraisal

Assuming he's playing it straight, he backs off kids that aren't going to fit into the system (Trae Young, Shabazz Mohammed) or kids that are clearly looking for a slush fund - too numerous to mention

so I'm guessing that limits the pool noticeably.

So to reverse a Rolling Stone line - he may not get what he needs, but he gets what he wants.

Whats hurting us is that the system is built around having overwhelming talent tied to recruiting. If that doesn't happen, then we have 2 months of this purgatory where we hope the light bulb goes off.

Odds are it won't but we'll get a 22-25 win season,an elite 8 rewarded with a mass exodus in late April and an opportunity to hype up the next recruiting class into the 40-0 dream team.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Cats in the NFL BBNFL Week 10: Another week, another touchdown for Seth McGowan
  2. 02 KSR Basketball You can scout Indiana, Kentucky's next opponent, tonight vs. Arkansas
  3. 03 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Zoom Diallo is 'trending in the right direction' after near triple-double vs. Grambling State
  5. 05 KSR KSR Show, 11/17: Tune in for UK-Grambling takeaways and more