Blue to Red - first post over here

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
Ten of the seventeen cities you listed are in Red States. Red State penal codes and Red State judges and juries. Try again, Trump Cultist.
at the risk of adding a smidge of sanity to this discussion, why are we trying to outdo ourselves with red vs blue state crime. Can't we admit that we as a nation have a problem and combine our ideas on ways to solve the problem. Seems kind of pointless to decide which of the worst cities is the worst. If I were the mayor of one of these crime ridden cities, now is the time to get the federal government to fund crime fighting efforts. I'd get in front of the problem at a time when crime is on the front burner. Fighting it just makes it look like you're in favor of crime instead of crime fighting
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
I'm one of those that moved south, from Pa to Florida. There were multiple reasons, non of them political. I'm retired, so weather and taxes were my principal reasons. Florida has no income tax so what I would have paid in income taxes just about covered the mortgage for a florida. Yea, insurance costs are higher, property taxes are about a wash. We have crime, but the police here don't fool around. and golf is a 12 month/year event

So far we haven't had too many hiccups on politics. In fact there are more conservatives registering to vote than liberals. Which, depending on your viewpoint, is either good or bad.
I believe Hurricane Season just started back there in Florida, and that it runs until November. Aren't you just a tad concerned? There is no such thing as "high ground" in Florida.
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
You have a friend? That’s your empirical data on the issue, your friend. lol bro. I guess all the main stream news is just making up all the stories of businesses and people leaving California. Hilarious.

Here’s some real data, for your “friend”.
• A 2022 Hoover Institution report cited 352 companies moving their headquarters out of California from 2018 to 2021, with 153 leaving in 2021 alone, doubling the 75 in 2020 and tripling the 46 in 2018.


• Build Remote data, reported by The Epoch Times, noted over 90 companies with more than 100 employees left California from 2020 to June 2024, including high-profile names like Tesla, Chevron, and Ruiz Foods.


• A January 2024 California Globe article reported 53 headquarters left San Francisco alone since 2020, with many relocating to Texas, Arizona, and other states.

Finally the part where you say it’s just a skill issue, if that’s true, why does California lead the nation in DEI hiring. I didn’t know being non-white or gay was a skill. Please explain what you mean here. Maybe people are tired of getting f’d over by the woke police.
Sigh ... Many companies that have "left California" and moved to Red States have done so to take advantage of lower costs of living, the prevalence of "right to work" (e.g. anti-union and anti-employee) laws, and offers of tax holidays from Red State governments with little else to offer.

What most of these Red States do NOT have is the kind of trained and educated populace that can serve as the work force in jobs requiring actual, technical, financial and intellectual skills. San Francisco, San Jose, Los Angeles, and San Diego in fact HAVE ample populations of trained and educated people. They also have undocumented immigrants who tend to work in less intellectually demanding but nonetheless important jobs. But the fact remains that many Red States have essentially moribund economies and dwindling populations marked by lack of opportunity, lack of education, lack of relevant job skills, increased reliance on government benefits, and high rates of alcohol and drug abuse.
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
What is your deal? Did I make any negative comments about rural America?

If anything, I am sympathetic to them because many of the healthcare cuts will mean many facilities in rural America won’t be able to survive.

For the record, I grew up in rural America and most of my family still lives there. So before you start an argument with someone, you might want to actually know what their ****** opinions are.
Meh. Take it easy on him. He's angry as a consequence of visiting various and sundry alt-right web sites and perusing culture war articles about how "libtard wokesters" from Blue States are responsible for all of this country's woes. So he's venting by posting his Trumpian blather on this Board. But that's what makes this Board entertaining.
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
Ten of the seventeen cities you listed are in Red States. Red State penal codes and Red State judges and juries. Try again, Trump Cultist.
You don’t think a local community has more to do with this than the leadership of a state? I’ve always thought this was a dumb argument anyway because they’re not factoring in relevant data. For instance, Florida has more gator attacks than Idaho, if you just say that without context it’s kinda dumb.
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
You don’t think a local community has more to do with this than the leadership of a state? I’ve always thought this was a dumb argument anyway because they’re not factoring in relevant data. For instance, Florida has more gator attacks than Idaho, if you just say that without context it’s kinda dumb.
Addressing crime in our cities and towns is a joint responsibility of both local and state government, and an area where the federal government has little or no role. (At least it should not, if those in charge of our Executive Branch respected the limits of their constitutional authority, those in charge of the Legislative Branch shouldered their duty of Executive Branch oversight, and those in charge of the Judicial Branch had some backbone and enforced the separation of powers set forth in the Constitution.)

Local government is responsible for creating, staffing and overseeing municipal police and sheriffs, and for enacting appropriate local ordinances. State government is responsible for enacting the statewide penal (i.e., criminal) code, and for creating, staffing and overseeing the criminal and civil courts. So the responsibility for addressing crime is a shared responsibility.

It is a pretty facile argument to assert that Blue States are "soft on crime" while at the same time defending Red States with higher crime rates by foisting all of the blame on Blue city governments within those Red States. Moreover, there is ALWAYS going to be more crime in large cities than small towns, because FAR more people live in large cities than in small towns. It's comically unrealistic to expect otherwise. If your compare crime statistics on a per capita basis, you are at least getting closer to a meaningful comparison.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
I believe Hurricane Season just started back there in Florida, and that it runs until November. Aren't you just a tad concerned? There is no such thing as "high ground" in Florida.
I've been threw just about 1 hurricane per year. I live in central Florida, 1 hour from closest ocean. I have been there, not same house, since 2014. In all that time, lost power once for a couple of hours, then last year lost power for couple of days. I've been through worse in my life. Was on army field exercise during Agnes one year, that was significantly more exciting.

So far so good.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
Sigh ... Many companies that have "left California" and moved to Red States have done so to take advantage of lower costs of living, the prevalence of "right to work" (e.g. anti-union and anti-employee) laws, and offers of tax holidays from Red State governments with little else to offer.

What most of these Red States do NOT have is the kind of trained and educated populace that can serve as the work force in jobs requiring actual, technical, financial and intellectual skills. San Francisco, San Jose, Los Angeles, and San Diego in fact HAVE ample populations of trained and educated people. They also have undocumented immigrants who tend to work in less intellectually demanding but nonetheless important jobs. But the fact remains that many Red States have essentially moribund economies and dwindling populations marked by lack of opportunity, lack of education, lack of relevant job skills, increased reliance on government benefits, and high rates of alcohol and drug abuse.
Bear, this is the most generalized post I've ever seen from you. lack of opportunity, lack of education lack of relevant job skills... you make it sound as if all southern states are moribund and occupied by the Beverly hillbillies.
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
Addressing crime in our cities and towns is a joint responsibility of both local and state government, and an area where the federal government has little or no role. (At least it should not, if those in charge of our Executive Branch respected the limits of their constitutional authority, those in charge of the Legislative Branch shouldered their duty of Executive Branch oversight, and those in charge of the Judicial Branch had some backbone and enforced the separation of powers set forth in the Constitution.)

Local government is responsible for creating, staffing and overseeing municipal police and sheriffs, and for enacting appropriate local ordinances. State government is responsible for enacting the statewide penal (i.e., criminal) code, and for creating, staffing and overseeing the criminal and civil courts. So the responsibility for addressing crime is a shared responsibility.

It is a pretty facile argument to assert that Blue States are "soft on crime" while at the same time defending Red States with higher crime rates by foisting all of the blame on Blue city governments within those Red States. Moreover, there is ALWAYS going to be more crime in large cities than small towns, because FAR more people live in large cities than in small towns. It's comically unrealistic to expect otherwise. If your compare crime statistics on a per capita basis, you are at least getting closer to a meaningful comparison.
What do you think about the mayor of DC thanking Trump for the NG and reporting an 87% reduction in car jackings? How could you even debate the results and the difference in application and enforcement of the laws.

The point I think most of us are trying to make is by and large it’s safe everywhere, but cities with democratic leadership are violent. Then that spins into liberals claiming that red states (that contain those blue cities) are the most violent. I also don’t think it’s a stretch to say democrats are softer on crime. It’s pretty obvious. And sure, look at per capita and it bolsters my argument. Statistically speaking blacks commit more violent crime, vote 90% democrat in their communities, yet live predominantly in red states.
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
Bear, this is the most generalized post I've ever seen from you. lack of opportunity, lack of education lack of relevant job skills... you make it sound as if all southern states are moribund and occupied by the Beverly hillbillies.
Fair enough, Ned. There are Red States, such as Florida, Texas, and Georgia, to which that characterization does not apply, But consider the plight of folks in Red States like Arkansas, Mississippi, Alabama, and West Virginia. If New Orleans did not exist, Louisiana would be a wasteland of bayous and poverty. Most of it is, anyway, Gulf cities excepted. You've been to the Florida panhandle. You know as well as I that it is not exactly an economic powerhouse.
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
What do you think about the mayor of DC thanking Trump for the NG and reporting an 87% reduction in car jackings? How could you even debate the results and the difference in application and enforcement of the laws.

The point I think most of us are trying to make is by and large it’s safe everywhere, but cities with democratic leadership are violent. Then that spins into liberals claiming that red states (that contain those blue cities) are the most violent. I also don’t think it’s a stretch to say democrats are softer on crime. It’s pretty obvious. And sure, look at per capita and it bolsters my argument. Statistically speaking blacks commit more violent crime, vote 90% democrat in their communities, yet live predominantly in red states.
I'm reluctant to accept any statistics about DC crime rates at this particular point. They are all over the map, depending on who you listen to.

But let's assume for the sake of discussion that DC crime has completely evaporated over the last few weeks. That is surely a good thing (which largely explains the Mayor of DC thanking your Orange Guru), but you also have to ask what is the cost of that reduction in crime? Is having large squads of National Guard or active military patrolling the streets of our big cities, automatic rifles in hand, something that you truly wish for? Permanently? Moreover, we're talking about federalized National Guard troops subject to the sole direction of the President, and put in place over the objections of local mayors and governors, And composed of National Guard troops from Red States only. What if the roles were reversed, and a Democratic president federalized the National Guard under his sole control and sent them into Red cities and towns, rifles in hand, and over the objections of Red mayors and governors? Would you still be supportive of it in that case? Rhetorical question, Farley.

If more crime suppression is needed in, say, Los Angeles, then I believe the people who run city, county and state government in the City and County of Los Angeles and State of California should be the parties who make those decisions, not Donald Trump (or any other president). Trump sending the National Guard to Los Angeles only inflamed a problem (ICE raids and the resulting protests) that was of Trump's creation in the first place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
I'm reluctant to accept any statistics about DC crime rates at this particular point. They are all over the map, depending on who you listen to.

But let's assume for the sake of discussion that DC crime has completely evaporated over the last few weeks. That is surely a good thing (which largely explains the Mayor of DC thanking your Orange Guru), but you also have to ask what is the cost of that reduction in crime? Is having large squads of National Guard or active military patrolling the streets of our big cities, automatic rifles in hand, something that you truly wish for? Permanently? Moreover, we're talking about federalized National Guard troops subject to the sole direction of the President, and put in place over the objections of local mayors and governors, And composed of National Guard troops from Red States only. What if the roles were reversed, and a Democratic president federalized the National Guard under his sole control and sent them into Red cities and towns, rifles in hand, and over the objections of Red mayors and governors? Would you still be supportive of it in that case? Rhetorical question, Farley.

If more crime suppression is needed in, say, Los Angeles, then I believe the people who run city, county and state government in the City and County of Los Angeles and State of California should be the parties who make those decisions, not Donald Trump (or any other president). Trump sending the National Guard to Los Angeles only inflamed a problem (ICE raids and the resulting protests) that was of Trump's creation in the first place.
all fair points and I for 1 don't like armed soldiers on our streets.

But here's the point IMO. Citizens should be allowed to live peacefully without fear of being victims. So far, we could debate whether or not that is the case and whether or not that has been the case for years. We talk about crime being down 30% you, BFD. People are still being robbed, carjacked, assaulted and murdered at unacceptable rates. And clearly, to me at least our governors and mayors - not all, and not just in blue states - have not been up to the task. The defund the police movement has not delivered the results it promised.

As I posted previously, if I were a governor or mayor with a crime issue, I would ask the president for help. Let me get in front of the issue and let the federal government pay for it. To me, governors like pritzger look dumb by accepting the crime in Illinois just because he doesn't want trump involved.

And yes, the whole national guard thing is a short term solution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MTTiger19

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
I'm reluctant to accept any statistics about DC crime rates at this particular point. They are all over the map, depending on who you listen to.

But let's assume for the sake of discussion that DC crime has completely evaporated over the last few weeks. That is surely a good thing (which largely explains the Mayor of DC thanking your Orange Guru), but you also have to ask what is the cost of that reduction in crime? Is having large squads of National Guard or active military patrolling the streets of our big cities, automatic rifles in hand, something that you truly wish for? Permanently? Moreover, we're talking about federalized National Guard troops subject to the sole direction of the President, and put in place over the objections of local mayors and governors, And composed of National Guard troops from Red States only. What if the roles were reversed, and a Democratic president federalized the National Guard under his sole control and sent them into Red cities and towns, rifles in hand, and over the objections of Red mayors and governors? Would you still be supportive of it in that case? Rhetorical question, Farley.

If more crime suppression is needed in, say, Los Angeles, then I believe the people who run city, county and state government in the City and County of Los Angeles and State of California should be the parties who make those decisions, not Donald Trump (or any other president). Trump sending the National Guard to Los Angeles only inflamed a problem (ICE raids and the resulting protests) that was of Trump's creation in the first place.
So just let the cities rot with crime. Fair enough carry on. I actually agree that we shouldnt waste tax payer resources on stuff like this, as you say they voted for lawlessness, let them have it! Best thing that could happen is these large cities collapse and fail right. I have no clue what your point is and its relevance to anything Im talking about. You do use a lot of paragraphs and make wild assumptions tho so good on you.
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
LOL. Too bad that is not, in fact, the case.
lol. In fact, here’s the statistics. I know you all struggle with facts after being infected by TDS.

Murder: In 2023, 8,842 Whites and 6,405 Blacks were recorded as murder offenders. Blacks were overrepresented relative to their population share, especially in juvenile arrests (52% in 2016).


• Non-Fatal Violent Crimes: For non-aggravated assaults, Blacks were arrested at 2.7 times the rate of Whites, while Hispanic arrest rates were roughly proportional to their population share (18.4% of arrests vs. 18% of population).


• Property Crimes: Whites led in absolute numbers (414,500 arrests), followed by Blacks (191,000) and Hispanics (94,000).


Homicide Rates (CDC, 2020–2022)


• Blacks: Murder rate 653% higher than Whites in 2022 (averaging 569% higher from 1990–2022).


• Hispanics: Murder rate 65% higher than Whites in 2022 (57% higher from 1990–2022).


• Whites: Lowest homicide victimization rate among major groups.


• Asians: Highly underrepresented in homicide victimization, consistent with low offending rates.
Blacks are overrepresented in violent crime arrests and victimizations relative to their population share, particularly in homicides and robberies.


• Hispanics show moderate overrepresentation in arrests for serious violent crimes but are closer to proportional for non-aggravated assaults.


• Whites dominate absolute numbers due to their population size but are underrepresented per capita in violent crime offending.


• Asians consistently have the lowest rates of offending and victimization.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerRagRob

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,580
39,407
113
Good Lord dude. As I've said numerous times, you love to come in super hot and make all sorts of accusations.

I'm literally on staff at a Church. I'm a third generation southern preachers kid. I live in rural South Carolina and all of my family is from Alabama or Georgia. I hardly hate the rural South.
So wtf happened then professor yoshi???


😅🤣😂
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
I'm reluctant to accept any statistics about DC crime rates at this particular point. They are all over the map, depending on who you listen to.

But let's assume for the sake of discussion that DC crime has completely evaporated over the last few weeks. That is surely a good thing (which largely explains the Mayor of DC thanking your Orange Guru), but you also have to ask what is the cost of that reduction in crime? Is having large squads of National Guard or active military patrolling the streets of our big cities, automatic rifles in hand, something that you truly wish for? Permanently? Moreover, we're talking about federalized National Guard troops subject to the sole direction of the President, and put in place over the objections of local mayors and governors, And composed of National Guard troops from Red States only. What if the roles were reversed, and a Democratic president federalized the National Guard under his sole control and sent them into Red cities and towns, rifles in hand, and over the objections of Red mayors and governors? Would you still be supportive of it in that case? Rhetorical question, Farley.

If more crime suppression is needed in, say, Los Angeles, then I believe the people who run city, county and state government in the City and County of Los Angeles and State of California should be the parties who make those decisions, not Donald Trump (or any other president). Trump sending the National Guard to Los Angeles only inflamed a problem (ICE raids and the resulting protests) that was of Trump's creation in the first place.
Absolutely chilling footage of the NG in DC. God help us all. Thank you for foreshadowing these horrid, despicable events. Red state nazis marching around the streets, dragging all the libs out of their homes with their automatic weapons. Who could’ve thought? Chilling.

 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,392
10,819
113
all fair points and I for 1 don't like armed soldiers on our streets.

But here's the point IMO. Citizens should be allowed to live peacefully without fear of being victims. So far, we could debate whether or not that is the case and whether or not that has been the case for years. We talk about crime being down 30% you, BFD. People are still being robbed, carjacked, assaulted and murdered at unacceptable rates. And clearly, to me at least our governors and mayors - not all, and not just in blue states - have not been up to the task. The defund the police movement has not delivered the results it promised.

As I posted previously, if I were a governor or mayor with a crime issue, I would ask the president for help. Let me get in front of the issue and let the federal government pay for it. To me, governors like pritzger look dumb by accepting the crime in Illinois just because he doesn't want trump involved.

And yes, the whole national guard thing is a short term solution.
The reduction in crime on the streets of our nation's capital is an unambiguously good thing. Reduction in crime ANYWHERE is an unambiguously good thing. No argument from me at all about that, so it is inaccurate, Ned, to characterize me as saying "BFD," as you did in the above post. I've highlighted the spot where you did so, just to make sure you recall it.

You say that our mayors and governors have not been up to the task of addressing crime. Other Trump supporters on this Board continuously do so as well. But when I or another liberal posts statistics concerning crime rates in blue and red cities, you either pooh pooh it or ignore it, and instead respond with anecdotes about the poor dude in Cincinnati being pummeled by a group of street thugs. As if that incident (lamentable as it was) proves anything about crime rates in general.

The persons who should be deciding if the chief of police, county sheriff, mayor, city council members, county supervisors, state legislators, and/or governor in a given state are "not up to the task" of addressing crime are the voters who reside in that city, county or state. Not the President of the United States. Local crime prevention is a responsibility allocated to cities, counties and states, NOT to the federal government. If these local and state officials are not getting the job done, the voters should replace them. If the voters elect not to do so, then perhaps they are not doing as bad a job as Donald Trump and Faux News believes they are doing.

Finally, your advice to mayors and governors that they simply "ask the president for help" is remarkably facile. Trump doesn't want to help or cooperate. He wants to control, dictate, and grandstand. And he doesn't want to do it "short term." He wants a standing army of goons he can deploy in a number of U.S. cities to intimidate political opponents. There's no "working with" Donald Trump. That's a fantasy. Ask any of the many people he has fired, stiffed, sued, or lambasted in the media.
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
The reduction in crime on the streets of our nation's capital is an unambiguously good thing. Reduction in crime ANYWHERE is an unambiguously good thing. No argument from me at all about that, so it is inaccurate, Ned, to characterize me as saying "BFD," as you did in the above post. I've highlighted the spot where you did so, just to make sure you recall it.

You say that our mayors and governors have not been up to the task of addressing crime. Other Trump supporters on this Board continuously do so as well. But when I or another liberal posts statistics concerning crime rates in blue and red cities, you either pooh pooh it or ignore it, and instead respond with anecdotes about the poor dude in Cincinnati being pummeled by a group of street thugs. As if that incident (lamentable as it was) proves anything about crime rates in general.

The persons who should be deciding if the chief of police, county sheriff, mayor, city council members, county supervisors, state legislators, and/or governor in a given state are "not up to the task" of addressing crime are the voters who reside in that city, county or state. Not the President of the United States. Local crime prevention is a responsibility allocated to cities, counties and states, NOT to the federal government. If these local and state officials are not getting the job done, the voters should replace them. If the voters elect not to do so, then perhaps they are not doing as bad a job as Donald Trump and Faux News believes they are doing.

Finally, your advice to mayors and governors that they simply "ask the president for help" is remarkably facile. Trump doesn't want to help or cooperate. He wants to control, dictate, and grandstand. And he doesn't want to do it "short term." He wants a standing army of goons he can deploy in a number of U.S. cities to intimidate political opponents. There's no "working with" Donald Trump. That's a fantasy. Ask any of the many people he has fired, stiffed, sued, or lambasted in the media.
Do you watch the View?
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,366
35,151
113
The reduction in crime on the streets of our nation's capital is an unambiguously good thing. Reduction in crime ANYWHERE is an unambiguously good thing. No argument from me at all about that, so it is inaccurate, Ned, to characterize me as saying "BFD," as you did in the above post. I've highlighted the spot where you did so, just to make sure you recall it.

You say that our mayors and governors have not been up to the task of addressing crime. Other Trump supporters on this Board continuously do so as well. But when I or another liberal posts statistics concerning crime rates in blue and red cities, you either pooh pooh it or ignore it, and instead respond with anecdotes about the poor dude in Cincinnati being pummeled by a group of street thugs. As if that incident (lamentable as it was) proves anything about crime rates in general.

The persons who should be deciding if the chief of police, county sheriff, mayor, city council members, county supervisors, state legislators, and/or governor in a given state are "not up to the task" of addressing crime are the voters who reside in that city, county or state. Not the President of the United States. Local crime prevention is a responsibility allocated to cities, counties and states, NOT to the federal government. If these local and state officials are not getting the job done, the voters should replace them. If the voters elect not to do so, then perhaps they are not doing as bad a job as Donald Trump and Faux News believes they are doing.

Finally, your advice to mayors and governors that they simply "ask the president for help" is remarkably facile. Trump doesn't want to help or cooperate. He wants to control, dictate, and grandstand. And he doesn't want to do it "short term." He wants a standing army of goons he can deploy in a number of U.S. cities to intimidate political opponents. There's no "working with" Donald Trump. That's a fantasy. Ask any of the many people he has fired, stiffed, sued, or lambasted in the media.
Damn man, I'd give you five likes if I could. You hit the nail on the head - while they accuse Democrats of being opposed to fighting crime, it's really the sinister underbelly that they can't see or won't acknowledge - this is a predicate for something much worse down the line, after they normalize the sight of roving bands of soldiers in the streets. Bill Maher expressed it perfectly.

 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
The reduction in crime on the streets of our nation's capital is an unambiguously good thing. Reduction in crime ANYWHERE is an unambiguously good thing. No argument from me at all about that, so it is inaccurate, Ned, to characterize me as saying "BFD," as you did in the above post. I've highlighted the spot where you did so, just to make sure you recall it.

You say that our mayors and governors have not been up to the task of addressing crime. Other Trump supporters on this Board continuously do so as well. But when I or another liberal posts statistics concerning crime rates in blue and red cities, you either pooh pooh it or ignore it, and instead respond with anecdotes about the poor dude in Cincinnati being pummeled by a group of street thugs. As if that incident (lamentable as it was) proves anything about crime rates in general.

The persons who should be deciding if the chief of police, county sheriff, mayor, city council members, county supervisors, state legislators, and/or governor in a given state are "not up to the task" of addressing crime are the voters who reside in that city, county or state. Not the President of the United States. Local crime prevention is a responsibility allocated to cities, counties and states, NOT to the federal government. If these local and state officials are not getting the job done, the voters should replace them. If the voters elect not to do so, then perhaps they are not doing as bad a job as Donald Trump and Faux News believes they are doing.

Finally, your advice to mayors and governors that they simply "ask the president for help" is remarkably facile. Trump doesn't want to help or cooperate. He wants to control, dictate, and grandstand. And he doesn't want to do it "short term." He wants a standing army of goons he can deploy in a number of U.S. cities to intimidate political opponents. There's no "working with" Donald Trump. That's a fantasy. Ask any of the many people he has fired, stiffed, sued, or lambasted in the media.
you had me up until the last paragraph. I'll admit you MAY be 100% right....but you may also be 100% wrong. There is no evidence to support your theory about trump wanting a standing army of goons (retired ARMY, don't like that characterization) intimidating political opponents. He had 4 years in the first term to do that, crime was just as bad, or worse, in some cities.

Yea, there are instances of trump suing, stiffing, firing and lambasting, but never putting a standing army anywhere. Why not wait until we see what happens in DC before jumping to that conclusion. I'm not keen on armed soldiers on city streets. But I'm also not keen on mayors - blue or red - telling me there's no crime problem when I read statistics highlighting crime problems. I'm simply suggesting, If I were a mayor and I could get federal help, I'd take it.
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
you had me up until the last paragraph. I'll admit you MAY be 100% right....but you may also be 100% wrong. There is no evidence to support your theory about trump wanting a standing army of goons (retired ARMY, don't like that characterization) intimidating political opponents. He had 4 years in the first term to do that, crime was just as bad, or worse, in some cities.

Yea, there are instances of trump suing, stiffing, firing and lambasting, but never putting a standing army anywhere. Why not wait until we see what happens in DC before jumping to that conclusion. I'm not keen on armed soldiers on city streets. But I'm also not keen on mayors - blue or red - telling me there's no crime problem when I read statistics highlighting crime problems. I'm simply suggesting, If I were a mayor and I could get federal help, I'd take it.
There’s absolutely zero precedent for what he’s claiming is going to happen. It’s no different than saying you’re gonna be put in a concentration camp like some of the other libs here. The actual citizens of DC are thrilled with the safety and security improvements, as Trump has said, this is to show the public it can be done as well as the police in those areas. I posted a video yesterday of the NG raking leaves and cleaning up trash off the streets in DC. A far cry from this alarmists warnings. I wonder what he thought about federal vaccine mandates. What I’ve noticed with almost every lib on here is they just don’t like Trump - that’s it, that’s the problem. They hate him.

Look at the post: And he doesn't want to do it "short term." He wants a standing army of goons he can deploy in a number of U.S. cities to intimidate political opponents. There's no "working with" Donald Trump. That's a fantasy. Ask any of the many people he has fired, stiffed, sued, or lambasted in the media.

This is nonsense, complete lies. This is TDS.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
There’s absolutely zero precedent for what he’s claiming is going to happen. It’s no different than saying you’re gonna be put in a concentration camp like some of the other libs here. The actual citizens of DC are thrilled with the safety and security improvements, as Trump has said, this is to show the public it can be done as well as the police in those areas. I posted a video yesterday of the NG raking leaves and cleaning up trash off the streets in DC. A far cry from this alarmists warnings. I wonder what he thought about federal vaccine mandates. What I’ve noticed with almost every lib on here is they just don’t like Trump - that’s it, that’s the problem. They hate him.

Look at the post: And he doesn't want to do it "short term." He wants a standing army of goons he can deploy in a number of U.S. cities to intimidate political opponents. There's no "working with" Donald Trump. That's a fantasy. Ask any of the many people he has fired, stiffed, sued, or lambasted in the media.

This is nonsense, complete lies. This is TDS.
to be honest it's unlike bear. I have interfaced with him for a few years on the Penn state board (until it was eliminated) and he clearly does not like Trump or his policies, which is ok. I don't like quite a few of Trump policies either. But it seems as if he has given in to exaggeration/hyperbole since moving over here. He's not as over the top as dpic or Tboone (few are) as you can normally have a reasonable back and forth discussion as long as you are ok with his use of "Cheeto Hitler" in most of his anti trump posts. I think he's very clear in his opinions and seems to be reasonable (sometimes).
 

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
to be honest it's unlike bear. I have interfaced with him for a few years on the Penn state board (until it was eliminated) and he clearly does not like Trump or his policies, which is ok. I don't like quite a few of Trump policies either. But it seems as if he has given in to exaggeration/hyperbole since moving over here. He's not as over the top as dpic or Tboone (few are) as you can normally have a reasonable back and forth discussion as long as you are ok with his use of "Cheeto Hitler" in most of his anti trump posts. I think he's very clear in his opinions and seems to be reasonable (sometimes).
Maybe. I think reasonable people understand the desire to live in a safe, secure, normal environment. I also think reasonable people can look at places like Chicago and DC and it’s obvious that LE is incredibly hindered there, specifically due to leftist policies on enforcement and punishment of criminal offenses. These are factual things that no reasonable person can deny. Furthermore it’s the responsibility of the sitting president to ensure safety for his citizens. Imagine if Biden a couple of years ago says to the media, “Texas is not doing a good job at the border, they’re not enforcing our laws and I’m sending the NG down there to get it under control.” The reaction from the American people would have been positive overwhelmingly, that was one of the pivotal issues of the election. People want to feel safe, they want to know their neighbors and they want criminals off their blocks and out of their neighborhoods. That’s a fact. Maybe this is a mask off moment for bear. We’ve had a couple of moderates here get unmasked as flaming partisan liberals. Trump has made otherwise reasonable people become blubbering crybabies with just words and rhetoric. It makes me wonder how little these people have ever been coached or led by a tough leader.
 

ClemsonCO14

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2016
574
1,766
87
Absolutely chilling footage of the NG in DC. God help us all. Thank you for foreshadowing these horrid, despicable events. Red state nazis marching around the streets, dragging all the libs out of their homes with their automatic weapons. Who could’ve thought? Chilling.


See @dpic73 ’s post above. Armed NG soldiers on the streets of a major US city should make any freedom-loving-American gravely concerned.

There is no emergency in DC - violent crime has substantially declined in recent years. Outside of the obvious civil liberty concerns, how do you not see this entire fiasco - including NG soldiers landscaping - as an incredible waste of taxpayer resources? Of course crime will decline if you flood the streets with hundreds of soldiers, but what are you doing to address the systemic issues (eg, education, poverty, mental health, substance abuse, etc) that drive crime?

At best this is the world’s most expensive and temporary band-aid and at worst it is a trial run for projecting and maintaining power. You can’t accuse people of overreacting when your MAGA r*****s attacked the capital on January 6… and were subsequently pardoned by your god.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,366
35,151
113
you had me up until the last paragraph. I'll admit you MAY be 100% right....but you may also be 100% wrong. There is no evidence to support your theory about trump wanting a standing army of goons (retired ARMY, don't like that characterization) intimidating political opponents. He had 4 years in the first term to do that, crime was just as bad, or worse, in some cities.

Yea, there are instances of trump suing, stiffing, firing and lambasting, but never putting a standing army anywhere. Why not wait until we see what happens in DC before jumping to that conclusion. I'm not keen on armed soldiers on city streets. But I'm also not keen on mayors - blue or red - telling me there's no crime problem when I read statistics highlighting crime problems. I'm simply suggesting, If I were a mayor and I could get federal help, I'd take it.
You're right, Trump would never do anything crazy like that. We know we can trust him to do the right thing at all times and if you say differently, yOu hAvE TdS .

1756467515789.png

1756467558212.png

1756467620831.png





1756468251433.png




1756468903062.png
1756468918728.png
1756469924367.png
1756468961594.png
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ClemsonCO14

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
See @dpic73 ’s post above. Armed NG soldiers on the streets of a major US city should make any freedom-loving-American gravely concerned.

There is no emergency in DC - violent crime has substantially declined in recent years. Outside of the obvious civil liberty concerns, how do you not see this entire fiasco - including NG soldiers landscaping - as an incredible waste of taxpayer resources? Of course crime will decline if you flood the streets with hundreds of soldiers, but what are you doing to address the systemic issues (eg, education, poverty, mental health, substance abuse, etc) that drive crime?

At best this is the world’s most expensive and temporary band-aid and at worst it is a trial run for projecting and maintaining power. You can’t accuse people of overreacting when your MAGA r*****s attacked the capital on January 6… and were subsequently pardoned by your god.
I will never look at some dumb graphic dick pic posts. He’s a tool.
There is no emergency in DC? If people are getting carjacked at such an astounding rate that an entire army can only reduce it 87% there’s an emergency bro. You may not like that, I get it. If you don’t want NG then clean up your house. I don’t wanna hear anything about education or any of that other ****. Yall have your elected leaders destroying those communities for long enough. 90% of “graduates” from Chicago HS cannot read or write. That’s a ******* emergency. Start holding your leaders accountable and stop placating violent criminals.
 

dpic73

Heisman
Jul 27, 2005
37,366
35,151
113
I will never look at some dumb graphic dick pic posts. He’s a tool.
There is no emergency in DC? If people are getting carjacked at such an astounding rate that an entire army can only reduce it 87% there’s an emergency bro. You may not like that, I get it. If you don’t want NG then clean up your house. I don’t wanna hear anything about education or any of that other ****. Yall have your elected leaders destroying those communities for long enough. 90% of “graduates” from Chicago HS cannot read or write. That’s a ******* emergency. Start holding your leaders accountable and stop placating violent criminals.
Yeah @ClemsonCO14, listen to this man - you need to set a good example and hold your leaders accountable for placating violent criminals!

1756470937171.png
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
See @dpic73 ’s post above. Armed NG soldiers on the streets of a major US city should make any freedom-loving-American gravely concerned.

There is no emergency in DC - violent crime has substantially declined in recent years. Outside of the obvious civil liberty concerns, how do you not see this entire fiasco - including NG soldiers landscaping - as an incredible waste of taxpayer resources? Of course crime will decline if you flood the streets with hundreds of soldiers, but what are you doing to address the systemic issues (eg, education, poverty, mental health, substance abuse, etc) that drive crime?

At best this is the world’s most expensive and temporary band-aid and at worst it is a trial run for projecting and maintaining power. You can’t accuse people of overreacting when your MAGA r*****s attacked the capital on January 6… and were subsequently pardoned by your god.
I don't buy the argument that violent crime is substantially declined.

Let's ask a different question, how much violent crime is acceptable? In DC there has been 102 murders so far this year, So that's down from 115 yoy. Is that acceptable?

What your argument is saying is "yes". I'm willing to accept 102 murders over 8 months.
 

UrHuckleberry

Heisman
Jun 2, 2024
10,910
23,554
113
I don't buy the argument that violent crime is substantially declined.

Let's ask a different question, how much violent crime is acceptable? In DC there has been 102 murders so far this year, So that's down from 115 yoy. Is that acceptable?

What your argument is saying is "yes". I'm willing to accept 102 murders over 8 months.
Just wanted to note, that sort of line can be used to take away a lot of personal liberty we have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yoshi121374

MTTiger19

Heisman
Sep 10, 2008
7,198
10,627
113
Just wanted to note, that sort of line can be used to take away a lot of personal liberty we have.
Why do libs care about personal liberty now but not during vaccine mandates. The cheerleader that liked your post is a vax mandate supporter. A lot of libs talk out of both sides of your mouths. The argument for that very vaccine mandate was public safety. Same here. Literally.
 

ClemsonCO14

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2016
574
1,766
87
I don't buy the argument that violent crime is substantially declined.

Let's ask a different question, how much violent crime is acceptable? In DC there has been 102 murders so far this year, So that's down from 115 yoy. Is that acceptable?

What your argument is saying is "yes". I'm willing to accept 102 murders over 8 months.
As @UrHuckleberry notes, your logic is a slippery slope with precedent spanning generations and continents involving authoritarian leaders using the pretext of security to remove civil liberties and silence peaceful dissent.

In addition to reading up on the basics of authoritarianism, I’d also suggest developing basic logic and reasoning skills. Your post is one of the most ludicrous straw men arguments I’ve seen on this board, and that’s unfortunately saying something. I hesitated dignifying your post with a response, but your ignorance is astounding.
 

UrHuckleberry

Heisman
Jun 2, 2024
10,910
23,554
113
As @UrHuckleberry notes, your logic is a slippery slope with precedent spanning generations and continents involving authoritarian leaders using the pretext of security to remove civil liberties and silence peaceful dissent.

In addition to reading up on the basics of authoritarianism, I’d also suggest developing basic logic and reasoning skills. Your post is one of the most ludicrous straw men arguments I’ve seen on this board, and that’s unfortunately saying something. I hesitated dignifying your post with a response, but your ignorance is astounding.
Will just add that Ned has been a good addition to the board. While I agree its a slippery slope and have stated something similar multiple times, just wanted to point out he hasn't generally been one for histrionics and overkill and wanted to take up for him there.
 

UrHuckleberry

Heisman
Jun 2, 2024
10,910
23,554
113
I admit, I'm not sure I understand your post
Basically what ClemsonCO14 said but less confrontationally. Your argument could also be used to take away everyone's guns right? Or do you not care about the slaughter of kids?!

I'm just saying when you frame things like you did, there would be no reason ever to push back on government overreach.

Why can't they wire tap every citizen? It would help solve a lot of crimes. Do you not care about those?

Why can't they lock up anyone wearing a red bandana or whatever, could stop a lot of murders? Do you not care about gang violence?
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
As @UrHuckleberry notes, your logic is a slippery slope with precedent spanning generations and continents involving authoritarian leaders using the pretext of security to remove civil liberties and silence peaceful dissent.

In addition to reading up on the basics of authoritarianism, I’d also suggest developing basic logic and reasoning skills. Your post is one of the most ludicrous straw men arguments I’ve seen on this board, and that’s unfortunately saying something. I hesitated dignifying your post with a response, but your ignorance is astounding.
well, excusing my ignorance, is 102 murders in 8 months acceptable for you? And that's only murders, how about carjackings, which according to the DC mayor are down 87% in just the time the federal government has gotten involved.

You don't understand my logic. Let me expound...the objective here is to minimize crime so the citizens can live in peace without fear. To me the 102 murders and God knows how many assaults and carjackings, not to mention the petty stuff like shoplifting or petty larceny is not acceptable. Obviously, if I understand your post, it is to you. Now I don't believe for a minute that the current DC leadership is not trying to correct the problems. But based on actual results they are not succeeding. On the other hand, the actions of the federal government are. The mayor has thanked the federal government for their help and acknowledged the improvements.

And, my argument isn't strawman, it's based on fact..Don't believe me, look at mayor's comments and crime statistics since fed involvement. I get that you don't like Trump and don't like federal agents and NG on the streets. Neither do I and likely neither do a lot of the citizens of DC. On the other hand there are citizens who are very pleased and others who want more federal support in their neighborhoods.

By the way, personal attacks don't lend themselves much to discussion. I might not like or even understand your thinking on this, but I respect your opinion.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
Basically what ClemsonCO14 said but less confrontationally. Your argument could also be used to take away everyone's guns right? Or do you not care about the slaughter of kids?!

I'm just saying when you frame things like you did, there would be no reason ever to push back on government overreach.

Why can't they wire tap every citizen? It would help solve a lot of crimes. Do you not care about those?

Why can't they lock up anyone wearing a red bandana or whatever, could stop a lot of murders? Do you not care about gang violence?
again, I have to admit I don't understand the logic here. Is it over reach to send national guard in to DC. Sure it is. Is it illegal or unconstitutional, not it isn't.

Did DC have a crime problem, yes, and for decades.

Is the government effort working? According to the mayor, yes it is.

The concept of wiretapping every citizen, while I understand your example, is really far out. And, government can't do that without court authorization. Don't government agencies already wiretap citizens when they think it will help solve crimes? Sure, and with court orders.

The red bandana question is also kind of "out there". So far, the national guard can't arrest anybody.

Do I like the idea of national guard on the streets? I've posted many times "no". And, I've also posted that if I were a mayor in a city with a crime problem, I'd call the president and ask for federal help. I wouldn't ask for national guard, I'd ask for funding to put more police on the streets. I think you could make a case that financially and politically you could make a case that federal funding for more police would be cheaper and more cost effective than sending in national guard.

Obviously we are looking at same problem and seeing things differently. I look and see that a. there is a problem, b the DC government has not been able to fix it c. I have the authority and capability/resources to fix it and d. I'm going to use that authority. And, using that authority seems to be working.

You guys look at it and, if I understand correctly, a. there is a problem (or maybe you don't think so) b. the DC government has not fixed it and c. sending federal resources is a slippery slope that is authoritarian, a slippery slope to even greater government takeovers etc. And, again if I understand Clemson co14 correctly, trump using his authority could lead to removing civil liberties and silencing dissent. Now I might agree with Clemson if Trump were operating in a manner for which he is not authorized. But in this case, as I understand it, he is acting well withing his constitutional authority.

Who knows, you might be right. But so far there is no indication that the federal government is exceeding it's authority in DC. Now, might that change? With Trump, you never know. He'll push the envelope as far as he can, and then push a little more. If he goes too far, the courts will reign him in.

So far on this board there has been a lot of conjecture about what Trump might do. How he might take steps to remove our constitutional rights, jail his opponents, end our democracy, arrest people wearing red bandanas :). But in 4 years of first term and six months of his second that hasn't happened. At one point there was a lot of handwringing about trump not obeying court orders. That hasn't happened (so far) either. As I see it, you (collective, not individual) are accusing trump in similar ways that republicans did Biden. and yet, somehow we're still hwew
 

UrHuckleberry

Heisman
Jun 2, 2024
10,910
23,554
113
again, I have to admit I don't understand the logic here. Is it over reach to send national guard in to DC. Sure it is. Is it illegal or unconstitutional, not it isn't.

Did DC have a crime problem, yes, and for decades.

Is the government effort working? According to the mayor, yes it is.

The concept of wiretapping every citizen, while I understand your example, is really far out. And, government can't do that without court authorization. Don't government agencies already wiretap citizens when they think it will help solve crimes? Sure, and with court orders.

The red bandana question is also kind of "out there". So far, the national guard can't arrest anybody.

Do I like the idea of national guard on the streets? I've posted many times "no". And, I've also posted that if I were a mayor in a city with a crime problem, I'd call the president and ask for federal help. I wouldn't ask for national guard, I'd ask for funding to put more police on the streets. I think you could make a case that financially and politically you could make a case that federal funding for more police would be cheaper and more cost effective than sending in national guard.

Obviously we are looking at same problem and seeing things differently. I look and see that a. there is a problem, b the DC government has not been able to fix it c. I have the authority and capability/resources to fix it and d. I'm going to use that authority. And, using that authority seems to be working.

You guys look at it and, if I understand correctly, a. there is a problem (or maybe you don't think so) b. the DC government has not fixed it and c. sending federal resources is a slippery slope that is authoritarian, a slippery slope to even greater government takeovers etc. And, again if I understand Clemson co14 correctly, trump using his authority could lead to removing civil liberties and silencing dissent. Now I might agree with Clemson if Trump were operating in a manner for which he is not authorized. But in this case, as I understand it, he is acting well withing his constitutional authority.

Who knows, you might be right. But so far there is no indication that the federal government is exceeding it's authority in DC. Now, might that change? With Trump, you never know. He'll push the envelope as far as he can, and then push a little more. If he goes too far, the courts will reign him in.

So far on this board there has been a lot of conjecture about what Trump might do. How he might take steps to remove our constitutional rights, jail his opponents, end our democracy, arrest people wearing red bandanas :). But in 4 years of first term and six months of his second that hasn't happened. At one point there was a lot of handwringing about trump not obeying court orders. That hasn't happened (so far) either. As I see it, you (collective, not individual) are accusing trump in similar ways that republicans did Biden. and yet, somehow we're still hwew
I am saying that when people are arguing against it, it is not because they love crime, which I don't believe you are intending to imply, but using the argument "are you ok with 102 murders?" as an indicator doesn't give the other person any room to push back. So it doesn't really work as a valid argument for what should actually be done to me. Because I can argue for a whole lot of things using that terminology. Which is what I was saying with the red bandanas FYI, not predicting he could or would. Just saying, you could lower crime doing that, and if anyone pushed back, use the same argument you are.

My main issue overall is that this is a temporary pause and isn't accomplishing anything but said pause. That it isn't actually solving issues because they won't be there long term. They aren't working on laws that gets these cities more funding. They aren't working on federal bail reform, or officer training programs, or working to get more funding for mental health, or anything other than this large, expensive, show of force crime pause, and are doing it in exclusively the cities in states where the politics disagrees with them. They aren't going to Memphis, or Kansas City, or Houston, or Nashville. Those were all on a top ten crime rate list I just looked up.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,691
6,994
113
I am saying that when people are arguing against it, it is not because they love crime, which I don't believe you are intending to imply, but using the argument "are you ok with 102 murders?" as an indicator doesn't give the other person any room to push back. So it doesn't really work as a valid argument for what should actually be done to me. Because I can argue for a whole lot of things using that terminology. Which is what I was saying with the red bandanas FYI, not predicting he could or would. Just saying, you could lower crime doing that, and if anyone pushed back, use the same argument you are.

My main issue overall is that this is a temporary pause and isn't accomplishing anything but said pause. That it isn't actually solving issues because they won't be there long term. They aren't working on laws that gets these cities more funding. They aren't working on federal bail reform, or officer training programs, or working to get more funding for mental health, or anything other than this large, expensive, show of force crime pause, and are doing it in exclusively the cities in states where the politics disagrees with them. They aren't going to Memphis, or Kansas City, or Houston, or Nashville. Those were all on a top ten crime rate list I just looked up.
understood, and I couldn't agree more with your second paragraph
 
  • Like
Reactions: UrHuckleberry

tigerridge

All-American
Dec 8, 2005
4,800
6,124
93
I just visited that specific area this past weekend, to visit GW as part of them recruiting my son. For me personally I don’t understand the draw. It just seems like a normal international type city. But I am not upset about it like most here. I have 5 kids and we live on 20 acres and have a big house, sort of in the country but within striking distance of medium sized city. The thought of selling to move to northern Virginia to fight traffic, listen to people honk horns if you don’t move your car immediately, and general congestion - I look around and think I must not have all the data. There must be something great there since everyone wants to live on top of one another. I mumbled to myself many times “why would anyone want to live here?” But again it’s ok I am not mad about it. Hey good for those that found what they like.
I can answer that... Government Jobs... In my opinion, they should be cut in half, especially every agency not involved in military and law enforcement. Let the states handle their own business. Just my opinion.
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football LIVE UPDATES & DISCUSSION: Clemson at Duke
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Our final word on Clemson Football ahead of kickoff
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Tiger Illustrated's Clemson - Duke Forecast
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Clemson Football Insider