Bad Will and Good Will, up & down MSU QB

DamnitDog

Redshirt
Aug 7, 2008
1,123
0
0
...so again this is the problem with the true Mike Leach Air Raid Offense. In order for Leach to run this offense like he did elsewhere, you HAVE TO HAVE a SMART QB and one that is fearless to make decisions and one with a quick release. What I watched on Sat vs Memphis during the 1st-3rd Quarters was a slow, scared and timid QB holding the ball WAAAAYYYY TOO LONG, a scared QB afraid to throw the ball in the middle of the field, and an indecisive QB who continued to dump 3-5 yard high school passes to his check-down RBs who can only get very few YAC yards (Yards After Contact)...all against a MEMPHIS Defense who gave up 50 points last week to Arkansas State...50!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Now during the 4th Quarter, we saw the reverse. For one damn quarter, we saw a QB say in his mind "HOLY SH** we are about to lose this, let's go!" - Then and only then, we see a SMART QB, quick decision maker and one not afraid to throw long bombs down the field, but only when we are BEHIND in the game.

This Mike Leach Air-Raid experiment ONLY has 3 options going forward:

1. Will Rogers need to get his finger out of his A** and STOP playing conservation, scared and timid when we are ahead. He is playing not to lose, instead of playing to win by continuing to keep scoring, can't let a home team like Memphis hang around & get momentum with a home crowd going crazy...yes even a team like Memphis. He needs to play like he did in the 4th Quarter and forget about interceptions, being scared or whatever he had previously been taught to do in his background. He is too slow, scared and timid in the early part of games and he has almost cost us points in our two previous games by getting behind. Does anyone know why he is being taught like this? Is it his background being in his Dad's offense and playing conservative until you get behind in a game? He has almost cost us victories in two previous games and now he DID cost us a victory yesterday. He can't play this bad for 3 quarters, it is horrible to watch. He holds the damn ball way too long.

2. Mike Leach needs to replace WILL ROGERS now and play Sawyer Robertson and take our lumps now instead of next year. Look folks, there are only 2 more wins on our schedule: Vandy and TSU. We won't be able to beat any other SEC WEST team this year running the Will Rogers running this version of the Air-Raid. I would rather go 4-8 with Sawyer learning on the job training instead of more Will "Timid" Rogers 5 yard dump passes in the flat for no gain. Also, I'm not sure Will is SMART ENOUGH to run the real Air-Raid Leach Offense. From what I remember during recruiting, Sawyer is a SMART QB who has intangibles to run this offense like the Texas Tech years.

3. *IF* Will Rogers continues to play this bad for 3 quarters in every game for the whole year, with no accountability from this coaching staff and *IF* Mike Leach refuses to give another QB a shot, we will go 4-8 this year and probably 4-8 next year as well. In Year 4, Mike Leach needs to be fired for playing favoritism. Look, I love Will and he is a great kid from a great family, but performance speaks louder than words. He is not getting it done and if he can't, Leach needs to give him the backup QB job going forward. Will just maybe a good SEC backup for MSU and that is fine and nothing wrong with that and he can get his degree and get a real job in the future. Again, you have to have a SMART, FEARLESS, QB to run the true Air Raid.
 

DamnitDog

Redshirt
Aug 7, 2008
1,123
0
0
IF Will accepts a few interceptions and becomes more aggressive in his passing game (like he proved in the 4th Q vs Memphis yesterday) let's roll with him. But I doubt it, it seems he might have been taught to play not to lose instead of play to win? Maybe it stems from his background of being a coach's kid? Maybe he has been taught from his Dad to not take chances, rely on your defense & special teams and only when you get behind, then you become aggressive ONLY when you have to? Does anyone know his DAD to confirm this?

Maybe it is in his DNA as a coach's kid? Leach has said time and time again during post-game interviews since LA Tech that quote "Will needs to be more decisive and put the ball on him" and "Will needs to put the ball in play on the down the field routes" - can anyone who has been at Brandon HS during the Will Roger years confirm this? Why is he sooo super conservative when we are ahead then all of a sudden, we see a different QB when we get behind?
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
60,217
31,253
113
I suspect if Leach suddenly changed to either next week, we’d all be calling for Rogers by the 3rd quarter. Throwing a kid who no ready out there to “take his lumps” doesn’t do a damn thing for his development & actually can stunt it. For all Leach’s faults, not playing his best QB isn’t one of them.
 

DamnitDog

Redshirt
Aug 7, 2008
1,123
0
0
Sawyer is READY and is not scared or timid or indecisive. These kids are not as scared as you might think. Now, I agree, we can't win any games with him this year, but its all about 2022. Build toward the future and recruiting. We need to show potential WR recruits, we are ready, willing and able to showcase the TRUE AIR-RAID of the Mike Leach Texas Tech years.
 

Dawgzilla

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
5,406
0
0
I suspect if Leach suddenly changed to either next week, we’d all be calling for Rogers by the 3rd quarter. Throwing a kid who no ready out there to “take his lumps” doesn’t do a damn thing for his development & actually can stunt it. For all Leach’s faults, not playing his best QB isn’t one of them.

This. I'm not a "trust the coaches" kind of guy when people want to second guess. But Leach is going to play the QB he believes will be most effective. For now that is Roger's. He won't hesitate to change QBS when he thinks it makes sense.
 

22yardpunt

Senior
Dec 20, 2009
1,179
877
113
Let’s not forget that Will is only a Sophomore with not even a full season under his belt as a starter. In our conference sophomores should be standing in the sideline holding a clipboard and the only pantos taken is during garbage time. I hope Will is the Qb of the future, but the product we are seeing on the field is VERY MUCH a function of the turnover of the program in recent years. So calling for Will to be benched at this point is very premature and I don’t think he has had the chance yet to prove that he is or isn’t the guy.
 

ezsoil

Junior
May 26, 2013
1,348
284
83
Sawyer is READY and is not scared or timid or indecisive. These kids are not as scared as you might think. Now, I agree, we can't win any games with him this year, but its all about 2022. Build toward the future and recruiting. We need to show potential WR recruits, we are ready, willing and able to showcase the TRUE AIR-RAID of the Mike Leach Texas Tech years.


not sure how you can say he is READY ...he never really faced very good players in High School....west Texas isn't a hotbed of talent and when he advanced in the playoffs, he really dropped off production wise...the SEC has another level of Athlete that he has never seen ...I'd rather him learn from the sideline and then look to develop the tools that he has over next summer...but to throw him to the wolves early would be counterproductive
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Mississippi State PFF Grades from the 41-34 win over South Carolina
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football Standout Stats: Mississippi State 41-34 South Carolina
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Amaree Williams' breakout impact in Mississippi State's win at South Carolina
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Be a Brotherhood": Mississippi State holds fast in comeback win at South Carolina
  5. 05 Maroon and White Rapid Recap: Mississippi State 41-34 South Carolina