B1G Percent of Scoring returning

RUsojo

Heisman
Dec 17, 2010
30,224
29,687
113
The league has been pretty weak the last two years and for the most part the best players have now left and haven’t necessarily been recruiting that well to replace them (sans Michigan a few others).

Lot of opportunity for big bball programs the last two years and going forward.

Pike has done a good job to be the one making headway more than most
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13

Jtg=04131996

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2010
8,165
4,878
81
The league has been pretty weak the last two years and for the most part the best players have now left and haven’t necessarily been recruiting that well to replace them (sans Michigan a few others).

Lot of opportunity for big bball programs the last two years and going forward.

Pike has done a good job to be the one making headway more than most
The first part of your post is categorically false. Poor performances in a one and done tournament does not make the league weak.

In 2019 the B1G sent 8 teams the tournament. No one else had more than 7.

In 2020 the tournament got canceled but I can only assume the B1G would’ve had the most teams in the tournament because…

In 2021 AND 2022 the B1G sent 9 teams. The second most in 2021 was 7 teams and the second most in 2022 was 6 teams.

You can squirm around if you’d like but the B1G has objectively been strong the last four years, and REALLY strong the last 2.
 

Mr. Magoo1

Heisman
Nov 15, 2001
15,657
16,624
113
Indiana also brought in some 5 star recruits I believe
They have two 5 stars coming in…both ranked in the 20’s overall. Not sold on Woodson as a college coach yet, but they should easily be the favorite….and possibly a Top 10 team.

Teams like Michigan and Illinois will just re-load but they both lost a lot. Can’t see Purdue being nearly as good either. Michigan State and Iowa also lost a lot.

IMO, we have a good shot to finish in the Top 3rd of the league this year. Anything less than top half for us is a dissappointment.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13

Scangg

Heisman
Mar 19, 2016
25,508
49,539
113
I will believe it when I see it with the Hoosiers. They will be good, but champs? Not sure about that.
Agreed... the best part is that even though they likely have their best season in a LONG time... they are still set up for disappointment when they inevitably don't win the B1G
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13

Scarlet Shack

Heisman
Feb 3, 2004
26,408
16,328
73
People need to realize that the big ten having 9 bid a year isn’t a given . What the BIG-10 has done over the Two years getting 9 (and three years ago, it was at least 9,maybe 10 in the covid era). Is historical high numbers

Want to be safe …be too third in the big ten
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
I'm not sure his math works out, tbh.

We lost Harper (507), Baker (354), Jones (62), Agee (33), and Nathan (2).... that's 958 of our total 2192 points, for 56.3% of scoring returning. That'd still be 3rd on his list, but it makes me wonder if the other numbers are right.

I can get us to his 59.2% returning scoring number if I remove just Harper, Baker, and Agee.... and ignore the loss of Jones and Nathan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Indiana is losing Stewart (211), Phinisee (112), Durr (45), and Lander (38)... that's 406 of their 2478 points, for 83.6% returning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13

GM

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2020
1,597
2,703
51
I'm not sure his math works out, tbh.

We lost Harper (507), Baker (354), Jones (62), Agee (33), and Nathan (2).... that's 958 of our total 2192 points, for 56.3% of scoring returning. That'd still be 3rd on his list, but it makes me wonder if the other numbers are right.

I can get us to his 59.2% returning scoring number if I remove just Harper, Baker, and Agee.... and ignore the loss of Jones and Nathan.
Yeah, somehow his database or collection method is messed up, the original tweet he sent had us only returning like 28% of scoring. May not have flagged Jones as leaving or Nathan being part of his algorithm.I doubt he manually calculated all those numbers
 
  • Like
Reactions: MiloTalon13

kcg88

Heisman
Aug 11, 2017
10,862
17,230
0
This stat at best tells you nothing and at worst leads you down the complete wrong path. What's the quality of the shots that were taken to get those points? If one team is returning 75% of their points but 85% of their shot attempts, is that any good? Compared to a team bringing back 45% of their points and 40% of their shot attempts?
 

GM

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2020
1,597
2,703
51
This stat at best tells you nothing and at worst leads you down the complete wrong path. What's the quality of the shots that were taken to get those points? If one team is returning 75% of their points but 85% of their shot attempts, is that any good? Compared to a team bringing back 45% of their points and 40% of their shot attempts?
Yeah, it’s a stat that is now even more irrelevant with the transfer portal being the way it is. The two teams on the bottom are bringing in the best transfers of the conference and some great recruiting classes. Northwestern may return a decent bit yet probably not the scoring production you would have wanted to have returned. Ultimately stats like these do get overblown and it’s why preseason projections get messed up.
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
This stat at best tells you nothing and at worst leads you down the complete wrong path. What's the quality of the shots that were taken to get those points? If one team is returning 75% of their points but 85% of their shot attempts, is that any good? Compared to a team bringing back 45% of their points and 40% of their shot attempts?

It's not even accurate, so I'm pretty sure the "at best" option isn't available, either.
 

RutgersDom

All-American
Nov 18, 2003
6,163
7,546
113
They have two 5 stars coming in…both ranked in the 20’s overall. Not sold on Woodson as a college coach yet, but they should easily be the favorite….and possibly a Top 10 team.

Teams like Michigan and Illinois will just re-load but they both lost a lot. Can’t see Purdue being nearly as good either. Michigan State and Iowa also lost a lot.

IMO, we have a good shot to finish in the Top 3rd of the league this year. Anything less than top half for us is a dissappointment.
This is a sound take...
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Maybe it's B1G games only. I have no idea just guessing.
Couldn't get the numbers to work with conference only games, either. My guess is that the data is not correctly identifying what players have left vs are returning. If the database only marks Harper, Baker, and Agee as leaving, and has no flag on the rows for Jones and Nathan, the output would show what Rothstein is showing. My guess is the data quality is just poor for that particular value.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
Peter kiss was one of the leading scorers in the nation. If he came here you would have low expectations.

I expect us to be as tough as nails and will win the most 50/50 balls that we have ever seen. We will have more floor burns and bust our a$$ on D.

Anyone who is realistic is a tad worried on the offensive end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GM

GM

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2020
1,597
2,703
51
Peter kiss was one of the leading scorers in the nation. If he came here you would have low expectations.

I expect us to be as tough as nails and will win the most 50/50 balls that we have ever seen. We will have more floor burns and bust our a$$ on D.

Anyone who is realistic is a tad worried on the offensive end.
Agreed, going to be real interesting how we run the offense next year. Maybe we get a bit more creative or run sets better. Maybe someone takes a jump. But we certainly aren’t without fairly big concerns on that end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Greene Rice FIG

Scangg

Heisman
Mar 19, 2016
25,508
49,539
113
Peter kiss was one of the leading scorers in the nation. If he came here you would have low expectations.

I expect us to be as tough as nails and will win the most 50/50 balls that we have ever seen. We will have more floor burns and bust our a$$ on D.

Anyone who is realistic is a tad worried on the offensive end.
Spencer is an advanced analytics superstar
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,547
13,918
78
So were you in HS
First of all - Peter Kiss came in to RU averaging 3 turnovers a game in 29 minutes of action at Quinnipac. That’s a sign that at the next level the game may move too fast. The kid we’re bringing in averaged only 1.3 in over 36 minutes. So there’s that.

But the more important point of note is that we don’t really know what happened with Kiss in 2019-20. He averaged 6 ppg and over 18 minutes per game in 2018-19. He didn’t simply fall completely off the depth chart. Personality may be a factor there. He doesn’t exactly have a reputation of being a “nice kid” (I don’t remember the details but i remember there being a few Bryant stories and not just hot head emotional stuff). Cam Spencer has a reputation of being a class act model teammate on all counts. That’s important and a big reason I feel good about this addition.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
I am talking about post Rutgers Peter Kiss.

we won’t know how Spencer’s game translates to B1G until we see him play in B1G. I have no idea, but I am definitely making any assumptions that he plugs the Geo Baker hole adequately.

We have 2 separate dynamics at play….
1. Increased level of play
2. Bright lights of playing big time college basketball

In fantasy baseball I need to stop drafting people that switch teams. More often than not they underperform at their new team. How often do we find new players going to the Yankees (or Mets) struggle.

Steve Trout

or Ed Whitson

@zappaa
 
Last edited:

Eagleton95.99

All-American
Jul 25, 2001
7,562
6,490
113
I am talking about post Rutgers Peter Kiss.

we won’t know how Spencer’s game translates to B1G until we see him play in B1G. I have no idea, but I am definitely making any assumptions that he plugs the Geo Baker hole adequately.

We have 2 separate dynamics at play….
1. Increased level of play
2. Bright lights of playing big time college basketball

In fantasy baseball I need to stop drafting people that switch teams. More often than not they underperform at their new team. How often do we find new players going to the Yankees (or Mets) struggle.

Steve Trout
Regarding the Mets, it's not about switching teams. It's abut the Mets. When they switch to another team FROM the Mets they do great.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: RUChoppin

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,547
13,918
78
I am talking about post Rutgers Peter Kiss.

we won’t know how Spencer’s game translates to B1G until we see him play in B1G. I have no idea, but I am definitely making any assumptions that he plugs the Geo Baker hole adequately.

We have 2 separate dynamics at play….
1. Increased level of play
2. Bright lights of playing big time college basketball

In fantasy baseball I need to stop drafting people that switch teams. More often than not they underperform at their new team. How often do we find new players going to the Yankees (or Mets) struggle.

Steve Trout

It’s always a crap shoot with transfers. All I’m saying is it’s not necessarily fair to assume the Bryant version of Kiss (if he transferred into RU after playing 2+ years at Quinnipac and Bryant) would be identical to the one who came to us from Quinnipiac after only playing one season of collegiate basketball. Spencer has 2 full seasons (plus the short Covid year). Kiss probably did improve as a player over that time period and from his one season with Rutgers.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
It’s always a crap shoot with transfers. All I’m saying is it’s not necessarily fair to assume the Bryant version of Kiss (if he transferred into RU after playing 2+ years at Quinnipac and Bryant) would be identical to the one who came to us from Quinnipiac after only playing one season of collegiate basketball. Spencer has 2 full seasons (plus the short Covid year). Kiss probably did improve as a player over that time period and from his one season with Rutgers.
exactly it is a crapshoot with transfers....that is just my point.

I am not assuming anything with Spencer.
 

PSAL_Hoops

Heisman
Feb 18, 2008
14,547
13,918
78
exactly it is a crapshoot with transfers....that is just my point.

I am not assuming anything with Spencer.
But you are using Kiss as an example of a situation that didn’t work out. My point is that you can only consider the Quinnipac version of Kiss to make that point otherwise it’s not apples to apples. It doesn’t necessarily mean Spencer will work out, but he’s coming in as 3 year player who has consistently put up a lot better stats than Kiss did at Quinnipac.

Also - in fairness - while Kiss wasn’t the best defender - this wasn’t a situation like Jaden Jones where he was simply unplayable on that end. He played 18 mpg in 2018-19 which was more than Caleb and similar to Tez. It wasn’t like Pike had no other options. When JY and Paul came on board the following year I think it was more a case of us shifting to a faster paced style that didn’t really suit Kiss’ game with all the other guards we had. The Bryant version of Kiss would’ve helped Rutgers’ team last year as we played a half court style and he could score. He wouldn’t have started, but he could’ve contributed off the bench.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Notre Dame Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to Notre Dame in wild Players Era 8 OT showdown
  4. 04 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  5. 05 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three