Ash is not a Hicks Fan

LevaosLectures

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2015
3,977
3,156
0
Anyone else a little baffled by this. With our dearth of offensive weapons you would think there would be a role for a guy who is clearly one of the most physically talented on the team. This is a guy who ran for two hundred yards in a bowl game as a true freshman, who averaged over 5 yards a carry against a top 10 team just a few weeks ago....something mus be going on in practice, clearly, but I really believe the staff needs to find a role for this guy.
 
Last edited:

jerseyjustin

Junior
Nov 25, 2012
427
386
0
I wondered the same thing but Hicks struggles when it comes to pass-blocking (allegedly). If a RB can't do that then they're not going to see the field very often, and that's a fact.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jerzey devil

highsoxguy

Sophomore
Sep 19, 2015
113
137
0
And he single-handedly won the Army game last year in a tough spot - he's clearly talented and willing to do whatever it takes....
 
  • Like
Reactions: redking

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
Don't read too much into it. Nothing wrong with Hicks. Goodwin and Martin just passed him on the depth chart. That's all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AreYouNUTS

RUin2WIN

Senior
Sep 24, 2014
516
449
32
Don't read too much into it. Nothing wrong with Hicks. Goodwin and Martin just passed him on the depth chart. That's all.
I don't understand Goodwin passing Hicks to be honest. He's a good situational player and shifty towards the sidelines if we can get him in a screen or something similar on a second down. Other than that though in my opinion he goes down much easier than Hicks and lacks the explosiveness. I guess this is coming down to the pass block ability of the backs then?
 

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
The title of this thread is false, period.

He is doing punt returns and has been in on running plays.
 
Last edited:

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
I don't understand Goodwin passing Hicks to be honest. He's a good situational player and shifty towards the sidelines if we can get him in a screen or something similar on a second down. Other than that though in my opinion he goes down much easier than Hicks and lacks the explosiveness. I guess this is coming down to the pass block ability of the backs then?

Goodwin looked good against Iowa.
 

RUin2WIN

Senior
Sep 24, 2014
516
449
32
Goodwin looked good against Iowa.
Not saying he isn't good, and you're right he had some good plays against Iowa. Just in my opinion you don't drop a player who has proven he can produce multiple 100+ yd games behind a player who has been inconsistent in the past. I like all of our RBs though. Definitely a healthy stable.
 

RU2055

All-Conference
Sep 9, 2009
3,582
1,693
0
I don't understand Goodwin passing Hicks to be honest. He's a good situational player and shifty towards the sidelines if we can get him in a screen or something similar on a second down. Other than that though in my opinion he goes down much easier than Hicks and lacks the explosiveness. I guess this is coming down to the pass block ability of the backs then?

I agree Goodwin goes down easier than Hicks. Not sure about the explosiveness part. But it's more than just running per se. Pass block as you mentioned may be one reason. Another is Hicks and Martin are very similar runners while Goodwin is more of a change of pace. If Martin goes down, I think you'll see Hicks get majority of the carries rather than Goodwin.

They're all very good backs. But none are the dominant program changing "Ray Rice type."
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUin2WIN

hiwater

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2001
9,595
3,167
113
I wondered the same thing but Hicks struggles when it comes to pass-blocking (allegedly). If a RB can't do that then they're not going to see the field very often, and that's a fact.
That's just not true. He missed one block in the first game so some here are parroting this as his issue. The more they say it does not make it true. He has been a good blitz pickup blocker the last couple of years. One miss does not change that.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
15,322
9,520
113
I understand we are pretty stocked at RB.

But given the apparent lack of play makers, especially since Grant went down, I do wonder if we should be more creative in getting Hicks involved.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,377
113
Iowa
Goodwin: 11/74/6.7ypc
Hicks: 3/7/2.3ypc
Probably had something to do with it. Not a knock on Hicks, just Goodwin has a great game against Iowa.

Nobody ran particularly well last week, and just noticed Hicks had zero carries.
 

RUin2WIN

Senior
Sep 24, 2014
516
449
32
I agree Goodwin goes down easier than Hicks. Not sure about the explosiveness part. But it's more than just running per se. Pass block as you mentioned may be one reason. Another is Hicks and Martin are very similar runners while Goodwin is more of a change of pace. If Martin goes down, I think you'll see Hicks get majority of the carries rather than Goodwin.

They're all very good backs. But none are the dominant program changing "Ray Rice type."
I think with a better passing game Martin could have been the dominant program changing back honestly. He's managed to scrape yards even behind a questionable O-line and next to no deep threat, but who really knows. Maybe with a more dominant passing game we see much less of Martin and he still doesn't shine. It's all just speculation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruready07

RUSONIC

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2001
2,697
3,319
113
We have to stop questioning everything the coach decides to do when it comes to playing time. There are no conspiracies against certain players, it is just the way these coaches see the talent. Even in CL case, if any QB was better that CL he would be playing instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU2055

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
Everyone needs to keep in mind how playcalling affects the possible outcomes of these RBs opportunities.

Example: asking Hicks to run sideways when the opponent is stacking the line against the run.. which happens too often because of our QB limitations and playcalling as a result of that... not good for his yards-per-carry
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
That's just not true. He missed one block in the first game so some here are parroting this as his issue. The more they say it does not make it true. He has been a good blitz pickup blocker the last couple of years. One miss does not change that.

I don't think it's necessarily the pass blocking, but the overall role in the passing game. Hicks has no receptions this year (6 for Goodwin, 3 for Martin). For his career, he has 4 receptions for 25 yards (Goodwin has 38 for 285, Martin has 10 for 67). It doesn't appear as though Mehringer is seeing Hicks as a target in the passing game, which will also limit his time on the field at RB in this system.

So far this year, production has been:
Martin: 71 carries, 5.6 ypc; 3 rec, 8.3 ypr (74 touches, 5.7 per touch)
Goodwin: 32 carries, 4.5 ypc; 6 rec, 8.2 ypr (38 touches, 5.1 per touch)
Hicks: 27 carries, 4.7 ypc; 0 rec (27 touches, 4.7 per touch)

Martin is getting the most ypc on the ground, and Goodwin is providing more versatility as a receiver. A RB has to also function as a WR in this offense. Martin and Goodwin are both seeing more yards per touch so far this season... and the carries are split 55/25/20 between them.
 

NBKnight

Heisman
Jul 8, 2008
24,757
15,666
61
Not saying he isn't good, and you're right he had some good plays against Iowa. Just in my opinion you don't drop a player who has proven he can produce multiple 100+ yd games behind a player who has been inconsistent in the past. I like all of our RBs though. Definitely a healthy stable.

The staff is making their decison on what they see this year.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,628
61,992
113
Please change the title of this thread. Nothing to see hear. He just moved down the depth chart, that's all, SOMEONE has to.
 

imbazza2

Junior
Jul 9, 2009
612
276
0
I don't understand Goodwin passing Hicks to be honest. He's a good situational player and shifty towards the sidelines if we can get him in a screen or something similar on a second down. Other than that though in my opinion he goes down much easier than Hicks and lacks the explosiveness. I guess this is coming down to the pass block ability of the backs then?

SO TRUE hicks is not as good as Goodwin in picking up who to block but also getting between the rusher and the QB

That's just not true. He missed one block in the first game so some here are parroting this as his issue. The more they say it does not make it true. He has been a good blitz pickup blocker the last couple of years. One miss does not change that.

You are frack'ing not watching the games. I loved the one in the Iowa game hicks is in the backfield pumping his hands and feet and a D-line man runs right past him and almost sacks CL, as he throws an incomplete pass to Hicks no less. Yes is goes down as a hurry and an incomplete pass, but it was hicks failure to even attempt to block
 

Extra Point_rivals157299

All-Conference
Aug 9, 2001
13,166
4,692
0
Martin is better than Hicks. Goodwin is more of a complete player and is quicker. Hicks returning kicks looked like it was slow motion.
I agree. To me, Hicks is a power runner who is best when running north and south and blasts forward to get his yardage. If he tries to get the corner he is caught. A kick off guy needs to be fast. Terrell Willis was fast and did well and of course Grant. Hicks looks like a tractor on kick offs not a corvette.
 

RU old timer

Junior
Feb 26, 2015
594
316
0
Assessing Goodwin ahead of Hicks and assessing Laviano ahead of Rettig when we have the worst QB statistically in the country shows me we can assess talent accurately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ru-baby

jellyman_rivals307848

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
15,252
2,926
0
Anyone else a little baffled by this. With our dearth of offensive weapons you would think there would be a role for a guy who is clearly one of the most physically talented on the team. This is a guy who ran for two hundred yards in a bowl game as a true freshman, who averaged over 5 yards a carry against a top 10 team just a few weeks ago....something mus be going on in practice, clearly, but I really believe the staff needs to find a role for this guy.

I am a big Hicks fan, but even I have to admit Martin is running REALLY well the last few games ... heck, coming into the Ohio State game Martin WAS leading the Big Ten in rushing. And Martin did okay against Ohio State.

I actually think that Goodwin plays ahead of Hicks MAINLY in situational plays, while Hicks is the primary (not sole) back-up RB. Hicks does also play on special teams, though frankl;y, I would prefer to see Goodwin returning kicks, as he is faster than Hicks, and has been the #2 kick-off returner for 2 years now ... not sure why Hicks replaced both Grant AND Goodwin on kick off returns (Bailey was the 2nd returner back with Hicks in the last game, I think).
 

jsol_05

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2005
5,546
3,211
113
I am a big Hicks fan, but even I have to admit Martin is running REALLY well the last few games ... heck, coming into the Ohio State game Martin WAS leading the Big Ten in rushing. And Martin did okay against Ohio State.

I actually think that Goodwin plays ahead of Hicks MAINLY in situational plays, while Hicks is the primary (not sole) back-up RB. Hicks does also play on special teams, though frankl;y, I would prefer to see Goodwin returning kicks, as he is faster than Hicks, and has been the #2 kick-off returner for 2 years now ... not sure why Hicks replaced both Grant AND Goodwin on kick off returns (Bailey was the 2nd returner back with Hicks in the last game, I think).
Hicks is a good player, just may not be right for what the coaches are trying to fo. After a year Ash will know what players on the roster are his type of players and there will be a lot of movement after the season.
 

TM514

Junior
Nov 6, 2006
977
383
63
I'm not a fan of how Ash is handling some players. Obviously, he will favor and play his recruits. I didn't like him pulling Muller and Laviano at key points in games. You give your starters benefit of doubt, they may have a bad series or half but they are your starter.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start