Article on dook recruiting over players

BBUK_anon

Hall of Famer
May 26, 2005
52,358
124,843
0
My High School colors were Maroon and White. We may have the makings of Maroon and Maroon today... (Maybe...)
 

YouKay

Heisman
May 15, 2002
35,671
31,767
113
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is why you don't go to a school with 5 star bigs if you're a guard who can't shoot. Of course if you're Trevon Duval, you also can't read and write so you have to go to Duke.

Duke changed not only its entire recruiting philosophy, it also changed its offensive and defensive philosophy. That has served their players poorly and they haven't had all these 50-0 seasons people predicted. We can see now why Cal doesn't play zone all the time and has only done it when he has teams with length like this year's team. He knows the NBA requires you to play at least some defense, rebound, and pass the ball.

Malik Monk may have been pushed out the door, but not before Cal allowed him to have a 37 point game on national television and not before he forced him later to start rebounding and playing defense. That's why Monk has a better shot at making it in the NBA than Gary Trent Jr. does. Cal actually sacrificed Skal Labissiere's development in order to showcase his guards, Tyler Ulis and Jamal Murray. They are both tearing up the NBA now. And Skal is doing well, developing nicely as a power forward which he could not play at UK.

That article mentions Goodwin, Teague, and Harrison. Of course, Harrison wasn't OAD. Cal told him to come back and he did. He also told Goodwin and Teague to come back and they didn't.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
Duval and Trent are getting forced out of Duke, but they knew what they were getting into. Coach K is running a pro factory. He doesn’t need to develop players anymore. Future NBA stars are beating down his door to sign with him every season. If they wanted to take a slower route to the NBA, they could have signed somewhere else. No one is holding their hand at Duke, just like no one will hold their hand at the next level.
--------------------------------------

interesting close to the article.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JC43
Jan 3, 2003
145,534
15,709
0
There are good and bad points made in the story.
"Coach K has beaten John Calipari at his own game the past few seasons". What!
I think their recruiting class rankings have been pretty even the past few seasons (since K adopted Cal's model). As have the draft outcomes.

Yes, Duke has had a top 3 pick in each of the last 4 drafts, but only 3 other OAD first round picks.
UK has had a top 7 pick in the last 4 drafts, AND 6 other OAD first round picks.

2014 Duke: Parker #2, Hood #23 (not OAD, a transfer)
2014 UK: Randle #7, Young #17

2015 Duke: Okafor #3, Winsolow #10, Jones #24
2015 UK: Towns #1, Lyles #12, Booker #13, WCS #6 (not OAD, JR)

2016 Duke: Ingram #2
2016 UK: Murray #7, Labissierre #28

2017 Duke: Tatum #3, Giles, #20, Kennard #12 (not OAD, SOPH)
2017 UK: Fox #5, Monk #11, Adebayo #14

So in those 4 years, looking at the combined OAD draft positions:
Duke: 2, 2, 3, 3, 10, 20, 24
UK: 1, 5, 7, 7, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 28
I don't think you can say Coach K has beaten Cal. It's close, at most a draw, although I would give Cal the advantage (3 more OAD 1st round picks, 9 in the top 19 compared to 4).
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
Duval and Trent are getting forced out of Duke, but they knew what they were getting into. Coach K is running a pro factory. He doesn’t need to develop players anymore. Future NBA stars are beating down his door to sign with him every season. If they wanted to take a slower route to the NBA, they could have signed somewhere else. No one is holding their hand at Duke, just like no one will hold their hand at the next level.
--------------------------------------

interesting close to the article.
I agree with that, and I think it applies just as much at UK.

If a kid wants the fastest possible route to the pros, he can't expect to be coddled, and he needs to realize that the coach can't just hold his spot open because things didn't go as well as planned. If a kid comes to school planning to leave after 1 year, the coach needs to plan to replace him after 1 year. If the player does decide to come back, he should expect competition.

It would be nice to be able to balance out true studs with more multi-year development projects, but the reality is that's almost impossible, because when the development project turns out well (see Devin Booker and Tyler Ulis for 2 good examples), he's likely to bolt earlier than expected.

To me this means that guys like Diallo, Richards, and Gabriel need to think long and hard about their futures at UK. They've all been given shots to prove themselves, but none of those 3 has really done so yet. So they need to decide if they can handle a UK career somewhat like Alex Poythress had (meaning get an education and wait your turn, while often playing behind better pro prospects), or if they need to move on. If I'm Cal, and I think Keldon Johnson gives the team a better shot to win than Diallo, or EJ Montgomery is superior to Richards, then those are the guys who eat first.
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
I agree with that, and I think it applies just as much at UK.

If a kid wants the fastest possible route to the pros, he can't expect to be coddled, and he needs to realize that the coach can't just hold his spot open because things didn't go as well as planned. If a kid comes to school planning to leave after 1 year, the coach needs to plan to replace him after 1 year. If the player does decide to come back, he should expect competition.

It would be nice to be able to balance out true studs with more multi-year development projects, but the reality is that's almost impossible, because when the development project turns out well (see Devin Booker and Tyler Ulis for 2 good examples), he's likely to bolt earlier than expected.

To me this means that guys like Diallo, Richards, and Gabriel need to think long and hard about their futures at UK. They've all been given shots to prove themselves, but none of those 3 has really done so yet. So they need to decide if they can handle a UK career somewhat like Alex Poythress had (meaning get an education and wait your turn, while often playing behind better pro prospects), or if they need to move on. If I'm Cal, and I think Keldon Johnson gives the team a better shot to win than Diallo, or EJ Montgomery is superior to Richards, then those are the guys who eat first.

not sure I agree with that completely - for example, Gabriel could turn into a consistent 3 point shooter on the wing and a defender - and regardless of who is playing behind him, that skillset will demand significant playing time. So just because he has had two shots to prove himself to so to speak doesn't mean the light bulb doesn't go off next year and the kid turns into a poor mans Kevin Durant

If Cal chooses to put a 5 star freshmen in ahead of Gabriel when Gabriel can provide more value to the team, just because Gabriel has already had his shot the previous year, then that's a mistake on many levels - and its not good coaching.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
not sure I agree with that completely - for example, Gabriel could turn into a consistent 3 point shooter on the wing and a defender - and regardless of who is playing behind him, that skillset will demand significant playing time. So just because he has had two shots to prove himself to so to speak doesn't mean the light bulb doesn't go off next year and the kid turns into a poor mans Kevin Durant

If Cal chooses to put a 5 star freshmen in ahead of Gabriel when Gabriel can provide more value to the team, just because Gabriel has already had his shot the previous year, then that's a mistake on many levels - and its not good coaching.
It's good coaching if he thinks that the player is better than Gabriel.

And a lot depends on what Gabriel wants. If he wants to be the focus of a team, that ship has sailed unless he shows huge improvement. If he can handle being a role player, great. If he can't handle it, or wants any kind of promise of more, then there's a potential problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FrankUnderwood

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
It's good coaching if he thinks that the player is better than Gabriel.

And a lot depends on what Gabriel wants. If he wants to be the focus of a team, that ship has sailed unless he shows huge improvement. If he can handle being a role player, great. If he can't handle it, or wants any kind of promise of more, then there's a potential problem.

better in - at some point or better as in - at this moment in time?

what Gabriel wants or doesn't want is irrelevant really - as it should be with all players. Its about what can you deliver.

You put the best team out on the court to win - whether that is today or in March, but not because of some perception or strategy for the following year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: awf

WildMoon

Heisman
Apr 7, 2009
78,693
11,120
0
I don't mind coaches recruiting over a player .

Are we supposed to just maintain the weakness we have year before?

I don't care if Cal gets Wiseman and Carey. I won't feel bad about Nick Richards. Earned not given.
 
Mar 23, 2007
12,053
3,107
0
Surprised by Monk’s comments in that article. Didn’t know he was open to staying.

I think the writer most likely did not accurately reflect the context of Monk’s comment. Cal didn’t have to ask Monk to leave much less “kick him out of the program”. Anyone who paid attention to what Monk wanted is what all elite players want, to play one year in college and then make millions by getting drafted in the first round. I don’t believe for one instant that the quote attributed to Monk accurately reflects what Monk intended to communicate.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
better in - at some point or better as in - at this moment in time?

what Gabriel wants or doesn't want is irrelevant really - as it should be with all players. Its about what can you deliver.

You put the best team out on the court to win - whether that is today or in March, but not because of some perception or strategy for the following year.
What Gabriel wants is very relevant as to whether he should stay at UK.

Let's put it this way. Do you think UK would have been better off this year if Isaiah Briscoe had stayed in school?

Personally, I don't. For one thing, I don't think he really wanted to be here any more, and for another, I don't think the team would have been better with him at PG than what they ended up with in SGA, even if Briscoe was the best PG on the roster on November 1st.

This is actually far more relevant to Diallo than Gabriel, BTW. Gabriel has a relatively established role, and the only problem comes if he wants more. Diallo could easily lose his role. Ditto Richards.

It's great if everyone embraces the competition, but the reality is that only 8-9 players are likely to have meaningful roles with the team. Not every player is going to accept a change in role, or waiting his turn, and if they don't, they should probably leave.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KDCats11

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
I think the writer most likely did not accurately reflect the context of Monk’s comment. Cal didn’t have to ask Monk to leave much less “kick him out of the program”. Anyone who paid attention to what Monk wanted is what all elite players want, to play one year in college and then make millions by getting drafted in the first round. I don’t believe for one instant that the quote attributed to Monk accurately reflects what Monk intended to communicate.
Yep.

Cal kicked Fox, Monk, and Adebayo off the team to the extent that he knew all 3 were going to enter the draft, so he basically told them to get it over with. That's always been his philosophy. If a player is obviously leaving, and obviously going in or near the lottery, then go.

Knox seemed to be a little different, because he's so young for his class, and genuinely seemed to consider staying (or maybe his father was just blowing smoke. Who knows), but with every lottery pick Cal's had, it's pretty much been "I did my job, you did yours, now go get paid".
 

caneintally

Heisman
Oct 1, 2002
27,455
17,056
0
That article is a complete load of nonsense. His whole take on Duval is silly. Duval is what he is - a guard who can't shoot who trends to selfish play . He really has no business being one and done but he thinks he does. Sorta in the sense Diallo is . Trent I know won't be drafted high but that kid will be a damn good NBA and a starter IMO . He is elite shooter and scorer.
 
Apr 15, 2017
398
304
0
IMO, it is a horrible race to the bottom. I don't like the OAD era and believe Coach Cal (and Coach K) would be even more successful without OADs as he is a great teacher. Imagine the kind of defense the kids would play with 2 or more years of Coach Cal's tutelage.
 

BlueBlood66_rivals34314

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2012
3,469
1,233
0
Here’s a fact: Duval shot a higher percentage from three in 2018 than Trae Young. (This doesn’t mean I think Duval is a better shooter, just some perspective)
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
What Gabriel wants is very relevant as to whether he should stay at UK.

Let's put it this way. Do you think UK would have been better off this year if Isaiah Briscoe had stayed in school?

Personally, I don't. For one thing, I don't think he really wanted to be here any more, and for another, I don't think the team would have been better with him at PG than what they ended up with in SGA, even if Briscoe was the best PG on the roster on November 1st.
.

I think a key thing here however is that Briscoe is/was a member of the team until he isn't anymore. This idea that you didn't turn out as good as we hoped, therefore its time for you to move on its the antithesis of college sports. We *aren't* a professional team, we are a college basketball program comprised on student athletes. In no way should Briscoe (or any other player) feel pressured to leave college as a scholarship player in good standing just because the program has better options out there. Now Briscoe coming back with reduced role is fine, as long as that reduced role is because the player replacing him is a better player - not based on potential to be drafted but actually contributes more on the court/practice than Briscoe.

The program has an obligation to support any player that is in good standing with the program, not just the ones that are playing to their full potential.


Not only is pushing a player out the antithesis of a college program but its pretty much a slap in the face of a players first mantra.

Sorry, we have better options, you thought you were one and done , so did we and we've replaced you.

I don't think that is what you are saying but the distinction isn't as clear as I think it should be.

I can't support that, and I don't think our program operates that way - hence Montgomery and Hagan waiting to annouce until Knox and SGA determine what they are going to do.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
That article is a complete load of nonsense. His whole take on Duval is silly. Duval is what he is - a guard who can't shoot who trends to selfish play . He really has no business being one and done but he thinks he does. Sorta in the sense Diallo is . Trent I know won't be drafted high but that kid will be a damn good NBA and a starter IMO . He is elite shooter and scorer.
The writer isn't looking at things from a college perspective, he's looking at things from an NBA player development perspective.

The NBA didn't get to see the things from Duval that he would be expected to do as a pro, and even if he stayed, he still wouldn't get a chance to do those things.

But you're right in that, if he'd been a better player, it wouldn't be that much of a problem.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
I think a key thing here however is that Briscoe is/was a member of the team until he isn't anymore. This idea that you didn't turn out as good as we hoped, therefore its time for you to move on its the antithesis of college sports. We *aren't* a professional team, we are a college basketball program comprised on student athletes. In no way should Briscoe (or any other player) should feel pressured to leave college as a scholarship player in good standing just because the program has better options out there. Now Briscoe coming back with reduced role is fine, as long as that reduced role is because the player replacing him is a better player - not based on potential to be drafted but actually contributes more on the court/practice than Briscoe.

The program has an obligation to support any player that is in good standing with the program, not just the ones that are playing to their full potential.


Not only is that that antithesis of a college athlete but its pretty much a slap in the face of a players first mantra.

Sorry, we have better options, you thought you were one and done and we've replaced you.

I don't think that is what you are saying but the distinction isn't as clear as I think it should be.

I can't support that, and I don't think our program operates that way - hence Montgomery and Hagan waiting to annouce until Knox and SGA determine what they are going to do.
Yeah, because it's not what I'm saying at all.

I'm mainly saying that if you're coming to UK to train to be a professional basketball player (which is pretty much every recruit Cal signs), part of being a professional basketball player is the possibility of losing your role to someone who is better than you.

If you're in the NBA, and you're a middling starting PG on a bad team, and that team drafts a PG in the top 5, guess what's going to happen?

UK shouldn't operate all that differently, and would, in some ways, be doing a disservice to the players if it did.

But no one is talking about pulling scholarships, "cutting" guys, or encouraging anyone to transfer. "Replace" in this context just means there's never going to be (and shouldn't be) a guarantee that UK won't recruit someone better than you for next year, or the year after, and so on.
 
Last edited:

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
Yeah, because it's not what I'm saying at all.

I'm mainly saying that if you're coming to UK to train to be a professional basketball player (which is pretty much every recruit Cal signs), part of being a professional basketball player is the possibility of losing your role to someone who is better than you.

If you're in the NBA, and you're a middling starting PG on a bad team, and that team drafts a PG in the top 5, guess what's going to happen?

UK shouldn't operate all that differently, and would, in some ways, be doing a disservice to the players if it did.

But no ones talking about pulling scholarships, "cutting" guys, or encouraging anyone to transfer. "Replace" in this context just means there's never going to be (and shouldn't be) a guarantee that UK won't recruit someone better than you for next year, or the year after, and so on.


Then why would you frame your response this way?

Let's put it this way. Do you think UK would have been better off this year if Isaiah Briscoe had stayed in school?

Personally, I don't. For one thing, I don't think he really wanted to be here any more, and for another, I don't think the team would have been better with him at PG than what they ended up with in SGA, even if Briscoe was the best PG on the roster on November 1st.
 

MdWIldcat55

Heisman
Dec 9, 2007
21,733
87,994
113
Why do programs like Kentucky and now Duke get the best possible players even if that means recruiting over someone? Because they can.

Because having the most talent, even if its young talent, is still the most viable way to have a realistic shot at success every year. Sure, a program like Villanova will occasionally succeed with 4-star juniors. But for every VIllanova that pulls it off, there are 270 programs with ordinary talent that have zero shot at a Final Four. Kentucky has had a realistic shot at the Final Four or beyond 6 or 7 of Cal's 9 years. The Cats made it four times, were a bum ref from making a fifth time and a bad shooting game from making it a sixth time. What program without consistent 5-star talent has come close to that continual level of success since 2009? NONE.

So, what does that mean for the players? You get a great chance to showcase your talent on the most high profile stage. And, percentage wise, if your goal is the NBA you couldn't possibly do better than to play for Cal at Kentucky. What percentage of Jay Wright's players or John Beilein's are in the NBA? I'd say close to HALF of Cal's recruits at Kentucky have played in the NBA.

Not everyone is going to succeed and make a stable NBA career. But do you really think any of the players who have come through Kentucky under Cal would have succeeded more at Maryland or Mississippi State or Southern Cal? The NBA is a ruthless Darwinian struggle. Kentucky prepares you for that better than anywhere else. That's all you can ask for.
 
Last edited:

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
Then why would you frame your response this way?
Because I think it's true?

Do you really think anyone at UK somehow actively encouraged Briscoe to leave? I don't. He would have had a spot on the team had he wanted it, and I'm sure Cal would have found a way to make it work as well as possible. However, because of who Briscoe was, and because of how he viewed himself, I think it was probably better for him to leave. I think he would have potentially caused problems if he wasn't the 30 mpg starter at point, and the reality is that SGA turned out to be a much better player.

If Gabriel, Diallo, Richards, or anyone else is willing to accept whatever role they earn, great. If they expect to be catered to in any way, not so great.

When guys like Wiltjer and Matthews transfer, I have no real problem with it. They had chances at UK, they saw the level of competition they were dealing with, and they knew they had a chance for a lot more security elsewhere. Cal didn't begrudge them for their choices, and they didn't leave complaining that they were treated unfairly.

Don't come to UK (or Duke) and expect a high level of security. You don't get that in the pros, and you won't get it at UK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KDCats11

KyFaninNC

Heisman
Mar 14, 2005
195,719
24,518
0
But,but,but. According to a few posters here that say Cal does not kick players out. Monk just proved all of you wrong.

If you want to run a OAD program you have to recruit over players. That means you have to kick some out, whether they are ready or not.
 

docholiday51

Heisman
Oct 19, 2001
22,011
26,718
0
Skimmed the article.It seemed pretty fair and reasonable. The thoughts I have on the subject. Recruiting OAD's is like being an OAD player,it is a year by year process.Once the recruiting for any one year is done that year doesn't matter anymore,it is over.Recruiting success is measured in one year segments,in the previous 2 cycles K has beaten Cal both times in recruiting,however he has failed to capitalize on his success so far(current results remain to be seen next season) What a coach can or can't do with a given recruiting class is a whole separate matter for consideration and can be viewed collectively over a longer term.Cal is clearly better than K when it cones to using and preparing talent for the next level. If an elite player fails to see this then he is not paying attention or doing his homework.If your goal is not only to get to the NBA but succeed there as early as possible then Cal vs K is no contest unless there are other factors in play.

Cal coaching the U19 team cost him last year and we can speculate about shoe companies and money all day long.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KyFaninNC

ZaytovenCat

All-American
Apr 25, 2013
24,121
8,953
97
“ But once he’d finished addressing the entire team, Calipari wanted to deliver another message to three of his stars: point guard De’Aaron Fox, shooting guard Malik Monk, and center Bam Adebayo. For many teams, in many years, this would be a moment of talking about the future, of challenging young stars to commit themselves in the offseason to carrying the team even further the next spring. Not now.

“Basically,” says Monk, “he kicked us off the team.”

Kind of. Monk, Fox, and Adebayo were all slated as likely lottery picks in the upcoming NBA draft. They’d arrived in Lexington only a few months ago, and now, Calipari told them, it was time for them to go. “He said, ‘We’ve got another group of recruits coming in,’” Monk remembers. “‘There’s not room for you. You gotta go.’ He really kicked us out.” (Calipari declined to be interviewed for this piece.

———————————

^ that is absolutely sickening. Pisses me off to no end. Just confirms what we already knew though, atleast ones who weren’t in denial. I wonder who Cal has pushed out and cost us that would have came back. Cousins and Towns are candidates, MKG as well. What a joke.
 
May 9, 2002
2,542
310
0
But,but,but. According to a few posters here that say Cal does not kick players out. Monk just proved all of you wrong.

If you want to run a OAD program you have to recruit over players. That means you have to kick some out, whether they are ready or not.

From that same article,

“When he told me I was off the team,” says Monk, “I was so happy. It was a big step to the biggest dream in my life coming true.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lumpy 2

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
well, lets be fair - Monk wasn't considering coming back. Cal figuratively tearing up his scholarship was just a dramatic way of Cal saying you're ready to go - and its a huge recruiting tool to future recruits who want the same thing to happen to them.

To me the point of discussion is the Diallo level player - who has bought into the one and done mentality and can't rationalize why he needs to be on the team and faces the reality that the guy coming in next year may have as much slack to reach their potential as he did this year - meaning a reduced role for Diallo because he is a "known" quantity.

My point has been that should never be the case - Diallo should get first consideration and should be beat out for his spot in practice/games by an incoming freshmen. The idea that a kid coming in should be given a priority simply because he has a 5 star designation by his name is wrong, IMO.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
well, lets be fair - Monk wasn't considering coming back. Cal figuratively tearing up his scholarship was just a dramatic way of Cal saying you're ready to go - and its a huge recruiting tool to future recruits who want the same thing to happen to them.

To me the point of discussion is the Diallo level player - who has bought into the one and done mentality and can't rationalize why he needs to be on the team and faces the reality that the guy coming in next year may have as much slack to reach their potential as he did this year - meaning a reduced role for Diallo because he is a "known" quantity.

My point has been that should never be the case - Diallo should get first consideration and should be beat out for his spot in practice/games by an incoming freshmen. The idea that a kid coming in should be given a priority simply because he has a 5 star designation by his name is wrong, IMO.

There's almost always a good reason a kid has a 5 star designation by his name.

And a funny thing about this is that people bitched up a storm about the Harrison twins playing ahead of Ulis and Booker, bitched up a storm about how much Briscoe played, and bitched up a storm about how much slack Diallo was given this year. So someone comes in who is potentially better, and Diallo should get the benefit of the doubt? Why?
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
There's almost always a good reason a kid has a 5 star designation by his name.

And a funny thing about this is that people bitched up a storm about the Harrison twins playing ahead of Ulis and Booker, bitched up a storm about how much Briscoe played, and bitched up a storm about how much slack Diallo was given this year. So someone comes in who is potentially better, and Diallo should get the benefit of the doubt? Why?

you answered your own question. Because they are potentially better. Playing time is not guaranteed,remember?

you may get drafted on potential but you don't win games with it.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
you answered your own question. Because they are potentially better. Playing time is not guaranteed,remember?
Now you're talking out of both sides of your mouth.

Diallo should get preference because he has experience.

But it was perfectly OK that fans were clamoring for more Ulis and Booker over the Harrison twins, because Ulis and Booker had more potential than the Harrison twins.

You're basically asking for Cal to be a psychic. Defer to the experienced guys in cases where the 5 star freshmen don't turn out to be as good as advertised (which he's somehow supposed to know before he sees them play any real games), but go for the freshmen when they have more potential than the experienced guys (which, again, he's supposed to know before seeing them play actual games).
 

FrankUnderwood

Heisman
May 26, 2017
15,912
27,971
0
But,but,but. According to a few posters here that say Cal does not kick players out. Monk just proved all of you wrong.

If you want to run a OAD program you have to recruit over players. That means you have to kick some out, whether they are ready or not.


Lol
 

TankedCat

Heisman
Nov 8, 2006
22,792
21,500
0
Now you're talking out of both sides of your mouth.

Diallo should get preference because he has experience.

But it was perfectly OK that fans were clamoring for more Ulis and Booker over the Harrison twins, because Ulis and Booker had more potential than the Harrison twins.

You're basically asking for Cal to be a psychic. Defer to the experienced guys in cases where the 5 star freshmen don't turn out to be as good as advertised (which he's somehow supposed to know before he sees them play any real games), but go for the freshmen when they have more potential than the experienced guys (which, again, he's supposed to know before seeing them play actual games).

so I say one thing, then you refer to the fans saying another and I'm talking out of both sides of my mouth?

its actually pretty simple - instead of going by the hype, go by the actual contribution the player is currently making.

If Ulis and Booker were killing it in practice and in the games then they earn it, if not, they watch and work harder.

Lets flip it around, lets say SGA decided to come back regardless of where he was going to be drafted, you think Quickley should get the nod to start because he has the potential to be better than SGA?

potential shouldn't be used in the equation ever. Day 1 you line them up - whoever is better gets is starting the next game. After that it an ongoing evaluation as to who is the best contributor.
 

mjj_2K

All-American
Jul 11, 2010
12,603
7,296
113
so I say one thing, then you refer to the fans saying another and I'm talking out of both sides of my mouth?

its actually pretty simple - instead of going by the hype, go by the actual contribution the player is currently making.

If Ulis and Booker were killing it in practice and in the games then they earn it, if not, they watch and work harder.

Lets flip it around, lets say SGA decided to come back regardless of where he was going to be drafted, you think Quickley should get the nod to start because he has the potential to be better than SGA?

potential shouldn't be used in the equation ever. Day 1 you line them up - whoever is better gets is starting the next game. After that it an ongoing evaluation as to who is the best contributor.
You are completely, totally wrong about that.

And it's stupid and short-sighted.

No team sport on the planet operates like that, BTW, on any level. If Mike Trout is potentially Mike Trout, he's going to play as a 20 year old hitting .230 over some 30 year old average player who could probably contribute more right then and there. Every team sport in the world sees teams that sacrifice a little bit on the here and now because of potential future pay-off.
 

mustnotsleepnow

All-Conference
May 18, 2011
1,923
1,328
57
“ But once he’d finished addressing the entire team, Calipari wanted to deliver another message to three of his stars: point guard De’Aaron Fox, shooting guard Malik Monk, and center Bam Adebayo. For many teams, in many years, this would be a moment of talking about the future, of challenging young stars to commit themselves in the offseason to carrying the team even further the next spring. Not now.

“Basically,” says Monk, “he kicked us off the team.”

Kind of. Monk, Fox, and Adebayo were all slated as likely lottery picks in the upcoming NBA draft. They’d arrived in Lexington only a few months ago, and now, Calipari told them, it was time for them to go. “He said, ‘We’ve got another group of recruits coming in,’” Monk remembers. “‘There’s not room for you. You gotta go.’ He really kicked us out.” (Calipari declined to be interviewed for this piece.

———————————

^ that is absolutely sickening. Pisses me off to no end. Just confirms what we already knew though, atleast ones who weren’t in denial. I wonder who Cal has pushed out and cost us that would have came back. Cousins and Towns are candidates, MKG as well. What a joke.

I get it. Not really...but kinda.

However, none of those three were ever coming back. Except MAYBE Bam. MAYBE.

Guarantee Fox and Monk were one and done no matter what. And there's nothing wrong with that.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Where Kentucky sits in updated AP, Coaches Polls following loss at Mizzou
  2. 02 KSR Football SEC Officials Made an Egregious Error in Kentucky vs. Missouri
  3. 03 KSR Dethroned: Kentucky VB’s SEC title streak snapped, but chance for redemption is alive
  4. 04 KSR Football Kentucky will host Louisville as an underdog at Kroger Field
  5. 05 KSR Football KSR Today: Kentucky officially out of CFP race, but what's next?