Army vs. Rutgers Football

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Not worth playing them. Preparing to play them was always some of my worst game prep weeks. Injuries also always occur with the amount of cut blocks you see.
The injuries argument is lacking actual facts. Posted info multiple times but people just keep spilling this crap.
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,690
0
When a game is over -and a reporter asks Monken what the problem was on a broken play - he knows the answer. No "I have the worst seat in the house and have to see the tape." I've seen him say how an OL "didn't have his hands in the right position" when the play was busted. I've never heard him say "I don't know."

Schiano was always an option killer

The best home game coming-up at USMA is Air Force (Nov 2)


 
Last edited:

gef21

All-American
Jan 25, 2005
4,575
9,397
0
The injuries argument is lacking actual facts. Posted info multiple times but people just keep spilling this crap.
In my coaching experience we always had injuries playing against them beyond our normal statistical numbers.

Even taking the injuries out preparing for an offense you only see once is a pain.
 

Charles Grevious

All-Conference
Staff member
Aug 16, 2011
3,070
4,010
93
I just went and watched 2 minutes and 45 seconds of army highlights from 2024. I counted 3 cut blocks in the 10 clips. One from a tackle, one from a guard, and one from a RB.
Respectfully speaking, that is probably why you are on the message board and not in the coaching booth. #IamJustSaying!
 
Dec 17, 2008
45,214
16,775
0
I just went and watched 2 minutes and 45 seconds of army highlights from 2024. I counted 3 cut blocks in the 10 clips. One from a tackle, one from a guard, and one from a RB.

Yes you can but it’s limited so it essentially handicapped their offense to a point where he had to tweak it a bit. I think last year they ran out of the shotgun more but he wasnt happy with that and this year they’re under center again with some shotgun mixed in.


Even a USC receiver got a questionable penalty in the PSU game for a block which was deemed below the waist (I didn’t think it was). So it’s quite limited as to what you’re allowed to do.

From the articles:

The NCAA Football Rules Committee on Friday moved to ban all below-the-waist blocking outside the tackle box. Furthermore, any player who is not a lineman or a "stationary back inside the tackle box" would be prohibited from throwing cut blocks, period.

The committee cited data that shows passing the rule would cut down on the number of knee injuries suffered over the course of the season. "This proposal is a continuation of the committee's effort to enhance student-athlete safety," said Steve Shaw, secretary-rules editor.




People don’t want to have to defend it,” Monken says. “They don’t want to have to teach the cut block. It eliminates having to teach that fundamental skill. It eliminates them having to defend the offense because it’s going to be really difficult to run this offense the way we ran it without being able to block below the waist and those linebackers in the box that are screaming to the perimeter that you can’t cut-block anymore.”

Monken says he was surprised at how much the new rules limited the offense.

You can’t use a tackle and loop them and cut [defenders],” Monken says. “You can’t run the fullback out of the back field and cut. You can’t use the slot back and load them and cut them. All those blocks were effective from keeping the linebackers from getting out there, and everything we do is full flow under center.”
Monken had to go back to the drawing board, and he thought back to a chance meeting with a football mind that, as he described, was “smart as s---.”

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gef21

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,664
151,490
113
Army nor Navy are really worth playing at this point. They are good enough to compete but don't have any value when you win.

It's a lose lose. Play an SEC team OOC, which with the scheduling agreement that is being negotiated, is likely going to happen.
 

LETSGORU91

All-American
Jan 29, 2017
7,201
7,952
113
I just went and watched 2 minutes and 45 seconds of army highlights from 2024. I counted 3 cut blocks in the 10 clips. One from a tackle, one from a guard, and one from a RB.

Respectfully speaking, that is probably why you are on the message board and not in the coaching booth. #IamJustSaying!
@gef21 watched a short clip, and made an assessment which seems solid (if true). How does that lend to the conclusion he should "not be in the coaching booth"?
 

WhiteBus

Heisman
Oct 4, 2011
39,520
21,922
113
Army nor Navy are really worth playing at this point. They are good enough to compete but don't have any value when you win.

It's a lose lose. Play an SEC team OOC, which with the scheduling agreement that is being negotiated, is likely going to happen.
They are better then Howard and Akron. We get nothing from them either. Army and Navy would fill up Shi and maybe the two best away experiences on the North East Coast.
 
  • Like
Reactions: newell138

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
Complete nonsense and the so-called blocking you are referring to is no longer legal. You don't hear ND fans complaining and they play Navy every year.
Hm... My vast experience with ND fans is that they complain about everything. Usually loudly and obnoxiously.

It all starts with the typical ND fan's expectation that opponents should, instead of daring to tackle or block ND players, be in the ND locker room washing ND uniforms or shining ND cleats. And then it starts to get really arrogant.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gef21

LETSGORU91

All-American
Jan 29, 2017
7,201
7,952
113
He put a like on @gef21 's response. Relax
I was only trying to figure out what his thought process was, that's all. But you said the dude responded AND put a like on his response? It makes alot more sense to me now....thanks for talking me off the ledge.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gef21

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
I don't know about all this "relax" stuff. I'd really like to stay hyped up for the time being, if that's okay with everyone.
 

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,953
38,855
113
Gef is 100 % correct. And it may not mean that a player is out the next game- but the hits you take in the game have an effect.
Also- as much as we love our Cadets and Midshipmen for who they are any what they are giving the country- on the field- they are two of the dirtiest teams. Forget about pile ups- just everything you can think of like it is hand to hand

You get done with them and it is 1000 cuts vs a single bruise
 
  • Like
Reactions: gef21

megadrone

Senior
Jul 10, 2003
24,131
894
56
I would like to play either -- but I don't know how well they can work it into their OOC. They both will have Air Force and the Army-Navy game is technically an OOC game. Navy also has Notre Dame. Maybe we could play Army -- good solid regional game. But our admin wants cupcakes at home.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
I would like to play either -- but I don't know how well they can work it into their OOC. They both will have Air Force and the Army-Navy game is technically an OOC game. Navy also has Notre Dame. Maybe we could play Army -- good solid regional game. But our admin wants cupcakes at home.
There's no value to our FB program in playing the academies. It makes no sense at all.

Meanwhile, there is value to scheduling cupcakes. It makes getting to bowl games easier and winning, even against cupcakes, helps with recruiting (vs losing to non-cupcakes, at least).
 

megadrone

Senior
Jul 10, 2003
24,131
894
56
There's no value to our FB program in playing the academies. It makes no sense at all.

Meanwhile, there is value to scheduling cupcakes. It makes getting to bowl games easier and winning, even against cupcakes, helps with recruiting (vs losing to non-cupcakes, at least).
As a season ticket holder, my concern is my own entertainment! 3 cupcakes, and getting slaughtered in conference play, doesn't move the needle. I can't be the only season ticket holder that feels this way (even though there aren't enough season ticket holders).
 

HeavenUniv.

Heisman
Sep 21, 2004
135,536
16,405
0
If the Big Ten/SEC scheduling alliance goes through, it doesn’t sound like any games will be played against Group of Five schools. Not even sure games will be played against Big 12 or ACC schools .
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,274
0
As a season ticket holder, my concern is my own entertainment! 3 cupcakes, and getting slaughtered in conference play, doesn't move the needle. I can't be the only season ticket holder that feels this way (even though there aren't enough season ticket holders).
I understand that POV completely.

I'm just stating the logical argument. Right now, the most logical thing to do is whatever helps the team win as many games as possible, including beating some cupcakes at the start of the year. That's how GS built up the program the first time around and everyone (including me) complained about it back then.

But it worked. If we can't get to bowl games, then we can't recruit, and we will wind up having 2 or 3 win seasons. If that happens, all the season ticket holders go away anyway.

So first we need to win games against cupcakes. Build the program up to the point where bowl games are almost certain and there's a very real possibility of 8+ wins per season. Keep that going for 5-10 years, see if it's possible to get to 9 or 10 win seasons. And then eliminate the cupcakes. Harder to do than say, but that's the formula.

I'm pretty sure that if the team is winning regularly, every season, even against a couple cupcakes, will bring in plenty of new season ticket holders to replace those that leave because they want better competition for the early season OOC games.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Men's Soccer earns NCAA Tournament berth for first time since 2022
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football versus Michigan State Game Time Announced
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball Rutgers vs. Albany: How to Watch, Starting Lineups, Rankings & More
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Wrestling Takes Down No. 13 Lehigh - Breaking Down Huge Ranked Win - TKR Pod
  5. 05 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026