Are we doing more with less or did the recruiting gurus get it wrong?

Feb 18, 2014
437
8
18
Read an article on the espn sec blog about who has done more with less us or ga tech. For some reason this quote irked me... "Mississippi State's offense ranks top 10 nationally in yards per game, and not one starter was ranked in the ESPN 150 recruiting rankings." Why is it impossible to admit that a player has developed into better than his recruiting ranking or heaven forbid a recruiting guru missed on him. I guess it's because espn covers recruiting and admitting they were wrong on a player(s) is bad for business but still it's dumb. What's more logical.. "Man that Prescott is playing out of his mind to overcome that 3 star ranking" or maybe just maybe he developed or was better than that all along.
http://espn.go.com/blog/sec/post/_/id/95221/orange-bowl-take-2-has-georgia-tech-or-miss-state-done-more-with-less
 

KurtRambis4

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2006
15,926
0
36
Like the General said,

it's some of both. You cannot base the probability of success purely on some physical characteristics.
 
Feb 18, 2014
437
8
18
I agree with that as well. It just seems like these players can never shake the label of "only 3 star" when they obviously are more talented than that by their production on the field. Minor thing to be annoyed with I guess but still.
 

KurtRambis4

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2006
15,926
0
36
That speaks

to the stupidty of the general person more than anything else. People eat that **** up and act as if it's the be-all and end-all.
 

mount lefroy

Redshirt
Feb 10, 2013
2,501
0
36
Stars and preseason rankings are valuable commodities in the same way lottery tickets are. They give the seller a small profit individually But because there are enough suckers in the world, the margins are enormous.
No overhead. Simply find out who the perrineal top teams are targeting, take a few clips and highlights, pretend you have an formula that the other peddlers dont.

Of course, like the lottery ticket buyer, the signing day suckers get a little to dream about until that awful day the actual games start and the stars show to be pretty random save a select few.

It should be impossible for a texas florida usc nebraska michigan or tennessee to be anything less than 9 wins if they actually posses the elite players the ratings indicate.

Give me a very good coach, an advantageous schedule and some luck.
 

MarkDallas

Sophomore
Aug 27, 2014
2,607
121
63
You can "play out of your mind" for a half or a game, but if you do it for a season, then you're just that good.
 

MabenMaroon

Redshirt
Feb 2, 2014
128
0
0
Recruiting rankings ended up costing Mack Brown and Gene Chizik their jobs.
TU was loaded with 4/5*s to the very end for Coach Mack, so I guess you are right, he didn't win with highly rated classes and that cost him his job. That and too much comfort in the way things in general were set up around him.
 

thf24

Redshirt
Jan 28, 2011
1,334
3
38
The interesting thing with old Mack's case is that Texas recruiting evaluations tend to be incredibly inflated, much more so than the average region. Hard to say whether his talent wasn't nearly what the websites said it was, or he just mismanaged it that badly.
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
That's 19.83% correct. Losing cost Mack Brown his job, he's a great recruiter, even was at UNC

Absolutely. But do you think he got lazy with success and old age? I just can't unserstand for the life of me how you can whiff on an entire roster like he did.

And the QB who started for Auburn during Auburn's **** year, how are evaluations so wrong on a guy?
 

Strike.sixpack

Redshirt
Oct 18, 2013
1,214
0
0
That's 19.83% correct. Losing cost Mack Brown his job, he's a great recruiter, even was at UNC

I don't anyone is saying he wasn't a great recruiter. I think the issue is the talent is overvalued in Texas to a degree, their own evaluations on players became a big issue (lazy? Just missed? IDK) and the coaching became below average. Once it slipped they began loosing the team to a degree. They recruited fine in the rankings and he is a great salesman but the talent did not seem to be as good as the rankings suggested. I think you have to look at the staff turn over as well and the type of recruiters, talent evaluators, and coaches they were that he could not replace.
 

SignalToNoise

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
741
0
0
Here's the way I see it:

A recruits "star ranking" is like a student's GPA. It earns him a scholarship and the opportunity to play the same way as it earns the student an opportunity to study in his chosen field. Rather or not he excels at the college game depends on the work he does going forward, not the star ranking that was awarded for his work in the past. In this analogy, the student might not put forth any effort and end up flunking out because he's buys chasing women and drinking beer- admirable in it's own right, but not going to earn any academic accolades.

It is really funny (funny haha, not funny faux pas) to see people on message boards, social media, etc, making the argument that one player is better than another player based of recruiting ranking alone. "Ah, but you see, MSU can't possibly be this good- they didn't have any 5* 'croots!!!" Which would mean coaching, player development, scheme, etc, have no bearing on the game.
 
Aug 22, 2012
2,761
1
31
I heard a database manager say about databases, "Garbage in, Gospel out." His point was that people are hesitant to disagree with the database so you have to make sure the data going in is good. Same principle applies to recruiting. People are hesitant to disagree with recruiting rankings. Obviously many take them as gospel when they are anything but.
 

BulldogBlitz

Heisman
Dec 11, 2008
18,675
27,512
113
had he not landed VY, i think mack would have been run out long ago. i don't know what their recruiting scheme was thinking as they didn't get any quarterbacks recently that fit anything they do.

it seems like every day that is the discussion on the sports talk here is when/where is charlie strong going to find a QB because the current stable is a mixed bag of "we hope something works out"
 
Feb 18, 2014
437
8
18
"Ah, but you see, MSU can't possibly be this good- they didn't have any 5* 'croots!!!" Which would mean coaching, player development, scheme, etc, have no bearing on the game.

Exactly! As others have stated we definitely have a combo of guys who recruiting sites missed on who are stars (Prescott, JRob, McKinney, Bear) and guys we coached up/worked hard and turned into solid players (Clausell, Beckwith, Virges, Tubby Lewis, Jamerson Love). This rhetoric that it's some cosmic fluke we are good because we don't have a plethora of 4 and 5 stars is tiresome.
 
Last edited:
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State