another general fired

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
according to reports Hegseth recently fired the 3 star J5...plans...this is the second J5 fired...

no reasons given...which is understandable. But, you don't make 3 stars unless you have something on the ball....

You have to wonder what's going on in the Pentagon. Have promotion boards become inefficient or ineffective...have generals??

I can understand the desire to reduce the number of flag officers, but we need a J5...so we're not eliminating a position...makes you wonder
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,270
13,224
113
@baltimorened

Plead complete ignorance of the needs of a chain of command

So help me out with my impression based on industry and their rif practices

I see where based on the actual headcount of soldiers there are associated head counts of officers

Does the military have some way to associate officer headcount to enlisted head count

Also how does the military account for replacements of officers retiring etc and new opportunities needing more or less staff such as adding Space Force

Of course on here there are many experts to tell us how it should be done

I thought you might have some real deep insight on are the officer ranks too fat needing pruning or is the officers ranks OK

Thanks for any information you can provide
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
@baltimorened

Plead complete ignorance of the needs of a chain of command

So help me out with my impression based on industry and their rif practices

I see where based on the actual headcount of soldiers there are associated head counts of officers

Does the military have some way to associate officer headcount to enlisted head count

Also how does the military account for replacements of officers retiring etc and new opportunities needing more or less staff such as adding Space Force

Of course on here there are many experts to tell us how it should be done

I thought you might have some real deep insight on are the officer ranks too fat needing pruning or is the officers ranks OK

Thanks for any information you can provide
I know I won't get this right...been out for just about 40 years....My experience is only Army, don't have any idea of the other services (although for sure you could make a claim that some have a lot of officers as all the pilots are commissioned)

The Army officer corps has a bunch off "branches" ranging from Infantry, aviation, armor..there are the combat arms. But there are also some "administrative branches" Judge advocate general (lawyers) finance, adjutant general (administrators) .


    • Combat Arms: Infantry, Armor, Aviation, Corps of Engineers, Field Artillery, Air Defense Artillery, and Special Forces.
    • Combat Support: Military Intelligence, Signal Corps, Military Police Corps, Chemical Corps, and Cyber Corps.
    • Combat Service Support: Adjutant General's Corps, Finance Corps, Quartermaster Corps, Ordnance Corps, and Transportation Corps.
    • Special Branches (Medical & Professional): Medical Corps, Medical Service Corps, Medical Specialist Corps, Nurse Corps, Dental Corps, Veterinary Corps, Judge Advocate General’s (JAG) Corps, and Chaplain Corps
    It's easy to define officers in the combat arms...the combat forces have a table of Organization and Equipment (TOE) which lays out specifics...so many squads in a platoon, so many platoons in a company, same with battalions..and there are similar slots for officers....2nd lieutenant commands platoons, captains - companies, lt colonels, battalions all the way up to 2star for division commander...Then there are staff officers for battalion and brigade, S1 through S4, and division G1 through G4.
    So as you would expect from a military organization..it's all laid out. Oh and the TOE also lays out the specific equipment for each element..so many weapons, trucks etc.

    It gets little murkier, although the numbers are specified and approved by Congress, when you understand that not all officers are in the combat arms...typically, at least in the Army, you rotate through the combat arms into other jobs..For example in my career, after the training is out of the way, I had a combat assignment with the !st Cav, then A resource Management position at an Aviation training post, than an ROTC assignment, back to combat Divisions (25th Infantry) the a contract management...and more up to my final position in the Pentagon in Research and Development....In that office, we had 12 officers, all Lieutenant Colonels...to confuse things even more, each officer today has two specialties. Mine for example were aviation and procurement

    But bottom line, yes there are firm numbers of officers...based on job requirements and approved by congress

    The issue with Hegseth is the number of flag officers. He's comparing the number during WWII to today and there is a disparity...But, I don't think he understands that the Army of today is different from that of WWII..still, it's hard to make a case for the number we have today...but the other side of that is when you reach 20 years of service (eligible for retirement) if you can't see a path for promotion (not enough spaces for your skill set) you retire and service loses that 20 years of experience...so it's a two edged sword.

    Hope that helps. It's easy to Understand when you're in the system. Probably more than you wanted to know.





 
  • Like
Reactions: THE_DEVIL

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
Sounds like he failed multiple polygraphs concerning leaking of sensitive information
just saw that...leaking classified information will get him a court martial (or worse) and likely cost him retirement rank and pay. There are some people who just seem to see a need to talk to reporters. They fail to realize that their careers are just a stepping stone to the reporter's pulitzer.
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,270
13,224
113
I know I won't get this right...been out for just about 40 years....My experience is only Army, don't have any idea of the other services (although for sure you could make a claim that some have a lot of officers as all the pilots are commissioned)

The Army officer corps has a bunch off "branches" ranging from Infantry, aviation, armor..there are the combat arms. But there are also some "administrative branches" Judge advocate general (lawyers) finance, adjutant general (administrators) .


    • Combat Arms: Infantry, Armor, Aviation, Corps of Engineers, Field Artillery, Air Defense Artillery, and Special Forces.
    • Combat Support: Military Intelligence, Signal Corps, Military Police Corps, Chemical Corps, and Cyber Corps.
    • Combat Service Support: Adjutant General's Corps, Finance Corps, Quartermaster Corps, Ordnance Corps, and Transportation Corps.
    • Special Branches (Medical & Professional): Medical Corps, Medical Service Corps, Medical Specialist Corps, Nurse Corps, Dental Corps, Veterinary Corps, Judge Advocate General’s (JAG) Corps, and Chaplain Corps
  • It's easy to define officers in the combat arms...the combat forces have a table of Organization and Equipment (TOE) which lays out specifics...so many squads in a platoon, so many platoons in a company, same with battalions..and there are similar slots for officers....2nd lieutenant commands platoons, captains - companies, lt colonels, battalions all the way up to 2star for division commander...Then there are staff officers for battalion and brigade, S1 through S4, and division G1 through G4.
    So as you would expect from a military organization..it's all laid out. Oh and the TOE also lays out the specific equipment for each element..so many weapons, trucks etc.

    It gets little murkier, although the numbers are specified and approved by Congress, when you understand that not all officers are in the combat arms...typically, at least in the Army, you rotate through the combat arms into other jobs..For example in my career, after the training is out of the way, I had a combat assignment with the !st Cav, then A resource Management position at an Aviation training post, than an ROTC assignment, back to combat Divisions (25th Infantry) the a contract management...and more up to my final position in the Pentagon in Research and Development....In that office, we had 12 officers, all Lieutenant Colonels...to confuse things even more, each officer today has two specialties. Mine for example were aviation and procurement

    But bottom line, yes there are firm numbers of officers...based on job requirements and approved by congress

    The issue with Hegseth is the number of flag officers. He's comparing the number during WWII to today and there is a disparity...But, I don't think he understands that the Army of today is different from that of WWII..still, it's hard to make a case for the number we have today...but the other side of that is when you reach 20 years of service (eligible for retirement) if you can't see a path for promotion (not enough spaces for your skill set) you retire and service loses that 20 years of experience...so it's a two edged sword.

    Hope that helps. It's easy to Understand when you're in the system. Probably more than you wanted to know.





Thanks as the fairly comprehensive explanation was very informtive

like to add to the numbers probably now we have to have a drone warfare chain of command

I just saw what the guy was removed for and it was for providing combat details to reporters that was supposed to be secret

Think that will get anyone fired
 
  • Like
Reactions: Allornothing

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
Thanks as the fairly comprehensive explanation was very informtive

like to add to the numbers probably now we have to have a drone warfare chain of command

I just saw what the guy was removed for and it was for providing combat details to reporters that was supposed to be secret

Think that will get anyone fired
well, just to further complicate things...In the Pentagon, Army again, there are offices with single responsibilites that tie in together, if that makes sense. We have a requirements section, also made up of a bunch of Lt Colonels who are all war fighters,and these guys work with the combat Divisions staffs to come up with the requirements of the warfighters - and remember all these guys in the Pentagon office are all combat arms veterans. So if a G3 Operations) staff determines that in order to meet their combat operations they need some man portable, easily supported weapon to shoot down drones, that data is filtered through the requirements office in the Pentagon to the acquition people in a separate office....It is the acquisition folks responsibility to come up with requests for proposals throughout industry to see what kinds of ideas, might fill the need of the people who actually fight the war (all of these guys are also combat arms, combat veterans), From there it goes through a convoluted system of R&D into a procuremnet process with program offices/managers until a contract is awarded and funding is requested through Congress.

And you might imagine this process is as detailed and exact as is the creation of TOE in a combat Divisions...

It's a very structured world in the Army :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

dbjork6317

Heisman
Dec 3, 2009
18,949
75,093
113
according to reports Hegseth recently fired the 3 star J5...plans...this is the second J5 fired...

no reasons given...which is understandable. But, you don't make 3 stars unless you have something on the ball....

You have to wonder what's going on in the Pentagon. Have promotion boards become inefficient or ineffective...have generals??

I can understand the desire to reduce the number of flag officers, but we need a J5...so we're not eliminating a position...makes you wonder
I don’t think there’s much to wonder about. We put an alcoholic tv host in charge of the military.
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,270
13,224
113
well, just to further complicate things...In the Pentagon, Army again, there are offices with single responsibilites that tie in together, if that makes sense. We have a requirements section, also made up of a bunch of Lt Colonels who are all war fighters,and these guys work with the combat Divisions staffs to come up with the requirements of the warfighters - and remember all these guys in the Pentagon office are all combat arms veterans. So if a G3 Operations) staff determines that in order to meet their combat operations they need some man portable, easily supported weapon to shoot down drones, that data is filtered through the requirements office in the Pentagon to the acquition people in a separate office....It is the acquisition folks responsibility to come up with requests for proposals throughout industry to see what kinds of ideas, might fill the need of the
people who actually fight the war (all of these guys are also combat arms, combat veterans), From there it goes through a convoluted system of R&D into a procuremnet process with program offices/managers until a contract is awarded and funding is requested through Congress.

And you might imagine this process is as detailed and exact as is the creation of TOE in a combat Divisions...

It's a very structured world in the Army :)

My dad used to say that the Army only issues you a wife if they think you need one

Does that fit into that organizational structure
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
My dad used to say that the Army only issues you a wife if they think you need one

Does that fit into that organizational structure
absolutely..that saying still applies. The men are gone so much, late hours, field trips, deployments, wives.... make the army constant...my year in Vietnam..left my wife with a two month old, she had a home break in, a burglary, car issues, failed paychecks Army finance makes mistakes...(too many civilians)..we've moved about 20 times...

we loved the army...it fit my personality...but war is a young man's game.

People who have never served really missed life changing opportunities
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,531
39,383
113


Regarding the Secretary of War (Hegseth) firing the top Pentagon strategist (Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia), who was accused of leaking classified information on the Iran and Ukraine wars.

Here are the potential charges he could face, both in civilian court and under the UCMJ.

BTW: Sylvia failed not one, not two, but THREE polygraphs on the matter.
 

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,531
39,383
113


A three star general sitting in a diner in Arlington with notes he took from a classified report, reading them out loud to a reporter who was writing a book… think about that for a second.

According to the internal investigation report Axios got its hands on, Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, the man running strategy, plans and policy for the Joint Chiefs, admitted to leaking classified information on Iran and Ukraine to two reporters at two different outlets over about a year, and a U.S. official says he acknowledged it on video after he failed four polygraphs. It started as early as June 2025, it ran through Signal, and when one of those reporters lost Pentagon access he just moved the meeting to the Silver Diner. Then there is the Signal thread about Iran that he says he deleted by accident… investigators don't buy that and neither do I.

Now keep in mind the part the press is skipping. When Hegseth fired him, the Joint Staff put out a statement thanking him for 32 years of distinguished service, and according to a U.S. official it was acting Army Secretary Adam Telle's office pushing for that warm send off to limit the fallout. They pulled it once the full picture came out. So who exactly were they protecting, and why was the first instinct to polish the general instead of protecting the country he swore an oath to?

Here is the reality. This is what institutional rot looks like up close, a man with stars on his shoulders who decided the press was his chain of command, and the report even says he admitted being one of the 20 officials quoted in a story trashing Pentagon leadership. Rank was supposed to mean something. Honor was supposed to mean something. He traded both for a few pages in somebody else's book.

How many more of them are still sitting in that building? You already know the answer.

DOJ has the referral. Charge him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Allornothing

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,531
39,383
113
Would not surprise me.



Was Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia the source for Jennifer Griffin?

Almost all of her coverage of POTUS Trump and Hegseth has been negative.

Undercutting America.

She’s a propagandist and enemy of the people.

Failing 3 leaks polys is damning.

All about military engagements.

Oops!
 

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,531
39,383
113
according to reports Hegseth recently fired the 3 star J5...plans...this is the second J5 fired...

no reasons given...which is understandable. But, you don't make 3 stars unless you have something on the ball....

You have to wonder what's going on in the Pentagon. Have promotion boards become inefficient or ineffective...have generals??

I can understand the desire to reduce the number of flag officers, but we need a J5...so we're not eliminating a position...makes you wonder
More details. Not good.



Top Army Officer Arrested for Treason and Espionage

A three-star general trusted with America’s most sensitive war plans was stripped of his credentials, dragged from the Pentagon, and arrested for treason and espionage after he tried to hand President Trump’s post-midterm strike package straight to Tehran.

Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia, the Joint Staff J5 Director of Strategy, Plans, and Policy and former commander of the 101st Airborne Division, walked into the Pentagon Tuesday morning expecting another routine day. Five Pentagon Force Protection officers were waiting. His access was already dead. Hegseth had fired him without warning after an Air Force Office of Special Investigations probe that included multiple failed polygraphs. Sylvia stood stunned, demanding to speak to the War Secretary. The officers told him to surrender his badge, government phone, and briefcase and leave. He stormed out shouting that President Trump would hear about it.

Thirty minutes later he reached his Arlington home. Four unmarked SUVs blocked the driveway. A dozen Navy JAG officers were already inside, pulling evidence-taped boxes out of the residence. Agents surrounded him, read him his rights, and cuffed him on the spot. Sources confirm JAG holds irrefutable proof that Sylvia made clandestine contact with Iranian Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf and offered to supply Trump’s post-midterm war plans against the regime.

This is not a quiet personnel action. Sylvia held the exact post that shapes long-range military strategy for the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs. He had been in the seat since December 2025. The timing is no accident. Trump is weighing renewed action against Iran after the midterms. A third carrier group is already moving. The leaks Sylvia is accused of feeding to journalists covered both the Iran war and Ukraine. The Pentagon referred the entire matter to the Justice Department for potential criminal action. Zero tolerance is the new standard.

A military tribunal will decide his fate. If convicted he faces hanging or a permanent cell at GITMO. The same sources who tracked the arrest say this is only the opening move. Additional officers who green-lit unauthorized disclosures are already under the same microscope. Accountability is back inside the Department of War. The plan is in motion. More is coming in the weeks ahead.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113


A three star general sitting in a diner in Arlington with notes he took from a classified report, reading them out loud to a reporter who was writing a book… think about that for a second.

According to the internal investigation report Axios got its hands on, Lt. Gen. Brett Sylvia, the man running strategy, plans and policy for the Joint Chiefs, admitted to leaking classified information on Iran and Ukraine to two reporters at two different outlets over about a year, and a U.S. official says he acknowledged it on video after he failed four polygraphs. It started as early as June 2025, it ran through Signal, and when one of those reporters lost Pentagon access he just moved the meeting to the Silver Diner. Then there is the Signal thread about Iran that he says he deleted by accident… investigators don't buy that and neither do I.

Now keep in mind the part the press is skipping. When Hegseth fired him, the Joint Staff put out a statement thanking him for 32 years of distinguished service, and according to a U.S. official it was acting Army Secretary Adam Telle's office pushing for that warm send off to limit the fallout. They pulled it once the full picture came out. So who exactly were they protecting, and why was the first instinct to polish the general instead of protecting the country he swore an oath to?

Here is the reality. This is what institutional rot looks like up close, a man with stars on his shoulders who decided the press was his chain of command, and the report even says he admitted being one of the 20 officials quoted in a story trashing Pentagon leadership. Rank was supposed to mean something. Honor was supposed to mean something. He traded both for a few pages in somebody else's book.

How many more of them are still sitting in that building? You already know the answer.

DOJ has the referral. Charge him.

I don't want to sound snarky, but I'm somewhat surprised at the lack of combat decorations he has. It looks like he's got a load of Bronze Stars, but only 1 with a "V" device for "valor". The rest all look like for service...and that's the highest decoration...the rest of the higher ribbons are "service oriented" as opposed to combat heroism or action.

I would guess the west point ring has helped him to 3star rank
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,270
13,224
113
After seeing details of this general and his conduct I will say if what I have read is correct then he definitely needs to be escorted out of the building and fired with his pension severely penalized.

What he was doing was clearly wrong
 

alaskanseminole

Heisman
Oct 20, 2002
247,082
14,995
103
I just saw what the guy was removed for and it was for providing combat details to reporters that was supposed to be secret
Oh, you mean like when Hegseth posted the Yemen strike timeline in a Signal chat that accidentally included a reporter? F-18 launch times, when the strike windows would open, confirmation that a specific human target was at his known location, when the MQ-9 drones would hit, when the first bombs would drop, and when the Tomahawk missiles would launch. You know... actual operational details, shared BEFORE the strikes even started.


...rules for thee, not for me. Same ole double standard for those in the IC and/or military vs politicians.
Think that will get anyone fired
Except for Pete and the VP, of course.
 

Ghee Buttersnaps 2

All-Conference
Nov 12, 2023
2,859
4,471
113
oh $h1t! threads about to get good. and I'm here for it. LOL

Dis Gonna Be Good Jason Momoa GIF
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,270
13,224
113
Oh, you mean like when Hegseth posted the Yemen strike timeline in a Signal chat that accidentally included a reporter? F-18 launch times, when the strike windows would open, confirmation that a specific human target was at his known location, when the MQ-9 drones would hit, when the first bombs would drop, and when the Tomahawk missiles would launch. You know... actual operational details, shared BEFORE the strikes even started.


...rules for thee, not for me. Same ole double standard for those in the IC and/or military vs politicians.

Except for Pete and the VP, of course.

Seems like I remember reading about that and what you describe and what I read have no resemblance in any fashion.

Of course you have launched the hate Trump and all his minions storm.

On top of that you clearly don’t understand CHAIN OF COMMAND PROTOCOLS AND PRACTICES

My take on that was there needed to be some device communication cleaning up.
 

alaskanseminole

Heisman
Oct 20, 2002
247,082
14,995
103
Of course you have launched the hate Trump and all his minions storm.
Where in my post was Trump mentioned? ...when Hillary's private email server was the focus of concern, my issues were singularly focused then too. National Security transcends political motivations. I have been soapboxing the double standard for politicians vs those of us in the IC for the better part of 2 decades.
On top of that you clearly don’t understand CHAIN OF COMMAND PROTOCOLS AND PRACTICES

My take on that was there needed to be some device communication cleaning up.
So your take is my 28+ years as an Intelligence analyst, 20 on active duty and 8 as a government civilian/defense contractor somehow means, I don't "understand CHAIN OF COMMAND PROTOCOLS AND PRACTICES"?

Schitts Creek Please GIF by CBC
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,270
13,224
113
Where in my post was Trump mentioned? ...when Hillary's private email server was the focus of concern, my issues were singularly focused then too. National Security transcends political motivations. I have been soapboxing the double standard for politicians vs those of us in the IC for the better part of 2 decades.

So your take is my 28+ years as an Intelligence analyst, 20 on active duty and 8 as a government civilian/defense contractor somehow means, I don't "understand CHAIN OF COMMAND PROTOCOLS AND PRACTICES"?

Schitts Creek Please GIF by CBC

This is a board and without vetting

You can tell me anything and expect me to believe you.

My answer to you is you are just a disgruntled guy whose ideas have been ignored because they are not worthy

Accept your status and place on the totem pole
 

alaskanseminole

Heisman
Oct 20, 2002
247,082
14,995
103
This is a board and without vetting

You can tell me anything and expect me to believe you.

My answer to you is you are just a disgruntled guy whose ideas have been ignored because they are not worthy

Accept your status and place on the totem pole
So your first line of defense is to make assumptions about me, dismiss my background as something you can't verify, and then resort to a personal insult? I guess that's one way to engage on this forum (despite the fact I've never acted in a way contrary to my claims)

Regardkess, you don't have to believe my resume. Address the actual point.

I've been consistent on this board and my home board...National Security transcends political party. I don't get a pass for mishandling sensitive information, so why should a politician? I've spent nearly three decades working in the IC. You can dismiss that as a disgruntled guy whose ideas weren't valued (which is an ignorant response considering I'm not alone in what I said), but that doesn't address a single thing I've said. (if anything, I'd appreciate an answer to that direct question)

And "accept your place on the totem pole"? Seriously? Sorry, but that's spoken like a minion, rather than a free thinker.

Consistancy:


 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
So your first line of defense is to make assumptions about me, dismiss my background as something you can't verify, and then resort to a personal insult? I guess that's one way to engage on this forum (despite the fact I've never acted in a way contrary to my claims)

Regardkess, you don't have to believe my resume. Address the actual point.

I've been consistent on this board and my home board...National Security transcends political party. I don't get a pass for mishandling sensitive information, so why should a politician? I've spent nearly three decades working in the IC. You can dismiss that as a disgruntled guy whose ideas weren't valued (which is an ignorant response considering I'm not alone in what I said), but that doesn't address a single thing I've said. (if anything, I'd appreciate an answer to that direct question)

And "accept your place on the totem pole"? Seriously? Sorry, but that's spoken like a minion, rather than a free thinker.

Consistancy:


if your point is that we have hypocrisy and double standards in government, it would be extremely difficult to have a rational debate arguing against that point.

If you wanted you could carry that point to this board, and it would be equally difficult to have that same debate...
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Clemson Football Insider
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Basketball Thursday Dillon Hunter Update
  5. 05 On3 Football House working on small revisions of Protect College Sports Act before vote