Toggle sidebar

Absolute Travesty..

P

pascal_rivals499553

Redshirt
Aug 26, 2022
1,336
0
0
BrighteRed24 said:
Committee made the right decision. FSU is not an elite team nor would they have been competitive in the CFP without Jordan Travis.

SEC has won 4 straight national championships and 6 of the last 9. That conference deserves the benefit of the doubt until they are defeated when it counts
Click to expand...
Respectfully disagree on all counts. Concocting a future scenario based on perceived weaknesses due to injuries, or in Michigan's case, some penalty-suspension, shouldn't be a factor. IMO, FSU's problem is they play in a pony league despite having had ample opportunity to put on their sec big boy pants. What if Nebraska got a little better (fg kicker, OC, QB) and went to the Mountain West. Instead of losing every game 10-13 they could win 20-13. Should they then whine about not being invited?

As for what the SEC has done in the past, who cares? This is the 2023 playoffs. Should Nebraska and Oklahoma be considered for their past success?
 
Jaemekon

Jaemekon

Senior
Apr 23, 2007
26,162
623
113
AVeritas said:
like scott frost's ucf in that way.
Click to expand...

classic gif 🤣☠️
 
H

husker0028

Redshirt
Apr 5, 2015
118
17
0
It has been a joke forever, every division below can figure out a way to run a full playoff. I don't think the 12-team model is great either, just make it like every other division of football and let the players decide it not some dipshits in a room and tv brokers.

Actually, another travesty is how Michigan was even allowed to continue with all of the information that is already public about the actions of their program.
 
V

V-Doub

Heisman
Jul 8, 2007
22,364
29,063
0
bama_husker said:
My understanding is that the #1 seed chooses the venue, and Michigan will certainly choose the Rose Bowl over the Sugar Bowl.
Click to expand...

It will be the Rose Bowl 100%. But I’m not sure that’s an advantage to either team.
 
H

husker0028

Redshirt
Apr 5, 2015
118
17
0
pascal said:
Respectfully disagree on all counts. Concocting a future scenario based on perceived weaknesses due to injuries, or in Michigan's case, some penalty-suspension, shouldn't be a factor. IMO, FSU's problem is they play in a pony league despite having had ample opportunity to put on their sec big boy pants. What if Nebraska got a little better (fg kicker, OC, QB) and went to the Mountain West. Instead of losing every game 10-13 they could win 20-13. Should they then whine about not being invited?

As for what the SEC has done in the past, who cares? This is the 2023 playoffs. Should Nebraska and Oklahoma be considered for their past success?
Click to expand...
I agree, if you are going to say no to FSU over an injury then why not to Michigan who is on the path to victories being vacated due to cheating
 
B

BrighteRed24_rivals190920

Freshman
Nov 5, 2018
2,163
68
0
pascal said:
Respectfully disagree on all counts. Concocting a future scenario based on perceived weaknesses due to injuries, or in Michigan's case, some penalty-suspension, shouldn't be a factor. IMO, FSU's problem is they play in a pony league despite having had ample opportunity to put on their sec big boy pants. What if Nebraska got a little better (fg kicker, OC, QB) and went to the Mountain West. Instead of losing every game 10-13 they could win 20-13. Should they then whine about not being invited?

As for what the SEC has done in the past, who cares? This is the 2023 playoffs. Should Nebraska and Oklahoma be considered for their past success?
Click to expand...
Agree to disagree here.

This is simple for me, there are 4 teams that are deserving in the playoffs who each have a legit chance to win the playoff. If you take out Alabama and insert FSU, there are 4 deserving teams but 1 team with a 0.0% chance of winning the playoff.

Match up FSU with Georgia or Ohio State in a bowl game, watch them get beat soundly, and all this bickering about FSU is going to go away. They are not an elite team without Jordan Travis, plain and simple
 
TampaBaySkers

TampaBaySkers

Senior
Oct 30, 2010
18,392
525
103
HikingHusker said:
FSU didn't look that great all year and had their season saved thanks to Clemson using a former walk-on, grad student, as their kicker who shanked a 30 yarder when the pressure was on.

They also had close wins against fairly average teams.

5-7 Florida Team 9 point win after being behind halfway through the 4th quarter. A team Georgia beat by 23
7-5 Miami Team 7 point win

The Bama, Texas, and Georgia dynamic is interesting. Had Georgia won last night, I think Texas would have been left out and it would have been Georgia, Michigan, Washington, FSU. But that loss flipped all sorts of things and made Texas have a bigger win, which made Bama's only loss an even stronger loss.

Unfortunately this was a year where who you played and how you beat them mattered.
Click to expand...
Ok now do all the very close game bama had to ****** teams…

Arky
Auburn
So Florida

Oh and don’t ignore the two-score loss at home.
 
S

Spartanhusker

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
22,566
1,856
0
pascal said:
There is an ncaa rule called The Alabama Exemption. It is based on the mysterious phenomenon that every week, no matter what, some telecaster bozo will declare Alabama to be the best team in the country during their broadcast.
Toadies with votes will comply.
Bama can lose, sometimes twice, it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter their ridiculous noncon schedule or the fact they struggled to win all their legit games
They are the best team by default.
Click to expand...
You are not wrong
 
TampaBaySkers

TampaBaySkers

Senior
Oct 30, 2010
18,392
525
103
scarletred said:
And don’t ignore beating the two time national champions..
Click to expand...
They beat Georgia the past two years? I didn’t know this!

Even my seven year made fun of your comment.. he said then Colorado is really good since they beat last years runner up.

Now you’re getting dunked on by seven year olds… a new low
 
HuskerBruce81

HuskerBruce81

All-American
Nov 7, 2012
39,978
6,010
113
HuskerJose said:
It says they aren’t in a power conference
Click to expand...
ACC has more national titles than the Big since: name your amount of years
HikingHusker said:
FSU didn't look that great all year and had their season saved thanks to Clemson using a former walk-on, grad student, as their kicker who shanked a 30 yarder when the pressure was on.

They also had close wins against fairly average teams.

5-7 Florida Team 9 point win after being behind halfway through the 4th quarter. A team Georgia beat by 23
7-5 Miami Team 7 point win

The Bama, Texas, and Georgia dynamic is interesting. Had Georgia won last night, I think Texas would have been left out and it would have been Georgia, Michigan, Washington, FSU. But that loss flipped all sorts of things and made Texas have a bigger win, which made Bama's only loss an even stronger loss.

Unfortunately this was a year where who you played and how you beat them mattered.
Click to expand...
usf 13-3
Aggies 26-20
3 point win against Arky lol
Miracle against Auburn lol

ColoRed7 said:
Texas or Alabama would be 7-10 point favorites over Florida State.
Click to expand...
And Oregon was 9 point favorites against Washington. Hell, FSU was 17.5 point favorites against Nebraska for the 94 orange and if there was replay they lost that game 23-12.

All of you are casuals who believe in arguments that has ruined the sport and taken an opportunity away from aboit a hundred 18-22 year olds in Tallahassee who earned an opportunity to compete. Congratulations. I award you zero points and may God have mercy on your souls.
 
Last edited:
B

beaglehusker

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2006
13,178
3,891
0
AVeritas said:
you guys believe 3rd string qb fsu beats alabama? come on.
Click to expand...
Proving you're a moron since this second stringer will be back. Doesn't matter, undefeated and conf champ, with a better resume. How many teams did Bama struggle with. They don't deserve it, this is crooked big time
 
N

NECoach31BB

Senior
Mar 8, 2002
17,723
651
0
scarletred said:
Beating Bama at home by two scores was the bigger factor.
Click to expand...
As soon as Texas as the 3, I knew Bama was getting in. No way the committee was going to have ESPN, I mean the SEC not have a team in the playoffs.

Anyone actually think of the FSU QB is fully healthy and that is the only change the committee doesn’t anything differently? Raise your hand and then slap yourself with it.

To be honest, every fan of college football should find an Auburn fan and absolutely berate for about an hour for allowing their team to give up that throw in the Iron Bowl.
 
Y

Yantzeee

Redshirt
Nov 25, 2021
1,897
0
0
am I the only one that thinks they got it right? The top 3 are clearly correct. If it wasn’t for a PI against OU, I think Texas is unbeaten at this point. Bama, Ohio St, UGA, and FSU all had cases but Bama had the hardest schedule of the 4. Only one that played 2 out of the top 7 teams. UGA was probably the best out of them, with tOSU the second best. But they didn’t win their conference as either did UGA. FSU schedule was soft. Strength of Schedule matters
 
R

ru4nu2win_rivals

Junior
May 2, 2006
4,111
346
0
AVeritas said:
nope. they took the four best teams at season's close. that was their charge.
Click to expand...
So, according to your theory, if say Vanderbilt loses it's first 3 games of the year then goes undefeated the rest of the way and wins the SEC title, they should be in cause they're playing the best at seasons end?
 
Y

Yantzeee

Redshirt
Nov 25, 2021
1,897
0
0
TampaBaySkers said:
FSU beat Florida by two scores..

Oh now do New Mexico Sate vs Auburn- you walked right into that dumbass
Click to expand...
You clearly didn’t watch FSU vs Florida. And I didn’t know Auburn was in the talk.

Bama beat UGA. Who’d FSU beat? LSU? Wow, great. So did Bama
 
TampaBaySkers

TampaBaySkers

Senior
Oct 30, 2010
18,392
525
103
Yantzeee said:
You clearly didn’t watch FSU vs Florida. And I didn’t know Auburn was in the talk.

Bama beat UGA. Who’d FSU beat? LSU? Wow, great. So did Bama
Click to expand...
Wow you’re dumber than I thought.

New Mexico State DESTROYED auburn. The following week Alabama need the refs to barley beat auburn by 3… you obviously didn’t watch the game 🤣

hoisted by your own petard
 
P

poundth3rock

Junior
Jul 20, 2007
2,165
338
83
ru4nu2win said:
This is why I like the NFL more then college. ACC 6-4 against SEC. FSU got screwed!!
Click to expand...

Texas really what cost FSU. One loss Texas would have been left out had they not beaten Bama head up.

Also weren't leaving SEC out given viewership of that region and past dominance. This left FSU as odd man out with excuse of SOS, bad offense and hurt QB as justification.

SUCKS for fans of FSU and ACC but really not relevant in future with 12 team playoff. All major conference Champs and any Undefeated D1 teams in starting next year.
 
B

big red23

All-Conference
Dec 15, 2003
10,114
1,479
113
ru4nu2win said:
This is why I like the NFL more then college. ACC 6-4 against SEC. FSU got screwed!!
Click to expand...
If Texas or Alabama (Especially Alabama) win... and FSU beats Georgia. I say they give the NC to Florida State. Only undefeated P5 team with wins over Georgia and LSU
 
TampaBaySkers

TampaBaySkers

Senior
Oct 30, 2010
18,392
525
103
big red22 said:
If Texas or Alabama (Especially Alabama) win... and FSU beats Georgia. I say they give the NC to Florida State. Only undefeated P5 team with wins over Georgia and LSU
Click to expand...
those fart sniffing AP voters don’t have the literal or figurative balls to do that
 
Redscarlet

Redscarlet

Heisman
Jun 17, 2001
32,811
10,746
113
TampaBaySkers said:
They beat Georgia the past two years? I didn’t know this!

Even my seven year made fun of your comment.. he said then Colorado is really good since they beat last years runner up.

Now you’re getting dunked on by seven year olds… a new low
Click to expand...
Both you and your kido can’t comprehend, nothing was said about winning the last 2 years against Georgia, everyone that follows college football knew Georgia had a 29 game winning streak heading into the game..

Try this again Bama beat the 2 time defending National Champion, repeat it twice might help you let it sink in..
 
Last edited:
H

HuskerJose

Redshirt
Dec 1, 2023
22
0
0
Bruce1981 said:
ACC has more national titles than the Big since: name your amount of years
Click to expand...
If your undefeated confernce champion gets left out of a playoff in favor of not 1 but 2 one loss conf champions then that tells you all you need to know about the pecking order of your conference
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom